Protected no claims
Author
Discussion

Patrick Bateman

Original Poster:

13,219 posts

205 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Is it worth it?

I'll have 5 years NCB come the start of next month. Currently got a quote of under £500 with the 5 years NCB and 5 years driving. £540 if I include protected no claims.

Assuming a scenario where I had to claim and lost all my NCB the price is around £1200. Are there any catches to adding it to the policy? I've seen people rubbishing the idea before but it seems like a sensible option from where I'm sitting given the significant jump in price should they be lost.


Mave

8,217 posts

246 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
Is it worth it?

I'll have 5 years NCB come the start of next month. Currently got a quote of under £500 with the 5 years NCB and 5 years driving. £540 if I include protected no claims.

Assuming a scenario where I had to claim and lost all my NCB the price is around £1200. Are there any catches to adding it to the policy? I've seen people rubbishing the idea before but it seems like a sensible option from where I'm sitting given the significant jump in price should they be lost.
As a warning, if you protect it it doesn't mean you'd still pay £540 if you have a bash. You'd essentially keep the same percentage discount, but your underlying premium would increase due to the bash. So it might be that your underlying premium went from, say, £1200 to £2400, and so your discounted premium with protected NCB would go from £540 to £1080.

Patrick Bateman

Original Poster:

13,219 posts

205 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Mave said:
As a warning, if you protect it it doesn't mean you'd still pay £540 if you have a bash. You'd essentially keep the same percentage discount, but your underlying premium would increase due to the bash. So it might be that your underlying premium went from, say, £1200 to £2400, and so your discounted premium with protected NCB would go from £540 to £1080.
I checked that by adding in a non-fault claim and then an at fault claim. The premium didn't change with the non-fault, rose to a bit over £700 with the at fault. Fairly reasonable in comparison with no NCB though. Think I'll go for it unless someone can convince me otherwise.

dazz1871part2

234 posts

162 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Iv just done my insurance and got it for £150 more.

Upthejunction

108 posts

157 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Nope, not worth a penny.
I have 4 NCB and don't protect any of them

Patrick Bateman

Original Poster:

13,219 posts

205 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Upthejunction said:
Nope, not worth a penny.
I have 4 NCB and don't protect any of them
Care to elaborate given the differences in premiums I was quoted with/without the protection?

fastcarl

254 posts

251 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
I have had two claims in two years with protected and no increase worth mentioning, first I rear ended someone, second I destroyed my own car, a bad 12 months driving,lol


carl

stemll

5,656 posts

231 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
Mave said:
As a warning, if you protect it it doesn't mean you'd still pay £540 if you have a bash. You'd essentially keep the same percentage discount, but your underlying premium would increase due to the bash. So it might be that your underlying premium went from, say, £1200 to £2400, and so your discounted premium with protected NCB would go from £540 to £1080.
I checked that by adding in a non-fault claim and then an at fault claim. The premium didn't change with the non-fault, rose to a bit over £700 with the at fault. Fairly reasonable in comparison with no NCB though. Think I'll go for it unless someone can convince me otherwise.
Protected NCD could only make a difference in a fault claim (IME it won't make a difference even then). It can only make a difference if you stay with the same company (who will load your premium if you claim regardless). If you change company after a claim then they're only interested in how many claims you have had over how long and they will charge you accordingly. Even if you have protected NCD, you still have a claim (fault or otherwise).

Remember, the insurance companies exist purely to make money (like all other companies so not surprise or problem there). If the accident stats didn't show that they will make more money from what they charge for selling protected NCD than their customer will save by buying it, they wouldn't offer it.

Upthejunction

108 posts

157 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
Upthejunction said:
Nope, not worth a penny.
I have 4 NCB and don't protect any of them
Care to elaborate given the differences in premiums I was quoted with/without the protection?
The premium will go up to the amount they want to charge, protecting no claims is a marketing con.
Do you take out the extended warrantee on everything you buy? If so it may be for you, if not, avoid.
How much have you spent protecting it over the years ?

Chiswickboy

549 posts

219 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
Is it worth it?

I'll have 5 years NCB come the start of next month. Currently got a quote of under £500 with the 5 years NCB and 5 years driving. £540 if I include protected no claims.

Assuming a scenario where I had to claim and lost all my NCB the price is around £1200. Are there any catches to adding it to the policy? I've seen people rubbishing the idea before but it seems like a sensible option from where I'm sitting given the significant jump in price should they be lost.
Why are you expecting to loose ALL your NCD in the next year? In the event of a claim it is usual to lose only a couple or so years. Check the policy details and calculate on that basis.

Then again, perhaps you are planning to go wild and expect several collisions in the coming months?

Patrick Bateman

Original Poster:

13,219 posts

205 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
I was under the impression making a claim puts your NCB back to zero, no?

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
stemll said:
Protected NCD could only make a difference in a fault claim (IME it won't make a difference even then). It can only make a difference if you stay with the same company (who will load your premium if you claim regardless). If you change company after a claim then they're only interested in how many claims you have had over how long and they will charge you accordingly. Even if you have protected NCD, you still have a claim (fault or otherwise).

Remember, the insurance companies exist purely to make money (like all other companies so not surprise or problem there). If the accident stats didn't show that they will make more money from what they charge for selling protected NCD than their customer will save by buying it, they wouldn't offer it.
Many companies will allow you to transfer your Protected No Claims Bonus over and will normally deduct the same life you would have lost with your existing company.

