Service history dilemma?
Service history dilemma?
Author
Discussion

GAL001

Original Poster:

1,444 posts

206 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
Right, my friend viewed the yellow Monaro in Scotland for me today and the car is in pretty good nick, but and it's a BIG but, it's missing its last 55000 miles of service history!
Spent most of its life in Ireland, don't suppose it was one of our members cars at all?
In my eyes it's a big risk, what do you all think?
Cheers

lincsls2

4,109 posts

171 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
If the car is priced well and it is in very good order then subject to a thorough inspection and test drive I wouldn't worry too much.
If during an extensive test drive all appears well then it probably is!
There isn't a cambelt to worry about, you could buy it and then take it to a specialist and get a full service done.
Use it as a bargaining tool. Good luck!

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
Yeah who cares, if its fine as mentioned use it to beat them down on price.

preciousmetal

3,373 posts

207 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
Service history is relatively important on these for resale. And it has 55k missing from 80k miles so only 25k history. Check the previous mots online at VOSA and contact last owner to see if it was self serviced

if you are buying it as keeper for years then it wont bother you. But if its only for a couple of years then it won't be easy to sell as you are questioning buying it now.and so will other buyers

Good luck with progress

stick100

7,017 posts

199 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
preciousmetal said:
Service history is relatively important on these for resale. And it has 55k missing from 80k miles so only 25k history. Check the previous mots online at VOSA and contact last owner to see if it was self serviced

if you are buying it as keeper for years then it wont bother you. But if its only for a couple of years then it won't be easy to sell as you are questioning buying it now.and so will other buyers

Good luck with progress
Whs^^^^^


But as with any car buy on condition you can tell a car that's been looked after and one that hasn't

GAL001

Original Poster:

1,444 posts

206 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks all, it's got to be a keeper so will haggle him down, will let you know when I do

Wyld Stallyn

2,056 posts

159 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
GAL001 said:
Thanks all, it's got to be a keeper so will haggle him down, will let you know when I do
Good Luck thumbup and Make Sure BOTH the Keys Work wink

Monaro5.7

7,337 posts

210 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Is it the first 55k missing or it missing after 25k?

GAL001

Original Poster:

1,444 posts

206 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
It's the last 55k

Monaro5.7

7,337 posts

210 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
GAL001 said:
It's the last 55k
Shame if it had been the first 55K it might be in the Vauxhall system somewhere and maybe Dougie could of helped you out with this.

neiljohnson

11,298 posts

238 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
As long as the price of the car reflects this I wouldn't worry

When you come to sell it will be worth less but then you pay less to begin with!!

If the oils are clean & the air filter doesn't look like its Ben in a swamp it will show it has been serviced.

GAL001

Original Poster:

1,444 posts

206 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Sadly the dealer has had it serviced prior to sale so it's all clean, end of the day any 2nd hand car is a risk, just hope the warranty is worth the paper it's printed on!

preciousmetal

3,373 posts

207 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
GAL001 said:
Sadly the dealer has had it serviced prior to sale so it's all clean, end of the day any 2nd hand car is a risk, just hope the warranty is worth the paper it's printed on!
Make sure you do your own HPi check with NMR check and also get MOT test 12 digit no. to check online at www.gov.uk for consistant mileage and you will also see previous MOTs / Failures and advisories plus previous mileages plus where its been for its MOTs ie servicing garages

dealer should have done this himself to chase missing history. if dealer wont give info out start being concerned !! Goodluck

Tattooboy

7,946 posts

209 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
preciousmetal said:
GAL001 said:
Sadly the dealer has had it serviced prior to sale so it's all clean, end of the day any 2nd hand car is a risk, just hope the warranty is worth the paper it's printed on!
Make sure you do your own HPi check with NMR check and also get MOT test 12 digit no. to check online at www.gov.uk for consistant mileage and you will also see previous MOTs / Failures and advisories plus previous mileages plus where its been for its MOTs ie servicing garages

dealer should have done this himself to chase missing history. if dealer wont give info out start being concerned !! Goodluck
Good info and wise words James thumbup

