Golf R32, what are your opinions?
Golf R32, what are your opinions?
Author
Discussion

smallsmalls81

Original Poster:

99 posts

174 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
I looking to be getting one of these, looking for a manual.

Have any you owned one, good points, bad points?

Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
smallsmalls81 said:
I looking to be getting one of these, looking for a manual.

Have any you owned one, good points, bad points?
I owned a Mk5 for a while. The positives are that it makes a nice noise, was comfortable, practical and the 4wd is handy if it snows. But the negatives were high fuel consumption, not very quick, not a lot of engagement as a drivers' car, pretty numb handling, overly assisted brakes, and reliability issues (new clutch, flywheel, headlight adjuster thingy and coil packs during my 6 month tenure, and it was only 18 months old at the time).

The same money and running costs can get you much more entertaining cars - e46 M3 or 130i, for example.

If you're fixed on a VW, I'd buy an edition 30 GTI instead.

And if you want 4wd, buy the S3.

In summary, the R32 wasn't a bad car. It just wasn't very good.

Edited by Gruber on Tuesday 18th February 18:44

zeduffman

4,332 posts

182 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
I love mine

Good points: the noise, it's comfortable, lots of toys as standard and options were relatively cheap so many are well specced, tonnes of grip and the Haldex allows full acceleration in any weather (very helpful when pulling out of junctions in the rain), maintenance costs are typical VW + Haldex servicing every 20k miles, reliable (Mk5s pretty much solved the stretched chain issue on the Mk4s), Deep Pearl Blue looks incredible in the sun, as practical as any Golf

Bad points: heavy, eats tyres, not as quick as you want in the dry, likes a drink, despite the grip the front end needs to be kept in check on a hoon

smallsmalls81

Original Poster:

99 posts

174 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Gruber said:
I owned a Mk5 for a while. The positives are that it makes a nice noise, was comfortable, practical and the 4wd is handy if it snows. But the negatives were high fuel consumption, not very quick, not a lot of engagement as a drivers' car, pretty numb handling, overly assisted brakes, and reliability issues (new clutch, flywheel, headlight adjuster thingy and coil packs during my 6 month tenure, and it was only 18 months old at the time).

The same money and running costs can get you much more entertaining cars - e46 M3 or 130i, for example.

If you're fixed on a VW, I'd buy an edition 30 GTI instead.

And if you want 4wd, buy the S3.

In summary, the R32 wasn't a bad car. It just wasn't very good.

Edited by Gruber on Tuesday 18th February 18:44
Many thanks for this, I have been looking at the bmw m3, only thing that worries me is the insurance, I'm 32 years old.

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
You looking at mk4 or mk5

32years old with how many ncd?
Do a quick search on comparison site for insurance if its too high write it off now

I had one and was £500 Ish and I was younger

I had mk5 dsg version
Brilliant out the box
Grip was good in wet
Noise was sweet
Gearbox, steering was good for a hatch
It could have coped with more power
It's smooth power delivery
Had the mod cons, xenons, heated seats

Had no issues with mine

zeduffman

4,332 posts

182 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
smallsmalls81 said:
Many thanks for this, I have been looking at the bmw m3, only thing that worries me is the insurance, I'm 32 years old.
An E46 M3 is more to insure (2.5x more for me when I checked, but that was when I was 22) and more expensive to run, by a considerable margin.

smallsmalls81

Original Poster:

99 posts

174 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
p1tse said:
You looking at mk4 or mk5

32years old with how many ncd?
Do a quick search on comparison site for insurance if its too high write it off now

I had one and was £500 Ish and I was younger

I had mk5 dsg version
Brilliant out the box
Grip was good in wet
Noise was sweet
Gearbox, steering was good for a hatch
It could have coped with more power
It's smooth power delivery
Had the mod cons, xenons, heated seats

Had no issues with mine
Mk4 and mk4 looking at, I have 14 years ncb, no accidents, no points , but all of that is on my company van.

Gruber

6,313 posts

245 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
zeduffman said:
An E46 M3 is more to insure (2.5x more for me when I checked, but that was when I was 22) and more expensive to run, by a considerable margin.
Whereas for me the insurance was broadly the same (maybe £100 more for the M3). And in mpg terms there was virtually nothing in it between the M3 and the R32. The M3 costs a little more to service, but we're talking a few hundred quid a year - not significant sums.

