Would You Have Bought This Privately??
Would You Have Bought This Privately??
Author
Discussion

TVR4500cc

Original Poster:

188 posts

207 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
Would you have invested over £60k in a car privately??

I've sold my gorgeous 11,500 mile R8 V10 coupe to Hippo in Blackburn, and wondered if I should have tried to sell her privately first.

Too late now but would be handy for future reference.

Shmee

7,565 posts

244 months

Monday 3rd February 2014
quotequote all
I had many private offers selling my R8 V10 last month and did eventually sell it privately. The offers tended to be over the trade price (just) but obviously most people played hard to get as with any value car when it came to concluding a deal.

TVR4500cc

Original Poster:

188 posts

207 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Cheers, perhaps next time I should give it a whirl.

Here's a pic

Did you sell using PH? Is it worth the agro / risks?

Anyone else successfully sold cars of this value privately?

Or, any of you guys bought privately at this money?

My past experience of selling was the more ££ the fewer private buyers so less chance of a sale.

Sarnie

8,379 posts

240 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Sold all my cars privately, would never let a dealer bend me over at both ends of a deal. It takes a bit more due diligence from both parties but invariably will return more than a dealer will offer. You will always get the idiots who text "80g's $ ya ride bruv?" but they are pretty easy to weed out. I also refuse to talk about what I will accept for the car with people that haven't been to see the car...

Shmee

7,565 posts

244 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
I've always put my cars on PH and on Auto Trader but truth be told all the sales have come from AT in the end.

With my Aston before I was looking for a really quick sale so took the first private offer that was over the trade price and I recall that was about £2,500 over, then with the R8 I was quoted trade at £55k from 3 places straight off the CAP list but two small traders offered me the same low 60s figure. I had about 10 private offers all in the low 60s so it was a waiting game until my demands and a buyer agreed.

As mentioned before you do have to deal with a lot of people just calling and dreaming but at the end of the day it's going to make you £5k or more above what you'd get from a dealer, and save the buyer £5k or so. It's vital for private sales that the car comes with some warranty though.

Martian O

2,734 posts

193 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Sarnie said:
...I also refuse to talk about what I will accept for the car with people that haven't been to see the car...
confused

Why? A genuine question because it's pointless in investing time showing/driving a potential buyer around your car only to find out that you're miles apart on the deal.

If I'm buying a car, I'll always ask what the bottom line is after talking about the car to make sure it's the right one, I also don't want to travel hundreds of miles to see a car that I can't afford because the seller isn't negotiable over the phone.



DKL

4,997 posts

253 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
I'm with Sarnie here. If you want to negotiate you do it in person.

Martian O

2,734 posts

193 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
DKL said:
I'm with Sarnie here. If you want to negotiate you do it in person.
When I bought my 360, I didn't want the 400 mile round trip to be a wasted weekend and journey, it made sense to ask the question beforehand,

Sarnie

8,379 posts

240 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Martian O said:
confused

Why? A genuine question because it's pointless in investing time showing/driving a potential buyer around your car only to find out that you're miles apart on the deal.

If I'm buying a car, I'll always ask what the bottom line is after talking about the car to make sure it's the right one, I also don't want to travel hundreds of miles to see a car that I can't afford because the seller isn't negotiable over the phone.
Because invariably these questions are from complete timewasters hoping to strike it lucky with one desperate seller.

I'd be much more amenable to negotiating the deal once I know the buyer is genuine, has come to view the car and wants to do a deal to buy it. Rather than trying to knock an obligatory 10% off the price before turning up and then moaning about all and sundry to drive the price down further.

Martian O

2,734 posts

193 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Sarnie said:
Because invariably these questions are from complete timewasters hoping to strike it lucky with one desperate seller...
Invariably is the key word here, not all of us are timewasters, I have bought many cars which I have negotiated deals over the phone and then turned up and bought at that price (as long as the seller has been honest about it's condition etc).

topless360

2,763 posts

249 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Martian O said:
Invariably is the key word here, not all of us are timewasters, I have bought many cars which I have negotiated deals over the phone and then turned up and bought at that price (as long as the seller has been honest about it's condition etc).
I'm with you on this, when buying the 360 I got a full description of the car from the seller (private) and we agreed a price over the phone.

We then set a date, I went to see it, everything was as described so I went ahead with the purchase.

I would much rather have a deal sorted before hand, so then it is just a case of turning up and ensuring everything is as described. If it is, then you can go ahead with the deal, if it isn't then you can negotiate accordingly. I don't have the time to be travelling to see a car without any idea of whether the seller is negotiable. It saves both the seller and buyers time ultimately.

Coming back to the OP, whilst not at your level of value, I did buy mine privately and was happy with everything. Of course, it doesn't come with the standard 3 month warranty that dealers would provide but as long as you do your due diligence then there is no reason I wouldn't buy private again.

Mario149

7,789 posts

209 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Shmee said:
It's vital for private sales that the car comes with some warranty though.
I'd say very beneficial if it's manufacturer's (extended) warranty because it's still a new car. But realistically on something like a 10+ year old Ferrari/Lambo it's a bit pointless. Max payouts are low if you could even actually get them to cough up, I seem to recall the one for my 550 being a 3rd party's 'gold' policy or some such that McGurk supplied and raved on about. I remember looking at the details of it and thinking it'd barely cover the equivalent cost of a major and belts from an Indy let alone if something serious went pop hehe


Edited by Mario149 on Tuesday 4th February 15:36


Edited by Mario149 on Tuesday 4th February 15:37

F355spider

1,395 posts

262 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Sold my 430 spider privately a few weeks ago via the club scuderia classifieds.

