Hypothetical legal question 75
Discussion
Another one to try on you.
If person A obtains materials on credit for Limited Company A and then uses those materials do complete a job and gets paid into Limited Company B (both of which he owns), before declaring that Company A is insolvent (due to obviously owing lots of money and never receiving any) then is there any recourse?
I assume it's fraud but I mean recourse to actually getting the money back?
For example- could you sue the director personally for defrauding you?
Could you sue company B with whom you had no contract?
If person A obtains materials on credit for Limited Company A and then uses those materials do complete a job and gets paid into Limited Company B (both of which he owns), before declaring that Company A is insolvent (due to obviously owing lots of money and never receiving any) then is there any recourse?
I assume it's fraud but I mean recourse to actually getting the money back?
For example- could you sue the director personally for defrauding you?
Could you sue company B with whom you had no contract?
blindswelledrat said:
Another one to try on you.
If person A obtains materials on credit for Limited Company A and then uses those materials do complete a job and gets paid into Limited Company B (both of which he owns), before declaring that Company A is insolvent (due to obviously owing lots of money and never receiving any) then is there any recourse?
I assume it's fraud but I mean recourse to actually getting the money back?
For example- could you sue the director personally for defrauding you?
Could you sue company B with whom you had no contract?
How did you end up paying Limited Company B if you had no contract with them for the work?If person A obtains materials on credit for Limited Company A and then uses those materials do complete a job and gets paid into Limited Company B (both of which he owns), before declaring that Company A is insolvent (due to obviously owing lots of money and never receiving any) then is there any recourse?
I assume it's fraud but I mean recourse to actually getting the money back?
For example- could you sue the director personally for defrauding you?
Could you sue company B with whom you had no contract?
If the work was completed to your satisfaction (as I assume it would be if you paid) then how were you defrauded? Yes the supplier of the goods was technically defrauded, but not the customer of the work. Unless your hypothetical is from the point of view of the supplier of the materials? In which case, why did the supplier pay Limited Company B when they had a trade or sales account with Limited Company A?
Edit - just re-read your OP, and I think you are talking from the point of view of the customer, not the supplier, as you mention the supplier was working on a credit basis. So only the supplier suffers in your scenario, as they have extended credit to a company which will not pay them back.
Edited by mattmurdock on Wednesday 29th January 14:23
mattmurdock said:
Edit - just re-read your OP, and I think you are talking from the point of view of the customer, not the supplier, as you mention the supplier was working on a credit basis. So only the supplier suffers in your scenario, as they have extended credit to a company which will not pay them back.
]
Yes that. Client just pays for the work done as normal.]
Contractor gets paid 100% of the job value into Company B but loads 100% of the costs of the job into company A so effectively makes 100% profit on the job whilst the supplier loses 100% of his money.
blindswelledrat said:
Yes that. Client just pays for the work done as normal.
Contractor gets paid 100% of the job value into Company B but loads 100% of the costs of the job into company A so effectively makes 100% profit on the job whilst the supplier loses 100% of his money.
OK - then even if the supplier has evidence that is the situation I'm not sure there is much they can do. If they can prove without a doubt it is fraud, then they can get the police involved and bring criminal charges, but I don't think they would get far with any civil case.Contractor gets paid 100% of the job value into Company B but loads 100% of the costs of the job into company A so effectively makes 100% profit on the job whilst the supplier loses 100% of his money.
Of course, if the supplier knows that the guy has done this, and they have half decent credit underwriters, they should be able to ensure any companies of which this same guy is a director are never extended credit in the future. So he may get 100% profit on each job, but he is going to burn his ability to source materials (and burn through limited companies) so he isn't going to be able to do this continuously. Even if he did, he is going to be increasing the evidence of fraud each time.
If a director orders goods on credit on behalf of a company knowing the company is insolvent, he is probably liable personally to the seller of the goods in deceit (that is, fraudulent misrepresentation) on the basis that the director impliedly represented that the company was in a position to pay.
See the decision in Contex Drouzhba v Wiseman [2006] EWHC 2708 (QB) (Irwin J) and [2007] EWCA Civ 1201, [2008] 1 BCLC 631 (Court of Appeal). Both decisions are on BAILII (http://www.bailii.org/).
See the decision in Contex Drouzhba v Wiseman [2006] EWHC 2708 (QB) (Irwin J) and [2007] EWCA Civ 1201, [2008] 1 BCLC 631 (Court of Appeal). Both decisions are on BAILII (http://www.bailii.org/).
