Insurance and s139 LASPO Rehabilitation
Insurance and s139 LASPO Rehabilitation
Author
Discussion

10 Pence Short

Original Poster:

32,880 posts

248 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
It's been announced that this will be commenced from 10th March 2014. I note the rehabilitation period for a fine is reduced from 5 years to 1 year.

What impact will this have on insurers' right to ask for previous convictions over the preceding 5 years?

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
higher costs for consumer with absolutely no increase in profits for insurers

and they'll cook the books to prove it

barker22

1,037 posts

198 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
Quite simply you will not have to disclose after the points come off surely?

bradjsmith88

117 posts

159 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
I believe - but may be wrong - there was a discussion that motor insurance would become exempt from the act, where the conviction was relevant to the contract/risk.

agtlaw

7,433 posts

237 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Some info:


What are the rehabilitation periods for motoring offences?

An endorsement for a road traffic offence listed in Schedule 2 to the Road Traffic Offenders Act1988, imposed either by the court or by means of a fixed penalty notice (FPN) is a sentence for the purposes of the 1974 Act and may become spent after 5 years (or two and half years where
the offender is under 18). Road traffic legislation specifically provides for a FPN in these circumstances to be treated as a conviction and dealt with as such under the 1974 Act. Penalty points and a driving disqualification imposed by the court on conviction may become spent
when they cease to have effect (penalty points have effect for three years as set out in road traffic legislation). Where the court imposes more than one sentence or penalty for the offence then the longest rehabilitation period determines when the conviction may become spent

A fixed penalty notice (FPN) can be used to deal with minor road traffic offences, but it is not a criminal conviction or a caution and the 1974 Act does not apply.

Examples

An adult is convicted of a road traffic offence, and the court imposes a fine (rehabilitation period 1 year), an endorsement (rehabilitation period 5 years), penalty points (rehabilitation period 3 years) and driving disqualification for 1 year (rehabilitation period 1 year); the
rehabilitation period for this conviction will be 5 years because the endorsement carries the longest rehabilitation period.

If the offender was under 18 and received the above sentence, the conviction may become spent after 3 years because the longest rehabilitation period applicable would then be three years for the penalty points (the endorsement would become spent after two and half years).

Once the conviction becomes spent, the person is not required to declare it when applying for most jobs, or (motor) insurance

It is the case for all convictions (not only road traffic convictions) that where more than one sentence or penalty is imposed then the conviction may only become spent once the longest rehabilitation period which applies has ended.

For more information on the rehabilitation periods for particular driving offences, ...



http://www.crimeline.info/uploads/clc/miscresource...

10 Pence Short

Original Poster:

32,880 posts

248 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
I got the same email circular as you this morning. wink

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
An endorsement for a road traffic offence... is a sentence for the purposes of the 1974 Act and may become spent after 5 years.

http://www.crimeline.info/uploads/clc/miscresource...
Hmmm... have I missed something? Under the old regime an endorsement did most likely come under the "any other sentence subject to rehabilitation under this Act" provision in Section 5(2), and so had a rehabilitation period of 5 years. But the old Section 5(2) is gone, and the new legislation says "There is no rehabilitation period for... any other sentence in respect of a conviction where the sentence is not dealt with in the Table or under subsection (3)". An endorsement isn't included in the table or subsection 3, so where does the 5 years come from now?



agtlaw

7,433 posts

237 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
I was thinking the same thing. At first blush, it seems wrong. Where's davepoth?

Zeeky

2,954 posts

243 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
http://www.crimeline.info/uploads/clc/miscresources/rehaboffenders.pdf said:
Penalty points ... imposed by the court on conviction may become spent when they cease to have effect (penalty points have effect for three years as set out in road traffic legislation).
The author appears confused over the meaning of 'penalty' points for the purpose of the the RHoOA.

agtlaw

7,433 posts

237 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Who wrote it?

ETA - I've answered my own question - metadata says MOJ.

Edited by agtlaw on Wednesday 5th March 23:12

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
so what does this mean?

4 people want insurance on Monday when the new rules have taken effect, they all got 3 points and a fine, a got his a year and ago yesterday, b got his 2 years ago yesterday c got his 3 years ago yesterday, and d got his 4 years ago yesterday

what period should the insurer ask them about?
what should each of them tell the insurer, if the insurer asks about in the last 5 years

does it make a difference if they were convicted by a court of received a fixed penalty.

Also, if a person notifies his insurer of a pending prosecution at renewal, and is charged and increased premium, which he is told will be refunded should he win his case. What would that person tell his insurers if he was to receive an absolute discharge and therefore does not have any unspent convictions, or at-least no new ones

agtlaw

7,433 posts

237 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
The MOJ document should be read in conjunction with SI 2014 no. 423

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2014/423/note/m...

EXPLANATORY NOTE
(This note is not part of the Order)

This Order is the ninth commencement order made under the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (c. 10) (“the 2012 Act”).

Article 2 brings into force on 10th March 2014 sections 139 and 141(1) to (6), (10) and (11) of the 2012 Act together with Schedule 25 to that Act (with the exception of paragraph 4). Those provisions make amendments to the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (c. 53) (“the 1974 Act”) and make consequential amendments to other legislation. Article 2 is subject to the saving provision in Article 3.

