Police admit easy mobile speed cameras pickings
Discussion
From The Daily Telegraph (As if we didn't already know):
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/10656510/Police-ad...
The Association of Scottish Police Superintendents calls for a review of using mobile cameras on stretches of road without a history of frequent accidents.
Placing mobile speed cameras on stretches of road without a history of frequent accidents is like "shooting fish in a barrel", one of the country’s most senior police officers has admitted.
The Association of Scottish Police Superintendents (Asps) suggested tactics such as parking mobile camera vans on a bridge above stretches of motorway, such as the M9 approaching Stirling, is more likely to raise money than save lives.
Chief Superintendent David O'Connor, the organisation’s president, said speeding is dangerous but it was time to review how mobile cameras are used.
Figures released by Police Scotland last month revealed that mobile speed cameras earned a total of £2.75 million in 2012/13 compared to £1.5 million generated from fixed cameras.
Critics claim the location of mobile speed cameras on motorways and dual carriageways is primarily a revenue-raising exercise. There are more than 500 mobile cameras operating on roads north of the Border,
Ch Supt O’Connor said placing cameras on motorway bridges was like "shooting fish in a barrel" because of the number of vehicles driving under them at close to or over the limit.
"We need to make sure that the public perception of speed cameras is not that it is all about making money. Of course speeding on the motorway is dangerous, but these are not accident black spots,” he told Scotland on Sunday.
"There must be more flexibility and maybe it's time to review safety cameras and how they're located across Scotland."
He said he also wants speeding motorists to be offered safer driving courses as an alternative to fines and points on their licenses, arguing the emphasis should be on “education as well as enforcement”.
But he said the police have diminishing influence in local camera safety partnerships, which oversee speed camera use but also include council and health representatives.
Scotland’s most lucrative mobile camera site is the A9 Edinburgh to Perth Road, on the northern outskirts of Dunblane, where it crosses Allan Water.
Some 4,217 drivers were caught in the last financial year, paying a total of £253,020 in fines. The next most-ticketed spot for mobile cameras was the A74M northbound at junction 13 where 3,163 drivers were caught paying £189,780.
Alex Johnstone, Scottish Conservative transport spokesman, blamed the camera safety partnerships, adding: “If speed cameras were designed to save lives, we'd place them outside schools and in other built-up residential areas.
"Instead, they're situated where these partnerships know they can get the most money from them. Our motorways and dual carriageways are actually the safest types of roads. That's proof that cameras are not there to make roads safer, they exist to hit motorists in the pocket."
A spokesman for Transport Scotland, a Scottish Government quango, said: “New fixed and mobile camera sites must meet criteria based on accidents, casualty histories and levels of speeding.
“Once a site is established. levels of enforcement and other operational decisions are made by the partnerships themselves."
Police Scotland said there had been no change in the arrangements, but disclosed a review had been launched into where cameras are located.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/10656510/Police-ad...
The Association of Scottish Police Superintendents calls for a review of using mobile cameras on stretches of road without a history of frequent accidents.
Placing mobile speed cameras on stretches of road without a history of frequent accidents is like "shooting fish in a barrel", one of the country’s most senior police officers has admitted.
The Association of Scottish Police Superintendents (Asps) suggested tactics such as parking mobile camera vans on a bridge above stretches of motorway, such as the M9 approaching Stirling, is more likely to raise money than save lives.
Chief Superintendent David O'Connor, the organisation’s president, said speeding is dangerous but it was time to review how mobile cameras are used.
Figures released by Police Scotland last month revealed that mobile speed cameras earned a total of £2.75 million in 2012/13 compared to £1.5 million generated from fixed cameras.
Critics claim the location of mobile speed cameras on motorways and dual carriageways is primarily a revenue-raising exercise. There are more than 500 mobile cameras operating on roads north of the Border,
Ch Supt O’Connor said placing cameras on motorway bridges was like "shooting fish in a barrel" because of the number of vehicles driving under them at close to or over the limit.
"We need to make sure that the public perception of speed cameras is not that it is all about making money. Of course speeding on the motorway is dangerous, but these are not accident black spots,” he told Scotland on Sunday.
"There must be more flexibility and maybe it's time to review safety cameras and how they're located across Scotland."
He said he also wants speeding motorists to be offered safer driving courses as an alternative to fines and points on their licenses, arguing the emphasis should be on “education as well as enforcement”.
But he said the police have diminishing influence in local camera safety partnerships, which oversee speed camera use but also include council and health representatives.
