Police cells as a place of safety]
Police cells as a place of safety]
Author
Discussion

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,021 posts

279 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
http://www.theguardian.com/society/2014/feb/18/pol...

One small step: the target is to reduce the number of mentally ill taken to police cells under section 136 MHA. Even so, it is hardly full commitment as they are talking about putting mental nurses into cell blocks.

I remember this being brought up in the mid 80s, the decision being that 'something would be done' soon.


Elroy Blue

8,854 posts

223 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Most Mental health cases end up in Police cells after hours of trying to get all the other 'specialist ' teams in the NHS etc to accept their responsibilities. Ultimately, they just say "nothing to do with us" because they know the Police can't say no.
The massive amount of Police time dealing with other agencies workload is nothing short of a national scandal.

Greendubber

15,387 posts

234 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
Most Mental health cases end up in Police cells after hours of trying to get all the other 'specialist ' teams in the NHS etc to accept their responsibilities. Ultimately, they just say "nothing to do with us" because they know the Police can't say no.
The massive amount of Police time dealing with other agencies workload is nothing short of a national scandal.
Indeed.

The majoriry of our jobs are assisting the NHS with MH type jobs. They phone up, get a car dispatched and then say "sorry we have no staff to send" meaning the police are royaly stitched up with THEIR JOB and spend hours waiting for them to arrive. When its challenged they say "arrest them and take them to the police station". Oh right, so an unlawful detention under Sec 136 and a vulnerable person locked in a cell for hours?, I dont think so.

Something has to change, I'm police officer not a social worker, Dr, paramedic or psychiatrist. The Police need to start saying no and getting on with policing and leaving the MH stuff to the NHS.

Jasandjules

72,684 posts

260 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
This is one of the great disgraces of our country IMHO. The NHS NEED to have staff to deal with this situation to free up the police to undertake their role.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
Most Mental health cases end up in Police cells after hours of trying to get all the other 'specialist ' teams in the NHS etc to accept their responsibilities.
Is that true? Most mental health cases?

Silent1

19,762 posts

266 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
OpulentBob said:
Elroy Blue said:
Most Mental health cases end up in Police cells after hours of trying to get all the other 'specialist ' teams in the NHS etc to accept their responsibilities.
Is that true? Most mental health cases?
It is from what I've seen.

Elroy Blue

8,854 posts

223 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
OpulentBob said:
Is that true? Most mental health cases?
I was referring to the mental health cases that Police deal with. Which is a vast amount and which take up at least 70% of Police response time. Yet another one a few days ago. Person running around a motorway trying to throw themselves in front of cars. Two Officers spend hours on constant watch. Eventually the mental health 'specialists' turn up, declare them sane and make an appointment for them with a GP. We deal with them over and over again. When they do kill themselves, it becomes the Police's fault as the Police did 'nothing' last time they were dealt with.

These people are not criminals and should not be sat in Police cells being watched over by Officers.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Elroy Blue said:
I was referring to the mental health cases that Police deal with. Which is a vast amount and which take up at least 70% of Police response time.


Wow. I didn't realise it was that high a proportion.

Elroy Blue said:
These people are not criminals and should not be sat in Police cells being watched over by Officers.
Quite.

eldar

25,351 posts

227 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
OpulentBob said:
Is that true? Most mental health cases?
Emergency admissions outside 10am to 4pm mon - fri, absolutely.

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,021 posts

279 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
This is one of the great disgraces of our country IMHO. The NHS NEED to have staff to deal with this situation to free up the police to undertake their role.
Indeed. When these people are undergoing a psychotic episode and often at their most vulnerable they are told by the agencies that no one wants to know, because no one cares, and the police, the back stop, will put you in a cell.

There was a suggestion that the police should have mental health cells, this around the late 80s, and one force (Beds?) monitored the use of their cells and found that they would have needed over half their cells modified and even then they would not be able to guarantee all those suffering from MH issues to be allocated one.

No one cares.

Police cells are no place for those suffering from an illness. If hospitals shut their doors to those with broken legs and the police locked them up instead there would be a massive outcry. But then, everyone thinks they might be, at some time in their life, at risk from having a broken leg. No one thinks they might go mad. This despite a much higher percentage of people having mental health problems than ever break a leg.

Just imagine if it was your mother, wife, daughter, son, or you, suffering and wanting medical assistance but instead they are locked up in a cell block for hours. You'd be angry.

Be angry now because there and dozens of such poor buggers in cells at this very moment. And yet they are suggesting a reduction target of just 50%.

Greendubber

15,387 posts

234 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Silent1 said:
It is from what I've seen.
Yep

We have numerous "can you assist ambo with a MH patient"

They phone us because we cant say no (we should) due to them not having appropriate staff. It really needs to stop.

All this putting MH nurses in blocks and sending them out with police is a joke too. We have 1 'triage car' for our entire force. Why are we doing it in the first place?, there's a dangerous lack of resources as it is so leave the MH stuff to the NHS and policing to us.

Ridiculous.

Mk3Spitfire

2,921 posts

159 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Unfortunately, more and more external agencies are relying on the police to make up for their shortfalls. They know the key words to say on the phone which will mean the police HAVE to step in. It is wrong.

And yes, police ultimately get the flack when something goes wrong.

