:( On the spot 1500CHF (£1000) fine in Switzerland! :(
:( On the spot 1500CHF (£1000) fine in Switzerland! :(
Author
Discussion

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
So just arrived in Zurich today and was in a great mood having been upgraded to a 5 Series and looking forward to my skiing holiday with my family. I was driving sensibly and legally from the airport to Davos, which makes the following isolated incident extremely disappointing. I was following a line of 3 slow moving vehicles, travelling at 60 kmph on an 80 limit on one of the twisties. When it was safe I proceeded to overtake the row of cars but as I became parallel with - believe it or not - a Croatian registered Golf GTI, the miserable driver suddenly decided to put his foot down. As there was approaching oncoming traffic and I was on the wrong side of the road, I had to floor it in order to reach safety. You can guess the next part: there was an unmarked mobile camera unit at that specific patch of the 160km route I took! I was clocked at 130kmph.

To cut a long story shorter, I was pulled over shortly after. I had to make a written statement which the officer translated into German for me in which I rejected the charge on two grounds: 1) the camera hadn't been calibrated in almost a year (even though it was technically in-date under Swiss law; 2) I had to reach that speed for the sole purpose of safety. The officer claimed that, since I'm not a Swiss resident, they were obliged under Swiss law to charge me (which indeed they did) a deposit of the maximum fine of 1500CHF (£1000) until a court hearing is held. I'm was also banned from driving in Switzerland until the outcome of the hearing, which has had other untold of, but irrelevant, circumstances.

Clearly, it's not worth speeding in Switzerland unless perhaps in order to save your family's life (which in fact I was).

I'm very unsure on how to proceed at the moment and am just doing my best to not let this story affect the rest of my holiday. Things that have been running through my mind - whether reasonable/practical/effective or not - are hiring a Swiss lawyer, if financially viable, to defend me; just let it go undefended and probably losing my entire deposit; disputing the charge on my Amex based perhaps on the fact that I won't be able to defend myself in a Swiss court.

In any case, I would really like to hear from anyone with experience or knowledge of Swiss law or procedure. Also any Swiss legal contacts could be helpful.

Thanks





Edited by DaineseMan on Monday 17th February 18:36

amancalledrob

1,248 posts

165 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
I can't help, but I have a great deal of sympathy for you. I was banned for two months in France due to my own stupidity (210kph in a 130kph limit) but since I was almost at my destination and didn't need the car for a fortnight, I left it parked up till home time then drove back (800 miles) overnight, avoiding the autoroutes. I don't recommend you do anything like that, I was younger and stupider then.

Best of luck. It seems particularly harsh that you've been penalised due to someone else's irresponsible behavour. I believe in the UK you'd have been ok. Hope the Swiss can be made to see sense.

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
so, you were caught doing twice the limit because the golf accelerated when you were trying to overtake?

The sensible thing would have been to pull in behind him, but easy to say in hindsight.

I guess theres not much you can do, the Swiss take speeding very seriously, and twice the limit is pretty severe in any country. It may be worth talking with a swiss lawyer, but that in itself will increase the cost to you..

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
amancalledrob said:
I believe in the UK you'd have been ok. Hope the Swiss can be made to see sense.
If I had the time to come back to Switzerland and defend myself, maybe I would have some chance abolishing or at least reducing the charges. So not sure if to hire a lawyer or not.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Any chance the overtakee was caught on cam to corroborate your tale of woe? wink

Disastrous

10,218 posts

248 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Sympathies. I hate Switzerland for their irrelevant love for rules. How did Germans get tarred with that brush when the swiss are so much worse??

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
so, you were caught doing twice the limit because the golf accelerated when you were trying to overtake?

The sensible thing would have been to pull in behind him, but easy to say in hindsight.

I guess theres not much you can do, the Swiss take speeding very seriously, and twice the limit is pretty severe. (160kph is what? 100mph? i think in the UK you'd be looking at court for 100 in a 50)
It was doing 130kmph. The reference to 160 was the length of the route in km. Re-read the OP if you can be bothered.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
so, you were caught doing twice the limit because the golf accelerated when you were trying to overtake?

The sensible thing would have been to pull in behind him, but easy to say in hindsight.

I guess theres not much you can do, the Swiss take speeding very seriously, and twice the limit is pretty severe. (160kph is what? 100mph? i think in the UK you'd be looking at court for 100 in a 50)
I think you've misunderstood the OP.

Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
The Swiss are well know for their enthusiastic enforcement of the speed limit sadly. Personally I'd hand my wife the keys to the car for the holiday and spend my time drinking instead at this point, then happily drive again once back in sunny Blighty. It's really not worth getting caught driving while technically banned in Swisserland as Mr Prison will be a calling....and you won't be able to go on any more skiing hols their afterwards either as they are not a part of the EU.