preciousmetal

3,373 posts

207 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Tattooboy said:
preciousmetal said:
GAL001 said:
Sadly the dealer has had it serviced prior to sale so it's all clean, end of the day any 2nd hand car is a risk, just hope the warranty is worth the paper it's printed on!
Make sure you do your own HPi check with NMR check and also get MOT test 12 digit no. to check online at www.gov.uk for consistant mileage and you will also see previous MOTs / Failures and advisories plus previous mileages plus where its been for its MOTs ie servicing garages

dealer should have done this himself to chase missing history. if dealer wont give info out start being concerned !! Goodluck
Good info and wise words James thumbup
Thx Ian, Just tryingf to guide a buyer.

have been in trade long enough now to know the scams people pull, but the online data and info available now is making it safer and easier to check cars out plus good old google search.

The new scam is photo copying MOT and blanking out the advisories side. that's the problem with them being on std A4 paper and not official VOSA paperwork, but usual gov. cutbacks

Lil'RedGTO

808 posts

174 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Not being as mechanically adept as some, service history is important to me when buying a car (together with an inspection by a mechanic). It gives some peace of mind. It's such a valuable and important thing I just cannot understand any owner or dealer who could lose the service history paperwork, and that makes me wary. For that reason I personally would not buy a car without service history. Unless you have your heart set on a yellow Monaro (which don't exactly come up for sale every day) I wouldn't take the risk and would wait for a car where the owner could be bothered to keep the paperwork.

Lil'RedGTO

808 posts

174 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
preciousmetal said:
The new scam is photo copying MOT and blanking out the advisories side. that's the problem with them being on std A4 paper and not official VOSA paperwork, but usual gov. cutbacks
Sneaky! Thanks for the heads up.

GAL001

Original Poster:

1,444 posts

206 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Sadly after missing out on a yellow one previously have my heart set, but will happily walk away if I can't get anymore out of the dealer

stevieturbo

18,107 posts

278 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
preciousmetal said:
Service history is relatively important on these for resale. And it has 55k missing from 80k miles so only 25k history. Check the previous mots online at VOSA and contact last owner to see if it was self serviced

if you are buying it as keeper for years then it wont bother you. But if its only for a couple of years then it won't be easy to sell as you are questioning buying it now.and so will other buyers

Good luck with progress
yes and no.

Some people do obsess about service history. The problem is, and especially with main dealers. A stamped history is often not even worth the ink use to stamp the book with ! Because far too often service work is not carried out correctly, if at all, and parts used, oil etc is often not up to standard.

A lot of dealers a service seems to be washing the car so the customer thinks they've received good service.

I'd sooner buy a car after a good inspection and drive and one that feels good, over one that appears good with a stamped service book, which can often be very misleading.

Now on the other hand if you know who has been maintaining the car and can speak to them and know of their reputation, that is a different story.

But I would never trust a dealer history.

Tattooboy

7,946 posts

209 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
preciousmetal said:
Tattooboy said:
preciousmetal said:
GAL001 said:
Sadly the dealer has had it serviced prior to sale so it's all clean, end of the day any 2nd hand car is a risk, just hope the warranty is worth the paper it's printed on!
Make sure you do your own HPi check with NMR check and also get MOT test 12 digit no. to check online at www.gov.uk for consistant mileage and you will also see previous MOTs / Failures and advisories plus previous mileages plus where its been for its MOTs ie servicing garages

dealer should have done this himself to chase missing history. if dealer wont give info out start being concerned !! Goodluck
Good info and wise words James thumbup
Thx Ian, Just tryingf to guide a buyer.

have been in trade long enough now to know the scams people pull, but the online data and info available now is making it safer and easier to check cars out plus good old google search.

The new scam is photo copying MOT and blanking out the advisories side. that's the problem with them being on std A4 paper and not official VOSA paperwork, but usual gov. cutbacks
Exactly, and as such, buyers should take note of your guidance with interest.

As you say, the on-line check of MOT's will give the buyer knowledge of the mileage history and an easy way to tell if something is not quite right.

It's def something I will remember for future ref.