Vehicle recovery/Insurance claim question
Vehicle recovery/Insurance claim question
Author
Discussion

Jamie P

Original Poster:

4 posts

245 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
(I not sure if this is the correct section to post this)

My car was recently hit whilst parked in the street outside my home, a neighbour passed on their insurance details and I proceeded to claim against them through my insurance. I specified the body shop used and the insurance were happy with this. They did say I would need to pay the £150 excess on the policy upon collection of the vehicle after it was repaired and this would be reimbursed back to me once the claim has gone through.

Just prior to the accident the vehicle dumped its power steering fluid on the road and I was intending to get it repaired.

When I reported the accident I informed the insurance company the vehicle was possibly unsafe to drive.

The body shop called and said the insurance company had advised the vehicle should be recovered to their premises. A low loader was sent and my car is currently being repaired.

I have had a call from the body shop; the insurance assessor has inspected the damage to the car. They have said they are only willing to pay for the damage caused by the accident itself, leaving me with a £100 bill for transporting the car there.

As it is I am insured fully comprehensively and my vehicle was hit by another road user, my insurance is presumably recovering costs from their insurance. I don’t see (morally) how I should be out of pocket for someone else damaging my property. At no stage was it explained I may have to pay for anything other than: the excess and for an optional courtesy car (which I didn’t take as I decided I didn’t need one), both of which I was told I would be refunded once the claim was successfully processed.

I have not yet contacted my insurance company to discuss this and if I am honest I am not sure where I stand legally.

Does anyone actually know?

marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
Was it unsafe to drive because of the accident, or because of the PAS fault which occurred before the accident ?

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
If the collision did not render the car undriveable, and if your car had not been hit by another car, how would you have dealt with the power steering fluid leak? Would you have had the car towed to a garage? Repaired it on the spot? Also, if the collision did not immobilise the car, was the car really undriveable without power steering?

frag68

273 posts

175 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
If the PAS leak was pre existing the insurers will not repair as not accident related. Your policy only covers accidental damage and not mechanical faults and designed to put you back into the position you were in pre accident.

So if the impact resulted in panel damage only, the car may have been legally driveable hence the bill for recovery for a potentially unrelated matter

Best speaking with the chap from the insurer who inspected your car for clarification.

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
As said already your insurance won't pay for it and nor should they, nor should the other person's insurance.

Out of interest isn't there some sort of rule about repairing cars on the public highway too?

littleredrooster

6,417 posts

227 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
frag68 said:
If the PAS leak was pre existing the insurers will not repair as not accident related. Your policy only covers accidental damage and not mechanical faults and designed to put you back into the position you were in pre accident.

So if the impact resulted in panel damage only, the car may have been legally driveable hence the bill for recovery for a potentially unrelated matter

Best speaking with the chap from the insurer who inspected your car for clarification.
He's not asking about a repair to the PAS, he's asking about them not paying the transport costs for picking it up and taking it to the body shop. Read the OP.

Jamie P

Original Poster:

4 posts

245 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
The vehicle was not drivable before the accident. I understand that the fact that the accident had absolutely nothing to do with the car being un-drivable.

I had planned to repair the car myself at a later date, although I fail to see how that has any relevance to the situation.

As it stands it appears I will be spending money on transportation fees as a result of the accident that I otherwise would not be.

I am not trying to argue the case that I should/should not foot the bill for shipping the car because I’m sure that is debateable, that was not the intention of my post.

That said, on a personal note, I’ll be disappointed if I do have to shell out. Like may others I, hate how people see it their right to milk the system, and that goes both ways customers/scammers of insurance companies and the companies themselves. I could have taken a courtesy car which would have been at great expense considering the time my car has been off the road. I didn’t because I have access to another car and figure the cost eventually filters back to us in our premiums.

I just wanted to know if anyone knows where I stand legally. Basically am I legally obligated to pay it?


Edited by Jamie P on Saturday 1st February 15:47


Edited by Jamie P on Saturday 1st February 15:48

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
I question whether a car that has a power steering fault is undriveable (t is not so long ago that few cars had power steering, although of course modern cars are all horribly heavy), but never mind that. The insurer's point is, I take it, that the transport costs arose from the pre-existing fault, not from the accident damage.

