School teachers examining mobile phone contents
School teachers examining mobile phone contents
Author
Discussion

richie99

Original Poster:

1,125 posts

217 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
My son has told me that his school is about to start searching pupils and to examine the contents of their mobile phones. After checking, the 2011 education act appears to give teachers the right to do this and even includes statutory guidance on dealing with electronic devices. https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploa...

What doesn't seem to be covered is just how is a teacher to get access to the phone unless they are told the password. There does seem to be no requirement to hand over a password - unless this would qualify as a refusal to consent to a search - which would be a bit draconian.

Grateful for any views on whether a pupil could be compelled to provide a password. Perhaps they could be tortured for it.

markiii

4,340 posts

225 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
hmm teacher searches teenagers phone, finds naked selfie taken for boyfriend/girlfriend

are they now guilty of looking at indecent images of a child?

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
What sort of stuff would they be looking for?

I imagine it isn't going to be a daily check, just if certain complaints come in.

hondafanatic

4,969 posts

232 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Mot kids at my school don't actually have passwords set despite repeatedly suggesting they do.

If there was a serious enough requirement, then I would hand the phone to the PCSO to deal with. Most kids cough up or others are happy to drop others in it. Alternatively, parents are normally very happy to help assist in getting the passcode from their child.

I would imagine that if I asked a pupil to unlock a phone they probably would...but as I said, if that was ever required, I'd have passed it on to senior staff and/or PCSO before I got to that question.

untakenname

5,373 posts

223 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Does it apply to data physically on the device or can the teachers search the pupils cloud based storage as well? Seems a bit 1984 tbh, kids will get around stuff like that by using snapchat and other apps.

agtlaw

7,433 posts

237 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
hondafanatic said:
If there was a serious enough requirement, then I would hand the phone to the PCSO to deal with
If it were serious then a real police officer would be dealing with it.

hondafanatic

4,969 posts

232 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
agtlaw said:
hondafanatic said:
If there was a serious enough requirement, then I would hand the phone to the PCSO to deal with
If it were serious then a real police officer would be dealing with it.
We don't have real police on site. The PCSO is permanently on site to help with issues that spill outside of school, Facebook issues being a common problem.

dudleybloke

20,553 posts

217 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
i think its illegal under the data protection act.
pretty sure that even the police have to have a warrant to look at or delete any pics from someones phone.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
That appears to give teachers more powers than the police to delete data or images from a mobile phone.
What constitutes reasonable belief? You've broken the school rules lad/lass. Judge, jury, and executioner. You're guilty.

I wonder how many teachers will exercise their right not to carry out searches? The head teacher cannot compel them to.
So it would have to be done by the head or security staff (underpaid G4S robot anyone?).

Seems to me very easy to defeat, especially for a male pupil.

DfE Advice Guidance said:
The person conducting the search may not require the pupil to remove any clothing other than outer clothing.
Stuff the phone down your undercrackers. wink

Evil.soup

4,047 posts

236 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
I would imagine it is only enforced when the pupil is suspected of having evidence of some kind of wrong doing or crime such a video of bullying, harrasment or a criminal act.

richie99

Original Poster:

1,125 posts

217 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
It's just disturbed me on so many levels. As rightly pointed out, the law gives teachers greater powers than the police have - so much for the current lot being liberal and in favour of individual freedoms - not like the last lot, oh no. No need for the aforementioned PCSO or PC to deal with it as they have less power than the teachers. In what world does this make sense.

Also, no communication from school to parents - just told the kids about it today.

Finally, the governing body wasn't informed either.

As for asking parents to get children to reveal their password. I can just imagine the conversation.
School - Can you make your child tell us their phone password?
Me - What do you want to know for?
School - I'd like to have a ferret around on it to see if it has anything I might not approve of on it.
Me - How can I know what you would disapprove of?
School - You'll just have to take a chance on what level of obsessive PC bigot I am.
Me - Would you like to have a look at our family cloud storage too as the phone accesses it?
School - Oh yes please, that would be great.
Me - Get stuffed.

richie99

Original Poster:

1,125 posts

217 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Evil.soup said:
I would imagine it is only enforced when the pupil is suspected of having evidence of some kind of wrong doing or crime such a video of bullying, harrasment or a criminal act.
You obviously didn't read the link.

"In determining a ‘good reason’ to examine or erase the data or files the staff member must reasonably suspect that the data or file on the device in question has been, or could be, used to cause harm, to disrupt teaching or break the school rules."

....just about any reason will do, in other words. It then goes on to spoil things further by resorting to the dreaded PC word 'inappropriate'.

hondafanatic

4,969 posts

232 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
richie99 said:
It's just disturbed me on so many levels. As rightly pointed out, the law gives teachers greater powers than the police have - so much for the current lot being liberal and in favour of individual freedoms - not like the last lot, oh no. No need for the aforementioned PCSO or PC to deal with it as they have less power than the teachers. In what world does this make sense.

