Box Junction Fines
Author
Discussion

19Dogger87

Original Poster:

68 posts

170 months

Sunday 23rd February 2014
quotequote all
Think i was caught in a box junction earlier on today, not complaining about it just wondering, after reading on the internet, that not all councils have the power to enforce fines for this type of moving traffic offence who would actually fine you? The junction quite clearly has 2 cameras pointing on it, its actually to keep a "Gala Bingo" exit clear on a retail sort of estate.
If the council cannot enforce it, whats the point in the cameras!?

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
They can, they will. PCN in then post.
dvd

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
They can, they will. PCN in then post.
dvd
AFAIK the local authority must have applied for specific authorisation to apply moving traffic offence contraventions per Schedule 8 of the Traffic Management Act 2004. It's certainly a given in Greater London (all 33 boroughs and the CoL have this power).

I would be surprised if LAs which have not applied for Civil Enforcement for parking have done so for moving traffic contraventions. There are still some parts of England where the local authority is not empowered to raid your wallet - https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploa...


19Dogger87

Original Poster:

68 posts

170 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
The council in question, appear not to have this privilege (this is going off their website list of offence codes for traffic contaventions). So, what is the point in the cameras on it? Who can enforce it?
Surely they do not pay somebody to watch the cameras then to pass on the info for a fine to be issued? It would be a waste of their money would it not?

I'm thinking that the cameras may actually be for monitoring the traffic couming in and out in that case?

creampuff

6,511 posts

174 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
The box junctions also have to be a specific shape. They cannot just be yellow boxes painted wherever someone has felt like it.

mgtony

4,226 posts

221 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Some interesting reading here about rules and regs concerning box junctions and reasons for stooping in the junction that are not an offence:

http://www.ticketfighter.co.uk/yellow.htm

19Dogger87

Original Poster:

68 posts

170 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Yeah i seen that page earlier on. Still not sure as to who enforces the fine mind!

Swervin_Mervin

5,013 posts

269 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
What sort of cameras? They could just be for monitoring traffic.

19Dogger87

Original Poster:

68 posts

170 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Just 2 white cameras 1 on each lane (only 1 lane has box junction)

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
The presence of cameras indicated to me the high probability that LA have obtained the necessary authority to issue PCN's.
dvd

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
maybe Bingo is very important to the local economy
doesn't sound like Eastbourne
where was it?

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
The presence of cameras indicated to me the high probability that LA have obtained the necessary authority to issue PCN's.
dvd
I don't share your confidence. I wouldn't trust some local authorities to organise a drinking session in a manufacturing facility. Their incompetence and duplicity in pursuit of revenue knows no bounds.

Non-compliant PCNs, signage, and road markings (far too many to mention), unapproved CCTV cameras (LB Richmond-on-Thames obtained VCA 'approved device' certification for the wrong equipment in ALL of its Smart parking enforcement cars and when they introduced new cars with new and different cameras they failed to get ANY authorisation at all), etc. etc.

The upshot in the Richmond case was that not one legal PCN was issued over a 2 YEAR period between 2009 and 2011. It only came to light when one determined motorist refused to back down and challenged the LA at PATAS. The failure was so egregious that the adjudicator awarded the driver costs in full against the Council (a very unusual move) as its actions were deemed wholly unreasonable. They were forced to take the cars off the road and suspend enforcement. Plus repaying £648k to 12,000 wrongly penalised drivers/owners (the final bill was even higher as the total number of unlawful penalties was 18,500).

And the cost of that incompetence came from monies already paid by Richmond Council Tax payers. Such things are an utter disgrace and it's high time that the power to surcharge officers which was removed by the Local Government Act 2000 was brought back. These faceless, unaccountable, and unsanctioned bureaucrats should be made to suffer the consequences of their failures where it hurts. In their pockets just as ours have been.

Did I mention that Councils are not to be trusted where automated revenue generation is concerned...?

19Dogger87

Original Poster:

68 posts

170 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Gateshead council will be the chaps in question. Looking at their list of approved moving traffic offences... Theyre not approved, or their list is out of date

Edited by 19Dogger87 on Monday 24th February 19:34

Vipers

33,525 posts

259 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
mgtony said:
Some interesting reading here about rules and regs concerning box junctions and reasons for stooping in the junction that are not an offence:

http://www.ticketfighter.co.uk/yellow.htm
Looked at the link, badly worded I thought, this bit -

The offence as stated in the regs below is "no person shall cause a vehicle to enter the box junction so that the vehicle has to stop within the box junction due to the presence of stationary vehicles

Of course you can stop on a box if your turning right and prevented by oncoming traffic, or other vehicles also turning right, so if you can fit two cars on the box both turning right, they are allowed to do it, and both be stationary. So the second would be stopped due to a stationary vehicle (the one in front turning right as well)

Strange thar link doesn't explain that bit. It's amazing how so many drivers seem to have absolutely idea of how a box works.




smile

Edited by Vipers on Monday 24th February 19:22

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Many Councils have bus lane enforcement powers standing alongside parking in their CEA but I believe not many, if indeed any, outside London currently do for other moving traffic contraventions. Back in 2012 several were said to be lobbying the Secretary of State for such powers (I haven't been able to find any published evidence that shows they have been given them). They include Birmingham, Brighton and Hove, Bristol, Leeds, Liverpool, Manchester, Newcastle, Nottingham, Plymouth, Reading, Salford, Sheffield and Southampton. I think Leicester is another. I don't know if Gateshead is among them.

However, if this is to be believed, it now looks like Cardiff will emerge as leader of the pack to grab these additional powers.