Edited by Pablo68 on Monday 17th February 18:39

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Any chance the overtakee was caught on cam to corroborate your tale of woe? wink
They showed me two very high-res pictures which show me on the wrong side of the road along the Croatian car.

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Pablo68 said:
The Swiss are well know for their enthusiastic enforcement of the speed limit sadly. Personally I'd hand my wife the keys to the car for the holiday and spend my time drinking instead at this point, then happily drive again once back in sunny Blighty. It's really not worth getting caught driving while technically banned in Swisserland as Mr Prison will be a calling....and you won't be able to go on any more skiing hols their afterwards either as they are not a part of the EU.

Edited by Pablo68 on Monday 17th February 18:39
Had to sign a statement (the only one they provide in English) saying that if I drove again, I'd face 2 years imprisonment!

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
Fidgits said:
so, you were caught doing twice the limit because the golf accelerated when you were trying to overtake?

The sensible thing would have been to pull in behind him, but easy to say in hindsight.

I guess theres not much you can do, the Swiss take speeding very seriously, and twice the limit is pretty severe. (160kph is what? 100mph? i think in the UK you'd be looking at court for 100 in a 50)
It was doing 130kmph. The reference to 160 was the length of the route in km. Re-read the OP if you can be bothered.
ah sorry.. mis-read.

my concern is the cost of a swiss lawyer compared to potential fine?

Pablo68

910 posts

166 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
hornetrider said:
Any chance the overtakee was caught on cam to corroborate your tale of woe? wink
They showed me two very high-res pictures which show me on the wrong side of the road along the Croatian car.
So if you challenge it what the Beak will be shown will be two very high-res pictures which show you on the wrong side of the road along the Croatian car along with a speed meter reading showing 130kmh. Does not paint a pretty picture even if you plead the Croat was being a dick I'm afraid.

Vaud

60,025 posts

186 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
You overtook a line of 3 cars and were significantly over the limit. Switzerland is the land of needing to drive defensively.You were in a new car with good brakes - braking and dropping behind would have been safer. Never accelerate into a closing gap.

Don't take it personally though, they would have done the same to a local / their neighbour, etc. 130 in an 80 is very serious. I've lived out there - I'm not sure what your appeal would be in Swiss law.

Which Canton out of interest?

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Vaud said:
You overtook a line of 3 cars and were significantly over the limit. Switzerland is the land of needing to drive defensively.You were in a new car with good brakes - braking and dropping behind would have been safer. Never accelerate into a closing gap.

Don't take it personally though, they would have done the same to a local / their neighbour, etc. 130 in an 80 is very serious. I've lived out there - I'm not sure what your appeal would be in Swiss law.

Which Canton out of interest?
The choice was either accelerating into an open road or dropping into a closing gap (the latter option would have been far more dangerous).
It was in Graubünden.


Vaud

60,025 posts

186 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
The choice was either accelerating into an open road or dropping into a closing gap (the latter option would have been far more dangerous).
It was in Graubünden.
Sorry, you said there was oncoming traffic, which creates a closing ago between the accelerating golf and the oncoming traffic?

Sorry to say, but I think you are screwed.

DaineseMan

Original Poster:

628 posts

180 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Vaud said:
Sorry, you said there was oncoming traffic, which creates a closing ago between the accelerating golf and the oncoming traffic?

Sorry to say, but I think you are screwed.
So it seems I am. Correct, there was oncoming traffic, but it was a 528i and was easily capable accelerating into the gap. The ability of the car to safely do that was never the issue, but I guess it also had other consequences too

agtlaw

7,439 posts

237 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
DaineseMan said:
frown On the spot 1500CHF (£1000) fine in Switzerland
Can you do a cheese awareness course?

TwigtheWonderkid

49,274 posts

181 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
I think this comes under the heading of "accelerating out of trouble", which is a phrase people use to justify not having a low powered car or bike.

Personally, I can count on the fingers of one foot the amount of times in my 34 yrs of driving that accelerating out of trouble was the correct thing to do. Braking out of trouble is usually the answer.

OP, firstly, the car you were overtaking sped up, and there was oncoming traffic. This means that the gap behind the car you were trying to pass was opening up, not closing, and the gap ahead of the car you were overtaking was closing.

Secondly, in the split second you have to make the call, I might have done the same thing as you. But in hindsight, I'd probably admit to having got it wrong.

Vaud

60,025 posts

186 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
The only roads worth speeding on in Switzerland are terminating valleys where you can do a sighting run first or if you know the local police. Even then, a local is likely to call the police.