Verbal contracts and moving goalposts
Verbal contracts and moving goalposts
Author
Discussion

thunderbelmont

Original Poster:

2,982 posts

255 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
First a bit of background.

I contract install equipment to a large organisation which runs a lot of vehicles, and have done for over ten years. No formal written contracts, everything has been verbal and never been a problem in the past.

About a year ago I was informed about two new vehicle programs that I would be working on. The first was for a batch of cars to begin in August 2013. The second for a larger batch of "big" vehicles to begin in September 2013.

I had meetings with the customer's head of fleet, timescales and build times were discussed and agree with "production" set to eight vehicles per week, four cars, and four of the other types.

The builds were delayed, and we had more meetings to discuss the programs, with October set for the cars, and November for the larger vehicles. Again, the build times were re-iterated of 4 of each per week, or 8 of either per week (which could be a mix).

More delays, December was planned. Nothing happened, other than the "prototype" of the larger vehicles was delivered to their workshops, and I was informed that it needed to be installed quickly, so I fitted two days before Christmas.

On Jan 1st, the organisation has a new CEO.

No more vehicles were delivered by their suppliers, and suddenly some cars arrive late January. I'm told by other sources that a fair number of the large vehicles are at the dealer for PDI. Other equipment installers are organised for the first week of Feb, and we turn up and make a start on the cars. Then some more of the large vehicles turn up.

Now, the projects are for 68 cars, and 147 of the larger vehicles.

Suddenly the CEO makes commitment to have just under 30 of the larger vehicles on the road in operation by the end of March. Those are new additional vehicles. A couple of problems in that the management haven't previously ordered any of the other equipment to go into these.... but that's by the by...

Now a director has deemed that "we will put 15 of these large vehicles on the road each week, AND five cars will be replaced at the same time too per week". That's 20 vehicles per week. Not 8. My capacity is realistically about 12 per week, maybe 13, based on 5 days.

I have a verbal agreement/contact for 8 per week - 215 vehicles in total - plus a few others that will happen during the main program too.

They are talking about getting in another company to make up the shortfall.

Where do I stand on this? Can I claim breach of contract - even though it's verbal? Are there any legal precedents set?

I'm going to try to negotiate a mutually agreeable outcome to this, I think, as do some of the organisation's own fleet staff, and IT Staff, that this is unreasonable, and unnecessary with the director trying to make himself look good in front of the new CEO.

Looking forward to constructive replies....

southendpier

6,239 posts

260 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
Unless the verbal agreement states you cannot subcontract part or all of the order then why don't you just take on a subcontractor company?

Only having verbal agreements seems poor business form on what seems to be a lot of work. I very much doubt it will be financially worthwhile fighting.

Simpo Two

93,087 posts

296 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
You want to sue because they gave you too much work? Well that's a first.

If you can only make 10 but they want 20 and another company does the extra 10, so what? It's up to them. You can't do them so you're not losing anything.

Time to start getting your side down in writing. 'Dear CEO, As agreed with you on xxx we will be plased to make 10...'

thunderbelmont

Original Poster:

2,982 posts

255 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
That's true - taking on someone else to do "my" work for me. It would mean a dramatic drop in income for me as I'd have to pay them almost as much as I charge.

However, they seem to expect "instant" response, and to get someone in, vetted (oh yes!), and trained to do the job to the same (OCD) quality level that I work to will take quite a few weeks. There is a "licence" required which requires many hoops to be jumped through via the Cabinet Office too....

Another company could be there in about a week, they seem to think that they'll be able to "help me", rather than take my work away!!

I'm thinking of a cunning plan, so cunning you could put a tail on it and call it a weasel, and it just might work.....

Bottom line is, I alone can do the job they need (ie: meeting the target) - and get all of the vehicles done in the timescales that they want. They just seem to want to rush towards the finish line and get it all done in a much shorter time, which is being unreasonable in my book.

