eBay Competition
Discussion
Hi All,
Looking for some wisdom and of course to have a little rant.
I started my online business selling items on eBay approx 6 months ago and I have been very fortunate to have done well.
I have noticed that competition is very strong as is expected on eBay as your range of competitors are across the UK ranging from small businesses right up to huge companies selling volumes.
What I cannot comprehend is this strategy of selling "cheap" or at a loss in order to get rid of the competition.
E.g. There is a beauty item I sell and when I first started to sell it there was only one other seller in the market place and so I priced mines exactly the same as his/hers, provided good information on product and our customer service and that was it.
Since then I have done well on the product - other sellers have seen this and gone NUTS - 20 other big sellers decided to come in at 50% off and sell them by the bucket which I know for a fact is making no money at all or very little at maybe 10p a unit. Most you would sell a day of this product is 30.
I have seen this happen A LOT where it seems to be sellers are willing to make a loss to get to the stage of showing on their listing they sold the most so "SOLD 4,400" units. GREAT Wo Ho Amazing!
What is the point if you made a loss to get there?
I know some have mentioned this is a strategy to purely get rid of the competition so they stop selling it, but do they honestly think that once they have done it, that no other seller will do the same: come in 50% off.
so whats the bloody point when you have made sweet F*** ALL in the process of making your figures look great.
Do that many sellers forget the underlying purpose of running a business!!!!!!! MAKE A BLOODY PROFIT!!!!!!!
Or have I missed something?
Looking for some wisdom and of course to have a little rant.
I started my online business selling items on eBay approx 6 months ago and I have been very fortunate to have done well.
I have noticed that competition is very strong as is expected on eBay as your range of competitors are across the UK ranging from small businesses right up to huge companies selling volumes.
What I cannot comprehend is this strategy of selling "cheap" or at a loss in order to get rid of the competition.
E.g. There is a beauty item I sell and when I first started to sell it there was only one other seller in the market place and so I priced mines exactly the same as his/hers, provided good information on product and our customer service and that was it.
Since then I have done well on the product - other sellers have seen this and gone NUTS - 20 other big sellers decided to come in at 50% off and sell them by the bucket which I know for a fact is making no money at all or very little at maybe 10p a unit. Most you would sell a day of this product is 30.
I have seen this happen A LOT where it seems to be sellers are willing to make a loss to get to the stage of showing on their listing they sold the most so "SOLD 4,400" units. GREAT Wo Ho Amazing!
What is the point if you made a loss to get there?
I know some have mentioned this is a strategy to purely get rid of the competition so they stop selling it, but do they honestly think that once they have done it, that no other seller will do the same: come in 50% off.
so whats the bloody point when you have made sweet F*** ALL in the process of making your figures look great.
Do that many sellers forget the underlying purpose of running a business!!!!!!! MAKE A BLOODY PROFIT!!!!!!!
Or have I missed something?
kiethton said:
If they are confident in selling at such substantial volume are you sure that they haven't managed to obtain a cheaper price from the supplier/manufacturer?
That way they can still trade profitably yet under-cut you?
In all honesty - its a very cheap small item. I actually get it for 10pence delivered to my door. So even if they got it free its only a difference of 10pence and doesn't explain the massive difference in sales price they are willing to sell for. That way they can still trade profitably yet under-cut you?
Fees - Royal Mail - paypal are going to be near enough the same give or take 2% if your lukcy so its not a case of getting it cheaper or their operating costs being cheaper.
Also its more a case of now that a few of the sellers have got to "sold 2500" they have put their price up to the same as mine.
However there is an influx of new sellers selling cut price to get to the same level. Pointless as far as I am concerned.
Edited by IATM on Tuesday 4th February 13:52
Years ago we were selling a training CD on eBay for £22.00, free postage. They cost us £3.50 + VAT from memory so it was a nice little earner.
First competitor appears & drops the price to £14.99 - why? Naturally we dropped ours but only to £14.95, continued selling well.
Before long several foreign sounding gentlemen from certain Northern cities were counterfeiting them & selling them at £6.50, they even copied our listing word for word!
