Ever wondered why American cars make so much power?
Ever wondered why American cars make so much power?
Author
Discussion

DaciaBumdart

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oT0r6xQJU_4 around 5m 15 in, it appears they went to the same dyno school as a can of tuna and a honey bee

the car is making over 70bhp than what Audi claim, on a stock car. So either audi ticked the "press" performance tick box, underrated their output (unlikely) or just as with the down hill not actually a 1/4 mile, 1/4 mile times it shows why Americans get so much hp from something as simple as a turbonator.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
Im less concerned about dodgy dyno numbers than the shocking lack of decency shown in the posting of a fisting foreplay video in this forum.

EssexVXR8

1,790 posts

218 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
ringram said:
Im less concerned about dodgy dyno numbers than the shocking lack of decency shown in the posting of a fisting foreplay video in this forum.
Where? I missed that frown

DaciaBumdart

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
EssexVXR8 said:
ringram said:
Im less concerned about dodgy dyno numbers than the shocking lack of decency shown in the posting of a fisting foreplay video in this forum.
Where? I missed that frown
based on some of my browsing history I had a bit of a double check moment I didn't paste the wrong link!

EssexVXR8

1,790 posts

218 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
That what I thought!

TeflonT

1,670 posts

294 months

Sunday 9th February 2014
quotequote all
DaciaBumdart said:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oT0r6xQJU_4 around 5m 15 in, it appears they went to the same dyno school as a can of tuna and a honey bee

the car is making over 70bhp than what Audi claim, on a stock car. So either audi ticked the "press" performance tick box, underrated their output (unlikely) or just as with the down hill not actually a 1/4 mile, 1/4 mile times it shows why Americans get so much hp from something as simple as a turbonator.
I gave up when he made the example " if a 4wd car is making 10obhp on the dyno, thats 120hp at the wheels" This was after he said a 4wd car typically loses 20%.

So Americans can't do maths as 100/8 is 125hp.

Knob.

minime68

399 posts

166 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
DaciaBumdart said:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oT0r6xQJU_4 around 5m 15 in, it appears they went to the same dyno school as a can of tuna and a honey bee

the car is making over 70bhp than what Audi claim, on a stock car. So either audi ticked the "press" performance tick box, underrated their output (unlikely) or just as with the down hill not actually a 1/4 mile, 1/4 mile times it shows why Americans get so much hp from something as simple as a turbonator.
DaciaBumdart,

You know, you seem to come across as a hater. This is not your first post bashing Americans. I don't see whats wrong with the review to be honest. First of all, BHP is crank horsepower NOT at the wheels. Some manufacturers underrate their cars this is nothing new. There are different dynos in the industry. Everyone knows DynoJet typically yields higher number but we also use the same DynoDynamics and Mustang Dynos that read just like in the UK.

Most quarter mile tracks are not downhill. The few that may be or have fairly uneven surface are not sanctioned by the NHRA. There are regulations and tolerances governing this. A lot of quick tracks like ATCO and PBIR consistently put out faster times due to the track prep and DA. Why do UK 1/4 times seem a little bit behind for the same mods? My guess is that most tuners here seem to map on the safer less aggressive side of things.

When I brought my car over I was told the same story. Then wen't to SRR and put down 630 to the wheels on my stock engine and 1.9 supercharger. Was it pushed to it's limits? Yes, yes it was. But that doesn't mean the numbers were false and I also have the 1/4 times at the pod to show it. So either you are being biased, or you refuse to accept the fact that the performance figures are there.

Edited by minime68 on Monday 10th February 08:40

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
tumbleweed

minime68

399 posts

166 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
TeflonT said:
I gave up when he made the example " if a 4wd car is making 10obhp on the dyno, thats 120hp at the wheels" This was after he said a 4wd car typically loses 20%.

So Americans can't do maths as 100/8 is 125hp.

Knob.
I think you need to get your ears checked. He said at 4:50 that if the Audi put down 100 to the wheels with an estimated 20% loss, then it would be making 120 at the crank. He used this as an example and according to my math, that is 20%.

DaciaBumdart

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
minime68 said:
TeflonT said:
I gave up when he made the example " if a 4wd car is making 10obhp on the dyno, thats 120hp at the wheels" This was after he said a 4wd car typically loses 20%.

So Americans can't do maths as 100/8 is 125hp.

Knob.
I think you need to get your ears checked. He said at 4:50 that if the Audi put down 100 to the wheels with an estimated 20% loss, then it would be making 120 at the crank. He used this as an example and according to my math, that is 20%.
no what he said was 20% of 120 is 20, which it isn't, its 24 which would equate to 94 at the wheels. 125 - 20% is 100 at the wheels.

