Armchair lawyers - copyright question...
Discussion
I have a cretinous young teenager who I mistakenly involved in a business venture of mine creating a sh*t storm for me over the alleged copyright infringement of aircraft images he re-touched in Photoshop for me. I ditched him from the project some weeks ago and since then he's managed to get me banned from Facebook, had YouTube videos taken down and now the little sh*t has even got my website pulled down by the hosting company.
Replacing the images will be a pain in the ass so here's the question - if I send someone an image and they add some blur and colour in photoshop and then send it me back - who owns it? Me or him?
Replacing the images will be a pain in the ass so here's the question - if I send someone an image and they add some blur and colour in photoshop and then send it me back - who owns it? Me or him?
you need to research 'commissioned work' and work in 'employment',.
if he was in your employment then default legal position it is the employers unless otherwise agreed - this is within the copyright,designs and patents act 1988 i believe
ipo.gov.uk will have the answers
as above poster says, did you own the copyright in the image for him to alter? if not he can argue that the original persons copyright has been infrigned - althugh arguably that person should be complaining themselves.
if he was in your employment then default legal position it is the employers unless otherwise agreed - this is within the copyright,designs and patents act 1988 i believe
ipo.gov.uk will have the answers
as above poster says, did you own the copyright in the image for him to alter? if not he can argue that the original persons copyright has been infrigned - althugh arguably that person should be complaining themselves.
bennyboydurham said:
I have a cretinous young teenager who I mistakenly involved in a business venture of mine creating a sh*t storm for me over the alleged copyright infringement of aircraft images he re-touched in Photoshop for me. I ditched him from the project some weeks ago and since then he's managed to get me banned from Facebook, had YouTube videos taken down and now the little sh*t has even got my website pulled down by the hosting company.
Replacing the images will be a pain in the ass so here's the question - if I send someone an image and they add some blur and colour in photoshop and then send it me back - who owns it? Me or him?
Oft repeated question with a fairly simple answer: something can both infringe someone else's copyright and have its own separate copyright at the same time. Replacing the images will be a pain in the ass so here's the question - if I send someone an image and they add some blur and colour in photoshop and then send it me back - who owns it? Me or him?
Eg: I get hold of a photograph that X has taken. X is unrelated to me. X owns the copyright in his photo. I fiddle around with it a bit, adding bits here, taking bits out, and recolouring it. Comparing the two side by side, they are different, but it remains obvious to anyone that X's image is "substantially reproduced" (to use the statutory phrase) in my picture.
X's copyright has been infringed by me, een though I have produced, using X's work, an original image which itself is a,copyright work and in which I own the copyright.
Adjust the facts: if I engage an employee or commission a subbie to do the work, the end result is pretty much the same for me: I am as liable to X for infringement by authorising the employee/subbie to act on my behalf as I am doing it myself; and under the terms between me and the employee/subbie, one way or another I am likely to own the copyright in what they produce.
A wrinkle though: it is possible that as between me and the employee/subbie I can say that they are liable to inmdenify me for my exposure to X that results from their infringement. This will depend on the precise terms on which they were engaged.
HTH.
That would/could be classed as a derivative work.
Some info here for you
http://www.copyrightservice.co.uk/copyright/p22_de...
This is the relevant portion
" Bear in mind that to be subject to copyright the creation of the derivative work must itself be an original work of skill, labour and judgement; minor alterations that do not substantially alter the original would not qualify."
if it is just colour correction and some minor tweaks then it would not count as being copyright in its own right.
Some info here for you
http://www.copyrightservice.co.uk/copyright/p22_de...
This is the relevant portion
" Bear in mind that to be subject to copyright the creation of the derivative work must itself be an original work of skill, labour and judgement; minor alterations that do not substantially alter the original would not qualify."
if it is just colour correction and some minor tweaks then it would not count as being copyright in its own right.
Where did the original photos come from, who owns the copyright, you, some body else or some form of public domain/creative commons.
If the original photos are public domain, or creative commons, he cannot assert copyright.
If the original photos are your copyright, you retain that. Touch up and minor changes is a derivative work and your copyright remains.
If he took the original photos it depends on how he was employed as work for hire or not
Chances are he's invoked the DMCA which means he has committed perjury (but as an American law unenforceable) but enough grounds to follow these.
Simply reject his claim to copyright and assert your own.
https://www.youtube.com/yt/copyright/counter-notif...
http://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/responding-dmca-ta...
If the original photos are public domain, or creative commons, he cannot assert copyright.
If the original photos are your copyright, you retain that. Touch up and minor changes is a derivative work and your copyright remains.
If he took the original photos it depends on how he was employed as work for hire or not
Chances are he's invoked the DMCA which means he has committed perjury (but as an American law unenforceable) but enough grounds to follow these.
Simply reject his claim to copyright and assert your own.
https://www.youtube.com/yt/copyright/counter-notif...
http://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/responding-dmca-ta...
Edited by Martin4x4 on Saturday 22 February 21:32
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