Unfortunately the publisher wasn't too bothered, it was only a small part of their much larger business so we just dropped out of it & left them to it.
First competitor appears & drops the price to £14.99 - why? Naturally we dropped ours but only to £14.95, continued selling well.
Before long several foreign sounding gentlemen from certain Northern cities were counterfeiting them & selling them at £6.50, they even copied our listing word for word!
Unfortunately the publisher wasn't too bothered, it was only a small part of their much larger business so we just dropped out of it & left them to it.
LordHaveMurci said:
Years ago we were selling a training CD on eBay for £22.00, free postage. They cost us £3.50 + VAT from memory so it was a nice little earner.
First competitor appears & drops the price to £14.99 - why? Naturally we dropped ours but only to £14.95, continued selling well.
Before long several foreign sounding gentlemen from certain Northern cities were counterfeiting them & selling them at £6.50, they even copied our listing word for word!
Unfortunately the publisher wasn't too bothered, it was only a small part of their much larger business so we just dropped out of it & left them to it.
Exactly this! Haha. I don't understand it. If it was me and I managed to locate the product at the same price as you I would advertise it selling it at the same price as you. First competitor appears & drops the price to £14.99 - why? Naturally we dropped ours but only to £14.95, continued selling well.
Before long several foreign sounding gentlemen from certain Northern cities were counterfeiting them & selling them at £6.50, they even copied our listing word for word!
Unfortunately the publisher wasn't too bothered, it was only a small part of their much larger business so we just dropped out of it & left them to it.
At a cost price of the product at 3.45+VAT, the minimum I would like to sell the item for is 9.99 - below that and it starts getting into being a waste of time.
Before I take on a product to sell I take into account how much I will have left after taking into account, VAT, cost of selling and even though I don't have the following costs I still take them into account to see if its worthwhile to sell in the future such as staff costs etc.
If there buying for 10p and there making 10p before packaging, shipping and staff costs maybe they see it as worth wile if there also doing the same on 100,000 items +
Not saying we would bother, but some people will happily sell anything for a profit, even if its so small!
The only real way we make good money on the bay is by selling stuff we control, Own branded or imported product.
However it requires storage and capital to buy.
If the item is no longer worth you while move on and find something else.
However we find its sometimes nice to sell items in smaller volume but lots of different products.
This way competitors dont really bother, and we maintain a good variation of sales.
We do have a product similar to the one you mention however.
We import and sell it to a large amount of UK independent retailers and big chains so we import it any ways.
we sell it to the trade for around £6-7 delivered.
and we started to sell it online ourselves for £20
the same product now retails at £10 online and the person buying it, buys it through our sister company at £6
The item has to be shipped packet 1st class at least due to size and weight.
thats £2.29+ Vat
So before overheads they already make a 1.33 loss...
However we get huge orders monthly for it all paid up front...
Ebay is just a big puzzle, full or people subsidising or hoping to own the market one day...
It hasn't effected our sales to shops so we cant really complain, and we still sell them online at £12.00 making decent money...
Some people are just clueless or are doing something they shouldn't.
Not saying we would bother, but some people will happily sell anything for a profit, even if its so small!
The only real way we make good money on the bay is by selling stuff we control, Own branded or imported product.
However it requires storage and capital to buy.
If the item is no longer worth you while move on and find something else.
However we find its sometimes nice to sell items in smaller volume but lots of different products.
This way competitors dont really bother, and we maintain a good variation of sales.
We do have a product similar to the one you mention however.
We import and sell it to a large amount of UK independent retailers and big chains so we import it any ways.
we sell it to the trade for around £6-7 delivered.
and we started to sell it online ourselves for £20
the same product now retails at £10 online and the person buying it, buys it through our sister company at £6
The item has to be shipped packet 1st class at least due to size and weight.
thats £2.29+ Vat
So before overheads they already make a 1.33 loss...
However we get huge orders monthly for it all paid up front...
Ebay is just a big puzzle, full or people subsidising or hoping to own the market one day...
