Opposite home fence broke and flew in to my car - advice?
Discussion
OK so these freak storms finally caused me some damage last night. My car was parked on the street amd the house opposite lost a 6ft fence panel that flew into the side of my car.
They are saying I need to go through my car insurance but I don't see why I should be liable to pay for my excess for their bloody fence panel!
Any advice as to where I stand? Would their home insurance cover damage to my car?
They are saying I need to go through my car insurance but I don't see why I should be liable to pay for my excess for their bloody fence panel!
Any advice as to where I stand? Would their home insurance cover damage to my car?
I would think as their property has caused third party damage, then yes, the only problem is have they got insurance, as it's not compulsory for property and I'm not sure if they are not obliged to give you there details, most normal neighbours would, but you know what some people are like.
I think establishing a duty of care and that they failed in that duty of care and that their failure led to your loss is going to be nigh on impossible. Particularly when you're competing with well publicised abnormal weather conditions.
You have motor insurance for these kind of events and in this case I'd imagine that's the appropriate method of recompense. If you don't want to pay for the repair yourself.
You have motor insurance for these kind of events and in this case I'd imagine that's the appropriate method of recompense. If you don't want to pay for the repair yourself.
Ironically, none of the lawyers who post here are ambulance chasers and we tend more often than not to advise people not to sue in respect of the various things that people come on here to ask about. WW may be one of the unduly keen amateurs. He may perhaps have been trapped down a mine for a bit and missed the recent weather reports as well. They are only 24/7 on every news medium, so missing them is understandable.
WinstonWolf said:
A well maintained fence should not blow away.

Trees blow down, lorries overturn, roofs fly off houses....but look after your fence and 100mph winds will be no match for it!

OP, you've done nothing wrong, but neither has your neighbour. The damage is down to you I'm afraid.
TwigtheWonderkid said:
WinstonWolf said:
A well maintained fence should not blow away.

Trees blow down, lorries overturn, roofs fly off houses....but look after your fence and 100mph winds will be no match for it!

OP, you've done nothing wrong, but neither has your neighbour. The damage is down to you I'm afraid.
I'm feeling smug, I replaced my fence with a wall

The finest book ever written about fencing*. Recommended - it is dark, funny, twisted, etc. Written by an ex bus driver.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Restraint_of_Beas...
* except for "The Princess Bride", but wrong sort of fencing.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Restraint_of_Beas...
* except for "The Princess Bride", but wrong sort of fencing.
"I'm not left handed either".
I LOVE that film. The book is pretty good, too. William Goldman is a mensch.
As for the OP having a claim absent negligence: inconceivable! If he tries, he had better get used to disappointment. Making a claim would be like starting a land war in Asia. Etc, etc, etc.
I LOVE that film. The book is pretty good, too. William Goldman is a mensch.
As for the OP having a claim absent negligence: inconceivable! If he tries, he had better get used to disappointment. Making a claim would be like starting a land war in Asia. Etc, etc, etc.
Edited by anonymous-user on Saturday 15th February 13:00
Breadvan72 said:
"I'm nit left handed either".
I LOVE that film. The book is pretty good, too. William Goldman is a mensch.
As for the OP having a claim absent negligence: inconceivable! If he tries, he had better get used to disappointment. Making a claim would be like starting a land war in Asia. Etc, etc, etc.
I never knew there was a book. Is it a book of the film, or is it a film of the book?I LOVE that film. The book is pretty good, too. William Goldman is a mensch.
As for the OP having a claim absent negligence: inconceivable! If he tries, he had better get used to disappointment. Making a claim would be like starting a land war in Asia. Etc, etc, etc.
Another thumbs up for The restraint of beast, great book.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


