Audi s4 avant 4.2 v8 - workhorse am I mad ?
Audi s4 avant 4.2 v8 - workhorse am I mad ?
Author
Discussion

dank

Original Poster:

1,160 posts

283 months

Sunday 2nd February 2014
quotequote all
So looking for a replacement workhorse, family car, and can't get the b6 s4 v8 out of my mind, am I seriously deluded thinking I can run one of these for not mega bucks? Looking at 6k cars, avants, manual and ideally Nogaro blue, they all seem very high miles, over 100k, but have seen one with Cambelt done on schedule and fsh, what's people's opinions, I know an rs4 would cost more than my 911 turbo to run, but need a workhorse that won't cost the earth, but still gives me some fun if working a long way away.


Ant1984

141 posts

178 months

Sunday 2nd February 2014
quotequote all
I think it all depends on how many miles you will be covering. I have just bought a B7 S4 avant and have justified it to myself due to the relative lack of mileage that i cover.

I had (and still have until its sold) an A6 2.5 tdi and by comparison the mpg of the S4 is woeful but sometimes there is more to life than mpg ;-)

Also, no cambelt on the V8, its a chain.

Ant

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 2nd February 2014
quotequote all
They do not have much rear legroom so may not be suitable for a family unless the kids are small or the front seat passengers are not tall, an S6 has a lot more room.

I have a B7 S4 avant and really enjoy it, mpg is around 20 but they are not cheap cars to look after.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 2nd February 2014
quotequote all
They do not have much rear legroom so may not be suitable for a family unless the kids are small or the front seat passengers are not tall, an S6 has a lot more room.

I have a B7 S4 avant and really enjoy it, mpg is around 20 but they are not cheap cars to look after.

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Workhorse that doesn't cost the earth
If you're doing big mileage apparently the auto is better ratio for better mpg
But I believe people are still talking like 20mpg, so that would be the main cost factor on a daily basis

As above not cambelt as cam chain and apparently important to have regular servicing/ new oil

I'm looking to at similar price range, but for a cabriolet

Pentoman

4,838 posts

294 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Have wondered the same.

I imagine that they are like any Audi A4, with increased fuel costs.

Owner's opinions welcomed though which will probably show that I and OP are way, way off.

In a very similar vein, I've been curious about this

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/used-cars/mercedes-ben...

VeegasS4

367 posts

188 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
As an owner of a B7 S4 avant with the auto box, happy to share my thoughts.

Upkeep and cost are all relative, as one of the other posters has said, it's just like any other audi, but more cylinders and likes petrol.

Honest mpg for me, is 23 to 25 with a mix of town and Nsl driving, along with some blats thrown in for good measure. Servicing should be kept up and oil changes are a must.

Rear legroom isn't great, but the seats are very comfortable and an adult can fit in okay with a reasonable sized person in the front. Boot is okay sized but not huge, lengthwise with the seats flat will get you something about 7 foot in length in.

Gearbox in the auto is spot on, 6 gears gives okay economy at 70/80 and sport mode gives 5 well spaced gears for making progress.

I love mine, I've spent the last 5 years or so looking for the perfect fast estate and this is my ideal ( others are C5 RS6, S6, Subaru forester XT and Sti, Passat R32, 535d) only thing I'd swap for is a new S4.

Look put for a decent one with a decent history and you can't go wrong.

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Veegass4
Did you consider manual, are you much a manual lover smile

VeegasS4

367 posts

188 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
My track and weekend blast car (MR2 Turbo) is a manual, as was a number of my previous cars, so definitely a fan of a well balanced three pedal set up.

I didn't try a manual in the S4, due to hearing that it wasn't all that. Considering the type of driving I do in the S4, read lazy, the auto suits, but when you do want to press on, the gear change is in all honesty quicker than I could do.

Happy to answer any specifics.

Cheers

Steve

AudiWurst

4,826 posts

258 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Pentoman said:
I imagine that they are like any Audi A4, with increased fuel costs.
Presume that statement refers to the ownership costs and not the driving experience!

As well as increased fuel costs, there are increased tyre costs, a 4WD drivetrain to maintain, an auxilliary radiator exclusive to the V8 cars mounted in a damage-prone position, as well as the "S tax" on parts exclusive to the S4/RS4.

Tony Hetherington's thread is worth reading if you haven't already read it.

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Yes like an A4 but more expensive.

For example a set of tyres will last no more than 15000 miles, replacement cost for decent rubber £700-800, ditchfinders are cheaper but not recommended. A replacement clutch and flywheel from Audi dealer £2500, replacement of timing chain guides is around £5000 from a dealer, front discs and pads £750 fitted. These are without doubt cheaper at an independent specialist but still not what you call cheap.

The engine takes best part of 10 litres of oil for a service so thats £80-100 just on oil, twice the number of spark plugs so just like an A4 then :-)

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Audiwurst, good link


Phil Dicky

7,194 posts

294 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
gottans said:
Yes like an A4 but more expensive.