Also, no communication from school to parents - just told the kids about it today.

Finally, the governing body wasn't informed either.

As for asking parents to get children to reveal their password. I can just imagine the conversation.
School - Can you make your child tell us their phone password?
Me - What do you want to know for?
School - I'd like to have a ferret around on it to see if it has anything I might not approve of on it.
Me - How can I know what you would disapprove of?
School - You'll just have to take a chance on what level of obsessive PC bigot I am.
Me - Would you like to have a look at our family cloud storage too as the phone accesses it?
School - Oh yes please, that would be great.
Me - Get stuffed.
The PCSO is useful because their information on high risk kids includes incidents that happen outside of school. It's not about who has more power, but the school doesn't necessarily know that a kid's big brother has been arrested for burglry last night and the kid is coming into school very distressed. That's just an example.

As for your imagined conversation, in my experience, it would be a face to face conversation, never over the phone and even then this would only happen when it's a safeguarding issue. I've never heard of parent kicking off when there is a believed threat to their child. It would only happen with a few members of staff that are trained to deal with that level of incident.

All I have ever witnessed from pastoral teams is a genuine concern to make sure there is no actual safe guarding issues and try to resolve situations if there is.

I can't ever imagine your imagined conversation. But I've only got my experience to go off. smile

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Here's a thought. Try not sending your kid to school with a feckin mobile phone.

They don't need them in school.

At the least the school could provide a locker in which the phone is dropped of and picked up and the start and the end of the day.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
Here's a thought. Try not sending your kid to school with a feckin mobile phone.

They don't need them in school.
In one sense I agree with you, but on the other hand, if most kids have them, I wouldn't want to turn my kid into one of the billies who doesn't.

Martin_M

2,071 posts

258 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
I work in a primary school in Scotland but even if something serious did happen, I don't think we'd be asking to look through a phone. Usually parents/carers are contacted and we take it from there.

richie99

Original Poster:

1,125 posts

217 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
Here's a thought. Try not sending your kid to school with a feckin mobile phone.

They don't need them in school.

At the least the school could provide a locker in which the phone is dropped of and picked up and the start and the end of the day.
That's certainly a thought, but sadly no help. It's the hours journey by public transport to and from school that makes the phone helpful. They are already not allowed to use a phone in school and have to leave in their lockers.

Evil.soup

4,047 posts

236 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
richie99 said:
Evil.soup said:
I would imagine it is only enforced when the pupil is suspected of having evidence of some kind of wrong doing or crime such a video of bullying, harrasment or a criminal act.
You obviously didn't read the link.

"In determining a ‘good reason’ to examine or erase the data or files the staff member must reasonably suspect that the data or file on the device in question has been, or could be, used to cause harm, to disrupt teaching or break the school rules."

....just about any reason will do, in other words. It then goes on to spoil things further by resorting to the dreaded PC word 'inappropriate'.
I think you are missing my point. Just because they have the power it does not mean they will enforce it without good reason. I would imagine there are procedures to follow to do it anyway and doubt a teacher would bother unless as said there were issues of safeguarding, criminal activity or risk of harm.

I work in post 16 education and we do not have these powers, however even if we did it would be rare that I would want to use them.

I agree its a difficult subject but people have to be trusted to use the powers responsibly for the protection of the young person in question........

rambo19

2,970 posts

168 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Just ban the phones from school.

richie99

Original Poster:

1,125 posts

217 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
hondafanatic said:
The PCSO is useful because their information on high risk kids includes incidents that happen outside of school. It's not about who has more power, but the school doesn't necessarily know that a kid's big brother has been arrested for burglry last night and the kid is coming into school very distressed. That's just an example.

As for your imagined conversation, in my experience, it would be a face to face conversation, never over the phone and even then this would only happen when it's a safeguarding issue. I've never heard of parent kicking off when there is a believed threat to their child. It would only happen with a few members of staff that are trained to deal with that level of incident.

All I have ever witnessed from pastoral teams is a genuine concern to make sure there is no actual safe guarding issues and try to resolve situations if there is.

I can't ever imagine your imagined conversation. But I've only got my experience to go off. smile
You're obviously a reasonable chap but I think the problem here is more the message it sends. Citizenship has done a (too) good job of teaching them about human right abuse by draconian regimes around the world only to find they live in one.

To give you an idea of what they've stirred up, those with Android phones are already comparing notes on how to set up a dummy second account they can let the staff log on to. They're the ones not planning a human rights challenge from the class reps.