Which fast Audi? B7 S4/RS4, RS6 or S8?
Which fast Audi? B7 S4/RS4, RS6 or S8?
Author
Discussion

white_goodman

Original Poster:

4,528 posts

222 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
I've been driving an SUV (2001 Jeep Grand Cherokee) for a while and have decided that my next vehicle will be a car, as I'm prepared to sacrifice some ground clearance/off-road ability for better performance and handling.

I would definitely be looking to buy one of these:

B7 RS4 or the S4 equivalent.



RS6 (the original V8 bi-turbo one)



Or a D2 S8 (Ronin-style)



I'm fairly open on age but ideally something newer and lower mileage than my current Jeep. My preference is a manual but that limits my options, so would consider an auto. I've done the whole Impreza thing and they're awesome but I'm older now so would prefer something a bit more grown up.

The RS4 would probably be my first choice but also the most expensive option. They're pretty rare here (only 17 for sale on Autotrader)but tick all the boxes and I'd be looking at about 25000 pounds for a 2007 (definitely don't want to be spending any more than this). Normally the Avant version is cooler but I actually prefer the saloon version of these.

Obviously, it's not exactly going to be economical but then I'm used to 18mpg with the Jeep, so I can live with that for the near supercar performance!

How about reliability, servicing and running costs though? I presume they need V Power or similar and what are they like on fuel range (petrol stations are pretty sparse out here)!

Looking around, a D2 S8 (Ronin-style) or RS6 (the twin turbo V8 one - sorry not very good with my Audi model codes) would be about half the price but obviously older and probably much higher mileage. I've also heard RS6 running costs can be pretty astronomical.

Would a B7 S4 offer a similar drive to an RS4 for a lot less or are they completely different animals. I thought I heard that the manual S4s were to be avoided? I have also seen a few B8 S4s for close to RS4 money, so perhaps I should also consider those?



iluvmercs

7,541 posts

258 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Depends what you are after.
S8 and S4 (B7 and B8) are more cruisers that hard-edged sports saloons.
The "Ronin" S8 is getting on a bit. If this is the route you wish to go, I'm sure your budget would stretch the later V10 engined car?

RS6 is a weapon in a straight line, but being auto only (a manual conversion is possible using B7 RS4 gearbox gubbins - probably quite expensive) and tad heavier than the S4/RS4, I don't know if a standard car would handle as well, or have as much involvement. This is just my belief as I confess to have not driven this car. I'm certain owners will be along to correct me smile
Having had a drag race with a stock C5 RS6 it was a dead match with my standard B7 RS4 from around 30 to 140mph.

RS6 and B8 S4 are renown for their tuning scope,but both are cracking cars out of the box.
I have heard the RS6's limiting factor is often the gearbox.

RS6 and RS4 have known DRC suspension issues and the RS4 for its carbon build up resulting in a deficit of measured power - I've never had my checked for carbon, but it produced 390bhp on a rolling road. Having said that, it performs to Audi's quoted figures, so I'm non too bothered by this.

In my experience, the B7 S4 is completely different to the RS4. The RS4 is harder, revvier and feels little more special, IMO.
The interior of my B7 does feel a little dated now, though all the expected modern toys are present and correct.

I can't comment on running costs of the others, but the B7 RS4 is serviced every 2 years/20k miles or when the indicator says - because I track my car and do drive a little briskly, this means around £400 is spent at the main dealer every 16k/18 months.
There are no A and B services, just a full one each time. Some buyers are put off if they don't see a regular service every year, but the car just doesn't need it.
If enthusiastic driving is undertaken regularly, it may be worth changing the diff oil and gearbox oil - something I have done every couple of years, because of the track work.
Any recalls should now have been attended to - but spark plugs and battery bracket were the main couple in recent years.
OEM front discs and pads are about £1000. Rear discs and pads will be about £800. Brakes can suffer from pad build up, resulting a judder from the brakes. It doesn't feel very nice, but so long as the car stops as it should, then I wouldn't class it as a deal breaker - you can either clean the discs using a special disc cleaner, or perhaps find a non main dealer garage to skim the discs.
Full set of tyres is likely to be anywhere between £900 and £1200. I made the popular switch to Michelin Pilot Super Sports and have never looked back.
Petrol consumption is around 18-20mpg, meaning around 250-280 miles per tank from the approximate 62 litre capacity. I only use the higher octane stuff, but it can easily run on 95 RON.
Expect the car to use around 1 litre of oil every 1500 miles or so.
Clutch and flywheel costs around £2000 from a main dealer.
If used in deeper snow, expect to require engine trays and under body panels. They seem a bit of a week point, the fixing points breaking easily. I've required at least one plastic panel each winter which cost around £50-60.
I have had a few "one off" items which needed addressing over my 5 years ownership - £1000 for an oil cooler; a couple of front suspension arms (~£200 each IIRC); air conditioning condenser recently had a hole, thanks to wayward stone (£1700); headlight control unit (~£750) and new headlights fitted (£500 each for my bi-xenon corning lights).
Touch wood, in my 60,000 miles of ownership, I haven't yet had a problem with the DRC shock abosrbers leaking.