EW109 said:
If a director orders goods on credit on behalf of a company knowing the company is insolvent, he is probably liable personally to the seller of the goods in deceit (that is, fraudulent misrepresentation) on the basis that the director impliedly represented that the company was in a position to pay.
See the decision in Contex Drouzhba v Wiseman [2006] EWHC 2708 (QB) (Irwin J) and [2007] EWCA Civ 1201, [2008] 1 BCLC 631 (Court of Appeal). Both decisions are on BAILII (http://www.bailii.org/).
Very interesting, thanks.See the decision in Contex Drouzhba v Wiseman [2006] EWHC 2708 (QB) (Irwin J) and [2007] EWCA Civ 1201, [2008] 1 BCLC 631 (Court of Appeal). Both decisions are on BAILII (http://www.bailii.org/).
Just reading through this an I'm not certain that you could prove that his intention at the time of signing was to defraud in the more detailed circumstances of the real case. His intention in the end was clearly to defraud, but that case sets a precedent for intention at signing of contracts, if you see what I mean.
Is there a more general rule about suing for fraud?
If I have understood this correctly, the owner (and director/shadow director) of companies A and B is procuring goods on credit for company A, transferring them to company B at nil cost, then having company B do the work for which it receives payment.
Then company A is unable to pay for the goods at the end of the credit period, is insolvent and is wound up/put into administration in an attempt to frustrate the creditor(s). Query: has company A already been wound up/put into administration?
I would expect the creditors to appoint an administrator to company A, at which time the administrators would review the acts of the directors in the time leading up to the insolvency of the company.
If the director(s) have not been fraudulent (which it sounds like they may have been), then transferring the goods to company B at nil cost were almost certainly in breach of their directorial duties pursuant to ss170-177 of the Companies Act 2006.
Depending on the precise circumstances, and the amounts involved, I'd say that your next move would be to instruct solicitors/procure the appointment of an administrator to company A.
Then company A is unable to pay for the goods at the end of the credit period, is insolvent and is wound up/put into administration in an attempt to frustrate the creditor(s). Query: has company A already been wound up/put into administration?
I would expect the creditors to appoint an administrator to company A, at which time the administrators would review the acts of the directors in the time leading up to the insolvency of the company.
If the director(s) have not been fraudulent (which it sounds like they may have been), then transferring the goods to company B at nil cost were almost certainly in breach of their directorial duties pursuant to ss170-177 of the Companies Act 2006.
Depending on the precise circumstances, and the amounts involved, I'd say that your next move would be to instruct solicitors/procure the appointment of an administrator to company A.
OutOfSync said:
Then company A is unable to pay for the goods at the end of the credit period, is insolvent and is wound up/put into administration in an attempt to frustrate the creditor(s). Query: has company A already been wound up/put into administration?
Actually no. This company has filed dormant accounts despite a £10k CCJ. Their accountants who filed it are a bit sheepish but said that the director told them that all trade was done through company BOOS said:
Depending on the precise circumstances, and the amounts involved, I'd say that your next move would be to instruct solicitors/procure the appointment of an administrator to company A.
Too expensive to wind them up and no faith whatsoever in liquidators/administrators doing anything at all about this.Unfortunately too much experience of insolvency practitioners who's standard lines are "I will file my condifential report to the Dti in die course blah blah blah" so that definitely isn't the route for this case.
How you proceed probably depends on the value of the claim.
If it's a large amount then it's at least worth getting an initial opinion from a solicitor. Most solicitors will be willing to meet with you to have a 30min/1hr chat for free to establish the facts before advising whether or not it is worth pursuing.
Then at least you will know your chances of success (ie do you have a decent shot of getting some/all of your money back or would paying a lawyer be throwing good money after bad?)
From the information you've given it seems like there is the basis of a claim against this guy/his companies.
If it's a large amount then it's at least worth getting an initial opinion from a solicitor. Most solicitors will be willing to meet with you to have a 30min/1hr chat for free to establish the facts before advising whether or not it is worth pursuing.
Then at least you will know your chances of success (ie do you have a decent shot of getting some/all of your money back or would paying a lawyer be throwing good money after bad?)
From the information you've given it seems like there is the basis of a claim against this guy/his companies.
As it's all hypothetical anyway, there may be some fellow PHers that may know someone you could redress the balance of things here:-
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


