Should rape suspects be named?
Should rape suspects be named?
Author
Discussion

Mill Wheel

Original Poster:

6,149 posts

227 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
In the light of comments in the celebrity abuse allegations thread, I thought it pertinent to ask for views on this separately.

When a celebrity is named, then everybody must realise that their identity can be in little doubt to a victim.

Some victims seem to go first to the press with their story. I can understand that if they are not doing that for money, then it could be that they want support from others - fearing the ordeal of a trial on their own, or thinking they would not be believed.

For other suspects, revealing their names might not mean much to another victim - if they did not know who the attacker was.
In those cases, there is little to be gained by releasing their names as an investigative tool.

When there is a pattern of repeated abuse involving multiple victims and attackers, the argument becomes complex, and also the police do not seem able to keep a lid on their investigations.
Names leak out even when the police do not wish them to.

In this weeks Daily Mail...
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2272253/Ti...
No mention of the alleged perpetrators.

But simply enter "The Elm Guest House" into Google and the alleged perpetrators in this case are an open secret, with various blogs, and even a YouTube video detailing the people allegedly being investigated.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vv05Ul8iCGU

THAT is not the way the alleged perpetrators should be revealed, as all manner of speculation and fiction become rife before the details are known.

So, are the authors of blogs, videos etc. in breach of any laws;
are they hindering the investigations;
and if the allegations are true, how much pressure can be put on police officers to drop cases - or destroy evidence? That seems a bit far fetched to me...!

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Mill Wheel said:
When a celebrity is named, then everybody must realise that their identity can be in little doubt to a victim.

For other suspects, revealing their names might not mean much to another victim - if they did not know who the attacker was.
A complication is: what is celebrity? I have no knowledge of soap operas & therefore the names mean nothing to me, even though others in the world can tell you their life history.

How do you decide who is likely to be known & who is not?

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
I am against any kind of secret court. Historically "Rule of Law" is the exception.

We need to string up journalists until they responsibly report "accused" and "accuser" without prejudice. Obviously, we don't need a court of any kind for that - a CV will do. hehe

markiii

4,340 posts

225 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
either name the alleged victim and alleged perpetrator or neither

there are as many women these days who would make up an allegation as men who would commit the crime

all IMHO of course

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Do we know the name of the woman who "cannot remember it but thinks it happened" in the DLT case? I would like to give her a very wide berth in future.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
The issue in rape cases is always that emotion gets intertwined with logic.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,280 posts

181 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
markiii said:
there are as many women these days who would make up an allegation as men who would commit the crime
Any evidence for this? You're seriously saying that for every genuine sexual attack, there is a made up allegation of a sexual attack!

I don't think I've ever read such tripe.

markiii

4,340 posts

225 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
I said IMHO

I believe it, I don't need to prove it

your are free to believe differently, but I've known more women who have lied about their men than men who were guilty of whats alleged (not rape persee)

one mate in particular is being accused by his ex of beating her up to the point of miscarriage before they split.

Did he? nope, is the vindictive bh using it to cause him pain as she hates he is happy with the new mrs.

yep


Edited by markiii on Wednesday 5th February 13:43

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Any evidence for this? You're seriously saying that for every genuine sexual attack, there is a made up allegation of a sexual attack!

I don't think I've ever read such tripe.
7% of rape claims result in conviction.

Feminists cite this as poor prosecution rates, the other side might cite this as malicious allegations.

The truth is probably in between, but these are the known facts.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
markiii said:
there are as many women these days who would make up an allegation as men who would commit the crime
Any evidence for this? You're seriously saying that for every genuine sexual attack, there is a made up allegation of a sexual attack!

I don't think I've ever read such tripe.
I agree.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Any evidence for this? You're seriously saying that for every genuine sexual attack, there is a made up allegation of a sexual attack!

I don't think I've ever read such tripe.
You need to read more. The statistics for false accusations by repeat accusers are eye-watering.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
markiii said:
I said IMHO

I believe it, I don't need to prove it

Edited by markiii on Wednesday 5th February 13:43
Indeed, you can believe anything you want. It's a free country.

However holding such a view without any evidence to support it except anecdotes is bloody stupid. Given the seriousness of the offence one would hope that people's opinions on the subject would be considered and based on the what facts were availible. Cleary with you this is not the case.

markiii

4,340 posts

225 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
then as per the previous poster point go do your research on false reports and conviction rates

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Any evidence for this? You're seriously saying that for every genuine sexual attack, there is a made up allegation of a sexual attack!

I don't think I've ever read such tripe.
7% of rape claims result in conviction.

Feminists cite this as poor prosecution rates, the other side might cite this as malicious allegations.

The truth is probably in between, but these are the known facts.
Surely the truth is that in many cases rape comes down to my word against yours. Hardly supprising that it's hard to gain a conviction.


grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
Surely the truth is that in many cases rape comes down to my word against yours. Hardly supprising that it's hard to gain a conviction.
Now who is holding a view without evidence to support it?

markiii

4,340 posts

225 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
this is true and under a he said she said scenario your basically saying

the man is the type to commit a horrid offence against the woman or
the woman is the type to commit a horrid offence against the man

in the absence of any additional evidence I'm no more inclined to believe one over the other


Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
grumbledoak said:
Devil2575 said:
Surely the truth is that in many cases rape comes down to my word against yours. Hardly supprising that it's hard to gain a conviction.
Now who is holding a view without evidence to support it?
I was simply putting forward a hypothesis. If you have evidence that it isn't the case then please say.

How about some evidence of your eye watering stats?

A quick google would suggest that anywhere between 2 and 10% of rape accusations are thought to be false.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,280 posts

181 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
grumbledoak said:
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Any evidence for this? You're seriously saying that for every genuine sexual attack, there is a made up allegation of a sexual attack!

I don't think I've ever read such tripe.
You need to read more. The statistics for false accusations by repeat accusers are eye-watering.
rofl

Let's see these eye watering stats then. Don't keep them to yourself.

markiii

4,340 posts

225 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
I find it odd that the old argument gets trotted out that a woman wouldn't lie about a rape simply because of the pain involved in reporting it.

This conveniently forgets that whilst I'm sure its a trauma for the woman that really has been raped to report it.

For one who is lieing their is no trauma to relive, because it simply didn't happen.