I have also addressed a few cosmetic issues from time to time - wheel refurb (twice and due another), painting for stone chips and driver seat bolster repairs.
On the point of the seats, if the B7 RS4 has the bucket seats, don't be too alarmed if they look tired even with lower mileage cars - they are known for premature wear. New items can be sourced from Audi, but I had a local trimmer re-colour mine. It's not 100% new, but looks ALOT better.

Yes it's not the most confortable of your choices, nor the most economical to run, but chasing that 8,000rpm red line in a cross-country B-Road blast is superb - the car still puts a smile on my face!

All your choices have their merits and disadvantages.
Go out and drive them to decide which is best for you.

It would also be worth checking out rs246.com for detailed information on all your choices.
You say you are finding it hard to find RS4 saloons out there? Plenty on PH, and RS246.com. There should also be a few more than that on Autotrader! Just keep and eye out. It took me 5 months to find my car, but it was worth the wait!
Good luck!

Darren

Edited by iluvmercs on Thursday 13th February 01:51

s4tronic

245 posts

157 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Audi S4 B8 - £23,500
MRC stg 2 package - £1,500
490bhp, around 4s to 60, 4 wheel drive in stealthy packaging - priceless.

Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
^^^ This.

I was just watching the Chris Harris comparison of the S4 v RS4. And then the same S4 v the RS4.

Worth a watch if you wanted a newer car and the performance from an RS4.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2KfMY96v_Gc


lengster

215 posts

190 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Great if you want to drive a totally bland looking car,sure a chopped s4 goes well but does everything else in a so so fashion,rs6 come with potential big bills,rubbish handling and auto box,s8 is a bit pipe n slippers fast cruiser,rs4 is the only choice if you want a sports car,standard power isnt great but theyre also tuneable up to 460ps which brings them nicely alive.

white_goodman

Original Poster:

4,528 posts

222 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
iluvmercs said:
Depends what you are after.
S8 and S4 (B7 and B8) are more cruisers that hard-edged sports saloons.
The "Ronin" S8 is getting on a bit. If this is the route you wish to go, I'm sure your budget would stretch the later V10 engined car?

RS6 is a weapon in a straight line, but being auto only (a manual conversion is possible using B7 RS4 gearbox gubbins - probably quite expensive) and tad heavier than the S4/RS4, I don't know if a standard car would handle as well, or have as much involvement. This is just my belief as I confess to have not driven this car. I'm certain owners will be along to correct me smile
Having had a drag race with a stock C5 RS6 it was a dead match with my standard B7 RS4 from around 30 to 140mph.

RS6 and B8 S4 are renown for their tuning scope,but both are cracking cars out of the box.
I have heard the RS6's limiting factor is often the gearbox.

RS6 and RS4 have known DRC suspension issues and the RS4 for its carbon build up resulting in a deficit of measured power - I've never had my checked for carbon, but it produced 390bhp on a rolling road. Having said that, it performs to Audi's quoted figures, so I'm non too bothered by this.

In my experience, the B7 S4 is completely different to the RS4. The RS4 is harder, revvier and feels little more special, IMO.
The interior of my B7 does feel a little dated now, though all the expected modern toys are present and correct.