Imagine if your employer comes to you and says - we'll get someone in to help you with your work, and the upshot is you only get paid half as much what you expected, you'd be pretty hacked off?


thunderbelmont

Original Poster:

2,982 posts

255 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
You want to sue because they gave you too much work? Well that's a first.

If you can only make 10 but they want 20 and another company does the extra 10, so what? It's up to them. You can't do them so you're not losing anything.

Time to start getting your side down in writing. 'Dear CEO, As agreed with you on xxx we will be pleased to make 10...'
No, I don't want to sue because they gave me too much work, they want me to do the work that we agreed to do over a given period of time in less than a third of that time. That is my gripe.

It was a 9 month program that they now want in effecively 3.




LooneyTunes

9,517 posts

189 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
I would put it to them that, from the old "Fast v. Right v. Cheap" you assume that in delivering "Fast" they don't want to compromise on "Right" so "Cheap" will almost certainly fall by the wayside (you're going to need to incentivise various parties to meet their new schedule). Back with updated costs in a couple of days but would like to confirm understanding of their needs is correct...

Obviously be as diplomatic as you can.

Ean218

2,046 posts

281 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
I would put it to them that, from the old "Fast v. Right v. Cheap" you assume that in delivering "Fast" they don't want to compromise on "Right" so "Cheap" will almost certainly fall by the wayside (you're going to need to incentivise various parties to meet their new schedule). Back with updated costs in a couple of days but would like to confirm understanding of their needs is correct...

Obviously be as diplomatic as you can.
Definitely agree with this. Offer them your normal timescales at your normal prices, and also offer to achieve their escalated timescales at a suitably escalated price, enabling you to get a proficient subbie or two and make a profit.

Sid's Dad

576 posts

172 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
You may not have the right view of this situation, OP. You seem to be thinking like an employee, and you seem to feel that they owe you something. They don't. They have a requirement that you can't apparently meet, so they're getting someone else to help. If the new supplier can do a better job than you, or a quicker job, or a cheaper job, then they will give their business to their new supplier.

And all you should do is smile, thank them immensely for all their business over the years, and offer to help them whenever they need it. Keep in touch. Be friendly. Then when the new supplier fks up - as they surely will - you can step in to "bail them out" and win the business back.

But if you get all sniffy about it they'll just not give you any more business and never think about you again.

Oh and by the way - you already know that a verbal contract is meaningless. If you want to rely on a contract, get it in writing. And keep it up to date.

thunderbelmont

Original Poster:

2,982 posts

255 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Sid's Dad said:
You may not have the right view of this situation, OP. You seem to be thinking like an employee, and you seem to feel that they owe you something. They don't. They have a requirement that you can't apparently meet, so they're getting someone else to help. If the new supplier can do a better job than you, or a quicker job, or a cheaper job, then they will give their business to their new supplier.

And all you should do is smile, thank them immensely for all their business over the years, and offer to help them whenever they need it. Keep in touch. Be friendly. Then when the new supplier fks up - as they surely will - you can step in to "bail them out" and win the business back.

But if you get all sniffy about it they'll just not give you any more business and never think about you again.

Oh and by the way - you already know that a verbal contract is meaningless. If you want to rely on a contract, get it in writing. And keep it up to date.
No I'm not thinking like an employee at all. I've been working for some 31 years since leaving school, and other than my first seven years out of school, I've been self employed. I'm thinking like "it's my feckin' contract, you can't bloody do this"

Actually, verbal contacts have been declared binding in courts of law. Especially when you're sitting in a meeting of ten people and you're told that you're doing the work.

Though thankfully, I didn't need to get all 'umpty on this one. Common sense struck in when the "other company" couldn't provide an engineer to "support me" for at least six weeks. By then, the knee-jerk panic deadline will have passed.

A compromise was put forward at one point - they didn't want to take the work away from me, just "get me some help", how getting a competitor in to do my work for me is help, I'm not sure... but a plan was hatched where the competitors engineer (if available) would have come in and be restricted to doing some of the "more difficult to screw up" tasks, like de-installing the old vehicles, and fixing a few simple ancillaries in the new ones. I would still be able to bill them the full amount for the job. Which could have been a win-win scenario.

