Audi TTS or Scirocco R?
Author
Discussion

davey68

Original Poster:

1,199 posts

268 months

Sunday 2nd February 2014
quotequote all
Hi, looking at one of these as a new car, around £18k to spend. Looking for comparisons/experience. TTS seems to be rated quicker off the line but is that down to 4wd traction? once rolling is there much between them (scirocco lighter?). More importantly, what is the steering/ride/handling like on them? which is better? I've read that the adaptive ride on scirocco is pretty good even on 19s, TTS ride even with mag ride can be a bit firm. Running costs presumably similar. I think i'd get a slightly newer scirocco but which is the better drivers car? Dr G any experience of the two?

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Try both as would be down to personal opinion, your body frame, size, weight, eye level in seat may feel completely different in each

I personally would go tts, more coupe than hatchback looking in my eyes

scherzkeks

4,460 posts

165 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
As nice as the Scirocco is to drive and look at, the TTS is at another level both objectively and subjectively. The TTS will do just about whatever you want on the road or track; I think the only real neg is the mediocre steering feel (but honestly even most RWDs also have that these days).



Edited by scherzkeks on Monday 3rd February 10:25

dododo

761 posts

158 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
TTS. It's faster, drives better and is a lot of fun to drive. The Scirocco won't maintain the smile on your face the longer you have it because it is duller.

Deerfoot

5,258 posts

215 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Scirocco R for me. More exclusive than the TT, more practical and, in my eyes at least, a more cohesive design.

Driving wise I doubt there'll be much difference.

Lostprophet

2,549 posts

200 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
I asked myself this very question a few years ago...

And it defo had to be the TTS!!!!! Without a doubt! 4 wheel drive, great engine, extremely rapid... good resale values!

Edited by Lostprophet on Monday 3rd February 17:48

SMB

1,523 posts

297 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
dododo said:
TTS. It's faster, drives better and is a lot of fun to drive. The Scirocco won't maintain the smile on your face the longer you have it because it is duller.
Now to me, I have to say the TTS was the duller drive, faster maybe,even probably, but the scirocco r is pretty much just as fast. The Audi wins the badge snobs war but generally lacks steering and suspension feel, so not sure you would ever call it an entertaining/enthusiasts drive.

The scirocco wins on practicality, with bigger interior/boot space, and as far as VW interiors go a nice place to be. And as said elsewhere there are only 700 Scirocco R's registered in the UK, getting on for 2000 TTS so is also more exclusive. Exclusivity will likely protect values longer term.

Autocar also prefered the R over the TTS.
http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-categories/hot-hatche...


ubbs

711 posts

248 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
dododo said:
TTS. It's faster, drives better and is a lot of fun to drive. The Scirocco won't maintain the smile on your face the longer you have it because it is duller.
I drove both prior to purchasing my scirocco r apart from the grip at launch once moving they were both the same if anything the r felt a smidge quicker maybe down to the dsg (tts was manual) as for driving dynamics I miss the rear end adjustability of the r in my current 4 wheel drive audi

davey68

Original Poster:

1,199 posts

268 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the feedback! I'd expect in real world driving the Scirocco would be as quick as the TTs (50kg lighter, less drivetrain losses front to 4wd). I like the styling particularly with the R spoilers etc and really like the 19 talladega alloys. Interior I think the TTS is nicer, and the proper 4 seat practicality isn't that critical to me (drive an S2000). I'd think the TTS in all weathers would put the power down better as even with an electronic diff the Scirocco might scrabble the front wheels but overall its a tough choice. Think I need to drive both. Still interested in steering/ride/handling comments from those who owned/driven either.

ubbs

711 posts

248 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Another thing is tyre choice on the r mine came with Dunlop's which were garbage in the wet, I replaced them with Goodyear asymmetrics which were much better grip wise, I'll be doing the same when the continental 5s wear out on the rs3
Ubbs

ubbs

711 posts

248 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Any excuse for a pic

davey68

Original Poster:

1,199 posts

268 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Nice car mate! Does it have leather or cloth?

ubbs

711 posts

248 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Spec was
Dsg
19" tallagadas
Leather
Reflex silver
Covered centre console cup holders
Rear cup holders
Covered ashtray
(I had the above fitted from the golf r much nicer!)
It only had 13k on it when I p/x it for the rs Leeds VW only had it for a week before somebody snapped it up it was absolutely unmarked.
If the new one gets 300 ps and a mechanical diff I'd have one in a heartbeat

sumo69

2,164 posts

251 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
There isn't going to be a new Scirroco R alongside the Golf R - it has been dropped from the range.

David

SMB

1,523 posts

297 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
sumo69 said:
There isn't going to be a new Scirroco R alongside the Golf R - it has been dropped from the range.

David
Do you have inside knowledge to that effect or just using the fact it's been dropped short term until the facelift arrives later this year? Various press article refer to it's return in 2015.

scherzkeks

4,460 posts

165 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
SMB said:
Now to me, I have to say the TTS was the duller drive, faster maybe,even probably, but the scirocco r is pretty much just as fast. The Audi wins the badge snobs war but generally lacks steering and suspension feel, so not sure you would ever call it an entertaining/enthusiasts drive.

The scirocco wins on practicality, with bigger interior/boot space, and as far as VW interiors go a nice place to be. And as said elsewhere there are only 700 Scirocco R's registered in the UK, getting on for 2000 TTS so is also more exclusive. Exclusivity will likely protect values longer term.

Autocar also prefered the R over the TTS.
http://www.autocar.co.uk/car-categories/hot-hatche...
What is this link showing? I see only Autocar's top-five hot hatches. The TT is a coupe.

SMB

1,523 posts

297 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
scherzkeks said:
What is this link showing? I see only Autocar's top-five hot hatches. The TT is a coupe.
depends on your definition of a coupe vs a hatch, you can argue either car either way. But the TT doesn't make either the top coupe or top hatch list

scherzkeks

4,460 posts

165 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
SMB said:
depends on your definition of a coupe vs a hatch, you can argue either car either way. But the TT doesn't make either the top coupe or top hatch list
I don't think so. A hatch is more utilitarian. And as far as the AC lists, the hot hatch field is less competitive from a performance standpoint than the coupe field in which the TTS would be pitched against some pretty serious hardware.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
sumo69 said:
There isn't going to be a new Scirroco R alongside the Golf R - it has been dropped from the range.

David
That's not correct - it has only been dropped from the current range.

Source - http://www.pistonheads.com/news/default.asp?storyI...

Edited by andrewparker on Tuesday 4th February 15:01

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
scherzkeks said:
I don't think so. A hatch is more utilitarian. And as far as the AC lists, the hot hatch field is less competitive from a performance standpoint than the coupe field in which the TTS would be pitched against some pretty serious hardware.
Most magazines have tested the TTS alongside the Scirocco and Peugeot RCZ. Hardly serious hardware.