I can't comment on running costs of the others, but the B7 RS4 is serviced every 2 years/20k miles or when the indicator says - because I track my car and do drive a little briskly, this means around £400 is spent at the main dealer every 16k/18 months.
There are no A and B services, just a full one each time. Some buyers are put off if they don't see a regular service every year, but the car just doesn't need it.
If enthusiastic driving is undertaken regularly, it may be worth changing the diff oil and gearbox oil - something I have done every couple of years, because of the track work.
Any recalls should now have been attended to - but spark plugs and battery bracket were the main couple in recent years.
OEM front discs and pads are about £1000. Rear discs and pads will be about £800. Brakes can suffer from pad build up, resulting a judder from the brakes. It doesn't feel very nice, but so long as the car stops as it should, then I wouldn't class it as a deal breaker - you can either clean the discs using a special disc cleaner, or perhaps find a non main dealer garage to skim the discs.
Full set of tyres is likely to be anywhere between £900 and £1200. I made the popular switch to Michelin Pilot Super Sports and have never looked back.
Petrol consumption is around 18-20mpg, meaning around 250-280 miles per tank from the approximate 62 litre capacity. I only use the higher octane stuff, but it can easily run on 95 RON.
Expect the car to use around 1 litre of oil every 1500 miles or so.
Clutch and flywheel costs around £2000 from a main dealer.
If used in deeper snow, expect to require engine trays and under body panels. They seem a bit of a week point, the fixing points breaking easily. I've required at least one plastic panel each winter which cost around £50-60.
I have had a few "one off" items which needed addressing over my 5 years ownership - £1000 for an oil cooler; a couple of front suspension arms (~£200 each IIRC); air conditioning condenser recently had a hole, thanks to wayward stone (£1700); headlight control unit (~£750) and new headlights fitted (£500 each for my bi-xenon corning lights).
Touch wood, in my 60,000 miles of ownership, I haven't yet had a problem with the DRC shock abosrbers leaking.

I have also addressed a few cosmetic issues from time to time - wheel refurb (twice and due another), painting for stone chips and driver seat bolster repairs.
On the point of the seats, if the B7 RS4 has the bucket seats, don't be too alarmed if they look tired even with lower mileage cars - they are known for premature wear. New items can be sourced from Audi, but I had a local trimmer re-colour mine. It's not 100% new, but looks ALOT better.

Yes it's not the most confortable of your choices, nor the most economical to run, but chasing that 8,000rpm red line in a cross-country B-Road blast is superb - the car still puts a smile on my face!

All your choices have their merits and disadvantages.
Go out and drive them to decide which is best for you.

It would also be worth checking out rs246.com for detailed information on all your choices.
You say you are finding it hard to find RS4 saloons out there? Plenty on PH, and RS246.com. There should also be a few more than that on Autotrader! Just keep and eye out. It took me 5 months to find my car, but it was worth the wait!
Good luck!

Darren

Edited by iluvmercs on Thursday 13th February 01:51
That's quite the garage you have there! I think your enthusiasm for the RS4 has struck a bit of a chord with me. I was working at an Audi/VW garage when it first came out and my boss had one. Sadly, the closest I got do driving it was moving it a few feet to get another car out but is sounded awesome! He also had an S4 Avant Auto which was nice that I did get to drive a bit further. It was nice but probably not as special as the RS4. Later, I was pretty content that I had the nicest car in the street (Impreza WRX) until a new neighbour moved in with a 2006 RS4 Avant and then my other neigbour bought an R32 (Golf)! The whole street did kond of know when he was going out or coming home though. I got on quite well with him and always regret not asking him to take me for a ride in it!

Anyway my quandry is this?

I could probably afford to buy this:

http://www.autotrader.ca/a/Audi/S8/CALGARY/Alberta...

or this now:

http://www.autotrader.ca/a/Audi/RS+6/Saint-Laurent...

The S8 looks pretty tidy and lowish kms for a 2001 but it is 12 hours drive away and it's no younger than my Jeep. Silver wouldn't be my first colour choice but I could live with it and I think this is one of the handsomest big saloons ever made. I could look at a newer V10 but wouldn't really want to run a V10 as a daily. Were these NA or turbocharged?