Article 3 makes saving provision for an endorsement given by a court for an offence mentioned in Schedule 2 to the Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988 (c. 53) (“the 1988 Act”). Such an endorsement is a sentence in relation to which the last entry in Table A in section 5(2) of the 1974 Act applies. The principal effect of this saving provision is that such an endorsement continues to attract a rehabilitation period of 5 years.

Article 3 also provides that the saving provision does not apply to the commencement of section 139(5)(b) of the 2012 Act, which omits section 6(6) of the 1974 Act. The effect of the omission of section 6(6) of the 1974 Act is that summary offences and other offences in that subsection are taken into account when calculating the rehabilitation period under section 6(4) where a person is convicted of a further offence. The effect of article 3 is therefore that a conviction resulting in an endorsement given by a court in relation to an offence mentioned in Schedule 2 to the 1988 Act is affected by the omission of section 6(6) of the 1974 Act in the same way as any other conviction.

Article 4 specifies 10th March 2014 as the commencement date for the purposes of section 141(1) to (6) of the 2012 Act.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
As you may remember I had an argument with my insurers on this very subject last year.

I'm not entirely convinced by the MoJ guidance. If it's law, why not quote the law, or the relevant precedent? As far as I can work out the authority in this matter is Power v Provincial, which the ABI declared to give no rehabilitation period to endorsements. My insurer agreed, and if there was any question about which way it should be interpreted I'm sure my insurer would have gone the other way.

I'm guessing this is what has been worked out with the insurance industry as a "transitional" arrangement. They'll put this out, and then it'll take a few years for any binding court case to work its way through the system to challenge it.

Because I'm an angry nerd, I've already volleyed off an email to the Minister for Rehabilitation and an FOI request to the MoJ to try and find out what's going on. wink

agtlaw

7,433 posts

237 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
MOJ says:

" ... imposed either by the court or by means of a fixed penalty notice is a sentence ... "

What is the authority for the emboldened part? - it's not in the S.I. Anyone?

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
The MOJ document should be read in conjunction with SI 2014 no. 423

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2014/423/note/m...
Thanks, that makes sense then... In as much as a speeding ticket having a longer rehabilitation period than a 6 month prison sentence can ever make sense.

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
MOJ says:

" ... imposed either by the court or by means of a fixed penalty notice is a sentence ... "

What is the authority for the emboldened part? - it's not in the S.I. Anyone?
Road Traffic Offenders Act section 58?

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
davepoth said:
As far as I can work out the authority in this matter is Power v Provincial, which the ABI declared to give no rehabilitation period to endorsements.
I don't think that's the correct interpretation of Power v Provincial. That case specifically concerned an 11 year endorsement for drink driving. There were 3 possible interpretations of the law

(1) An endorsement is a disqualification, disability, prohibition or other penalty and gets a rehabilitation period of however long it stays on your licence for (11 years in Power's case)
(2) An endorsement is not a disqualification etc or other penalty but it is another type of sentence, and gets a rehabilitation period of 5 years under the "any other sentence" clause in 5(2)
(3) An endorsement is not a sentence at all, and has no rehabilitation period

The Appeal Court decided by a 2-1 majority that an endorsement is not a disqualification, disability prohibition or other penalty, so (1) is not correct. They didn't have to make a definitive ruling on whether (2) or (3) was correct as Power's conviction was spent either way, but all three judges did express the opinion that an endorsement was a sentence so they seemed to think that (2) was correct.

agtlaw

7,433 posts

237 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
Aretnap said:
Road Traffic Offenders Act section 58?
That looks like it.

58 Effect of endorsement without hearing.

Where a person’s licence is endorsed under section 57 of this Act he shall be treated for the purposes ... of the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 as if—
(a)he had been convicted of the offence,
(b)the endorsement had been made in pursuance of an order made on his conviction by a court under section 44 of this Act

44 Endorsement of licences.

(1)Where a person is convicted of an offence involving obligatory endorsement, the court must order there to be endorsed on any licence held by him particulars of the conviction ... [etc, etc.]

Zeeky

2,954 posts

243 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
The Order simply exempts endorsements from the changes brought about by the new legislation. Power is authority for the proposition that an endorsement for a fixed penalty is not a 'penalty' for the purpose of Section 5(8( RoOA. If it were a 'penalty' the rehabilitation period would expire when the points expired.

The CA stated, obiter that an endorsement is proabbaly a sentence for the purpose of the RoOA.

Under the old legislation - still applicable to endorsements - “any other sentence subject to rehabilitation under this Act" has a rehabilitation period of 5 years.

That is where the 5 years comes from. Power is still good law.

Aretnap

1,984 posts

182 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
One thing which might be relevant to motorists is that under the new section 8AA will mean "alternatives to prosecution" will be treated in the same way as cautions and will become spent immediately (added - or in 3 months depending in the type of alternative). I haven't managed to find the full definition of alternatives to prosecution" as the wording if the act just says that it means the same as it does in Scotland, but I imagine that it would apply to,speed awareness courses. So would I be correct in thinking that people who've done SACs will no longer have to declare them to insurers (particularly Admiral)?

Added: Think I've found it - http://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2010/13/section/... The oat relevant part seems to be if he "has accepted an offer made by a procurator fiscal in respect of the offence to undertake an activity or treatment or to receive services or do any other thing as an alternative to prosecution".

Edited by Aretnap on Thursday 6th March 23:18