It hasn't effected our sales to shops so we cant really complain, and we still sell them online at £12.00 making decent money...
Some people are just clueless or are doing something they shouldn't.
Some products just become commoditised, keep expanding your business with new lines at the right price and it won't be a problem would be my advice. On eBay it's not so much what you sell as how cheap you can send it and how much you can buy items for.
Perhaps there's a slightly different way you could sell them? Multi-quantity, sell as job lots, sell as a kit with other items, etc.
Always look for advice about eBay, there's plenty of people out there who could blow you away with excellent advice, contacts, etc.
Perhaps there's a slightly different way you could sell them? Multi-quantity, sell as job lots, sell as a kit with other items, etc.
Always look for advice about eBay, there's plenty of people out there who could blow you away with excellent advice, contacts, etc.
Maybe these products are loss-leaders, intended to get the customer on board where they might just spring for a better delivery at extra cost, or buy something else while they're on there, or maybe it's worth it to get the customer contact details to steer them to the sellers own site. Maybe some of them are slightly more sinister money-laundering things - I can't see how that would work unless the seller can buy the product in cash, but then I don't know much about money-laundering anyway.
Selling at a loss purely to get rid of the competition on eBay would seem a bit short-sighted - as soon as one seller goes, another two will pop up, it would be a never-ending process surely.
Selling at a loss purely to get rid of the competition on eBay would seem a bit short-sighted - as soon as one seller goes, another two will pop up, it would be a never-ending process surely.
IATM said:
Hi All,
Looking for some wisdom and of course to have a little rant.
I started my online business selling items on eBay approx 6 months ago and I have been very fortunate to have done well.
I have noticed that competition is very strong as is expected on eBay as your range of competitors are across the UK ranging from small businesses right up to huge companies selling volumes.
What I cannot comprehend is this strategy of selling "cheap" or at a loss in order to get rid of the competition.
So basically (apologies for being so cut throat in my reply) you typed a generic but popular product search into ebay - saw how many they sold and then - went with your own or someone elses decision "yeah you'll sell loads!" or perhaps your own intuition - bought loads in thinking "we'll be millionaires rodders" but infact failed to keep tabs on your competition?? Please do correct me if im wrong.Looking for some wisdom and of course to have a little rant.
I started my online business selling items on eBay approx 6 months ago and I have been very fortunate to have done well.
I have noticed that competition is very strong as is expected on eBay as your range of competitors are across the UK ranging from small businesses right up to huge companies selling volumes.
What I cannot comprehend is this strategy of selling "cheap" or at a loss in order to get rid of the competition.
There will ALWAYS be someone with more investment funds and cheaper postage rates.
The thing is businesses (with decent rates) WILL cotton on to products such as the one you are ranting about and WILL be able to compete and WILL have the capacity to sell a huge volume - thats not to say they will make a profit. But remember - do they do the math you do? - do they work out X % on eBay/FVF/PayPalFees? - Yes/No. So many things to think about but that shouldn't really matter.
What matters is your business at the end of the day. If you are not making a profit on the product that is all that matters. There is no point pissing all over competitions sales if you are not making a profit.
You move on.
End of my rant.
pmcuksnapper said:
IATM said:
Hi All,
Looking for some wisdom and of course to have a little rant.
I started my online business selling items on eBay approx 6 months ago and I have been very fortunate to have done well.
I have noticed that competition is very strong as is expected on eBay as your range of competitors are across the UK ranging from small businesses right up to huge companies selling volumes.
What I cannot comprehend is this strategy of selling "cheap" or at a loss in order to get rid of the competition.
So basically (apologies for being so cut throat in my reply) you typed a generic but popular product search into ebay - saw how many they sold and then - went with your own or someone elses decision "yeah you'll sell loads!" or perhaps your own intuition - bought loads in thinking "we'll be millionaires rodders" but infact failed to keep tabs on your competition?? Please do correct me if im wrong.Looking for some wisdom and of course to have a little rant.
I started my online business selling items on eBay approx 6 months ago and I have been very fortunate to have done well.