PNCB can help with a non fault claim as your Insurers will normally regard the claim as being at fault until they or you recover losses from the other party. If your renewal falls before they or you have recovered losses you will pay the renewal based on the maximum no claims bonus along with any loading for a claim (If any) as opposed to normally the renewal being invited with the no claims bonus if you don't have protected

stemll

5,656 posts

231 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Protected NCD is a waste of money. If you cannot see that then that is your loss and I suppose I should be grateful that you're giving the insurers money that I don't have to . For me, it falls into the same category as an extended warranty from Currys, legal expenses cover or holiday cancellation cover. The chances of having to claim are so remote as to be not worth worrying about. On the extremely rare case that I'd be able to claim I'll take the hit and still end up in front.

Quite why anyone would pay an extra 10% - 15% now just in case they might lose 25% in the future is beyond me unless they have a very low opinion of their likelihood to need to claim. That's really lousy odds.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,277 posts

181 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
stemll said:
Remember, the insurance companies exist purely to make money
Shame on them. A business, that exists to make money. Shouldn't be allowed. What we need is more business that exist purely to lose money. rolleyes

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Saturday 8th February 2014
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
I was under the impression making a claim puts your NCB back to zero, no?
Generally you lose two years per claim, or you go back to 3 if you have more than 5 years.

Whether protecting your no claims is a good deal depends largely on how likely you think you are to make a claim. If you have to claim you'll be glad you did it. If you don't, it's money down the toilet. A bit like all insurance really. wink

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
Aretnap said:
Generally you lose two years per claim, or you go back to 3 if you have more than 5 years.

Whether protecting your no claims is a good deal depends largely on how likely you think you are to make a claim. If you have to claim you'll be glad you did it. If you don't, it's money down the toilet. A bit like all insurance really. wink
It's especially handy if you're unfortunate enough to have two claims within a year or so, without PNCB you could end up losing all your no claims or being left with just 1 year. This can be a discount of circa 60% off a premium that would also have a loading on for the claims.

In my experience it would save between about £600 for a few years so in these circumstance can save a substantial amount.

The saving with three claims would be slightly more although you would generally just have maximum bonus after tree claims

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
Normally I wouldn't bother either, however my premium went from £181 to £183 with it protected so I thought "what the hell, it's only £2" biggrin

Patrick Bateman

Original Poster:

13,219 posts

205 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
stemll said:
Protected NCD is a waste of money. If you cannot see that then that is your loss and I suppose I should be grateful that you're giving the insurers money that I don't have to . For me, it falls into the same category as an extended warranty from Currys, legal expenses cover or holiday cancellation cover. The chances of having to claim are so remote as to be not worth worrying about. On the extremely rare case that I'd be able to claim I'll take the hit and still end up in front.

Quite why anyone would pay an extra 10% - 15% now just in case they might lose 25% in the future is beyond me unless they have a very low opinion of their likelihood to need to claim. That's really lousy odds.
Well if I'm only losing 2 years NCB in the event of a claim rather than them all it's a bit different.

Out of interest, would you put breakdown cover in the same category? I suspect if it wasn't compulsory, you wouldn't buy any insurance at all either?

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
NCD is a crock of st
i don't see why we need it
they take our claim history
and they only seem to care about the first 4 or 5 years worth of NCD

If you got fk all for the first 5 years, but started to build up big discounts when it went above that, i could see the sense in it, i've got 12 year NCD and have been driving for 12 years, yet some wife beating coke snorting tracksuit wearing st stain can go out ram raiding lidl and then run a school bus off the road into a bus shelter full of grannies, and still get the same discount as me after a couple of year
i hate it

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
ging84 said:
NCD is a crock of st
i don't see why we need it
they take our claim history
and they only seem to care about the first 4 or 5 years worth of NCD
We don't need it really. It started life as a marketing gimmick, but now people treat their NCD as if it was a basic human right, and the most valuable thing they've ever owned (you can even get insurance for it). So any insurer which stopped offering it would immediately lose all,their business.

From the insurer's viewpoint it does at least serve a couple of purposes. It shows you've held a policy, and therefore presumably been driving for those five years - if you have had no accidents for five years that might just be because you haven't get behind the wheel for that time. And if you say you've had no accidents in any car that can be hard to prove or disprove, but if you say you have X years on one policy that's at least an aspect of your claims history which is easily checked.

ging84 said:
If you got fk all for the first 5 years, but started to build up big discounts when it went above that, i could see the sense in it,
But an equal number of people would be outraged at being effectively penalised for the way they drove many years ago. Imagine the howls on PH if you had to declare every accident you had as a teenager for the rest of your life.

In practice I believe that insurers tend to find that your accident history from more than a few years ago makes little difference to your risk profile, or at least I assume that's why many (eg Admiral, Direct Line) don't even bother asking about your accident history for more than the last THREE years. There's no reason why they'd want to give you a bigger discount than someone who'd been claim free for 11 years if they thought the difference in your risk profile was negligible.

ging84 said:
i've got 12 year NCD and have been driving for 12 years, yet some wife beating coke snorting tracksuit wearing st stain can go out ram raiding lidl and then run a school bus off the road into a bus shelter full of grannies, and still get the same discount as me after a couple of year
i hate it
Good lord, all that because you're worried that someone else might be paying the same as you for insurance? I dread to think how angry you must get about things which actually matter.