This is the link to the code list for London - http://www.londoncouncils.gov.uk/policylobbying/tr... - yellow box contraventions are code 31. AFAIK the list is standard so any authority outside London which is given other moving traffic contravention powers should be using that code number.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Vipers said:
mgtony said:
Some interesting reading here about rules and regs concerning box junctions and reasons for stooping in the junction that are not an offence:

http://www.ticketfighter.co.uk/yellow.htm
Looked at the link, badly worded I thought, this bit -

The offence as stated in the regs below is "no person shall cause a vehicle to enter the box junction so that the vehicle has to stop within the box junction due to the presence of stationary vehicles
It's not badly worded at all. It is a verbatim statement of The Traffic Signs Regulations and General Directions 2002 Schedule 19 Part II Section 7(1).

Vipers said:
Of course you can stop on a box if your turning right and prevented by oncoming traffic, or other vehicles also turning right, so if you can fit two cars on the box both turning right, they are allowed to do it, and both be stationary. So the second would be stopped due to a stationary vehicle (the one in front turning right as well)

Strange thar link doesn't explain that bit. It's amazing how so many drivers seem to have absolutely idea of how a box works.




smile
You didn't scroll down far enough. Further down there is a box out which quotes Schedule 19 including the exceptions in Section 7(2)(a) & (b) and incorporating the amended wording per The Traffic Signs (Amendment) (No. 2) Regulations and General Directions 2011. smile

Vipers

33,525 posts

259 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
You didn't scroll down far enough. Further down there is a box out which quotes Schedule 19 including the exceptions in Section 7(2)(a) & (b) and incorporating the amended wording per The Traffic Signs (Amendment) (No. 2) Regulations and General Directions 2011. smile
Your right, tks for that. I read the first post in isolation, which may well be what the regulation says, I interpreted it differently.




smile

Basic

86 posts

212 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
Many Councils have bus lane enforcement powers standing alongside parking in their CEA but I believe not many, if indeed any, outside London currently do for other moving traffic contraventions. Back in 2012 several were said to be lobbying the Secretary of State for such powers (I haven't been able to find any published evidence that shows they have been given them)...

However, if this is to be believed, it now looks like Cardiff will emerge as leader of the pack to grab these additional powers.

This is the link to the code list for London - http://www.londoncouncils.gov.uk/policylobbying/tr... - yellow box contraventions are code 31. AFAIK the list is standard so any authority outside London which is given other moving traffic contravention powers should be using that code number.
I haven't checked, so might not be exactly correct on this but...

I don't think the relevant schedules of the Traffic Management Act have been enacted to allow local authorities to enforce moving traffic offences (except in London and, more recently (or just about to be) Wales).

So, in England, outside of London, local authorities can enforce only against parking at the moment.

Ian Geary

5,651 posts

223 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
Such things are an utter disgrace and it's high time that the power to surcharge officers which was removed by the Local Government Act 2000 was brought back. These faceless, unaccountable, and unsanctioned bureaucrats should be made to suffer the consequences of their failures where it hurts. In their pockets just as ours have been.

Did I mention that Councils are not to be trusted where automated revenue generation is concerned...?
As a local government officer (not involved in automated revenue generation though) I'd like to point out

- we're accountable to our Head of Paid Service, who is accountable to the Council leader and his elected cabinet, who are accountable to the voters.
- we are sanctioned to carry out such works, e.g the de-regulation of parking etc where the police willingly passed powers to the council to carry out this type of enforcement
- faceless - well, yes, to the extent I don't know who it is in the insurance company who answers my call when I ring them, or who in BT puts my phone bill in an envelope each month. People who need to work with the public are out there, and those that don't, aren't. Believe me, having our faces out there and known is not going to improve your view of Local Authorities.


Also, the surcharge was I think applied to elected Councillors, rather than officers. I recall something about Liverpool refusing to set a poll tax in the 80s, and all the members having to pick up the council's budget between them. Also, the Westminster leader who got stung for some Gerry-mandering fraud (who promptly buggered off and hid all her cash).

If officers were to be held financially liable for mistakes, then we'd just get insurance against it (as any self employed professional does), which we'd claim as a cost of the job, which the employer would pay or we'd get tax relief on.

If people do lose out financially from genuine mistakes or miss applied regulations, there's plenty of routes for them to take to appeal it - which many do, going from the Council's complaints process right through to a sob story in the Daily Wail. But for every one of those, there are also plenty of people who get a fine legitimately, can't deal with the fact they're wrong, and cause all sorts of unnecessary grief to people just trying to enforce some pretty clear and uncomplicated rules.



And whilst I think there is sharp practice going on in Councils, I don't think putting an employee under financially (who would then be entitled to housing benefit, council tax benefit etc) is really the way forward. All organisations tend to keep their internal discipline out of the public eye (apart from perhaps football clubs) but persistent mistakes or poor customer feedback from an employee would get tackled pretty quickly at the place where I work, just as I hope it would at Tesco, or Lloyds bank etc.



I totally agree Richmond did drop the ball big time. What they did was wrong, and hopefully some Director there got a boot up an orifice. But there's 430 odd other local authorities in the UK who haven't been caught out, and I reckon it was as much incompetence, bad planning and lack of knowledge on Richmond's part rather than some grant scheme to defraud motorists by Town Hall's.


On my trek home the traffic is made far worse by donkey's not following yellow box protocol, and I'm glad there's a chance they'll get some comeuppance for it, because it is very irritating to have to ride around them. £80 is quite steep though, £40 is probably enough to make them think about re-reading the highway code.


Ian