Question about ebay purchase
Discussion
Hi all. I made a purchase on ebay. The item was not as described (damaged).The advert clearly states that it is down to the buyer to pay any return postage costs. However, is this the case if the item is not as described (damaged)?
Just to be clear the damage did not occur in transit. It is quite obvious that it was dispatched in this state.
Any help would be much appreciated.
Just to be clear the damage did not occur in transit. It is quite obvious that it was dispatched in this state.
Any help would be much appreciated.
Unless they specifically state in their T&Cs that they will refund your return postage, it's usually a given. I bought some motorcycle gloves from Ghostbikes once, using their sizing instructions which were not accurate. They would not pay my return postage so I left neg feedback. Then commence a tit-for-tat feedback war which did neither of us any good. I don't bother leaving neg anymore even if I'm dissatisfied. In the end no one, who is looking to trade, is any the wiser anyway
You have to pay the postage to return. I once sold a G27 wheel on eBay that had no clamps as described in the adverts so sold it cheap, two weeks later got an email saying the wheel wasn't performing as it should (it was) they had to pay the postage. ironically when I took it out the box to test it it was working fine. obviously hadn't realised you can't get the clamps as spares. annoyed me greatly at least I didn't have to pay for the return. On the brightside I then sold it to someone who had messaged me previously about it who just missed out on the winning bid who snapped it up off me after explaining what happened.
If the seller has sent you an item that is damaged prior to despatch and has made no mention of it in their listing, then you should be expecting a full refund including postage.
You would not have bought the item in the first place if you had known it was damaged, so why should you be left out of pocket now by having to pay for its return?
You would not have bought the item in the first place if you had known it was damaged, so why should you be left out of pocket now by having to pay for its return?
Rubin215 said:
If the seller has sent you an item that is damaged prior to despatch and has made no mention of it in their listing, then you should be expecting a full refund including postage.
You would not have bought the item in the first place if you had known it was damaged, so why should you be left out of pocket now by having to pay for its return?
If you bought an item from a shop then found it was broken when you got home would you ask for your petrol and parking costs to be refunded?You would not have bought the item in the first place if you had known it was damaged, so why should you be left out of pocket now by having to pay for its return?
Negative Creep said:
If you bought an item from a shop then found it was broken when you got home would you ask for your petrol and parking costs to be refunded?
Not quite the same though is it. Buying on Ebay is putting faith in someone else - that the seller has described it correctly & that they can package it safely enough to get to you in one piece.I'm an Ebay seller & occasionally we'll send something out that may have a fault on we hadn't noticed. We'll refund the postage if we want it back or we'll send out a replacement & tell the buyer to bin or keep the original.
Negative Creep said:
Rubin215 said:
If the seller has sent you an item that is damaged prior to despatch and has made no mention of it in their listing, then you should be expecting a full refund including postage.
You would not have bought the item in the first place if you had known it was damaged, so why should you be left out of pocket now by having to pay for its return?
If you bought an item from a shop then found it was broken when you got home would you ask for your petrol and parking costs to be refunded?You would not have bought the item in the first place if you had known it was damaged, so why should you be left out of pocket now by having to pay for its return?
This situation though is very very different.
If you are buying in a shop you have the opportunity to inspect the goods.
Buying off ebay you don't, so the distance selling regulations apply.
These state clearly that the seller is responsibe for the cost of returning faulty goods.
http://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/regulation/...
If a seller has failed to mention damage to an item then he has misled you; again, why should the buyer be left out of pocket?
Rubin215 said:
Actually, yes, I have asked for and received compensation for my inconvenience from Argos, Ikea and Costco to name but a few. Most major retailers will give you a voucher or a discount if you complain.
This situation though is very very different.
If you are buying in a shop you have the opportunity to inspect the goods.
Buying off ebay you don't, so the distance selling regulations apply.
These state clearly that the seller is responsibe for the cost of returning faulty goods.
http://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/regulation/...
If a seller has failed to mention damage to an item then he has misled you; again, why should the buyer be left out of pocket?
Thats business sellers only. This situation though is very very different.
If you are buying in a shop you have the opportunity to inspect the goods.
Buying off ebay you don't, so the distance selling regulations apply.
These state clearly that the seller is responsibe for the cost of returning faulty goods.
http://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/regulation/...
If a seller has failed to mention damage to an item then he has misled you; again, why should the buyer be left out of pocket?
The distance selling regulations don't deal with faulty goods: they deal with cancelling contract to bridge the gap between sales with an opportunity to inspect and distance sales.
Sale of Goods Act covers faulty goods and describes what should happen. In general it means the retailer should cover the cost of refund / replacement or repair -- at the retailer's choice -- including the cost of moving the goods around -- to and from the retailer.
Simple in cases of a postable item, but less clear if you buy a bed and ship it to the moon. Does the retailer then need to go to the moon to get it back? (Which - broadly - is the crux of a court case I'm looking at at the moment)
eBay's returns process is modernising to reflect this -- the managed returns process is used by some retailers and is going to be rolled out more widely. eBay contract with collect+ to make the return and then charge either the buyer or the seller according to whomever the buyer says is at fault. Can anyone guess who is going to be paying?
Sale of Goods Act covers faulty goods and describes what should happen. In general it means the retailer should cover the cost of refund / replacement or repair -- at the retailer's choice -- including the cost of moving the goods around -- to and from the retailer.
Simple in cases of a postable item, but less clear if you buy a bed and ship it to the moon. Does the retailer then need to go to the moon to get it back? (Which - broadly - is the crux of a court case I'm looking at at the moment)
eBay's returns process is modernising to reflect this -- the managed returns process is used by some retailers and is going to be rolled out more widely. eBay contract with collect+ to make the return and then charge either the buyer or the seller according to whomever the buyer says is at fault. Can anyone guess who is going to be paying?
The DSR do deal with faulty goods in respect of costs of return. See Regulation 14. The retailer is not permitted to charge for the return of goods where the buyer has a legal right to return the goods, for example, under the SOGA's implied term of quality and fitness.
If a consumer has a right to reject faulty goods the retailer does not have a right to repair or replace them at its discretion.
If a consumer has a right to reject faulty goods the retailer does not have a right to repair or replace them at its discretion.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


