Which BMW tourer?
Author
Discussion

hornetrider

Original Poster:

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Looking to buy something to chew some serious miles on a commute (80-100/day round trip). Have considered a Pan but am edging towards a BMW, no real reason, just fancy one. Don't want to do it in a car because the journey has tolls (free on a bike) and is quite often jammed.

Needs to be:

- comfortable
- have good weather/wind protection
- as large range as possible (250 if possible?)
- reliable

Shortlist is R1150RT, K1200RS, K1200GT. Budget is flexible, but 2-4k.

Can anyone educate me on them? Anything else I should consider?

RizzoTheRat

29,153 posts

223 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Dunno about the BMW's but in terms of other stuff the dirt cheap end of the spectrum is the Diversion 900, generally known as being about as reliable as a CG125.

If you're used to a more sportsbikey riding position then you might find a sports tourer like the FJR or K1200S suits you better.

dibblecorse

7,666 posts

223 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
I asked this exact question on the BMW stand at the Excel yesterday, the answer from the man in the know was that for a mix of motorway / urban and rare pillion work the GS800 Adventure was the one for me .... made perfect send, everything else was wider than Fleegle !!!

hornetrider

Original Poster:

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
I have a Falco which I've tweaked and sorted over the years, fits me like a glove, so I'll be keeping that (and doing my Euro touring on it) so I literally need something to eat miles on the motorway. K1200S are ok but too much like the Falco really, I want something more suited to comfortable motorway work.

hornetrider

Original Poster:

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
dibblecorse said:
GS800 Adventure
Don't fancy being Ewan McCharlie, and they don't look very protected from the elements. The R1150RT directs warm air from the engine onto your hands, for example cloud9

dibblecorse

7,666 posts

223 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
I have a Falco which I've tweaked and sorted over the years, fits me like a glove, so I'll be keeping that (and doing my Euro touring on it) so I literally need something to eat miles on the motorway. K1200S are ok but too much like the Falco really, I want something more suited to comfortable motorway work.
Fair enough, my 90 mile round trip is evenly split motorway then crossing London, so if yours is way more motorway biased then you're probably right ..... enjoy the search ....

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
I don't know much about the K's - there's a guide of sorts here:

http://www.visordown.com/road-tests-used/buyer-gui...

R's will need a clutch change between 40k - 80k miles, so make sure this has been done or budget for it. It's a dry clutch like a car, and costs the best part of £1k to pay someone else to change.

ABS switched in 2001 to a servo assisted weird ass system which seems to go wrong sooner or later and cost £££ to sort out. It switched back to a more conventional and reliable set up in 2007ish. Either buy a bike w/o it, or a pre 2001 bike.

The R1100RT is fine and can be found very cheaply. Both it and the 1150 can have funny surging characteristics on part throttle. Try and have a ride if you can - it should be smooth, although might just need the throttle bodies synching.

Check for play in the rear diff (shouldn't be any) and that all the electrics work. Gearboxes can also be fragile as they age, so check for crunches, whines and false neutrals.

Rosscow

9,729 posts

194 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Standard Pistonheads reply = 330 with a re-map laugh

black-k1

12,813 posts

260 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
If it were my money being spent I'd go for a K1200RS. Rock solid if boring "brick" engine but with a bit of get up and go that the twins won't match. No significant issues to look out for other than play/noise from the shaft UJs and ABS warning lights that either stay on or don't go out.

The UJs are not part of the service schedule so don't get greased. Sorted by ... er ... greasing them.

The ABS light can either be the sign of a dying battery, which is easily solved, or an ABS control unit failure which is rare but expensive to replace.

Other than the GS Adventures, you're unlikely to get a 250 mile tank range. 180 - 200 is realistic between fill ups.

TimmyWimmyWoo

4,364 posts

212 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Buy my father's K1200GT. It's very well looked after and he's been trying (not very hard) to sell it since last May. He loved its power, handling and gadgets. He's only selling because he replaced it with a K1600, which is a whole extra thing...

RizzoTheRat

29,153 posts

223 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Dullville?

The BMW800 engine is very good on fuel so the F800GT/ST might be worth a look, but probably not as good a faring as the bigger BMWs.