No hassles and no cost!

4DAM

20 posts

204 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
This is a very interesting discussion as I am currently looking for a 360 as a private sale.

I think if the buyer is genuine and asks reasonable, sensible questions then I can't see why a seller would not consider discussing money over the phone. The deal clearly will eventually come down to money so why leave that last bit out? The main part?

It would save the prospective buyer and seller time if each describes their position exactly as it is.

To the seller of the R8, just out of curiosity, did you check the 'Wanted' adverts prior to selling your car to the aforementioned dealer? The reason I am curious is I was considering placing a Wanted Advert but wondered how productive they actually are.

Mario149

7,789 posts

209 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Tbh, I'm not totally sold (see what I did there wink ) on this discussing price on the phone thing before they've even seen it. When I advertised my 355 I asked a very sensible price (actually, I didn't even have to, a PHer bought it from me via word of mouth and I didn't have to advertise) and what I thought the car was worth itself, with the option of chucking in the Capristo for another £1k as it had 2nd hand value on its own and the new owner may not have wanted it.

In the end I sold the car for asking price which we agreed when he came to see it if I recall and effectively threw the in the Capristo for free as

a) the new owner was happy to go ahead without making me wait for an inspection to be done and I was in a hurry to sell
b) I was about to put 1k miles on it on a final weekend or 2 away on the continent and I had £2k of his money in my bank account as his good faith deposit

....deal done, you rub my back and I'll rub yours. If someone had rung me up and said "seen the ad, what'll you take for it?" without having even seen the car the answer would be "what it says in the ad unless you can give me a reason why it is worth less without even seeing it". Why should I chip my sensible price already when they might just have another go at chipping further when they arrived/got it inspected etc later?

If someone rang up the day I put the ad up and said "Love the car, think the price is good, can you do me £500 off in good will if I turn up tomorrow, the car is as described, and I do a CHAPS to your account and we'll have lunch while the funds clear before me driving it home", then I'd almost certainly say yes, quid pro quo

I guess it's an attitude test combined with the fact that it's not that difficult to price a (not particularly rare) car sensibly to sell. I do the latter so the potential purchaser has to pass the former. And if you're not willing to drive for a few hours to go see a car AND don't want to pay a (what is presumably a) sensible asking price, then I would tentatively suggest that you're probably interested in the wrong car.

Edited by Mario149 on Tuesday 4th February 17:51


Edited by Mario149 on Tuesday 4th February 17:52

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
I've always sold privately (and through PH)... An AM V8 Vantage, Ferrari 430, Lamborghini Gallardo... You have to weigh the buyer up as much as they are you!

About to put the LP560 on as well. You just have to price it lower than the dealers so that both parties gain something from doing things privately.

Andy M

3,755 posts

290 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
I've sold a few cars through PH, though never for as high as £60k (I think the highest has been mid-30s).

I'm currently selling a 2 year old Jag XF S and have never had so many timewasters contact me, some very obviously attempting to be fraudulent.

Each has followed a similar theme:

First email is in perfect English, and requests more photos (interior, exterior and engine bay). The second email, in broken English, goes on to request:

1. Current mileage
2. V5 registration document serial number (The V5 serial number should be 2 letters followed by 7 numbers on the front page)
3. V5 registration document issue date
4. MOT certificate number
5. when was the car last serviced and where?
6 . which dealer you purchased the car from and are you the 1st owner


I'm happy to provide the service history, current mileage, the reg plate and the VIN but not the V5 serial etc.

What could they be up to? Attempts to clone the vehicle?

TVR4500cc

Original Poster:

188 posts

207 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Good comments everyone, interesting to get wider opinion on the question

Surprised that so many would buy privately to save a couple of £1k or sell privately to potentially make a couple of £1k

I'm happy with my cash sale, maybe I could have got a bit more ££ but then I could have lost so much more too.

Certainly avoided lots of car washing and hanging about.

And it allowed me to rush out and buy a lovely tweeked T350C too and get a litte cash discount.

I did check the wanted adds, and would defo respond to these in the future - there were no private wanted adds. There were lots of we want your car adds on PH, the one I contacted never even had the decency to call or mail me back with an offer.

If you're after a quick fair trade sale, worth contacting Hippo.

Likewise if you want a lovely V10 R8 ;-) I'm now realising how fast and truly competent that car was.

Shmee

7,565 posts

244 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
On my car there was a 5 figure spread between what the trade offered me and what private offers were coming in at. What surprised me most about that was that it implied a trade seller would re-advertise the car for at least £15k more than they were offering me.

I'd definitely argue for £1k it's a waste of time, but when you're talking £5k plus that is always going to depend on each person's individual situation but worth it in my opinion - it's not *too* much hassle.

magnum555

473 posts

190 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Andy M said:
I'm happy to provide the service history, current mileage, the reg plate and the VIN but not the V5 serial etc.

What could they be up to? Attempts to clone the vehicle?
With the V5 serial number they could be checking previous mot's online.