Protecting idea for TV programme
Protecting idea for TV programme
Author
Discussion

andyps

Original Poster:

7,819 posts

313 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
I have an idea for a TV programme which I am going to discuss with the local TV station which will start broadcasting shortly under the licences recently awarded. Whilst it may not be a mega programme and I certainly don't expect to replicate the fortune Simon Cowell has created through X-Factor I would like to ensure that if it gets taken up even just by the one local station that I receive appropriate credit for it. What can I do to protect this and ensure it is recognised as my idea? Does the write it down and post yourself a copy but not open the envelope to show the date through the postmark still work?

Any useful advice gratefully accepted!

StevieBee

15,511 posts

286 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
To a degree, yes but as with anything, to secure proper and full protection you need to pay somebody some money.

I working with a chap who's developed a children's TV series and this was covered off by his publisher - the person you need to pay some money to. I think the main thing they did was to register him in IMDM and publish the show's précis.

Also, when you say local TV do you mean regional? Local TV tends to refer to very small, community TV stations whereas regional refers to Meridian, BBC North West, etc. These tend not to be commissioning stations (other than very specific local newsy type programmes). Shows are commissioned centrally but their production is often outsourced to regional stations (for example, at the end of Dr Who, the final credit frame shows BBC Wales because that's the division of the BBC who made it and where it's filmed but the show would be commissioned by the BBC in London. Or Salford. Or wherever they're based this week!

All that said, regional stations are likely to be more receptive to new ideas and can at least give you a steer or introduction to the right people in the right places.

HTH

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
andyps said:
I have an idea for a TV programme which I am going to discuss with the local TV station which will start broadcasting shortly under the licences recently awarded. Whilst it may not be a mega programme and I certainly don't expect to replicate the fortune Simon Cowell has created through X-Factor I would like to ensure that if it gets taken up even just by the one local station that I receive appropriate credit for it. What can I do to protect this and ensure it is recognised as my idea? Does the write it down and post yourself a copy but not open the envelope to show the date through the postmark still work?

Any useful advice gratefully accepted!
First off I think I know the guys you are dealing with.

I don't know the full ins and outs of Copyright rules, but if you can prove the idea is yours IE write out in detail everything and then post it to yourself registered post (although long time since I did a course in the legalities of entertainment industry as an A level course). Then it should be ok.

Good luck though.


FurtiveFreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
If someone stole the idea and passed it off as their own, do you have the financial resources and time to take them to Court?

If the answer is "no", it's not worth trying to protect the idea.

andyps

Original Poster:

7,819 posts

313 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the responses. I doubt it will make much money (but you never know, and I am always hopeful) so don't want to spend any large sums to protect it specifically, just to have some proof that it is my idea and when I had the idea. I certainly can't afford to challenge a large organisation in the courts!

In terms of the local TV it is one of those given the licences here - http://licensing.ofcom.org.uk/tv-broadcast-licence...

FurtiveFreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
I didn't want to come across as being flippant, it's just that trying to protect creative ideas is really very difficult unless you have a lot of money in the first place to put international branding, trademark, copyright etc. protection in place or you have a lot of money after someone has stolen the idea to challenge them in Court.

There was quite a big case recently where Brian Belo (think Big Brother) took ITV and a production company to court because it looked very much like they stole the idea of TOWIE from him. When you look at the evidence, I think most people would agree they probably had.

The legal wrangles went on for years before ITV settled with him out of Court late last year.

Best thing IMO would be to get NDAs signed by whoever you present the idea to. It might discourage the casual idea-stealer and won't cost you anything.

andyps

Original Poster:

7,819 posts

313 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
I didn't think you were being flippant, and fully appreciate what you said. I know that I don't have the resources to fight a major (or even minor) broadcaster, but would like to have a basic defence. An NDA is worth considering before I have the meeting.

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
The fact is that ideas are ten a penny.

There a thousands of ideas fro tv shows hitting the desks of commissioning editors every year.

Many of them are very similar. However, not necessary 'ripped' off from each other.

In this regard, tv companies are always very wary - very often they will not accept unsolicited material and will only accept treatments/scripts via agencies etc.

If you do want to pitch an 'idea' rather then a pilot or a full script, the best way to protect its original elements is to produce a very very detailed treatment of the show that you propose. THe more developed it is, the better; and the more likely you are to be able to lay claim to some elements of it from an IP rights point of view.

Good luck.


Billsnemesis

817 posts

268 months

Sunday 16th February 2014
quotequote all
The catch with a TV idea is that there is no copyright in an idea, only in the visual and text representation of that idea

So the idea of a quiz show answering questions against the clock is not subject to copyright but having two rounds, one specialist and one general, with the ability to pass on questions and with a stong visual style of a single chair in the centre of the room is obviously Mastermind

It will not be possible to copyright your idea but if the visual manifestation is strong enough and if there are elements that are unique either in terms of the names or the image then it might be possible to claim copyright on enough elements to make the overall package difficult to copy. Something like "Who wants to be a millionaire" built on that title as a phrase with additional elements such as "fifty fifty" and "phone a friend" - catchy little add on's that are subject to copyright in that context.

This is not my main area of work but I have had experience of similar concepts for contacts in the past and I know some specialist who may be able to help, both in working out what can be protected and also looking at developing the idea to build a package that is as well protected as the law allows. PM me if you want to go through it in more detail

RickRolled

339 posts

208 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Sorry for going slightly off topic here, but let's say one has an idea for a TV show that so far has nothing similar to it broadcasted in UK. How do you go about getting it broadcasted? Are the any particular routes / any tips or recommendations?


H18 ENF

700 posts

200 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
This industry is generally all about being careful with who you pitch ideas to. Friends, by and large, will not rip you off, however you kind of have to prove the concept works in order to successfully pitch it.

At the point you have created the programme you have a greater chance of winning any case because, as someone mentioned earlier, the visual elements can be compared.

What you have currently is an idea.

The problem with ideas is that they evolve during the production process.

Lets say your idea is to host a gameshow about Cricket hosted by Bill Clinton. You've called it 'Billy Cricket'

You pitch this idea.

A member of the production team likes your idea, though thinks that Bill Clinton would be a crap host and instead suggests it should be Noel Edmunds and he should always wear a blue shirt. Instead of giving you that feedback he says to you, yes I like the idea but their isn't an audience for that at the moment so thanks but no thanks.

That Production Member talks to his producer and shares their idea based on their interpretation of your idea. The producer consider's the re-hashed idea and says he'll consider it.

The Producer consider's it and figures that Noel Edmund should never wear a Blue Shirt but instead it should be Sparkly and Golden.

The Producer takes the idea to a Commissioner and pitches his version of his production team's interpretation of your idea but calls it Sparkly Golden Cricket Quiz. It gets commissioned and wins a BAFTA for being the Best Entertainment Show.

Whose show is it?

You have nothing to prove it's yours other than a written brief. Had you made a demo of it before you pitched it then you could see show some comparisons and maybe get a credit on the show and a small payment.

If you're lucky.

This is an exaggerated example I know, but the general idea is sound, I know this from first hand experience.

What makes 'Who Wants to be a Millionaire" a global franchise is the look of it, the Lighting Design is patented, so is the set design (copywritten in that case I think). The format is nothing new really, it a re-working of an age old principle.

You may think this post is extremely negative, it's not. I actually think you're doing a great thing trying to come up with new entertainment formats, 'cos Christ in a Boat we need them. What I'm saying is make sure you develop it as far as you can first, I can offer my services (mainly gratis) if you want help building it up, but don't fall into the trap that you can take a producer to court because you came up with a very similar idea first.

Good Luck and I really hope it works out for you.