My American bashing knows no bounds, despite having many American friends I dislike the countries world policies, the politics and the bullst that comes our way. That video is a great example of the bullst in dyno talk and horsepower figures. We regularly see claims of 2 billion hp from a simple supercharger bolt on, its fairly accepted that American BHP is about as believable as the lunar landings.

Should I put a 9/11 never forget t-shirt on and walk around as if we're the biggest victim of terrorism or should I wear a T-shirt that displays the numbers killed in the name of American global policy or the millions donated to the IRA? Take your pick

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
minime68 said:
DaciaBumdart said:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oT0r6xQJU_4 around 5m 15 in, it appears they went to the same dyno school as a can of tuna and a honey bee

the car is making over 70bhp than what Audi claim, on a stock car. So either audi ticked the "press" performance tick box, underrated their output (unlikely) or just as with the down hill not actually a 1/4 mile, 1/4 mile times it shows why Americans get so much hp from something as simple as a turbonator.
DaciaBumdart,

You know, you seem to come across as a hater. This is not your first post bashing Americans. I don't see whats wrong with the review to be honest. First of all, BHP is crank horsepower NOT at the wheels. Some manufacturers underrate their cars this is nothing new. There are different dynos in the industry. Everyone knows DynoJet typically yields higher number but we also use the same DynoDynamics and Mustang Dynos that read just like in the UK.

Most quarter mile tracks are not downhill. The few that may be or have fairly uneven surface are not sanctioned by the NHRA. There are regulations and tolerances governing this. A lot of quick tracks like ATCO and PBIR consistently put out faster times due to the track prep and DA. Why do UK 1/4 times seem a little bit behind for the same mods? My guess is that most tuners here seem to map on the safer less aggressive side of things.

When I brought my car over I was told the same story. Then wen't to SRR and put down 630 to the wheels on my stock engine and 1.9 supercharger. Was it pushed to it's limits? Yes, yes it was. But that doesn't mean the numbers were false and I also have the 1/4 times at the pod to show it. So either you are being biased, or you refuse to accept the fact that the performance figures are there.

Edited by minime68 on Monday 10th February 08:40
If you'd met him, like a lot of us have, you would know that he is absolutely not a hater, but (in a not nasty way) he will try to wind you up.

Apparently he succeeded wink

BTW I suspect that there are a many more Brit bashers in the States than visa versa (starting with your President).




minime68

399 posts

166 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
DaciaBumdart said:
no what he said was 20% of 120 is 20, which it isn't, its 24 which would equate to 94 at the wheels. 125 - 20% is 100 at the wheels.

My American bashing knows no bounds, despite having many American friends I dislike the countries world policies, the politics and the bullst that comes our way. That video is a great example of the bullst in dyno talk and horsepower figures. We regularly see claims of 2 billion hp from a simple supercharger bolt on, its fairly accepted that American BHP is about as believable as the lunar landings.

Should I put a 9/11 never forget t-shirt on and walk around as if we're the biggest victim of terrorism or should I wear a T-shirt that displays the numbers killed in the name of American global policy or the millions donated to the IRA? Take your pick
Correction, you are right on the % numbers. I am the first to admit if I am wrong. But you should keep your political views to a political forum as I think most people are here to talk about cars. Now, if you think the claims are bogus and we are full of st I'd be happy to run you for pinks if you're putting down the same power/weight as me.

minime68

399 posts

166 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
MyM8V8 said:
If you'd met him, like a lot of us have, you would know that he is absolutely not a hater, but (in a not nasty way) he will try to wind you up.

Apparently he succeeded wink

BTW I suspect that there are a many more Brit bashers in the States than visa versa (starting with your President).
Actually, while living in the states I never heard many bad things about the British. Are there people that talk bad? Of course there are on both sides. Just seems here it is constant.

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
minime68 said:
MyM8V8 said:
If you'd met him, like a lot of us have, you would know that he is absolutely not a hater, but (in a not nasty way) he will try to wind you up.

Apparently he succeeded wink

BTW I suspect that there are a many more Brit bashers in the States than visa versa (starting with your President).
Actually, while living in the states I never heard many bad things about the British. Are there people that talk bad? Of course there are on both sides. Just seems here it is constant.
The anti British undertones are probably just how it comes over to me in many US TV programs and in US films? But Obama did recently give BP a good bashing over the gulf spill, specifically referring to "British" Petroleum whereas the company is 40% US owned and has not been called that for years. The name was changed to reflect its global ownership.

