is this guy right or wrong
Author
Discussion

binnerboy

Original Poster:

488 posts

181 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
DreadUK said:
The one statutory defence in law (in the UK anyway) for running into the back of someone is that the car in front slowed unexpectedly.

Do you have a problem with that? It is a stated case relative to the Road Traffic Act, has been for more than 40 years.
I think he is wrong as the Highway Code clearly contradicts his statement

covboy

2,593 posts

205 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
I suppose it depends on the circumstances. There seems to be a few examples (see You Tube) of Crash for Cash instances where the following car was NOT in the wrong.

creampuff

6,511 posts

174 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
You may be prosecuted for suddenly slowing without good reason. An example was the motor car driver in L3 of a motorway who braked from 70 to 10mph for no good reason, thus causing the fatal crash of a motorcycle rider behind.

However if you run into the back of someone then almost certainly you will be paying for it.

V8forweekends

2,506 posts

155 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
I am not a lawyer - but I thought Statutory Defence had a particular meaning - i.e. mentioned as a defence in the relevant legislation, rather than a defence that was used successfully in the past and formed part of case law. I very much doubt if there's any such provision in the RTA.

That's different in any case from the question of who pays (as observed above by others already). I'm guessing you could cite contributory negligence if a person in front was brake testing you for no apparent reason.

AJI

5,180 posts

248 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
Sorry to nit-pick your reply here but....

if this is true...
creampuff said:
You may be prosecuted for suddenly slowing without good reason.
then surely this is contradictory..
creampuff said:
However if you run into the back of someone then almost certainly you will be paying for it.
?

It suggests that the person at fault could be the person slowing down without good reason but then if you happen to run in to the back of said person you would be liable to pay for it.

Like I say, sorry to nit-pick, but just checking that I'm following the logic correctly.

V8forweekends

2,506 posts

155 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
AJI said:
Sorry to nit-pick your reply here but....

if this is true...
creampuff said:
You may be prosecuted for suddenly slowing without good reason.
then surely this is contradictory..
creampuff said:
However if you run into the back of someone then almost certainly you will be paying for it.
?

It suggests that the person at fault could be the person slowing down without good reason but then if you happen to run in to the back of said person you would be liable to pay for it.

Like I say, sorry to nit-pick, but just checking that I'm following the logic correctly.
Two separate issues

1) Is someone going to get prosecuted (eg for Due Care)
2) Who is paying

Outcomes may not follow each other - i.e. just because there's no Due Care prosecution doesn't mean my insurer won't pay you if I rear end you.

4lf4-155

700 posts

274 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
I think the point here is that the guy said, possibly miss-understanding what the term means, that there is a statutory defence - there isn't.

There may be case law where the person who hit the car in front was not found to be at fault, nut that's not a statutory defence.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
A statutory defence is, in brief, a defence that is in a statute. There is no such statutory defence as quoted aove.

If you run into the back of another car there is a rebuttable presumption that you were not driving with a big enough gap to stop safely. The facts, as they say, speak for themselves. There are a number of defences to this: mechanical failure, automatism, medical condition, but even these are not even as good as the shields on NCC-1701.

prand

6,246 posts

227 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
AJI said:
?

It suggests that the person at fault could be the person slowing down without good reason but then if you happen to run in to the back of said person you would be liable to pay for it.

Like I say, sorry to nit-pick, but just checking that I'm following the logic correctly.
I also read this as if you ran into someone who had slowed to 10mph on a motorway, then you would be paying in a non financial sense, like the poor motorcyclist mentioned above.

creampuff

6,511 posts

174 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
This is the 10mph/biker fatality case:
http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/420940/Driver-kil...
(just picked the first link from a Google search)

Just because the driver was convicted of dangerous driving does not mean the biker was not also at fault - there was just no point in charging the biker with anything as he was dead.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
There's two distinct parts to the legal process, criminal and civil, each with their own burdens of proof.

Many people can be charged with a driving offence and found not guilty but be 100% liable for the costs of the accident.

KM666

1,757 posts

214 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
Is the issue not the difficulty of proving that the fault lies with the struck car, so fault is assumed?

jith

2,752 posts

246 months

Tuesday 28th January 2014
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
A statutory defence is, in brief, a defence that is in a statute. There is no such statutory defence as quoted aove.

If you run into the back of another car there is a rebuttable presumption that you were not driving with a big enough gap to stop safely. The facts, as they say, speak for themselves. There are a number of defences to this: mechanical failure, automatism, medical condition, but even these are not even as good as the shields on NCC-1701.
Derek, you're a Trekkie!!

Fantastic; I now look upon you in a different light!

J

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
I think the word 'statutory' is confusing matters.

The car in front stopping "unexpectedly" is the only defence that's ever worked afaik.