For example a set of tyres will last no more than 15000 miles, replacement cost for decent rubber £700-800, ditchfinders are cheaper but not recommended. A replacement clutch and flywheel from Audi dealer £2500, replacement of timing chain guides is around £5000 from a dealer, front discs and pads £750 fitted. These are without doubt cheaper at an independent specialist but still not what you call cheap.

The engine takes best part of 10 litres of oil for a service so thats £80-100 just on oil, twice the number of spark plugs so just like an A4 then :-)
All valid costs, but who would honestly pay 6k for an Audi (OP's budget) then take it a main Audi dealer...specialist all the way.

Pentoman

4,838 posts

294 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for those replies - and sorry for my minor thread hijacking!

Those parts costs sound similar to my AMV8 so hardly sensible as a cheap everyday commuter but as someone else said, I'm sure things would be a lot cheaper away from a main dealer.

But I still just like the idea of it as something that's a sleeper, something more special and rare than the ubiquitous 2.0 Tdi.

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
I've checked out prices of brakes and service parts via euro car parts and seems reasonable so any Indy garage can fix

But the main risk is if the engine needs to be worked on

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Ah glad someone linked to my thread - hopefully that helps a lot with costs.

You're right, the engine needing to be worked on would be big money, but (touch wood), I've not heard any horror stories about it. There are the common things that people have mentioend in this thread (radiators, for example), none of which are mortgage-busting money to fix.

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
I run a high-mileage B6 avant (just ticked past 150k). I've had it for two years and (touch wood) the only costs have been servicing, fuel(!) and a set of tyres all round (came in at about a grand for Pirellis).

Mine likes a drink of oil, so I've upped the thickness a bit (running on 5w 40 rather than 0w 30), and plugs don't seem to last very long (the ones I had put in 12 months ago will need replacing at the next service this month). These issues may be mileage related.

Great cars imho, some people say they're not 'fast'. I can only imagine that they mean in comparison with a Zonda, as, for an innocuous family estate, they are properly quick.

comp80

12 posts

202 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Two words - Buy it!!!

I have had manual sedan over two years now, and can honestly say that of the 21 cars I have owned over the last 17 years, it's brought more smiles per mile than any other. Always choose it over my Giulietta QV or the WRX RA when I go for a drive.

Only mods (prior to me) are RS4 style 19's, and a more vocal exhaust. Have done about 30,000km in it so far, and have no intention of selling any time soon. I'm up to 185,000km and the only problems have been a window regulator, split CV boot and a suspension arm bush.

Cons
Fuel econo not amazing (but not bad either for the HP). I get ~12.5l/100km with very spirited combined driving
Heavy wear on tyre edges, both front and rear (expect no more than about 25,000km on NZ's coarse chip roads). Not helped by driving style either.
Bose Symphony II sound is terrible. And has a tape deck. In 2004?!? In the process of changing.
Uses about 9 litres of fancy oil for a service.
Heavy on brakes. Not helped by driving style.

Pros
Sound at full song. Ahh-mazing.
Torsen ATB diffs in the wet (with ESC off)
Smooth power delivery, revs very freely
Seats
Gearbox
Compact(ish) size

For those that are saying that this is a 'lazy' car and suits an auto, I think they need to try the manual. For a V8, it's not huge capacity, and so doesn't have huge torque (~410Nm)... But if you want to hear it sing, give it the beans and have some fun! smile

Hope this helps!



MattS3

2,117 posts

222 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Great car.
I ran a manual for the last 7 years, but at 11 years old and coming up to 100k miles, it was only a matter of time before it needed a clutch and/or potential cam chain guide issues. (it would seem they are starting to crack with more frequency around the 90-100k mileage band)
If they'd have required doing, I would have sorted them, but then would have needed to keep the car for another 2-3 years to get the value back, if I'd just ploughed £2-3k into it.

I decided against the risk and bought a replacment car as didn't want to keep the S4 as it was getting old and would then need suspension.

If you get one, make sure you get a Milltek, it transforms the sound. Loved it.

20mpg over the 60k miles I did, and keep an eye on the oil consumption, they do like a drink.


comp80

12 posts

202 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
MattS3 said:
Great car.
...coming up to 100k miles, it was only a matter of time before it needed a clutch and/or potential cam chain guide issues.

If you get one, make sure you get a Milltek, it transforms the sound. Loved it.
Very interesting that you've found this to be common. I did a lot of research on higher mileage vehicles before I purchased mine, and couldn't find too much other than one thread on the cam chain guide. I had read a lot about the engines being fairly bulletproof (as I reach out to touch some wood), so I'm servicing regularly and hoping for the best!

My exhaust sounds very similar to this catless Milltek:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iyb1EhPeD6M