Scotland’s most lucrative mobile camera site is the A9 Edinburgh to Perth Road, on the northern outskirts of Dunblane, where it crosses Allan Water.
Some 4,217 drivers were caught in the last financial year, paying a total of £253,020 in fines. The next most-ticketed spot for mobile cameras was the A74M northbound at junction 13 where 3,163 drivers were caught paying £189,780.
Alex Johnstone, Scottish Conservative transport spokesman, blamed the camera safety partnerships, adding: “If speed cameras were designed to save lives, we'd place them outside schools and in other built-up residential areas.
"Instead, they're situated where these partnerships know they can get the most money from them. Our motorways and dual carriageways are actually the safest types of roads. That's proof that cameras are not there to make roads safer, they exist to hit motorists in the pocket."
A spokesman for Transport Scotland, a Scottish Government quango, said: “New fixed and mobile camera sites must meet criteria based on accidents, casualty histories and levels of speeding.
“Once a site is established. levels of enforcement and other operational decisions are made by the partnerships themselves."
Police Scotland said there had been no change in the arrangements, but disclosed a review had been launched into where cameras are located.
at the bottom of hills on dual tracks has never made sense other than revunue generation!!!
I would much rather have them in built up areas.
If they had one in my village my dick head neighbour would be out of a car and job or would of slowed down by now. Since he lives 1 mile from work and doesnt seem to go out much other than around town he seems to avoids most camera vans. If he traveled extensively like he would be screwed as he drives faster than me everywhere and is a full bore nutter in residential areas.
After compliants from 3 other sets of neighbours the police have threatened him which he doesnt like as he gives me evils and now just revs his engine (Must be late 30's please sad act).
Once he is out of our development he bangs through the village like a nutter but so far just lots of near misses no accidents.
I would much rather have them in built up areas.
If they had one in my village my dick head neighbour would be out of a car and job or would of slowed down by now. Since he lives 1 mile from work and doesnt seem to go out much other than around town he seems to avoids most camera vans. If he traveled extensively like he would be screwed as he drives faster than me everywhere and is a full bore nutter in residential areas.
After compliants from 3 other sets of neighbours the police have threatened him which he doesnt like as he gives me evils and now just revs his engine (Must be late 30's please sad act).
Once he is out of our development he bangs through the village like a nutter but so far just lots of near misses no accidents.
Jagmanv12 said:
At last, at least some of the police realise the truth about the cameras.
They've always known. Years ago a chief constable was quoted in an in-house type magazine as saying that the cameras would be an important source of revenue.At last some of them are admitting the truth in public.
"But he said the police have diminishing influence in local camera safety partnerships, which oversee speed camera use but also include council and health representatives."
I thought the Police had the maximum influence as without them the prosecutions couldn't go ahead. I thought that the prosecutions, whether FPN or summons, were issued in the name of the Chief Constable.
I thought the Police had the maximum influence as without them the prosecutions couldn't go ahead. I thought that the prosecutions, whether FPN or summons, were issued in the name of the Chief Constable.
In somerset the camera partnership was desolved a few years ago and all fixed cameras switched off.
I have not seen any evidence the accident rate has increased and most people seem to slow down for them still.
They have just done a deal with the council to buy the for £1 each as I think they have seen a plug for the government funding gap!
They have continued to run the SCV in house.
I have not seen any evidence the accident rate has increased and most people seem to slow down for them still.
They have just done a deal with the council to buy the for £1 each as I think they have seen a plug for the government funding gap!
They have continued to run the SCV in house.
It's a shame that roads like the A74M where the only issue is numerical speed rather than any notable accident rate is even allowed to be subject to remote enforcement. It's a waste of everyone's time and money.
I read a while ago that the M6 Toll was monitored thus recording numerous triple digit speeds before enforcement was stepped up. The irony is that despite these speeds there were no accidents noted. We are left with speed control 'for the sake of it' and for no real gain to society.
The problem is that these cracks in the armour of the speed kills brainwashing could bust the whole 'system' that starts with ludicrous limits (enabling the 'easy picking' enforcement). So the bulls
t is perpetuated.
On open roads (not around high levels of vulnerable road users, its clearly different then) speed is not and never has been a sensible parameter to choose if one is attempting to measure or improve safety of vehicles. Everyone knows it, event the 'authorities'. They just can't admit it, which is why the Superintendent comment is actually a shock. Albeit and nice one
I read a while ago that the M6 Toll was monitored thus recording numerous triple digit speeds before enforcement was stepped up. The irony is that despite these speeds there were no accidents noted. We are left with speed control 'for the sake of it' and for no real gain to society.