Alucidnation

16,810 posts

201 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
A car that has hydraulic PAS is almost impossible to steer with it not working.

The best ones are when the belt is slipping. biggrin

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
Jamie P said:
The vehicle was not drivable before the accident. I understand that the fact that the accident had absolutely nothing to do with the car being un-drivable.

I had planned to repair the car myself at a later date, although I fail to see how that has any relevance to the situation.

As it stands it appears I will be spending money on transportation fees as a result of the accident that I otherwise would not be.

I am not trying to argue the case that I should/should not foot the bill for shipping the car because I’m sure that is debateable, that was not the intention of my post.

That said, on a personal note, I’ll be disappointed if I do have to shell out. Like may others I, hate how people see it their right to milk the system, and that goes both ways customers/scammers of insurance companies and the companies themselves. I could have taken a courtesy car which would have been at great expense considering the time my car has been off the road. I didn’t because I have access to another car and figure the cost eventually filters back to us in our premiums.

I just wanted to know if anyone knows where I stand legally. Basically am I legally obligated to pay it?
I simply cannot beleive you do not think you should pay.

The car was undrivable prior to the crash end of.
You then dictated that it he'd to be recovered due to a fault not relating to the crash.

Jamie P

Original Poster:

4 posts

245 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan,

The PAS system has a hydraulic pump that is belt driven by the engine, running the pump dry (due to the leak) will cause damage to the pump.

Other than fixing the leak and adding fluid, the only other way around it would be to remove drive to the pump. This would not be possible as the belt drives other ancillaries.

Jamie P

Original Poster:

4 posts

245 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
TPS,

My opinion is kind of irrelevant, I just want to know if I must pay or not.

General Fluff

478 posts

168 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
TPS said:
I simply cannot beleive you do not think you should pay.

The car was undrivable prior to the crash end of.
You then dictated that it he'd to be recovered due to a fault not relating to the crash.
I'm not sure it's that clear cut. I can see the insurance company's point but you might argue that the OP should be put back in the position he was before the accident. Car parked outside without damage.

Also, if they were going to charge him for the recovery then they should have told him that before they booked it. He may have chosen to find another way to get it to the garage or maybe delay the repair a week to give him time to fix the PAS beforehand.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,280 posts

181 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
It's a tricky one. Had it not been for the power steering fault, the car could have been driven to the garage to have the accident damage fixed. Had it not been for the accident, the OP would never have had a bill for taking the car to the garage as he would have repaired it in situ.

I would point this out to insurers and see if they would agree to pay 50% of the recovery costs in the circumstances.

barker22

1,037 posts

198 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
Wouldn't the insurance company have normally recovered the car there and back anyway?

jellypig

112 posts

178 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
barker22 said:
Wouldn't the insurance company have normally recovered the car there and back anyway?
Thats what I was thinking
- costs incurred using "standard methodology" down to the Insurance company.
- Extra over costs due to "unusual methods" required due to pre-existing mechanical condition of the vehicle - down to the OP.

But if the two are the same...

TwigtheWonderkid

49,280 posts

181 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
barker22 said:
Wouldn't the insurance company have normally recovered the car there and back anyway?
They might have sent someone to pick it up, so the OP wasn't inconvenienced, but they wouldn't arrange recovery of a drivable car, and the extra expense that involves.

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
They might have sent someone to pick it up, so the OP wasn't inconvenienced, but they wouldn't arrange recovery of a drivable car, and the extra expense that involves.
and the OP chose his own garage rather than the Insurers own approved repairers

Who me ?

7,455 posts

243 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
dabouch- your problem .IMHO, I as the insured have the right to decide who repairs my vehicle. He decided likewise that the garage he trusted should do likewise. It would be repaired by folk he trusted. I can echo his sentiments.I once had a company vehicle shunted so bad it needed a re-shell. it was returned from a main dealer, but it developed major problems and was returned to a dealer I trusted, where major faults were discovered. The report simply said that the vehicle had not been repaired to the standard expected by a main dealer of that maker.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 1st February 2014
quotequote all
Fair enough re the power steering, but that means that the insurer isn't on the hook for the cost of transporting the car for panel repairs.