As I said above, if I were buying another Golf of that era, it would be ed30 GTI all the way. Feels quicker, drives better - just lacks the noise.

dododo

761 posts

158 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
Agree with the S3 suggestion. It's faster, drives better, lighter, no more thirsty (unless you really drive it hard) and typically has a better spec than the R32.

craig2003

1,209 posts

237 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
I had my MKIV R32 for a few years and had no issues other than the usual servicing, radiator fan and a boot lock solenoid.
Mine had a few bits done to it, suspension, exhaust, mapped, decent tyres etc etc
After being in Evo's for so long it really took a while to adjust to the loss of power low down the revs but a few runs out I really bonded with it and found it to be a very capable car when driven spiritedly. The 4WD system had been upgraded in the past so it had a slightly more rear bias than a standard.
I moved from an Evo IV - E46 330 on sale after 6 weeks as it was just too bland, - Evo VII - R32 then to an S4 V8 and now in to an RS4 V8 but I still miss the way Golf drove, probably more so than any of the cars listed above
Don't rule one out totally would be my advice

Basil Hume

1,389 posts

283 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
I had a 2010 S3 Sportback (with S-Tronic / DSG) and I've just picked-up a 2008 Golf R32 (manual). Most people would go the other way, but I've had a diesel company car in between and I didn't want to spend so much on a privately-owned car this time.

My R32 is a grey 5-door with leather and just looks like a high spec Golf to most people. From the point of view of someone who needs a compact car that's discreet, high quality and good at doing long distances, it fits the bill perfectly.

There's a stiff premium for the equivalent age of S3 Sportback, so unless you're looking at a 3-door I think you'd find the R32 cheaper to buy and similarly expensive to run. In terms of economy, there's not much in it despite what you may hear - I averaged 27mpg in the S3 and 25mpg in the R32 to date. Insurance is slightly less for the R32 (£290 R32; £390 S3).

The S3 Sportback (post-08) has Gen4 Haldex, whereas I think it's Gen2 in the R32 because it feels more like the '06 A3 2.0T quattro I had - which as definitely Gen2 (I think the pre-08 S3 3-door may also have it). The Sportback is slightly more capacious than the Golf 5-door (310 litres boot space plays 275) and I miss the Audi's roof rails. The S3 is almost certainly faster in a balls-out accelerative test, especially when re-mapped - but I found it quite laggy.

There's a certain quality to the R32 that I find it hard to put into words. Some of my silly word associations that come to mind include: "old money"; "blue cheese"; and "vintage". It's a connoisseur's car and represents probably your last chance to own a discreet, non-turbo large engined hatchback. I really like the instant response of the accelerator pedal (no lag) and it's still a very fast car.

Then there's the noise... wonderful. It really has soul. People who knew what it was tended to distantly respect the S3, while they come up and chat to me about the R32. That sums up the experience for me really.

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
There's no point discussing s3 2.0t or edition 30 if the OP is looking at r32 mk4 which is a of a lower bracket
£

What's your budget and what car you coming from

For that type of money I think its a good buy the mk4 r32

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
Sold my S3 8P and bought an R32... S3 was significantly quicker and better appointed but I found it soulless. The r32 isnt as quick but i love hearing a proper engine sound as opposed to what sounds like a washing machine (even with milltek)

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
An Audi S4 (B6 variant) probably comes in at the same purchase price budget and might not be much more to run (it will, however, be rather quicker...)

Basil Hume

1,389 posts

283 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
I think a B6 clocks 100 leptons in about 15.5 secs, which is about a second (at most) quicker than an R32 - not massive. But go for an 8P S3 if you want faster still: 14 secs out of the box.

smallsmalls81

Original Poster:

99 posts

174 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
p1tse said:
There's no point discussing s3 2.0t or edition 30 if the OP is looking at r32 mk4 which is a of a lower bracket
£

What's your budget and what car you coming from

For that type of money I think its a good buy the mk4 r32
Thanks for all the info guys, I am seriously thinking about a mk4 or mk5 golf r32, 5 door if I could. My other half she has a audi a3, s line so would feel like I was getting the same car if i bought an audi. If I got an audi it would be an r8 but can't afford that. I just can't seem to find a r32 in my budget of 10k, low miles and manual gearbox. Also would like an m3 e46

Edited by smallsmalls81 on Wednesday 19th February 22:33

jonlk

215 posts

201 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
I went from an SMG e46 M3 into a Manual MK5 R32.

No contest for me. The R32 was excellent (possibly too competent) but not even close to the M3 in terms of 'feeling' and the driving experience. Imho.

Has to said I did see an R32 this morning and did have a hankering for another though. So by no means a bad car!

smallsmalls81

Original Poster:

99 posts

174 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
jonlk said:
I went from an SMG e46 M3 into a Manual MK5 R32.

No contest for me. The R32 was excellent (possibly too competent) but not even close to the M3 in terms of 'feeling' and the driving experience. Imho.

Has to said I did see an R32 this morning and did have a hankering for another though. So by no means a bad car!
What are the rear seats like in the r32?

I also find these have high miles .

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
I have a soft spot for Golfs but the R32 left me cold. Gruber's answer just about sums it up perfectly.

I wanted it to be so good but the reality was 'Is that it?'. The only thing I recall feeling after driving one was a feeling of being underwhelmed.

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
If the budget is 10k seriously consider the edition 30