Divorce advice.
Author
Discussion

a311

Original Poster:

6,426 posts

208 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
Not that it matters but this is for a mate and not myself read

He's booked in to see a solicitor, I just wanted to hear others experiences and realise there's a few solicitors who contribute.

After being married a short 2 years my mate and his Mrs have split, not 100% but fairly sure she's done the dirty. No kids.

He owned his house (with mortgage) long before they met/married he's always paid the mortgage from his own account, inc after the marriage. Always earned more than her and genrally always paid for the lions share of things.

So cutting to the chase is she legally entitled to to half of everything? He's had a good pension since he was 18 will she be entitled to half of that as well? He's now 38. He'll have a decent chunk of equity in his house, she's asked for a fairly hefty cash settlement so far which has got him reeling. I'm sure 99% of people have started out the same but he's trying his best to remain civil, do as much as he can to do it as much between themselves etc to keep costs down.

Of course you don't know what advice she's getting of her mates, family, this other bloke..... He's thinking of making a counter offer which I'm not sure is the best thing until he gets the house valued, figures out the worth of other assests

Just trying to get clued up , help support him etc.

Any advice/anecdotes appreciated

Cheers

ruff'n'smov

1,092 posts

180 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
Tell your 'mate'. To buy a spade, paving slabs, black bags (preferably the strong garden type) . Arrange a good alibi. And Bobs your uncle, he'll do 10 years if caught so be out in 4 ish. And then clear.

Me bitter never.

Seriously don't be a gentleman fight for the lot and don't try to be 'adult' about it. Tell the brief what he wants and if he can't deliver bin him and get one who can.

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
Logic ought to dictate that a short marriage with no dependants would mean it would simply be a case of him saying "seeya!"

.. doubtful that logic will enter into the equation mind.

yzrh

171 posts

153 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
In whose name are the bank accounts & house?

I'm not a lawyer but as far as I know everything you had in net assets going into the marriage, you are entitled to when going out of it.

Either way there are no dependents here right, no custody or any other mitigating factors.

a311

Original Poster:

6,426 posts

208 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies, house just in his name.

Separate bank acounts but a housekeeping credit card joint that he'd pay 2/3 and she the remain 1/3 each month. She's neglected to pay her share inc non household stuff she's put on for months.

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
He didn't own the house going into the relationship though. I'd guess the equity/appreciation in value would be split?

Found this on another site, no idea if current or valid:

some website said:
2) Duration of the Marriage - Short Marriages
If a divorce petition is filed in a short, childless marriage (normally less than 5 years duration) it is unlikely that a 50/50 division of assets will be ordered particularly if one spouse brought substantially more assets to the marriage. Normally assets acquired prior to the marriage will be retained, or returned to the spouse who originally had them, and assets accumulated during the marriage will be divided on a 50/50 basis when the parties divorce.
Additionally consensus seems to be that infidelity/fault has no bearing on anything in terms of asset division.

Edited by Durzel on Wednesday 19th February 22:44

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
a311 said:
.

So cutting to the chase is she legally entitled to to half of everything?
No.

AIUI and IME, she would be after about 7 years of marriage. However, if each party brought very different things to the table then they would not expect to walk away 50/50 after only two years.

Proportions are a matter for negotiation, though. As ever, maintaining amicable relations and avoiding solicitors letter tennis will be the key to a good outcome for both parties...

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
Durzel said:
Logic ought to dictate that a short marriage with no dependants would mean it would simply be a case of him saying "seeya!"

.. doubtful that logic will enter into the equation mind.
Indeed it would. Having been through five divorces entirely caused by my totally unreasonable and outlandish behaviour (legendary) I settled each one amicably and retain reasonable relations with the ex wives who inevitably now know each other. Earned well enough to be able to do that. I did not wish any of them to suffer financially because of my madness. We have all come to reasonable terms over time. I think a civilised divorce is as much as your friend can hope for. I do think he would be well advised to err on the side of fairness and move on with his life. Revenge as the prophets say requires two graves to be dug. Try not to allow your friend to become buried in bitterness.

a311

Original Poster:

6,426 posts

208 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies. He’s going to see a solicitor today but from what he’s heard/read as she’s lived there for 5 years before they were married this will play a part. Doesn’t seem right to me-after the marriage fair enough but right isn’t necessary the law.

GhiaX

227 posts

177 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
I kept all my assets from before the marriage which produced two children. Whereas my partner got relatively little and only a split of the increase in value of the property since we were married, after my initial proportion and mortgage were deducted first.

kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Get some auctioneers to value the house on a 'reserve price' basis....

The lower the valuation the less will have to be paid, especially when the balance of the mortgage is taken off - auction also the best court recognised asset sales process as it guarantees market value smile

I, however would be taking the increase in asset values from the date of the marriage, taking off all costs to make them 50/50 (you mentioned he paid 2/3 of the cc bill? the additional paid by him should also be reflected).