The problem is that these cracks in the armour of the speed kills brainwashing could bust the whole 'system' that starts with ludicrous limits (enabling the 'easy picking' enforcement). So the bulls
t is perpetuated.On open roads (not around high levels of vulnerable road users, its clearly different then) speed is not and never has been a sensible parameter to choose if one is attempting to measure or improve safety of vehicles. Everyone knows it, event the 'authorities'. They just can't admit it, which is why the Superintendent comment is actually a shock. Albeit and nice one

Dave Hedgehog said:
Rovinghawk said:
Guybrush said:
mobile speed cameras earned a total of £2.75 million in 2012/13
I think the word 'earned' is inaccurate, as it implies producing value; a more suitable word would be 'extorted'.Look. Because of the cameras we don't trust you. Simple. If you want public trust, find a better way of weeding out dangerous motorists.
Davidonly said:
I read a while ago that the M6 Toll was monitored thus recording numerous triple digit speeds before enforcement was stepped up. The irony is that despite these speeds there were no accidents noted. We are left with speed control 'for the sake of it' and for no real gain to society.
Average speed on M6 Toll must still be pushing 90mph!Paddy_N_Murphy said:
mmm,
f
ksticks. Coming south from Glasgow on the M6 today, L1 doing 83 I saw a van up ahead.
They are that good with the distance targeting I assume if I've seen them - they've got me?
Do I live in hope he will have been hawk-eying the L3 or L2 ? and those of us trundling
up L1 would not have been in the sights?
I then start to wonder how accurate the 911 speedo is...... if it says 83, its more than bloody likely it is 79 or more isn't it ?

Indicated 83 in the last few cars I've had vs the sat nav was f
ksticks. Coming south from Glasgow on the M6 today, L1 doing 83 I saw a van up ahead. They are that good with the distance targeting I assume if I've seen them - they've got me?
Do I live in hope he will have been hawk-eying the L3 or L2 ? and those of us trundling
up L1 would not have been in the sights? I then start to wonder how accurate the 911 speedo is...... if it says 83, its more than bloody likely it is 79 or more isn't it ?

Cavalier : 69 mph GPS
Honda : 81 mph gps
MINI 1.6 cooper : 79 mph gps
mx5 : 75 mph gps
Volvo S40: 83 mph gps
Astra mk3 : 75 mph
mini 998 mayfair : well lets do it the other way. If the Sat nav was saying a very constant70 mph the speedo would be 65, 85, 69, 95, 55, 75, 70, 95, 65, 60, 75, 50
So just hope that it's as accurate as a 1992 1.8 cavalier (RIP)
Article said:
Chief Superintendent David O'Connor, the organisation’s president, said speeding is dangerous but it was time to review how mobile cameras are used.
Shouldn't that read:Article said:
Chief Superintendent David O'Connor, the organisation’s president, said in places speeding is dangerous but it was time to review how mobile cameras are used, where speeding isn't dangerous.
I'd say that there are several people pulling strings here
In terms of revenue and extorting money I did see a suggestion the other day.
The fine would be reduced to £15 to cover basic admin, but the punishment would be a week ban instead.
Speeding is enforced, no chance of accusations of profiteering.
- 1. Speeding is against the law.
- 2. Most police don't care about a bit if speeding, but also need to be aware of #1.
- 3. Some people in the greater police force recognise the need for camera based revenue.
- 4. I would guess that somewhere there is a report showing hours/tickets on different roads and there's no point putting camera where people aren't speeding.
In terms of revenue and extorting money I did see a suggestion the other day.
The fine would be reduced to £15 to cover basic admin, but the punishment would be a week ban instead.
Speeding is enforced, no chance of accusations of profiteering.
10 Pence Short said:
Why would people in the Police care about the revenue from the seed cameras? Where do you think it goes?
I would guess, someone in the police/treasury liaison department is asked to make more money.This person the encourages local chief constables to catch more speeders, who then suggests to his team an increased vigilance towards road safety.
There's certainly an element of money involved.
But, it's secondary.
The cameras are there primarily because of angry angry concerned citizens who don't like speeding and who bother local councilors until somethibg is done.
If it was about money there are better ways to make profit.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



