Any 458 owners gloating
Any 458 owners gloating
Author
Discussion

johnnyreggae

Original Poster:

3,175 posts

191 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
After all the grief a year or two ago here's one for apolo1 and all his mates : gt3 fire risk

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/motoring/car-manufactur...

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
Must be gutted!.

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
The launch of the car has been disastrous from the start with really poor communication from Porsche on allocations and build dates.

No matter how good the car is more bad press is p1551ng off owners and effecting the so called premiums

What with Porsche and McLaren making all these faux pas looks like the only supercar decision to be made is Ferrari or Lamborghini biggrin

av185

20,464 posts

158 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
Still taking delivery of mine, hopefully early summer now, don't worry Porsche will fix this bargain supercar and irrespective of this setback, residuals will clearly be strong on the car unlike nigh on 50 per cent first year depreciation on overpriced 458s and Lambs which coincidentally everyone remembers also had burning issues soon after launch.....biggrin:


Jules360

1,949 posts

233 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
av185 said:
Still taking delivery of mine, hopefully early summer now, don't worry Porsche will fix this bargain supercar and irrespective of this setback, residuals will clearly be strong on the car unlike nigh on 50 per cent first year depreciation on overpriced 458s and Lambs which coincidentally everyone remembers also had burning issues soon after launch.....biggrin:
50% depreciation on a 458? Where are these £100k 2013 cars you speak of please? The cheapest I can find on here is £173k. Yes the Porsche is cheap by comparison, but it's not what I would term a super car..but opinions vary. It's priced at a selling point same as the 458, if porsche could charge more and sell the same numbers they would, they are a business who understand their elasticity of demand. Same as Ferrari and they don't seem to have trouble shifting new ones at "inflated" prices.


Edited by Jules360 on Saturday 22 February 05:14

av185

20,464 posts

158 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
Jules360 said:
av185 said:
Still taking delivery of mine, hopefully early summer now, don't worry Porsche will fix this bargain supercar and irrespective of this setback, residuals will clearly be strong on the car unlike nigh on 50 per cent first year depreciation on overpriced 458s and Lambs which coincidentally everyone remembers also had burning issues soon after launch.....biggrin:
50% depreciation on a 458? Where are these £100k cars you speak of please? Yes the Porsche is cheap by comparison, but it's not what I would term a super car.. It's priced at a selling point same as the 458, if porsche could charge more and sell the same numbers they would, . And Ferrari don't seem to have trouble shifting new ones.
Ran a 458 Italia for a week last summer and loved every aspect of the car, decided to buy one then tried to find one at sensible money from F network but couldn't despite numerous stockpiled 458s at the back of dealers......yes

So ordered a GT3 instead....biggrin:

Yes, retail asking prices for F dealer cars appear to indicate depreciation is reasonable but there is plenty of evidence from owners being hosed at trade in time, and not just on the forums, that dealer bids on 1 year old 458s rarely exceed £120k....and why should they bearing in mind the trade bid on a 1 year old well specced low mileage Macca is the same.

I am not the only person to class the 991 GT3 as a super car.....the write up from respected experienced Autocars Steve Sutcliffe on the GT3 v 458 Speciale makes interesting reading.....basically same perfomance, same awesome sound, same drivability and interaction but the GT3 some £100k less.......thumbup

Sierra Mike

887 posts

226 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
Jules360 said:
Yes the Porsche is cheap by comparison, but it's not what I would term a super car..but opinions vary.
I expect the GT3 to destroy the 458 in a road test - I wonder if it will be accepted as a supercar then? If not, what does that make the 458? Time will tell.

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
Jules360 said:
av185 said:
Still taking delivery of mine, hopefully early summer now, don't worry Porsche will fix this bargain supercar and irrespective of this setback, residuals will clearly be strong on the car unlike nigh on 50 per cent first year depreciation on overpriced 458s and Lambs which coincidentally everyone remembers also had burning issues soon after launch.....biggrin:
50% depreciation on a 458? Where are these £100k 2013 cars you speak of please? The cheapest I can find on here is £173k. Yes the Porsche is cheap by comparison, but it's not what I would term a super car..but opinions vary. It's priced at a selling point same as the 458, if porsche could charge more and sell the same numbers they would, they are a business who understand their elasticity of demand. Same as Ferrari and they don't seem to have trouble shifting new ones at "inflated" prices.


Edited by Jules360 on Saturday 22 February 05:14
I can't find a 458 that's depreciated 50% in three years nevermind 12 months.
As for low offers from dealers I struggle to find a car that doesn't receive derisory offers from dealers and the GT3 will go the same way regardless of how good it is.

Jules360

1,949 posts

233 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
Sierra Mike said:
I expect the GT3 to destroy the 458 in a road test - I wonder if it will be accepted as a supercar then? If not, what does that make the 458? Time will tell.
Would you call a Nissan GTR a super car ?

Sarnie

8,379 posts

240 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
Sierra Mike said:
I expect the GT3 to destroy the 458 in a road test - I wonder if it will be accepted as a supercar then? If not, what does that make the 458? Time will tell.
No derivative of a 911 will ever be a 'supercar', in my opinion. Just being fast isn't enough ala GTR.....

Eleven

28,176 posts

253 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
sone said:
Jules360 said:
av185 said:
Still taking delivery of mine, hopefully early summer now, don't worry Porsche will fix this bargain supercar and irrespective of this setback, residuals will clearly be strong on the car unlike nigh on 50 per cent first year depreciation on overpriced 458s and Lambs which coincidentally everyone remembers also had burning issues soon after launch.....biggrin:
50% depreciation on a 458? Where are these £100k 2013 cars you speak of please? The cheapest I can find on here is £173k. Yes the Porsche is cheap by comparison, but it's not what I would term a super car..but opinions vary. It's priced at a selling point same as the 458, if porsche could charge more and sell the same numbers they would, they are a business who understand their elasticity of demand. Same as Ferrari and they don't seem to have trouble shifting new ones at "inflated" prices.