If you want to go the proper comfy tourer route there's not a lot a choice beyond the BMWs and Pan you've already identified.

hornetrider

Original Poster:

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
black-k1 said:
Other than the GS Adventures, you're unlikely to get a 250 mile tank range. 180 - 200 is realistic between fill ups.
Gah. If that's true then I may have to go for a Pan and it's 300 mile range. Doing 500 miles a week I'd want to minimise time spent stood filling up in my leathers/gear.

Tim1989

798 posts

165 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
The R1150RT is very good indeed. As mentioned above, they have the servo assisted brakes. When these work they're very, very good indeed, but some people have had problems (often it has to be said through lack of maintenance), the estimate is about 6% of all 1150RT's manufactured. The standard fix is to ditch the servos and ABS entirely (can be done for nothing if you're vaguely competent mechanically), leaving you with very good unassisted brakes. Either that or the best part of £1000 on a new servo unit. 2004 (twin spark) is the best year, with the least problems and next to no surging.

The R1100RT is very good too, not as fast but very comfortable. Some surging at low speeds and low revs (though a lot of the time this is because people aren't riding them properly. Contrary to popular opinion, they need to be revved to get the best from them). Someone said above that you can pick these up cheap, you can't. Often the asking prices for these aren't much less than the 1150's, with the 1150 being a much better all round package. Also have a look at the R1100RS, less desirable, so cheaper, but great for motorway miles. They have a sportier riding position which (to me) is a lot more comfortable.

The K1200RSs are the last of the transverse mounted fours. Great riding position, significantly faster (and smoother) than the boxers, ridden hard they'll give plenty of modern stuff a run for its money. Relatively trouble free, you have to watch the servo brakes again that they put on the very last ones. Can suffer drive-train problems, but again usually due to lack of maintenance.

SAS Tom

3,756 posts

205 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
The problem with all of them is the clutch really. There are varying ways of the being knackered from just wearing out to knackered input shaft splines requiring a new gearbox. I had an R1100S that needed a new clutch and gearbox at 47k and it cost 1300 quid to sort at an Indy!

I nearly bought a 1200GT as well but there are too many stories of those going wrong which put me off.

If it's just for commuting and nothing else what about a K75/100? Much cheaper to run and old now but if it's just for work and back it shouldn't matter too much. They aren't as big or heavy as the later stuff either.

Rosscow

9,729 posts

194 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
TimmyWimmyWoo said:
Buy my father's K1200GT. It's very well looked after and he's been trying (not very hard) to sell it since last May. He loved its power, handling and gadgets. He's only selling because he replaced it with a K1600, which is a whole extra thing...
Linky to advert?

TimmyWimmyWoo

4,364 posts

212 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
He's not advertising it at the moment - he was waiting until March I think. I can try and get some details for you if you like!

Rosscow

9,729 posts

194 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
TimmyWimmyWoo said:
He's not advertising it at the moment - he was waiting until March I think. I can try and get some details for you if you like!
No, you'd better not - don't tempt me laugh

TimmyWimmyWoo

4,364 posts

212 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Ah, I've chatted to him and he's after a bit more than your budget allows - I think he's looking for £5k...

...which means you should buy a Blackbird for £2k and marvel at the reliability, smoothness, speed and tank range (well, I get 165 miles out of my 2006 model easily, but they're more like £3.5k). Weather protection isn't as brilliant as on a Beemer with a taller screen, but you can outrun the rain.


hornetrider

Original Poster:

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
GT eh? What's the approximate value...? scratchchin

Cheers all above btw, good info and food for thought.

Wedg1e

27,045 posts

296 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Gah. If that's true then I may have to go for a Pan and it's 300 mile range. Doing 500 miles a week I'd want to minimise time spent stood filling up in my leathers/gear.
Aye, I can get 330 miles cruising at motorway speeds on my ST.
I see the 1300 prices might have dropped a bit; sub-£4K for a 2006 bike with 20-odd thousand went on Ebay a few days ago. Could be because it's winter, mind - and at auction so maybe the seller misjudged or was glad to be rid, who knows?