Police protecting private companies
Discussion
There is some fracking going on near me on private land that they use a public footpath to get the machinery along. There is a bit of protesting going on and the police are assisting the operators to get the machinery in and out. It is at Barton Moss, the site where that dodgy drink drive arrest was made recently.
As far as the fracking goes I'm not bothered one way or the other, most of the protesters seem to be delusional hippies but on the whole seem quite peaceful, its mostly old ladies and robinson cruso type lookalikes. I know the land is private, I think owned by the manchester ship canal company which might be owned by peel holdings, however it does have a footpath running through it which the public have every right to use.
My question is how can the police lawfully assist a private fracking company to get down the lane by pushing back the protesters in the opposite direction they want to go, surely the frackers are obstructing the hippies just as much, if I had a footpath across my land and I didn't want someone on it the police would say its a civil matter.
This is a recent video of the demonstration and I think the police are being a little heavy handed, skip to about 15 mins to see a bit of this.
http://youtu.be/5RCi6iDq46g
As far as the fracking goes I'm not bothered one way or the other, most of the protesters seem to be delusional hippies but on the whole seem quite peaceful, its mostly old ladies and robinson cruso type lookalikes. I know the land is private, I think owned by the manchester ship canal company which might be owned by peel holdings, however it does have a footpath running through it which the public have every right to use.
My question is how can the police lawfully assist a private fracking company to get down the lane by pushing back the protesters in the opposite direction they want to go, surely the frackers are obstructing the hippies just as much, if I had a footpath across my land and I didn't want someone on it the police would say its a civil matter.
This is a recent video of the demonstration and I think the police are being a little heavy handed, skip to about 15 mins to see a bit of this.
http://youtu.be/5RCi6iDq46g
Yes I follow that but why are they siding with the private corporation, why not keep the heavy plant equipment away because pedestrians are using the footpath, I know the path can have vehicles on it as well because there are a couple of farms and small businesses along the road, but if I drove something that big down a small track where children were playing I would probably get done for dangerous driving.
Conducting business is lawful (assuming that the business is not gun running etc). The police are there to preserve the peace and allow people to conduct their everyday business. They have to do this whilst also preserving the right to protest. They don't always get the balance right.
I suppose it is their own land and they want to get their vehicles on and off, I would be mightily pissed off if protesters were preventing me getting my car off my drive and would expect some police help. Having said that it is a public footpath and they have every right to be there, which comes first?
NH1 said:
I suppose it is their own land and they want to get their vehicles on and off, I would be mightily pissed off if protesters were preventing me getting my car off my drive and would expect some police help. Having said that it is a public footpath and they have every right to be there, which comes first?
I only got a couple of minutes into the video because it was far too loud and full of unnecessarily noisy protestors with big beards, but from what I could see, I don't think the police were suggesting the protestors couldn't be there, but more that they were trying to move them out of the way for their own safety, and as they could potentially have been committing offences if they were obstructing the highway. Is that a road they are on, or a footpath?Like you say, which comes first? It's a balance, and whichever way the Police go, one side is going to be disadvantaged and will feel wronged.
pork911 said:
An A-typical set of circumstances, which are covered by legislation (police act '96?). The thin end of the wedge! A private police force bla bla. What next? Football clubs paying the police to police their football match? Fascists, buying their own justice!
Mk3Spitfire said:
I only got a couple of minutes into the video because it was far too loud and full of unnecessarily noisy protestors with big beards, but from what I could see, I don't think the police were suggesting the protestors couldn't be there, but more that they were trying to move them out of the way for their own safety, and as they could potentially have been committing offences if they were obstructing the highway. Is that a road they are on, or a footpath?
Like you say, which comes first? It's a balance, and whichever way the Police go, one side is going to be disadvantaged and will feel wronged.
A footpath, being a right of way across land, is a road. It wasn't always. I was taught in the 70s that it wasn't a road but, for some strange reason, logic prevailed. Like you say, which comes first? It's a balance, and whichever way the Police go, one side is going to be disadvantaged and will feel wronged.
Fair enough some traffic is banned but that doesn't stop it being a road, any more than it does a motorway.
10 Pence Short said:
As an aside, I do wonder if private companies undertaking business requiring such protection should bear some of the cost of policing, in the same way football clubs are asked to, for example.
If these companies are paying NICs, business rates, corporation taxes etc, I do not see why they need to pay any extra to go about their daily business.oyster said:
If these companies are paying NICs, business rates, corporation taxes etc, I do not see why they need to pay any extra to go about their daily business.
Conversely, if they are asking the Police to act as security guards with powers of arrest, they should expect that to be a specific cost of business.Of course it's not black and white but, as pointed out, private organisations already pay the Police for policing events and so on.
La Liga said:
pork911 said:
An A-typical set of circumstances, which are covered by legislation (police act '96?). The thin end of the wedge! A private police force bla bla. What next? Football clubs paying the police to police their football match? Fascists, buying their own justice!

This piece of legislation was used in Balcombe, West Sussex last year: http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1992/52/sectio...
The circs were very similar - protestors attempting to block the entrance (which was private land) and the highway in order to disrupt vehicle movement to and from the site.
The circs were very similar - protestors attempting to block the entrance (which was private land) and the highway in order to disrupt vehicle movement to and from the site.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