In the end, the manager of the communications department came in from his leave, and stuck his oar in to the job, asking why - if the fleet manager is having a nervous breakdown, should everyone else be expected to have one! And pointing out that they had a contract, albeit verbal, with me to do ALL of the work. A couple of quick meetings, and the target build rate has been set at a "do-able" level, no additional people would be needed.

So, I'm off to Mrs Miggins' Pie Shop for a slap up meal and a flagon of ale to celebrate.


Du1point8

22,967 posts

223 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
Are you 24 vehicles behind schedule due to their short comings or your own company?

You are claiming breach of contract but yet yourself seemed to breach the original contract.

Steve Campbell

2,402 posts

199 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
I hope your taking the communications manager to Mrs Miggins with you :-)

Sounds like the only one with an ounce of sense in their team....

JM

3,170 posts

237 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
thunderbelmont said:
That's true - taking on someone else to do "my" work for me. It would mean a dramatic drop in income for me as I'd have to pay them almost as much as I charge.
Paying someone else to help you do the work, for less than you charge is only going to mean you make more money, not less and certainly not a "dramatic drop".

E.g.
You charge £100 to do one thing. You pay someone £80 to do the same thing = £20 to you.
You on your own can do 10 = 10 x £100 = £1000.
With help you can do 20 = £1000, + £20 x 10 = £1200.

So by getting help you do twice as many jobs and earn 20% more.

LooneyTunes

9,517 posts

189 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
JM said:
Paying someone else to help you do the work, for less than you charge is only going to mean you make more money, not less and certainly not a "dramatic drop".

E.g.
You charge £100 to do one thing. You pay someone £80 to do the same thing = £20 to you.
You on your own can do 10 = 10 x £100 = £1000.
With help you can do 20 = £1000, + £20 x 10 = £1200.

So by getting help you do twice as many jobs and earn 20% more.
That assumes there is the flow of work to support that.

Lots of people freelancing/providing services don't have that luxury so - if client requirements permit - are better off with the job taking twice as long and retaining all of the money for themselves than they would be doing it faster but paying away money.

thunderbelmont

Original Poster:

2,982 posts

255 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
Are you 24 vehicles behind schedule due to their short comings or your own company?

You are claiming breach of contract but yet yourself seemed to breach the original contract.
The "order" was for 8 vehicles for week. They then said, after I started that they wanted... 20 vehicles per week. Slightly different.

Still, it's all in the past tense now. All sorted, common sense has resumed, though with an increase in output (on my part) that IS achievable without outside interference (and decrease on how much cash ends up in my bank at the end of it).

thunderbelmont

Original Poster:

2,982 posts

255 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
JM said:
Paying someone else to help you do the work, for less than you charge is only going to mean you make more money, not less and certainly not a "dramatic drop".

E.g.
You charge £100 to do one thing. You pay someone £80 to do the same thing = £20 to you.
You on your own can do 10 = 10 x £100 = £1000.
With help you can do 20 = £1000, + £20 x 10 = £1200.

So by getting help you do twice as many jobs and earn 20% more.
If I did them ALL myself (as per the "order" then that's 20 x 100 = £2000 for me = £800 more in my bin, aye thankyou!

That was my issue with their "idea".


Tribal Chestnut

3,001 posts

213 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
I'm surprised at the number of seemingly 'intelligent' people who are of the opinion that the OP would have been in breach of contract for being unable to fulfil the clients acceleration requirements.

Edited by Tribal Chestnut on Sunday 2nd March 20:10

thunderbelmont

Original Poster:

2,982 posts

255 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
Tribal Chestnut said:
I'm surprised at the number of seemingly 'intelligent' people who are of the opinion that the OP would have been in breach of contract for being unable to fulfil the clients acceleration requirements.

Edited by Tribal Chestnut on Sunday 2nd March 20:10
That's because it seems that most people do not understand contract law in the UK, let alone reality.