I have noticed that competition is very strong as is expected on eBay as your range of competitors are across the UK ranging from small businesses right up to huge companies selling volumes.
What I cannot comprehend is this strategy of selling "cheap" or at a loss in order to get rid of the competition.
There will ALWAYS be someone with more investment funds and cheaper postage rates.
The thing is businesses (with decent rates) WILL cotton on to products such as the one you are ranting about and WILL be able to compete and WILL have the capacity to sell a huge volume - thats not to say they will make a profit. But remember - do they do the math you do? - do they work out X % on eBay/FVF/PayPalFees? - Yes/No. So many things to think about but that shouldn't really matter.
What matters is your business at the end of the day. If you are not making a profit on the product that is all that matters. There is no point pissing all over competitions sales if you are not making a profit.
You move on.
End of my rant.
When I sold on there, I found that you had to be creative to compete with people like this.
Pointless trying to complete on price, so go for a different angle, group products together to add value or make postage more attractive for the customer. They may be tempted to buy as group of products if the mailing price is the same or a little more.
It really is a cut-throat place to sell.
Pointless trying to complete on price, so go for a different angle, group products together to add value or make postage more attractive for the customer. They may be tempted to buy as group of products if the mailing price is the same or a little more.
It really is a cut-throat place to sell.
IATM said:
Since then I have done well on the product - other sellers have seen this and gone NUTS - 20 other big sellers decided to come in at 50% off and sell them by the bucket which I know for a fact is making no money at all or very little at maybe 10p a unit. Most you would sell a day of this product is 30.
Something not right here.Sounds like you buy this item in at £0.10 a unit and sell it at £0.40 a unit. You sell 210 a week (assuming 7 day trading). So £63 a week gross profit. £3,000 a year is OK but its not going to make you rich.
Competitors are now selling it at 100% mark-up, which is 50% less than you are selling it for. Your prices are too high.
Have you moved the decimal in your example? It would explain a lot. Dealing in pounds and not pence would make all the difference and on this basis I'd in no way surprised you've been undercut but competitors are still happy with 100% gross margin.
Wow quite a few different answers and its good to see different view points however my underlying question which I was looking for opinions on is why do sellers have the need to come in and start selling a product at say 50% off the normal market sales price; make little to no money in the process and as soon as they can see they have sold more than you, put up the price to match yours?
Its not a case of volumes being sold, bigger sellers coming in and bullying little sellers. That is not what I am referring to - Its more to do with the strategy of selling cheap in the beginning to put prices up later.
Its not a case of volumes being sold, bigger sellers coming in and bullying little sellers. That is not what I am referring to - Its more to do with the strategy of selling cheap in the beginning to put prices up later.
The secret to eBay is buying stock. If someone is importing the item you are selling, then someone else can buy it and WILL sell it cheaper than you. Ebay is a race to the bottom.
I started selling watches that I bought in the UK at wholesale and then sold on eBay. Pointless, ended up working hours for .20p.
So as a way to get stock that others cant or to minimise the amount of competitors, I started breaking cars, two per month gives me around £3k, still way less than if I could get a job. But its better than the dole. Just came over very depressed
I started selling watches that I bought in the UK at wholesale and then sold on eBay. Pointless, ended up working hours for .20p.
So as a way to get stock that others cant or to minimise the amount of competitors, I started breaking cars, two per month gives me around £3k, still way less than if I could get a job. But its better than the dole. Just came over very depressed

whythem said:
So as a way to get stock that others cant or to minimise the amount of competitors, I started breaking cars, two per month gives me around £3k, still way less than if I could get a job. But its better than the dole. Just came over very depressed
Do you specialise in breaking particular cars or brands or do you pretty much break anything?
Sorry for the thread hijack!
there is a really big seller on ebay call babz and they have a score of 3 million+
there was a post on here a while back about them how they make a loss or very little profit on a lot of items just to get high score and the top of the listings. there are some lines they make good profit on and when they kill competition on some lines they raise their prices
to do this they must have a lot of cash as they seem to hold alot of stock.
there was a post on here a while back about them how they make a loss or very little profit on a lot of items just to get high score and the top of the listings. there are some lines they make good profit on and when they kill competition on some lines they raise their prices
to do this they must have a lot of cash as they seem to hold alot of stock.
