Wheelie bin damaged neighbours car in last nights storm
Wheelie bin damaged neighbours car in last nights storm
Author
Discussion

JB8

Original Poster:

381 posts

176 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Yesterday was bin day, but due to the forecast windy weather I made the conscious decision not to put the bins out as they’d just get blown about, the bins weren’t that full and can wait till next week’s collection so I left them in the garden.

The neighbour next door though I’d ‘forgot’ to put the bins out and put them out on my behalf. We often take the bins out for each other and put them back in, and generally look out for each other, little favours and such, generally try to be as neighbourly as we can.

But when I got home last night my bin had blown into another neighbour’s (two doors down, we also get on well with them) car and it has caused a scratch along the rear wing and driver’s door. It was quite dark, wet and windy last night so have not had a chance to see the full extent of the damage, but it doesn’t look too bad.

Anyway, I discussed it with the neighbours last night, me and next door have agreed to cover the cost of repair 50:50 in the interest of maintaining neighbourly relations.

Question is do you think this arrangement if fair? My other half seems to disagree, and thinks next door should cover the full cost. What does PH think?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
I don't think you're legally liable for anything in this situation, but I think you're doing the right thing and it's how I'd like to handle it in your shoes.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
If you regularly put each others' bins out then he's not entirely to blame, so 50/50 sounds about right.

ShawCrossShark

4,300 posts

265 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Realistically, I wouldn't have thought either of you would be liable in the circumstances.

From my own POV I think that you are being more than fair and applaud the level of neighbourliness clap

The Beaver King

6,095 posts

226 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
.......

Freak accident, Act of God etc.

The simple fact is that your bin hit the neighbours car. While you didn't put the bin out yourself, your neighbour thought they were doing you a favour. So in return your going to demand they foot the full bill?

What's the damage likely to be? £200ish? Pay your half and consider yourself fortunate to have a neighbour good enough to realise he is partly responsible.

Your OH has obviously never lived next door to neighbours that don't get on, it's bloody horrible. Maintain the good relationship you have with both neighbours and split the bill.

MacW

1,352 posts

207 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
As you knew your neighbour was in the habit of doing you a favour and putting your bins out for you I'd say the arrangement is fair.

An argument could be made for him not using his common sense in the face of gale force armageddon but the same sort of argument could be made for you having a chat with him to let him know you didn't want the bins out.

It's a long way from being a clear cut situation, especially when you add in the whole 'Insurance! That's what it's for!' viewpoint but sharing the bill for the sake of a friendly neighbourhood would get my vote from a real world perspective.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
I'd agree with the others.
It's a rough situation, but the split of costs means that everyone deals with a bit of crap and nobody has to deal with the whole lot.

Everyone might not be happy.
But at least no one person is totally sad.

austinsmirk

5,597 posts

154 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
I appauld yr actions of splitting the bill to maintain the harmony where you live. its a nice thing to do.

whats £100 in a repair bill V the anguish of falling out with a neighbour, moving house etc etc.


CaptainSensib1e

1,534 posts

252 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
More than decent of you I'd say. To be 100% fair I'd split the cost 3 ways (you, neighbour who put bin out, neighbour whose car was hit). It's not really anyone's fault, just a very unfortunate incident.

JB8

Original Poster:

381 posts

176 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the comments/input guys, 50:50 seems the fairest way to go. It's just one of those things, no one is at fault in my opinion, just an unfortunate accident. Definitely not worth falling out with the neighbours over.

I'll be talking to them later tonight to discuss the quotes, and see how much it is going to cost.

juggsy

1,529 posts

161 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
JB8 said:
Thanks for the comments/input guys, 50:50 seems the fairest way to go. It's just one of those things, no one is at fault in my opinion, just an unfortunate accident. Definitely not worth falling out with the neighbours over.

I'll be talking to them later tonight to discuss the quotes, and see how much it is going to cost.
If only all neighbourhood communities were like this! Good on you for keeping up neighbourly relations. I assume you don't live on James Turner Street biggrin

JB8

Original Poster:

381 posts

176 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Update.

Had a proper look at the damage tonight and it wasn't at all that bad at all, the scratch wasn't that deep, just the clear coat, and a black plastic/rubber scuff, so jokingly said to my neighbor "that'll buff out". Anyway, we decided to give it a go, got the car in my garage, clay bar sorted out the rubber scuff, and my machine polisher got rid of the scratch nicely!



Anonamoose

442 posts

166 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Can I have your neighbours! I wish everyone was as understanding and well neighbourly.

JB8

Original Poster:

381 posts

176 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
I've really lucked out in this street, makes a refreshing change. I used to live in a flat surrounded by scrotes.

redstu

2,287 posts

270 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
A similar thing happened to me a couple of years ago.
It wasn't bin day but my bin managed to land on my neighbors car.
It wasn't stormy but the bin moved and dented his front wing.
He got a number of quotes and I paid the £70 total cost.
We are still neighbours and on good terms.
The bins are now secured with a bungee now so it won't happen again.
It hurt at the time, but I had forgotten all about it. I hope the nightmares don't start again.

22Rgt

3,575 posts

158 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Hardly the end of the world is it. Its a scratch/dent caused by a bin, its not going to have any impact on how the car runs or drives. Just forget it and move on, not yours or your neighbours fault and this guy should realise that..

rb5er

11,657 posts

203 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
22Rgt said:
Hardly the end of the world is it. Its a scratch/dent caused by a bin, its not going to have any impact on how the car runs or drives. Just forget it and move on, not yours or your neighbours fault and this guy should realise that..
Think I`d much rather live next door to the OP than you.

Ah my bin damaged your car......your problem. Nice. rolleyes

55palfers

6,396 posts

195 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Surely all bins belong to your local Council - mine is embossed to that effect.

TurricanII

1,516 posts

229 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
22Rgt said:
Hardly the end of the world is it. Its a scratch/dent caused by a bin, its not going to have any impact on how the car runs or drives. Just forget it and move on, not yours or your neighbours fault and this guy should realise that..
Whilst the car is fine the resale value is affected. The person who puts a bin out in a storm is at least half morally responsible imo

beko1987

1,722 posts

165 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Can't beat a bit of detailing to save the day! I did the same when someone clipped the missus car, no insurance all round!