The RS6 miraculously is only 3 hours away bearing in mind there are only two RS6s listed on Autotrader in the whole of Canada. I like that colour but hate those wheels and from what I've heard RS6 running costs are pretty eyewatering!

It would take me a while to save up the extra for an RS4 but this one looks perfect!

http://www.autotrader.ca/a/Audi/RS+4/TORONTO/Ontar...

It's in Toronto though so 3 days drive away! I would probably fly there though and then drive back (which I could do in 2 days at a push) but maybe not until the snow has gone away! I could dealer finance but sometimes this is difficult if you live out of province. Servicing sounds fairly reasonable from what you say but some pretty expensive parts prices (like brakes and you don't really want to cheap out on them)!

Although an S4 doesn't excite me as much, you have to concede that this looks pretty good value next to a 7 year old RS4!

http://www.autotrader.ca/a/Audi/S4/Edmonton/Albert...

As you can see, sourcing used vehicles is the biggest issue for me really. I can't just jump in the car and go down the road and test drive one!









Edited by white_goodman on Thursday 13th February 18:31

ChrisRS6

736 posts

214 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
C6 RS6 for the win!!

Not the last word in handling....however capable enough for fast road driving.

730 bhp no sweat with re map....and very reliable.


However if your concern is fuel consumption, don't bother!!!

white_goodman

Original Poster:

4,528 posts

222 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
ChrisRS6 said:
C6 RS6 for the win!!

Not the last word in handling....however capable enough for fast road driving.

730 bhp no sweat with re map....and very reliable.


However if your concern is fuel consumption, don't bother!!!
Is the C6 the V10 or the V8? What mpg?

ChrisRS6

736 posts

214 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
5.0 V10 TT

575 bhp standard.

Mpg?.....shocking.

Mine...8-12 blipping round town.

22-26 on run.

Murph7355

42,082 posts

287 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
iluvmercs summary is very good.

Ultimately I think these are very different cars, so it really depends what you want.

The S8 is a luxury cruiser with a turn of speed.

The RS4 is a road racer. Very chuckable, a lot of fun. Bugger all space in the back if you have the bucket seats though (the one you linked to doesn't).

The RS6 is something in between the two I guess.

Long journeys, straight roads, plenty of kit to transport I'd be going S8 or maybe RS6.

Twisty roads, two up most of the time, the drive is as much the point as the destination? RS4 or maybe RS6.

Dr G

16,012 posts

273 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
iluvmercs said:
I can't comment on running costs of the others, but the B7 RS4 is serviced every 2 years/20k miles or when the indicator says - because I track my car and do drive a little briskly, this means around £400 is spent at the main dealer every 16k/18 months.
There are no A and B services, just a full one each time. Some buyers are put off if they don't see a regular service every year, but the car just doesn't need it.
If enthusiastic driving is undertaken regularly, it may be worth changing the diff oil and gearbox oil - something I have done every couple of years, because of the track work.
Who told you this?

Longlife intervals are only suitable for long, smooth constant speed journeys (i.e. trotting up and down motorways).

Audi stipulate very clearly that for hard use they are serviced annually or 10,000 miles. Whichever is the sooner.

...and back on topic; have a good read of the B8 S4 thread. They're damn good cars and 25 would buy a fantastic one,

iluvmercs

7,541 posts

258 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
Dr G said:
iluvmercs said:
I can't comment on running costs of the others, but the B7 RS4 is serviced every 2 years/20k miles or when the indicator says - because I track my car and do drive a little briskly, this means around £400 is spent at the main dealer every 16k/18 months.
There are no A and B services, just a full one each time. Some buyers are put off if they don't see a regular service every year, but the car just doesn't need it.
If enthusiastic driving is undertaken regularly, it may be worth changing the diff oil and gearbox oil - something I have done every couple of years, because of the track work.
Who told you this?

Longlife intervals are only suitable for long, smooth constant speed journeys (i.e. trotting up and down motorways).