It's just the way eBay works unfortunately. If you sell something which is easy to purchase (or make) then your competitors will find it easy to purchase or make too, and those who are well established can accept smaller profit margins.
I used to sell limited edition t-shirts from Japan and eventually competition caught on, and we kept lowering the price competing with each other and eventually having to sell at a loss just to clear stock. To be honest I do similar myself now in the opposite sense. I search competitors and see what is selling well, then find the cheapest supplier and sell it a few pennies cheaper. It's a race to the bottom, and then someone has to give up and move onto the next product.
It's also worth noting those who can sell in really large numbers get discount on eBay fee's, and could negotiate with postage companies too, which allows them to sell at a much lower rate. The same with packaging too. I found all those things cut into profit so much, many items become a waste of time. I refuse to sell anything without £8 profit per item unless I can shift a lot of them as it's really not worth the hassle of writing up an advert, filling out those endless eBay boxes, trips to the post office, and of course writing down addresses and taping up boxes.
When my Grandmother was in her working age, she ran her own florist shop and went out of business due to Tesco. No suppliers could sell her flowers lower than Tesco were selling them to the public for. It's the same thing really, some of the eBay sellers are much larger than you realise.
I used to sell limited edition t-shirts from Japan and eventually competition caught on, and we kept lowering the price competing with each other and eventually having to sell at a loss just to clear stock. To be honest I do similar myself now in the opposite sense. I search competitors and see what is selling well, then find the cheapest supplier and sell it a few pennies cheaper. It's a race to the bottom, and then someone has to give up and move onto the next product.
It's also worth noting those who can sell in really large numbers get discount on eBay fee's, and could negotiate with postage companies too, which allows them to sell at a much lower rate. The same with packaging too. I found all those things cut into profit so much, many items become a waste of time. I refuse to sell anything without £8 profit per item unless I can shift a lot of them as it's really not worth the hassle of writing up an advert, filling out those endless eBay boxes, trips to the post office, and of course writing down addresses and taping up boxes.
When my Grandmother was in her working age, she ran her own florist shop and went out of business due to Tesco. No suppliers could sell her flowers lower than Tesco were selling them to the public for. It's the same thing really, some of the eBay sellers are much larger than you realise.
IMHO ebay is a good example of the free market at work.
I used to run an ebay biz, and would sell some stuff at a loss in order to generate a flow of folks to my store, once I got them used to buying stuff from me rather than our competitor I could sell them more stuff at a profit. I could also move them away from buying on ebay and into our regular online shop, which had less overheads. IT worked quite well. Cash flow, not cash, is king.
I used to run an ebay biz, and would sell some stuff at a loss in order to generate a flow of folks to my store, once I got them used to buying stuff from me rather than our competitor I could sell them more stuff at a profit. I could also move them away from buying on ebay and into our regular online shop, which had less overheads. IT worked quite well. Cash flow, not cash, is king.
steebo888 said:
there is a really big seller on ebay call babz and they have a score of 3 million+
[other stuff I can't fit in due to stupid iPhone]
to do this they must have a lot of cash as they seem to hold alot of stock.
I know one of the people that supply babz, maybe their biggest supplier, (my friend in turn actually makes a lot more money) and I happen to know the business makes a lot of profit. They buy at the right price, sell loads of lines with lots of stock and sell as much as possible.[other stuff I can't fit in due to stupid iPhone]
to do this they must have a lot of cash as they seem to hold alot of stock.
The problem isn't the eBay competition it's that your business model can be so easily copied that your business is doomed to fail as your only levers are price and eBay feedback profile.
Others copy your business model by getting great feedback then kill you on price. You need to think up a better business model.
Others copy your business model by getting great feedback then kill you on price. You need to think up a better business model.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


