Do I need roof rails?
Author
Discussion

LeoSayer

Original Poster:

7,865 posts

275 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
Probably a stupid question....I'm about to order a new A3 Sportback and roof rails are £250 extra, I'd rather not spend this unless I have to.

I carry bikes on a roof rack about 2 or 3 times a year and my previous cars have all had roof rails, however the A3 rails are a different style to the ones on my BMW so I'd need to get new feet for the roof bars anyway.

I see that you can also buy feet which fix directly onto the edge of the roof and door tops so you don't appear to need roof rails at all. Anyone used these?



Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
If it were me, I'd probably get the rails. I'm not sure I'd trust anything sitting directly on my paintwork and wrappign around the door tops.

Are the rails like the rest of the Audi range and flush? If so, they're silent in use. Or at least the ones on our A6 are. All you need is another footpack to make your existing roof bars fit.

If you only use them a few times a year, it might be worth considering not getting them, but I'd check first to see how you'd then attach bars.

The only exception I'd make to that is that if you don't get roof rails, do you get another type of fixing point? Even our TT had little flaps that lifted up to allow you to attach roof rails.

THe problem then, was that you had to buy the Audi ones, and they were £250.



Edited by Kell on Tuesday 28th January 15:17

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
I would go for them too. They add practicality to a fairly compact hatch and I think suit the car well too.

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
Can't you haggle with then to add them for free? (I suspect a high profit margin on them)

dododo

761 posts

158 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
Didn't bother on my sportback.

I carry bikes on the roof maybe once a month (during warmer months) and went for Thule bars with changeable feet. I got fed up with buying a roof rack for a car and then the manufacturer forced me to buy completely new bars when they updated the car.

LeoSayer

Original Poster:

7,865 posts

275 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
Dracoro said:
Can't you haggle with then to add them for free? (I suspect a high profit margin on them)
I'll try that but I doubt I can squeeze any more out of the salesman.

I will be paying the deposit on Sunday so it's my last chance to change the spec.



james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
I have some Thule roof bars and feet and they work just fine - They don't mark or make a mess and while the chrome roof bars look nice, I don't regret not getting them:



ETA - If you look for them second hand, the feet for the 8P are the same as the (current) 8V.

LeoSayer

Original Poster:

7,865 posts

275 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
That's great thanks James, just what I needed to see.

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
LeoSayer said:
That's great thanks James, just what I needed to see.
No worries, use this link to biggify smile

https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-ZCokXifZlH4/Uf9...

mattS4

2,117 posts

222 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Is that the thule 750 or 754 foot pack?

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
mattS4 said:
Is that the thule 750 or 754 foot pack?
I'd have to check the box when I get back home, but I think it's the 754 foot pack.

mattS4

2,117 posts

222 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
It's just I have a 750 foot pack and was hoping they're similar in terms of just being able to swap the fitting kit. (I've got the bars and cycle carriers for an A4 saloon, so with a fitting kit swap, for £35, I'm hoping to use them on an S3 sportback)

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
I bought them from a friend who has an 8P sportback and after some research, it showed that they were compatible. I'd lost the measurements that I needed, but it's not exactly rocket science (frustrating in the rain though....)

I will be back home at about 5 ish so I'll have a look at the box then - I can't find the correspondence where the footpack photo was in it...

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Sometimes I'm amazed at the crap I keep on my phone and I was wrong - the footpack is the 750, NOT the 754. This is what I have:




Sorry for the confusion, but, it all works and fits nicely as you can see above.

decadent

2,572 posts

206 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
I have whisper bars which have changeable feet.

Since i've upgraded from a Leon to an Exeo ST with roof bars I have fitting kit 512 going if you went down the whisper route (more aerodynamic bars).


mattS4

2,117 posts

222 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Excellent, cheers James.