Medic-one

3,143 posts

234 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Greendubber said:
Yep

We have numerous "can you assist ambo with a MH patient"

They phone us because we cant say no (we should) due to them not having appropriate staff. It really needs to stop.
I don't think it's a lack of appropriate staff, it's just staff that's not trained to deal with those kind of situations.

As a solo responder from "the green side" i do get send to a lot of mental health calls, varying from people just feeling depressed, people self harming and people theathening to kill themselves.

With most of these calls, we just go by with dispatch tells us, and if they don't deem it save for a solo or a crew to go in, they will tell us to wait nearby untill the police is on scene.

If i'm told there's family with the patient, he/she's is calm, but just can't deal with it anymore, then i'm happy to attend.

But if they tell me it's a 30-year old, who's been drinking and now states he wants to harm himself and has been agressive towards his family, then i'm not going anywhere near him untill i know it's safe for me to attend, which does mean the police going in first.

I'm not trained in combat or restraining techniques, i don't carry weapons/pepperspray and if he/she tells me to F* off, then i have to leave the house, i've got no power or authority to do anything else.

And yes, i can understand the police's frustration. We've all been to jobs together where they got in first, and the patient turned out to be really calm and no danger to anyone at all, but then i've also been into jobs that sounded ok only to have chairs thrown at me, or being chased out of a house by a mental person with a massive knife.

I do agree with those patients belonging in hospital though, not in a police cell.

dudleybloke

20,553 posts

217 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
why dont police top brass start getting on the backs of the mental heath bosses?
get them to do the jobs they are very well paid for instead of passing the buck.


Mk3Spitfire

2,921 posts

159 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Iv got no problem whatsoever in attending those calls, its what happens afterwards that I find frustrating. Not so much at paramedics, but at the social workers and phsyke doctors. They seem less and less interested in turning up and assessing people, and seem to want the police to do their job for them.
No issues with paramedics in the slightest, and I'll attend every single request to back them up every time.

Medic-one

3,143 posts

234 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Another reason why we'd need police to attend on mental health jobs is when we deem the patient to be not in a fit state of mind, and therefor lacking capacity to make his/her own decisions.

We carry forms and have procedures to assess if someone, who we deem needs further help/treatment, has capacity, and if we deem they don't, then we can tell them they MUST come with us, but if they don't listen or still not want to come, we cannot restrain them and drag them into the ambulance, so we would then need the police to restrain and remove that person.

For example, we went to a 16 year old who broke up with her boyfriend, drank a bottle of vodka and then took an overdose of her mothers tablets, which could potentially kill her.
She was so drunk that she didn't really understand what was going on, and couldn't understand the risks of the overdose after we explained it to her.
Because of that, and the fact that she was getting aggressive we got the police to restrain her and move her to the ambulance for us, without that, she would have died at home.

Obviously the police can section people as well under the MH act, but it gets a bit complicated if the person is in their own home, instead of a public place.


Mk3Spitfire

2,921 posts

159 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
dudleybloke said:
why dont police top brass start getting on the backs of the mental heath bosses?
get them to do the jobs they are very well paid for instead of passing the buck.
I think they are just about starting to now. Its still quite a taboo subject though, and people tend to walk on eggshells when discussing it.

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,021 posts

279 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Medic-one said:
Another reason why we'd need police to attend on mental health jobs is when we deem the patient to be not in a fit state of mind, and therefor lacking capacity to make his/her own decisions.
I don't think anyone is arguing that the police should not turn up when a warrant card is required. However, I think that if the only reason the police are required is because the regulations limit the ability of one agency to do their job then why not change the regs?

We were told in training, in answer to the question as to how we could tell the difference between someone 'mad' and another on drugs, both of whom are reacting irrationally, that we should treat both exactly the same so it didn't matter. Later on, following a course after a death in police custody in the Mets, we were told it was essential to treat them differently. It still wasn't explained what the differences were though.

One concern has to be the lack of knowledge on how to treat people going through a psychotic episode. I've seen a PC punch a (now called) bi-polar chap who ran at him. He returned to the hospital later after the chap was back on his pills and apologised and there were no hard feelings. That, though, was before CCTV. Can you imagine the headline in the DM or other crappy paper?

I've mentioned on here before, but it bears repeating, about a chap we used to put into the cells overnight about every couple of months. He'd be found standing on the wrong side of the fence on a bridge over a two lane dual carriageway. A PC would talk him back, he'd be banged up and then, in the morning the doctor would declare him sane. One doctor threw a wobbly after the third or fourth time he assessed him, suggesting that it was abuse of authority, which it was of course.

He would then be returned home, where his mother was unable to cope with him. After I left the division I heard the call to a bloke jumping from a bridge and I knew immediately who it was. One kid dead, a lorry driver traumatised.

I'm not sure what the answer is, but I know it is not what happens now.

But then the only ones affected are mad and who, amongst those who have the power to change things, gives a st about them?


dudleybloke

20,553 posts

217 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
maybe find the home addresses of the mental health bosses of the area and use them as a drop off point when you pick up any of their "clients".

"ere ya go mate, your the boss of this stuff so you should be REALY good at looking after em,..... enjoy."

wink



Edited by dudleybloke on Tuesday 18th February 15:52

carinaman

25,297 posts

203 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
No one cares.
frown