New parts ordered but supplied used - what are my rights?
Discussion
Evening all,
Recently ordered some parts from a well known specialist Porsche parts supplier.
After a long wait, supposedly due to stock availability coming from Germany, my 'NEW' 997 GT3 bumper was delivered today.
Now, unfortunately the supplier refused to provide any specific dates for delivery and insisted it had to be delivered today (I was told this yesterday). I work in London, and there is no chance I could have today off work to take delivery.
"No worries" I was told by the friendly parts supplier, we'll leave it with a neighbour or around the rear of your house in a safe place.
So, I come home today, inspect the bumper to find that it's not actually NEW but a second hand, damaged repaired bumper.
At no point on the parts suppliers website is or was it ever mentioned that this was a used and damage repaired bumper. They are a large supplier to Porsche parts and are charging the same prices as the OPCs charge for new.
Throughout the whole process it's never been mentioned to me that this would be a used and damage repaired bumper, because I simply wouldn't have bought it if it was!!
From a legal perspective, what are my rights? I'm assuming I'd be covered by trades description or Sale of goods act. Can anyone provide some guidance?
I just want the new bumper which was what I paid for.
The fact that it's used and previously damaged repaired is very evident from the fact that there are filled number plate fixings, damage to catches from previous fitting of lights, and also repaired damage to the top grill, along with remnants of old sticky fixings .



Recently ordered some parts from a well known specialist Porsche parts supplier.
After a long wait, supposedly due to stock availability coming from Germany, my 'NEW' 997 GT3 bumper was delivered today.
Now, unfortunately the supplier refused to provide any specific dates for delivery and insisted it had to be delivered today (I was told this yesterday). I work in London, and there is no chance I could have today off work to take delivery.
"No worries" I was told by the friendly parts supplier, we'll leave it with a neighbour or around the rear of your house in a safe place.
So, I come home today, inspect the bumper to find that it's not actually NEW but a second hand, damaged repaired bumper.
At no point on the parts suppliers website is or was it ever mentioned that this was a used and damage repaired bumper. They are a large supplier to Porsche parts and are charging the same prices as the OPCs charge for new.
Throughout the whole process it's never been mentioned to me that this would be a used and damage repaired bumper, because I simply wouldn't have bought it if it was!!
From a legal perspective, what are my rights? I'm assuming I'd be covered by trades description or Sale of goods act. Can anyone provide some guidance?
I just want the new bumper which was what I paid for.
The fact that it's used and previously damaged repaired is very evident from the fact that there are filled number plate fixings, damage to catches from previous fitting of lights, and also repaired damage to the top grill, along with remnants of old sticky fixings .
DSR rules are your friend, and I'd expect a refund of any/all postal charges as you haven't simply changed your mind, THEY have send you a falsely-described/incorrect part.
However, the Devil's Advocate in my wonders why you paid OPC prices for a part from a 3rd party - why not buy it from an OPC (assuming it was available) and get a proper warranty on the part?
However, the Devil's Advocate in my wonders why you paid OPC prices for a part from a 3rd party - why not buy it from an OPC (assuming it was available) and get a proper warranty on the part?
mmm-five said:
DSR rules are your friend, and I'd expect a refund of any/all postal charges as you haven't simply changed your mind, THEY have send you a falsely-described/incorrect part.
However, the Devil's Advocate in my wonders why you paid OPC prices for a part from a 3rd party - why not buy it from an OPC (assuming it was available) and get a proper warranty on the part?
Fair question - It was marginally cheaper than the price from dealers and the supplier provided the option for delivery which the main dealer wouldn't. Being a bumper I had no way of getting it to and from the dealer. However, the Devil's Advocate in my wonders why you paid OPC prices for a part from a 3rd party - why not buy it from an OPC (assuming it was available) and get a proper warranty on the part?
Re: warranty. I checked this with the dealer network, and they mentioned that any New parts are still covered by warranty, provided it came from an approved re-seller which the supplier is.
Description was brief.... Pasted below...
GT3 Front Bumper
Original Porsche 997 GT3 Kit front bumper, Fits all standard 997 & 997 S models. Polyurethane bumper not fibreglass
But nowhere did it state on the site or any subsequent email confirmation that it was used / damage repaired.
It didn't say it was new either, but this wouldn't be expected. You'd expect it to describe if it was used.
E.g if you went to M&S website and bought some jeans, you wouldn't expect them to describe them as 'New' it's expected. But you would expect them to describe them as used or factory seconds if they were.
This combined with the pricing near matching the dealers implies it's new to me. Either that, or it's intentionally done that way to be misleading.
GT3 Front Bumper
Original Porsche 997 GT3 Kit front bumper, Fits all standard 997 & 997 S models. Polyurethane bumper not fibreglass
But nowhere did it state on the site or any subsequent email confirmation that it was used / damage repaired.
It didn't say it was new either, but this wouldn't be expected. You'd expect it to describe if it was used.
E.g if you went to M&S website and bought some jeans, you wouldn't expect them to describe them as 'New' it's expected. But you would expect them to describe them as used or factory seconds if they were.
This combined with the pricing near matching the dealers implies it's new to me. Either that, or it's intentionally done that way to be misleading.
Think I can find the shop where you bought that. It's on a long list of parts (none described as used), reached via a menu of car models/parts (none described as used).
And there's a typical shopping cart system with a 'Quantity' box to type in. All of which would lead any reasonable person to believe they were buying a new part.
And at £4000, I'd certainly expect a new part.
And there's a typical shopping cart system with a 'Quantity' box to type in. All of which would lead any reasonable person to believe they were buying a new part.
And at £4000, I'd certainly expect a new part.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