But "unexpectedly" is a fairly difficult thing to prove and justify.
There would then be the question about the unexpected braking being malice, stupidity, accident, deliberate or mechanical failure.

It could work as a defence; but there would need to be a perfect set of circumstances.

Moonhawk

10,730 posts

250 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
AJI said:
It suggests that the person at fault could be the person slowing down without good reason but then if you happen to run in to the back of said person you would be liable to pay for it.
Well I guess technically - you should always leave sufficient gap assuming the vehicle in front may have to perform an emergency stop (you may or may not be able to see whether there is "good reason" for that stop). An emergency stop is by its very nature "unexpected".

The general rule of thumb is that if you hit them - you didn't leave enough room.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
There's two distinct parts to the legal process, criminal and civil, each with their own burdens of proof.

Many people can be charged with a driving offence and found not guilty but be 100% liable for the costs of the accident.
I hazard a guess that you're referring to the standard of proof required rather than the burden as being different in criminal and civil disputes.

In criminal your defence to a careless driving charge would be that your actions were consistent with that expected of a careful and competent driver. Evidence to support that would be that the other driver slowed down so unexpectedly and quickly that the notional driver would not have been expected to avoid them.

It may be that one, neither or both drivers were guilty of careless driving. The lead driver could have been careless in slowing down without good reason or signal and the following driver in not leaving a sufficient gap to avoid the collision.

But, as Derek has already said, there is no statutory defence relating specifically to a rear end shunt.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
I can't remember the details, so I might be confused on the matter, but wasn't there a case of a driver brake testing another driver he thought, quite rightly as it turned out, was driving too closely to be able to stop in an emergency? The car hit was done for reckless (as was) and the following driver was not prosecuted but only because it was not in the public interest as he was quite seriously injured, the suggestion being that his ws a clear case of careless.

DreadUK

206 posts

163 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
binnerboy said:
DreadUK said:
The one statutory defence in law (in the UK anyway) for running into the back of someone is that the car in front slowed unexpectedly.

Do you have a problem with that? It is a stated case relative to the Road Traffic Act, has been for more than 40 years.
really ? please provide the link to support you statement

from the Highway Code

"126
Stopping Distances. Drive at a speed that will allow you to stop well within the distance you can see to be clear. You should

leave enough space between you and the vehicle in front so that you can pull up safely if it suddenly slows down or stops. The safe rule is never to get closer than the overall stopping distance (see Typical Stopping Distances diagram, shown below)
allow at least a two-second gap between you and the vehicle in front on roads carrying faster-moving traffic and in tunnels where visibility is reduced. The gap should be at least doubled on wet roads and increased still further on icy roads
remember, large vehicles and motorcycles need a greater distance to stop. If driving a large vehicle in a tunnel, you should allow a four-second gap between you and the vehicle in front.
If you have to stop in a tunnel, leave at least a 5-metre gap between you and the vehicle in front."

IANAL




Edited by binnerboy on Tuesday 28th January 15:21
Lets get one thing straight here - The Highway Code is a book of advice, it is not the Law, The Road Traffic Act is! And whilst the Highway Code provides advice on stopping distances, it is nothing more than that, simple advice. From memory, the Road Traffic Act refers to maintaining a safe stopping distance, it is not prescriptive, however as it's a number of years since I used the RTA I'm perfectly happy to be corrected on that. So kindly reserve your patronising 'cut and paste' mentality for someone who might be impressed by your complete lack of insight into the subject. However if you insist on using it as a reference then it also tells you to watch the traffic ahead.....note 'traffic' not 'car' therefore it is not unreasonable to be making full observations, and if an idiot in front of you decides to jump on his brakes, it is perfectly possible to be surprised by the sudden slowing and fail to stop in time.

Perhaps the term "Statutory defence" was the wrong one to use, there are innumerable 'Stated Cases' on the subject which can be cited in a defence. Every case is, of course, considered on it's own merits so if it could be proven from perhaps credible witness statements or traffic cameras that the following driver was, say, tailgaiting (which is subject to interpretation) for example, then of course he's going to be at fault. But in some circumstances the Courts recognise that 'tailgaiting' is considered necessary and normal practise, does ANYONE in rush hour London traffic or M25 tailbacks conform to a 23 Metre gap at 30mph?........Not a chance in hell, queues would be 3 times as long and you would never reach your destination for cars jumping into the gap in front of you. The courts perfectly understand this.

And if you expect ME to find a precise case for YOU to examine you can get lost. If you want to find the evidence to support or refute my contention, get it yourself, I don't give a monkeys if you wander round in blissful ignorance imagining that the Highway Code even scratches the surface of good driving practise or does anything more than give the public a fleeting glimpse of The Road Traffic Act.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
What you meant to say was "I was wrong".

paintman

7,861 posts

221 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
.....and I can't find any stated cases to back up my assertion.
You'll fit in nicelysmile