Whinging parents - cost of holidays
Whinging parents - cost of holidays
Author
Discussion

rsl430

Original Poster:

29 posts

242 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Sorry, but am I the only one fuming over the school holiday pricing furore? As a forty something with grown up kids I never had anywhere near the benefits afforded to parents these days - extended maternity/paternity leave, family tax credits, subsidised child care etc. etc. Now they want holiday companies to cap prices during school holidays, which would inevitably mean price rises for the rest of the year - I should pay more for my holiday in September so that others with school age children can save money on a trip to Disneyland in August? What next - subsidised chocolate eggs at Easter, Xmas trees in December? It's supply and demand. Get used to it. Kids are expensive. Consider cutting back on the plasma tv's in every room, smart phones for all the family and a new Audi on the drive. Look back at the sacrifices parents had to make 20/30/40 years ago and realise that you've never had it so good. And on a positive note, lobby Mr Gove to stagger school holidays. This is the only workable solution and the travel industry would totally get behind it.

hman

7,497 posts

225 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
rsl430 said:
Sorry,
Apology accepted.


hman

7,497 posts

225 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
rsl430 said:
As a forty something - Look back at the sacrifices parents had to make 20/30/40 years ago .
you're 49 arent you.

You are old and turning into Victor Meldrew.

Your kids are embarrassed by you.

You are an embarrassment.

Your rant was st.

The Leaper

5,739 posts

237 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
rsi430,

Spot on. This is yet another example of the younger supposedly mature generation people of today looking for a way to avoid their responsibilities and expect, yes actually expect, the rest of society to financially bail them out because they have a financial grumble which they are looking to validate. It's just another symptom of the credit society: want and get it now, sort out whether I can pay for it later. Instead, they should consider the consequences of their actions, including having kids, and prioritize what they want and then plan ahead, instead of just expecting everything to come their way NOW.

Rant over. I could go on!

Mind you, it's their parents, ie me and you, who had a laisse faire attitude in the 70s and 80s that probably allowed this lack of discipline to develop when we were parenting. So blame us, but don't expect us to then feel guilty and resolve your personal issues.

R.

rsl430

Original Poster:

29 posts

242 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
you're 49 arent you.

You are old and turning into Victor Meldrew.

Your kids are embarrassed by you.

You are an embarrassment.

Your rant was st.

Your considered response is most valued. Such a display of intellect and eloquence I really can't compete with.. on account of my advancing years. But you may be right, if only I could remember

hedgefinder

3,418 posts

201 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
not to mention it being your generation that raped the country dry and wrecked its manufacturing industry allowing the privatisation of everything worth having... laugh

Podie

46,649 posts

306 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Surely it's supply and demand?

Should we lobby for high season to be the same price as low season?

paolow

3,262 posts

289 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
This comes up from time to time.....

For a bit of balance...

I enjoyed 4 annual snowboarding holidays in a row when relatively low paid because I could take random weeks off at zero notice.

Now, when holidays have to be taken in, well, holiday time prices are higher - though we have a double income to draw from - and lets face it most PHers will at some point be both students and parents at some point. So it kinda balances out.

It doesn't however make real sense for the travel industry to double prices in the 2 months it makes a profit to make a 2% margin against the loss it runs for all the other months. It also doesn't make sense for children between the ages of 5 and 16 to be bored for 5 out of 6 weeks in the summer.

I don't understand why parents of children in certain age groupings - obviously excluding exam years etc - can't take children out of school for an approved one/two week holiday - whenever they see fit. There is a standardised (well sort of) syllabus - so surely educational materials can be provided for the time lost to be 'made up for' either whilst on hols (unlikely I appreciate) or at some point by the parent (again - unlikely - I appreciate) - but a bug would wipe them out for a week anyway - is it so different?

We live in an electronic age - materials could even be emailed whilst on hols!

When I was at school in the last week of term we did sweet FA. The first week of term was ruled by chaos and children high from being away. Is there no provision to butt the holiday a week either side of the official holiday period either? At least that would provide some graduation?

I wonder how popular a fully independent school that had holidays (excluding obvious holidays like Christmas etc) massively outside the norm would fare? Even a budget holiday in Egypt for instance would drop from £800 per person to £350 per person. X 4 for 2 children and 2 adults and suddenly those school fees seem cheap....
(I assume theres some sort of reason behind this)

It just seems the concept of a 'summer holiday' is a dated one that needs to be brought into context.....

Halmyre

12,704 posts

170 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
rsl430 said:
Sorry, but am I the only one fuming over the school holiday pricing furore? As a forty something with grown up kids I never had anywhere near the benefits afforded to parents these days - extended maternity/paternity leave, family tax credits, subsidised child care etc. etc. Now they want holiday companies to cap prices during school holidays, which would inevitably mean price rises for the rest of the year - I should pay more for my holiday in September so that others with school age children can save money on a trip to Disneyland in August? What next - subsidised chocolate eggs at Easter, Xmas trees in December? It's supply and demand. Get used to it. Kids are expensive. Consider cutting back on the plasma tv's in every room, smart phones for all the family and a new Audi on the drive. Look back at the sacrifices parents had to make 20/30/40 years ago and realise that you've never had it so good. And on a positive note, lobby Mr Gove to stagger school holidays. This is the only workable solution and the travel industry would totally get behind it.
I'm sure they would. Instead of a six week period of ker-ching in the summer they'd have twelve weeks, or whatever the stagger period is.

Besides, travel is so educational, Tarquin and Jocasta will benefit so much more from their holiday than they would from being in school.


Mark.

