CGT: Improvements v. Maintenance
CGT: Improvements v. Maintenance
Author
Discussion

Elderly

Original Poster:

3,743 posts

269 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
There is a house with a long term tenant;
its carpeting and décor are probably from the 1950's.

The tenant dies and estate agents are brought in to market the property for sale.

They say that to increase the value of the property, it should be redecorated
re-curtained and re-carpeted with something clean and neutral
(all good sense IMO.).

I know that normal maintenance expenditure (such as decorating) is not allowable as a capital cost BUT ..... "improvement costs to increase the value of the property" are allowed.
So in this case, is the expenditure 'normal maintenance' and hence not allowable against CGT or is it 'improvement costs to increase the value of the property' which is allowable against CGT?

I'm only talking about the gain on sale, I'm not talking about normal maintenance which would have been set off against rental profits; these works were carried out after the tenant had died and the property was never let again - rent does not come into it.

Thanks.


northwest monkey

6,370 posts

220 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
I imagine it would be difficult to say whether new carpets & some paint would actually increase the value of the property. It would definitely increase its desirability, but that is different to value.


Ean218

2,046 posts

281 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
Carpets can be argued as plant, redecoration would more likely be revenue.

Edited by Ean218 on Wednesday 29th January 08:56

Eric Mc

125,936 posts

296 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
The CGT term is "Enhancement" expenditure.

Replacing old carpets or flooring with NEW carpets or flooring is NOT normally looked on as "Enhancement" expenditure UNLESS the new flooring is substantially different and better than what was replaced.

Replacing an old carpet with new wood flooring COULD be interpreted as enhancement (or vise versa) but replacing old wood with new wood or old carpet with new carpet might not.

At the end of the day however, the arguments over such types of expenditure can be a bit esoteric and on the whole, HMRC will mot challenge enhancement costs if the taxpayer has made a reasonable attempt to extract non-enhancement type elements of the expenditure.


Elderly

Original Poster:

3,743 posts

269 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks smile. It's a shame that the HMRC is ambiguous (or esoteric if you prefer) over the word 'Improvement' or 'Enhancement'.

I feel that HMRC's words below could be argued either way but I'm not going to bother trying to claim.






Eric Mc

125,936 posts

296 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
Life is ambiguous and tax law often reflects that. Like a lot of law, interpretation is the most difficult part of the legislation rather than the legislation itself. That's why we have courts and judges.

sumo69

2,164 posts

251 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Life is ambiguous and tax law often reflects that. Like a lot of law, interpretation is the most difficult part of the legislation rather than the legislation itself. That's why we have courts and judges.
...and Accountants??

David

sumo69

2,164 posts

251 months

Wednesday 29th January 2014
quotequote all
I would be tempted to get the works done but get a couple of agents round who agree that it would be necessary to enhance the value.

Ask them if they will do a before and after valuation which you can keep and produce to HMRC as evidence if needed.

My answer would be very different if this was a rental property, but it isn't.

David