Personally I haven't got an axe to grind and continue to assist the US economy by buying lost of parts there wink






ArnieVXR

2,458 posts

214 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
The reason why is that they do make lots of power. Of course, most dyno figures are questionable, but the same's true over here. There's no magic behind big hp numbers, just experience. And our American cousins have lots of that.

The quarter times are pretty truthful too. Of the handful of places you can run in the UK, all bar one are very poor (still great fun). The strips in the US are in a different league and are available much more frequently. So what's the difference between a good strip and a bad? Couple of seconds for a fast car IMHO.

On a personal note, I do find the anti-American comments a little offensive. I'm all for a bit of dry humour. This isn't it.

So thanks to the US for saving us in two World Wars, standing firm in the cold war, giving us Star Trek, inventing drag racing and, of course, giving the world the good old chevy V8.

And if there's stuff they do that you don't like, try looking at the shyte we do before moaning too loudly (preferably elsewhere).



ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
minime68 said:
Actually, while living in the states I never heard many bad things about the British. Are there people that talk bad? Of course there are on both sides. Just seems here it is constant.
If you are hearing it constantly, then have you thought that the only common denominator is you?

I didn't know that you were American, but that does explain a lot. Before you decide that I insulted you, we all have our traits according to how we have been brought up, and my experience of US citizens is that of a nation of people with a self assurance above that of an average Brit.

I'll make appropriate allowances for you in future. wink

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
ArnieVXR said:
And if there's stuff they do that you don't like, try looking at the shyte we do before moaning too loudly (preferably elsewhere).
Actually I thought we had the second largest foreign aid budget in the world - guilt money?

But we are no doubt the most hated country in the world. Just look at how our new "allies" in Europe treat us, especially in the Eurovision. Even the Scots are going to jump ship and who can blame them? And as Arnie has intimated, we are our own biggest enemies.

minime68

399 posts

166 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
ARAF said:
If you are hearing it constantly, then have you thought that the only common denominator is you?

I didn't know that you were American, but that does explain a lot. Before you decide that I insulted you, we all have our traits according to how we have been brought up, and my experience of US citizens is that of a nation of people with a self assurance above that of an average Brit.

I'll make appropriate allowances for you in future. wink
I am hearing it constantly on here and around British boards that's the common denominator. Often I hear bad things about British but not on American forums. Is it out there? Yes but not as common. I just think it's hypocritical to point out how bad US foreign policy is when indeed the UK is America's biggest ally and has it's share in history current and past.. I was not born America but currently hold citizenship.

minime68

399 posts

166 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
ArnieVXR said:
The reason why is that they do make lots of power. Of course, most dyno figures are questionable, but the same's true over here. There's no magic behind big hp numbers, just experience. And our American cousins have lots of that.

The quarter times are pretty truthful too. Of the handful of places you can run in the UK, all bar one are very poor (still great fun). The strips in the US are in a different league and are available much more frequently. So what's the difference between a good strip and a bad? Couple of seconds for a fast car IMHO.

On a personal note, I do find the anti-American comments a little offensive. I'm all for a bit of dry humour. This isn't it.

So thanks to the US for saving us in two World Wars, standing firm in the cold war, giving us Star Trek, inventing drag racing and, of course, giving the world the good old chevy V8.

And if there's stuff they do that you don't like, try looking at the shyte we do before moaning too loudly (preferably elsewhere).
Took the words right out of my mouth.

DaciaBumdart

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
minime68 said:
ARAF said:
If you are hearing it constantly, then have you thought that the only common denominator is you?

I didn't know that you were American, but that does explain a lot. Before you decide that I insulted you, we all have our traits according to how we have been brought up, and my experience of US citizens is that of a nation of people with a self assurance above that of an average Brit.

I'll make appropriate allowances for you in future. wink
I am hearing it constantly on here and around British boards that's the common denominator. Often I hear bad things about British but not on American forums. Is it out there? Yes but not as common. I just think it's hypocritical to point out how bad US foreign policy is when indeed the UK is America's biggest ally and has it's share in history current and past.. I was not born America but currently hold citizenship.
I guess on American forums they only think of America because in the main the people don't see outside of America. Anyway my point wasn't to stir up hatred it was to show that whilst yes, I accept we have some bloat with BHP figures, the bloat is continuously higher in America. We've had threads for long time over here questioning the power claims from our trans Atlantic cousins as the same mods on the same engines over here made consistently considerably less.

Do I hate Americans? No. Do I like America? Yes but only when I take it for what it is a stunning country with some excellent people ruined by a poltical and justice system from the dark ages.