Car damaged whilst in garage.
Car damaged whilst in garage.
Author
Discussion

davemac250

Original Poster:

4,499 posts

236 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
I posted this in the TVR area, wondered in anyone well versed in this sort of thing could give an opinion.

Thanks.

My car went to one of 'main dealers' on July 12th with a noisy cam and low oil pressure.

After a st load of fk ups I picked it up today! These included giving me the car back with no oil pressure showing!

I picked the car up and it has damage on it - scuffs to the front wing and chips out if the paint around the passenger door and on the bonnet where the lugs have caught the surround. They had to take the clocks out - I was warned the veneer might get chipped - it's fked.

I was told on collection that their standard terms and conditions state they cannot be held responsible for damage caused whilst with them.

This smacks of complete bks. I'd really appreciate some advice on this. The car has been a nightmare since I bought it. The dealer warranty has covered a lot of it, however they have had it for longer than I have in the last two years.

Does anyone know if this clause is enforceable?

Does anyone want to know which garage operates like this? PM me.

imagineifyeswill

1,250 posts

197 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
I would think they would certainly be responsible for damage caused while in there care. Im a self employed mechanic and share the parking around my premises with other businesses in the same yard. I repaired then parked a customers vehicle outside where it was hit by a delivery van going to the unit next door. I phoned my insurance to ask for advice, do I put the claim through my insurance against the van or leave the customer to go through his own insurance, they said as it was in my care they would handle it on behalf of myself and my customer.

davemac250

Original Poster:

4,499 posts

236 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks.

What do your T&C's say though?

I'd fully expect them to hold liability without this get out clause in their standard T&C's - available on their website but I can't name them?!?

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Are these T&Cs only on their website? Or we're they made apparent to you when you took the car to them and agreed with them that they would do the work.


catman

2,504 posts

206 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
I dont believe that they can escape responsibility just by saying this. If the law says they are responsible, then they are!

It's like having a sign saying no refunds. If the law says that you're entitled to a refund, their sign makes no difference.

Tim

wildcat45

8,160 posts

220 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all

After I had a car damaged at a dealers when they wouldn't accept resposinility, I always do a walk round with the garage prior to handing it over.

It is also worth checking that trim has been put back properly. I used this indy for my MG years ago. It was listed as an approved place by the owners club. The job invovled removing the scuttle panel at the base of the screen where the wipers sit. They presented me with the car missing the screw caps, and with the scuttle panel not refitted properly. One of the few times I have actually got shouty and mental with a garage. Its hard being 5 feet 8 and standing over the mechanic while he made good.

If they have it and break it, they should fix it. To hell with their Ts and Cs.

I hate this "its not company policy" attitude. fk that, its not the law.

Bumps do happen in garages - just one of those things. It has happened to me twice, when the garage they were quick to sort it even though there was little or no proof they had done it.


anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Attempts by a business that is dealing with a consumer to exclude liability for damage to the consumer's property caused by the negligence of the business are subject to fairly strict statutory and regulatory controls, and on the limited facts thus far stated I doubt that the workshop can successfully exclude liability.

A person who stores a car for someone else has a duty to store the car carefully. A person who works on a car for someone else has a duty to work on the car carefully.

There is the additional point that an exclusion clause has to be fairly drawn to the attention of the person who is later said to be bound by it, and this must be done before or when the contract is made, not later.

Be polite but firm, do not get angry or shouty. Push for the damage to be made good.


IAAL but IANYL.

dxg

10,836 posts

291 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
It can work the other way.

I once put a car into a main dealer with some horrendous gouges out the paint above the drivers door.

It was returned with the gouges repaired and not a word was said.

I reckon the workshop assumed they'd done them.


But then they collapsed the driver's sill by lowering the car onto something on a later visit. I didn't notice for months (when I next washed it) and couldn't prove anything.

Karma, perhaps?

4rephill

5,171 posts

209 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
Attempts by a business that is dealing with a consumer to exclude liability for damage to the consumer's property caused by the negligence of the business are subject to fairly strict statutory and regulatory controls, and on the limited facts thus far stated I doubt that the workshop can successfully exclude liability.

A person who stores a car for someone else has a duty to store the car carefully. A person who works on a car for someone else has a duty to work on the car carefully.

There is the additional point that an exclusion clause has to be fairly drawn to the attention of the person who is later said to be bound by it, and this must be done before or when the contract is made, not later.

Be polite but firm, do not get angry or shouty. Push for the damage to be made good.


IAAL but IANYL.
The biggest concern I'd have is that there was no inspection of the cars condition when it arrived at the dealership, so it's too easy for the dealership to claim that the damage was pre-existing, even if it wasn't. It then becomes the owners word against the dealerships, and that could go either way (unless the owner can somehow prove the damage was not there prior to the cars visit to the dealership/garage of course).

To be fair, how many people do go to the trouble of going round their car with a member of garage staff to confirm the condition of the car when it arrived, and get the garage to confirm the condition and agree to repairs if it's not in the same condition on collection? - Very few I suspect. Normally, you just go in, explain what seems to be the issue, try to get some sort of idea off cost/time to carry out the repair, give them the keys and then leave it with them, hoping for the best and expecting the car to be returned with no additional damage to it.

By the same token, how many people inspect the condition of the car with a member of staff when they go to collect it? - Again, not many I suspect.

(At the BMW dealership I go to, the previous group of Service Advisor's who used to work there used to always come out with Me to inspect the car and ensure that I was happy with it's condition before I left their premises, which I thought was a nice touch and great customer care. Sadly, that no longer happens! The group who work there now seem very reluctant to leave their desks and coffee, even if there's no other customers to deal with! They just take the payment, hand the keys back and say goodbye! - a sign of the times I suppose! frown ).

Also, how often do dealerships/garages get claims for damage to cars being made against them when it really wasn't their fault? - There are plenty of people out there who are happy to chance their arm and try it on! (BTW, I'm not saying that that is true in this case).

If a dealership/garage have genuinely caused damage to a vehicle in their care then yes, they should accept responsibility and carry out any required repairs FOC, without any arguments whatsoever, rather than simply claiming that any damage caused whilst they work on a car is the owners tough luck.

I think you're right and the OP should pursue the garage for the car to have the damage repaired, but without any pre-work inspection being carried out on the car, I suspect I know what they will claim. It then becomes a matter of how far the OP wants to pursue it.