Present this to her/her solicitor with a settlement proposal on the basis of the figure...if properly reasoned they should accept

JumboBeef

3,772 posts

208 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
a311 said:
He's had a good pension since he was 18 will she be entitled to half of that as well?
Two points:

She will be entitled to half of the pension that he paid into for the length of the marriage. ie: two years, so not a lot.

Second point: although they are separated, they are not yet divorced. Whatever he does now BEFORE they are divorced will count towards what she can claim off him. ie: if he met someone else and he bought a house with the new person then the ex can claim (up to) half of that new house. Same with if he wins the lottery, gets a better job etc. As divorces can take many months/year, he should just be aware of that.

dictys

914 posts

289 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
[quote]
Second point: although they are separated, they are not yet divorced. Whatever he does now BEFORE they are divorced will count towards what she can claim off him. ie: if he met someone else and he bought a house with the new person then the ex can claim (up to) half of that new house. Same with if he wins the lottery, gets a better job etc. As divorces can take many months/year, he should just be aware of that.

[/quote]

Only in England, in Scotland it is up to the agreed date of separation, not the date of the divorce which maybe as said a while later.

kam05

272 posts

176 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Short & childless marriage? You should leave the marriage with what ever you brought into the marriage in the first place.

Anything bought, build or acquired during the marriage should be split equally. That's the theory - chances are the wife will want everything and then some!

a311

Original Poster:

6,426 posts

208 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the additional replies.

He met with a solicitor today. The basic gist is he was told as she's lift there for around 5 years (3 pre marriage) that has to be taken into consideration. He's going to make her a lower offer for a quick, clean, divorce. I very much doubt it's going to go that way. I think he's grossly over valuing the house, which I guess if he wants to stay there isn't a bad thing if he gets it valued and it does come back lower than expected. The advice was she woudn't have much luck coming after his penson, althoug I'm just an armchair observer doesn't make sense why she's entitled to anything in the house pre-marriage. Somehow work out if it's increased in value in the last two odd years and then split the difference.

If I were him I'd just sell up and get a nice clean break.

chrisgtx

1,349 posts

241 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Steffan said:
Indeed it would. Having been through five divorces entirely caused by my totally unreasonable and outlandish behaviour (legendary) I settled each one amicably and retain reasonable relations with the ex wives who inevitably now know each other. Earned well enough to be able to do that. I did not wish any of them to suffer financially because of my madness. We have all come to reasonable terms over time. I think a civilised divorce is as much as your friend can hope for. I do think he would be well advised to err on the side of fairness and move on with his life. Revenge as the prophets say requires two graves to be dug. Try not to allow your friend to become buried in bitterness.
Bloody hell, Five marriages!!
I learnt my lesson after 1. Luckily it went amicably,no kids,fair settlement,job done.

kam05

272 posts

176 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
a311 said:
Thanks for the additional replies.

The advice was she woudn't have much luck coming after his penson...

If I were him I'd just sell up and get a nice clean break.
RE: Pension: The solicitor is right here. It's not worth going for the pension as she will only be entitled for the amount of pension that they have lived together (pre and post marriage). If there was a pension sharing order, this would only give the wife a pension income of a few pounds a year - not worth it.

I'm guessing the wife is young? Therefore it will be in her best interests to start and pay into her own pension. And yes, your mate needs a clean break order so that the wife cannot come back for a 2nd bite of the apple!

My ex-wife wanted a share of my pension during ancillary relief proceedings. The judge told her do one on the basis that my pension is currently small and she was better off starting and paying into her own pension!

XCP

17,761 posts

259 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
kam05 said:
Short & childless marriage? You should leave the marriage with what ever you brought into the marriage in the first place.

Anything bought, build or acquired during the marriage should be split equally. That's the theory - chances are the wife will want everything and then some!
I think Paul McCartney found differently.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Durzel said:
Additionally consensus seems to be that infidelity/fault has no bearing on anything in terms of asset division.
Correct. At least that's what my solicitor told me when I asked...

Also remember that you can’t give adultery as a reason if you lived with your husband or wife for 6 months after you found out about it. You would then need to rely on one of the other grounds.

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
Durzel said:
Additionally consensus seems to be that infidelity/fault has no bearing on anything in terms of asset division.
Correct. At least that's what my solicitor told me when I asked...

Also remember that you can’t give adultery as a reason if you lived with your husband or wife for 6 months after you found out about it. You would then need to rely on one of the other grounds.
I do think the Divorce Courts are rightly trying to avoid characterising particular activities as improper and in seeking to find fault or lay blame on either party generally. Rightly in my view. In my cases it was easy because the fault was always mine. But no court ever suggested that. I think that the reality of human behavior in relationships being down to the consenting adults involved has become generally accepted in divorce courts in the UK. Setting a fair settlement reflecting the needs and assets of the two parties seems to be the intention. No doubt some litigious people make as much as they can and other less avaricious individuals get less. Twas always the way of such matters.