Audi stipulate very clearly that for hard use they are serviced annually or 10,000 miles. Whichever is the sooner.
I confess nobody told me, just going on my service indicator's intervals paperbag
I stand corrected, and now will adjust my advice and regime thumbup

Darren

Edited by iluvmercs on Friday 14th February 02:58

white_goodman

Original Poster:

4,528 posts

222 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
iluvmercs said:
I confess nobody told me, just going on my service indicator's intervals paperbag
I stand corrected, and now will adjust my advice and regime thumbup

Darren

Edited by iluvmercs on Friday 14th February 02:58
Darren, was your car featured in the Evo buying guide? I know I have it somewhere but can't find it at the moment. Which issue was it and what was on the front cover?

Dr G

16,012 posts

273 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
The very same car:

http://www.evo.co.uk/buying/buyingguide/245446/aud...

Darren - your engine will thank you for it. A lot of people (particularly those using their cars in anger) prefer to run them on a 5w40 too; it's a little more manly under the temperatures an RS4 inflicts on its oil and seems to offer a reduction in oil consumption whilst still meeting Audi's specification.

Soupie69uk

1,117 posts

248 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
I would go for the V10 S8 over the older shape as it should be within your budget. I imagine the V10 will have a similar fuel efficiency to the old V8 since its about 5 years newer as well. Plus that V10 sounds amazing.

I would not go for an RS6 (C5) myself as the gearbox stories scare me. When I drove one it was amazingly quick however, felt like a spaceship to me. It was very heavy round the roundabouts however but it is a big car and the S8 will be the same.

If you want more fun handling or smaller car and do not plan to change too much then go for the RS4 (B7). If you want to tune a little then I would get the S4 (B8). But then if handling is a priority an M3 would probably be better.

slippery

14,093 posts

270 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
iluvmercs said:
Dr G said:
iluvmercs said:
I can't comment on running costs of the others, but the B7 RS4 is serviced every 2 years/20k miles or when the indicator says - because I track my car and do drive a little briskly, this means around £400 is spent at the main dealer every 16k/18 months.
There are no A and B services, just a full one each time. Some buyers are put off if they don't see a regular service every year, but the car just doesn't need it.
If enthusiastic driving is undertaken regularly, it may be worth changing the diff oil and gearbox oil - something I have done every couple of years, because of the track work.
Who told you this?

Longlife intervals are only suitable for long, smooth constant speed journeys (i.e. trotting up and down motorways).

Audi stipulate very clearly that for hard use they are serviced annually or 10,000 miles. Whichever is the sooner.
I confess nobody told me, just going on my service indicator's intervals paperbag
I stand corrected, and now will adjust my advice and regime thumbup

Darren

Edited by iluvmercs on Friday 14th February 02:58
it's too late now Darren, it's probably buggered and could go bang on you at any time.

















I'll give you £10k for it to get you out of trouble. hehe


getmecoat

toon10

7,154 posts

188 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
I'm not a fan of Audi but I have an irrational want for a phantom black RS4 Avant. I don't know why as I don't need 4WD, an estate car or even room in the back. I just want one. The other two cars will be good crusisers and straight line warriors no doubt but I have no desire to own either of them.

iluvmercs

7,541 posts

258 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
white_goodman said:
Darren, was your car featured in the Evo buying guide? I know I have it somewhere but can't find it at the moment. Which issue was it and what was on the front cover?
Yup, as Dr G has already confirmed, it is my car smile

Having now seen your location is Canada, do you get NAS spec cars - I'm not 100%, but IIRC, but with the R4, that means you guys didn't get the factory option of bucket seats or the flat bottom steering wheel - at least I'm sure this was the case south of the boarder.
Hopefully Canada's choices were different as the buckets and wheel are lovely biggrin

Darren

Edited by iluvmercs on Friday 14th February 14:09

iluvmercs

7,541 posts

258 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Darren - your engine will thank you for it. A lot of people (particularly those using their cars in anger) prefer to run them on a 5w40 too; it's a little more manly under the temperatures an RS4 inflicts on its oil and seems to offer a reduction in oil consumption whilst still meeting Audi's specification.
Thanks for the advice and correction, Dr G smile

Darren

iluvmercs

7,541 posts

258 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
slippery said:
it's too late now Darren, it's probably buggered and could go bang on you at any time.
I'll give you £10k for it to get you out of trouble. hehe


getmecoat
Quiet down you!
I'm surprised your 4.2 luxobarge Audi hasn't already gone pop - poor thing attending a PH Run drivingwhistle

Darren