Urban clearways
Author
Discussion

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Just turned off an urban clearway into a side street and noticed the clearway extends about 30 yards into the side street, where clearway ends signs are erected.

Never come across one of these before, is it commonplace?

Cliftonite

8,754 posts

169 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Just turned off an urban clearway into a side street and noticed the clearway extends about 30 yards into the side street, where clearway ends signs are erected.

Never come across one of these before, is it commonplace?
There is one in Brighouse, West Yorkshire. The "side street" used to be the main road through town (Huddersfield Road) until it was by-passed when a new road was built. But the signs were left up and are religiously enforced to this day by the local authority as a money spinner.

I ask you, a clearway in a side street!!

mad


anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Cliftonite said:
There is one in Brighouse, West Yorkshire. The "side street" used to be the main road through town (Huddersfield Road) until it was by-passed when a new road was built. But the signs were left up and are religiously enforced to this day by the local authority as a money spinner.

I ask you, a clearway in a side street!!

mad

Has anyone challenged them and are the signs still actually lawful ?

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all


This is it. Spot the "clearway ends" signs.

The Vectra is parked on the clearway.

Interestingly, gov website says "On a 24 hour clearway, the prohibition of stopping applies only to the main carriageway. You may stop in a lay by unless there are signs to say otherwise."

Question is, can this side street correctly be deemed to be "the main carriageway", or is the local authority abusing the rules?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Just turned off an urban clearway into a side street and noticed the clearway extends about 30 yards into the side street, where clearway ends signs are erected.

Never come across one of these before, is it commonplace?
Don't know about commonplace but I have seen this in quite a few other urban areas. All of the Red Routes in my neck of the woods have this arrangement.

mybrainhurts said:


This is it. Spot the "clearway ends" signs.

The Vectra is parked on the clearway.

Interestingly, gov website says "On a 24 hour clearway, the prohibition of stopping applies only to the main carriageway. You may stop in a lay by unless there are signs to say otherwise."

Question is, can this side street correctly be deemed to be "the main carriageway", or is the local authority abusing the rules?
Pass. I suspect not though - see above. Even if it is, in this location there is a very good reason for doing it imo.

sheffieldforum.co.uk post said:
You'll find that all of the roads that have a junction with any of the tram routes have a clearway that extends some of the way up the side road, which allows the traffic coming out of the side road to see out on to the main road without having the front end of their car taken off by a 68 tonne tram.
Edited by Red Devil on Wednesday 12th February 19:09

Cliftonite

8,754 posts

169 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Brighouse, West Yorkshire:

https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=brighouse&hl=...

The white van is illegally parked.



These signs are driving us mad



Many drivers do not understand the restrictions imposed by clearway signs in Bradford Road, Brighouse



Brighouse Echo
Published on the 26 May 2012
09:35



A BRIGHOUSE worker has accused Calderdale Council of entrapment for using “redundant, wrongly placed signs for fining unwitting motorists”.


Terry Armitage was given a fine for parking outside Armitage Sykes solicitors which is in a keep clear section while he was working in the area. “Paying the fine is not the issue, but the crass stupidity of the situation,” he said.

“The part of Bradford Road in question was a clearway and the sign dates from that period. But with the building of the new road, this part of Bradford Road is now a minor side street. It is not a clearway.

“The sign should have been moved to the junction with the new road to warn there is a clearway ahead,” he said.

“As an example, the clearway sign on the next side street, Water Street, is three to four metres from the junction. The sign on Bradford Road is 25 to 30 metres from the junction.

“Between the sign and the junction with the new road there is parking space for three cars. The road is wide and no obstruction is caused whatsoever.”

Since October Mr Armitage has seen no tickets being issued and assumed that common sense had prevailed.

“I believe therefore, that what the council is doing amounts to little more than entrapment, in that they are using redundant wrongly placed signage and no other reason, as a basis for fining unwitting motorists,” he said.

“So we have three perfectly good parking spaces, no yellow lines, no “no parking” signs, a clearway sign not on a clearway, and a council quite happy to entrap unsuspecting motorists, presumably for the money.”

The Brighouse Echo revealed in June 2011 that 181 motorists were fined for parking in the keep clear section in 12 months.

And that motorist Mike Battye has successfully won his appeal after putting across his argument that it wasn’t clear parking restrictions were in force.

A council spokesman said that the signs were still required and are lawful.




mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
mybrainhurts said:


This is it. Spot the "clearway ends" signs.

The Vectra is parked on the clearway.

Interestingly, gov website says "On a 24 hour clearway, the prohibition of stopping applies only to the main carriageway. You may stop in a lay by unless there are signs to say otherwise."

Question is, can this side street correctly be deemed to be "the main carriageway", or is the local authority abusing the rules?
Pass. I suspect not though - see above. Even if it is, in this location there is a very good reason for doing it imo.

sheffieldforum.co.uk post said:
You'll find that all of the roads that have a junction with any of the tram routes have a clearway that extends some of the way up the side road, which allows the traffic coming out of the side road to see out on to the main road without having the front end of their car taken off by a 68 tonne tram.
Reasonable point, but the clearway need not extend into the side road as far as it does. There's room for two more parked cars before any view obstruction occurs.

If the local authority did use this as justification, it got this one woefully wrong. Can you see the tram tracks very close to the junction? Trees on the right prevent any view of the tram until you're on the give way sign.


Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Councils in "Dodgy Road Signage Fines" shocker.

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Aye, they just can't help themselves.

Money grabbing fools can't see they're driving visitors away. I stopped going to London years ago and avoid my own city centre unless absolutely necessary.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Reasonable point, but the clearway need not extend into the side road as far as it does. There's room for two more parked cars before any view obstruction occurs.

If the local authority did use this as justification, it got this one woefully wrong. Can you see the tram tracks very close to the junction? Trees on the right prevent any view of the tram until you're on the give way sign.

I can see what you are driving at with that specific road.

However I could cite RTA 1988 sect 22 & CUR reg 103 plus Rule 224 of the Highway Code. smile

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:


This is it. Spot the "clearway ends" signs.

The Vectra is parked on the clearway.

Interestingly, gov website says "On a 24 hour clearway, the prohibition of stopping applies only to the main carriageway. You may stop in a lay by unless there are signs to say otherwise."

Question is, can this side street correctly be deemed to be "the main carriageway", or is the local authority abusing the rules?
As someone else has already suggested, its for tram safety. Not that I am ever keen to support Sheffield City Council...

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
However I could cite CUR reg 103
What's that when it's at home?

I'm guessing parking in a dodgy position.

If so, that's irrelevant in the last picture. When the tram first started running and I didn't know it had started running, I approached that give way sign and filled my pants pretty damn' quickly when the tram rumbled past my bonnet a couple of feet away.

Nothing to do with parking. My point is that the Council is not consistent. In one case, the clearway on the side road is excessively long, in the second case they allow those conifers to obscure oncoming trams until they're upon you.


Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
What's that when it's at home?

I'm guessing parking in a dodgy position.

If so, that's irrelevant in the last picture. When the tram first started running and I didn't know it had started running, I approached that give way sign and filled my pants pretty damn' quickly when the tram rumbled past my bonnet a couple of feet away.

Nothing to do with parking. My point is that the Council is not consistent. In one case, the clearway on the side road is excessively long, in the second case they allow those conifers to obscure oncoming trams until they're upon you.
You can't extract coin from trees, silly.