Edited by Jules360 on Saturday 22 February 05:14
I can't find a 458 that's depreciated 50% in three years nevermind 12 months.
As for low offers from dealers I struggle to find a car that doesn't receive derisory offers from dealers and the GT3 will go the same way regardless of how good it is.
Ah, you're making the mistake of confusing AV185's world with the real one.

In the former, every car AV185 owns is the very best on the road and not depreciating at all, in fact it's probably appreciating. Even the GT3 catching fire is good news for AV185 because it means that there are fewer about and that means the remaining ones will double in value.

Meanwhile in the real world...


av185

20,464 posts

158 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
sone said:
I can't find a 458 that's depreciated 50% in three years nevermind 12 months.
As for low offers from dealers I struggle to find a car that doesn't receive derisory offers from dealers and the GT3 will go the same way regardless of how good it is.
I agree nor could I find a 458 at sensible money that's why I didn't buy one and ordered a GT3 instead.

3 year old £90k new price 997 GT3s still command trade prices of c £75k and up to c £90k at OPCs and only a handful available.

Only 140 991 GT3s for UK market sold out, widely regarded as underpriced at £100k new with 458 performance will guarantee very strong residuals.....thumbup

qureshia

4,773 posts

237 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
av185 said:
... depreciation is reasonable but there is plenty of evidence from owners being hosed at trade in time, and not just on the forums, that dealer bids on 1 year old 458s rarely exceed £120k....
:
I keep hearing this, but never see the private one year old cars for anything below £150k++, also a couple of 2012 MP4s have gone though auctions for circa £130k, so I would have thought a trade in bid would be at least stronger than this.

Only asking as I can buy one at the prices you suggest, but can't find one confused

av185

20,464 posts

158 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
qureshia said:
av185 said:
... depreciation is reasonable but there is plenty of evidence from owners being hosed at trade in time, and not just on the forums, that dealer bids on 1 year old 458s rarely exceed £120k....
:
I keep hearing this, but never see the private one year old cars for anything below £150k++, also a couple of 2012 MP4s have gone though auctions for circa £130k, so I would have thought a trade in bid would be at least stronger than this.

Only asking as I can buy one at the prices you suggest, but can't find one confused
It was my intention to buy a 458 privately at the sensible figure I suggest but as I said I couldn t find one at the time but ththat's not to say they don t exist. After all, if you are only bid £120k trade then why wouldn t you sell at say £130k?

Yes there were 2 black 12 62 plate low mileage good spec Maccs in Blackbushe on two successive weeks in December seem to recollect one sold the other did not....trade was £125k......thumbup

hazy

1,174 posts

299 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
Sarnie said:
No derivative of a 911 will ever be a 'supercar', in my opinion. Just being fast isn't enough ala GTR.....
+1. Being a Supercar isnt much to do with outright performance and Ring times, its the whole package, I can understand Beetle owners wanting their car to be veiwed as a Supercar, thats natural, but it just aint, sorry.

And before some wag starts Ive got a 997.1 GT3 and a 430 so I can be accused of favouritism biggrinbiggrinbiggrin

A1

681 posts

242 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
2012 458, low miles, decent spec.....been offered 152k from f dealer plus couple grand off the car I'm looking at.

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
A1 said:
2012 458, low miles, decent spec.....been offered 152k from f dealer plus couple grand off the car I'm looking at.
Ok so 152k on a two year old car I'm guessing with reasonable spec £190-200k new so 40-50k drop. By my calculations that's around 25% over 2 years. I know there's a lot of ish's there but you get my gist.
Where's that 50% in 12 months people talk about.

You appreciate the custard test is required if you buy the car!. The last time some one made such claims of a cheap 458 he failed the test and I don't think reappeared on the forum, strange that!

steelej

1,761 posts

238 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
Sierra Mike said:
I expect the GT3 to destroy the 458 in a road test - I wonder if it will be accepted as a supercar then? If not, what does that make the 458? Time will tell.
Don't forget the 458 is coming to the end of it's life, most probably with a replacement next year so it's not surprising that the GT3 might have the edge over a 5 year old car.

John.

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
Sierra Mike said:
I expect the GT3 to destroy the 458 in a road test - I wonder if it will be accepted as a supercar then? If not, what does that make the 458? Time will tell.
At the end of the day a 911 however fast or good it is does not cut the mustard as a proper supercar and that's from someone with a 991 GT3 on order.

My last top spec fully aerokitted 911 turbo was epically fast and a great car but no one came up to me or pointed at it like the Ferrari and Lambo.
Just another Porsche I'm afraid

Sierra Mike

887 posts

226 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
There are many facets which determine whether a car should be considered a supercar or not and, in fairness, it's rather subjective. I agree that not one Porsche apart from the likes of the Carrera GT, 959 or 918 could be considered supercars however I think the 991 GT3 has moved things along a bit. It's not about just how fast it is but its desirability. It's a lot to do with how it's perceived not just by its owners/drivers but onlookers as well. To many it will still be just another 911 variant however the car does have a serious 'wow' factor to it which has been absent on many preceding 911s.

I accept the 458 is an older model but, back in the day, the 911 and V8 Ferraris were rivals till Ferrari moved the game on and Porsche fell behind. For the first time in many years, a valid comparison can once again be made between these great cars. I think it's rather exciting and looking forward to reading the outcome.