11,104 posts

307 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Never ceases to amaze me that parents find it acceptable to moan about holiday prices and not being able to take kids out of school.

Think about it for half a second before slapping an unwrapped one up your misses.

You have kids, the rules say they must go to school so by default that means you need to take them out of school during the.....yes that's it school holiday!
Before you had your 30 seconds of pleasure you might have thought it through a bit - kids, that's an expense and they are going to have to go to school and holidays are going to be expensive. It's just the way it is.

Bit like moaning you bought a high performance car and finding out is doesn't do 85 MPG - no st Sherlock.

rsl430

Original Poster:

29 posts

242 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
[report] [news]  20:46
not to mention it being your generation that raped the country dry and wrecked its manufacturing industry allowing the privatisation of everything worth having...


Not all of us supported Thatcher, or her arch disciple Blair, or the incumbent bunch of jokers. On a political level I suspect we may be on the same page. And please don't have a dig at "my generation". Friends ten years older have retired in early 50's on very generous final salary pension schemes (which we are still paying for) and friends ten years younger are getting far more child rearing benefits than we had (which we are still paying for) so don't begrudge my unwillingness to subsidise other folks holidays.

Leemcd

246 posts

163 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Moan, moan, moan! Good on you!.. What a full life.

paolow

3,262 posts

289 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
paolow said:
This comes up from time to time.....

I wonder how popular a fully independent school that had holidays (excluding obvious holidays like Christmas etc) massively outside the norm would fare? Even a budget holiday in Egypt for instance would drop from £800 per person to £350 per person. X 4 for 2 children and 2 adults and suddenly those school fees seem cheap....
(I assume theres some sort of reason behind this)
Edit - apparently this is allowed for free schools - they can have hols when you want.

Other schools 'feather' the holidays/half terms into normal term time which adds another week onto each side of the holiday.

So the holiday periods aren't as abrupt as maybe they could be - a step in the right direction IMHO - but there is still a gulf there admittedly...

Leemcd

246 posts

163 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Also, how much of an adverse affect can a week out of school have on say a 6 year old?? A week of no colouring in? World has gone mad IMHO!

aizvara

2,067 posts

198 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Mark. said:
Never ceases to amaze me that parents find it acceptable to moan about holiday prices and not being able to take kids out of school.

Think about it for half a second before slapping an unwrapped one up your misses.

You have kids, the rules say they must go to school so by default that means you need to take them out of school during the.....yes that's it school holiday!
Before you had your 30 seconds of pleasure you might have thought it through a bit - kids, that's an expense and they are going to have to go to school and holidays are going to be expensive. It's just the way it is.
Actually they don't have to go to school at all, and there's nothing stopping an independent school having atypical term times. Problem solved!

On the other hand, surely it is acceptable to have a good moan about stuff you're unwilling to do anything about? That's part of being British.

MitchT

17,167 posts

240 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
How much over the odds do the moaners have to pay for holidays and how does that weigh-up against the sprog-related tax breaks/benefits they get to claim, I wonder?

Mark.

11,104 posts

307 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
aizvara said:
Actually they don't have to go to school at all, and there's nothing stopping an independent school having atypical term times. Problem solved!

On the other hand, surely it is acceptable to have a good moan about stuff you're unwilling to do anything about? That's part of being British.
Quite, home educate them, then you'll have no job and won't be able to afford a holiday anyone as it'd be one lovely holiday colouring in with little Sky Flower Pot smile

Love a good moan us Brits biggrin

rsl430

Original Poster:

29 posts

242 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
rsl430 said:
Sorry, but am I the only one fuming over the school holiday pricing furore? As a forty something with grown up kids I never had anywhere near the benefits afforded to parents these days - extended maternity/paternity leave, family tax credits, subsidised child care etc. etc. Now they want holiday companies to cap prices during school holidays, which would inevitably mean price rises for the rest of the year - I should pay more for my holiday in September so that others with school age children can save money on a trip to Disneyland in August? What next - subsidised chocolate eggs at Easter, Xmas trees in December? It's supply and demand. Get used to it. Kids are expensive. Consider cutting back on the plasma tv's in every room, smart phones for all the family and a new Audi on the drive. Look back at the sacrifices parents had to make 20/30/40 years ago and realise that you've never had it so good. And on a positive note, lobby Mr Gove to stagger school holidays. This is the only workable solution and the travel industry would totally get behind it.
I'm sure they would. Instead of a six week period of ker-ching in the summer they'd have twelve weeks, or whatever the stagger period is.

Besides, travel is so educational, Tarquin and Jocasta will benefit so much more from their holiday than they would from being in school.


What's broken is the school holiday system, not the travel industry that is just responding to demand. The world is full of holiday resorts, many of them small operators that close for 2-3 months off season because no one wants to go there. In high season everyone wants to go there, and in between some people will risk unpredictable weather and some facilities not being open in return for lower fares. Prices reflect this. Is there any good reason why school holidays should come in three big chunks, including 6+ weeks in the summer, instead of spread over the year? We have many broken markets to complain about - banking, energy, supermarkets, television.. The travel industry is the least of our problems.

IanMorewood

4,309 posts

279 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
My kids went back today, some kids are off this week, some the week previous it would seem some staggering of holidays is already happening. Wouldn't surprise me if instead of one week being cheaper than the other the winter holiday companies haven't stuck 50%+ on the price of any holiday throughout February.

aizvara

2,067 posts

198 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Mark. said:
Quite, home educate them, then you'll have no job and won't be able to afford a holiday anyone as it'd be one lovely holiday colouring in with little Sky Flower Pot smile
Christ, don't tell everyone!