Thoughts on knock (with data ;))
Thoughts on knock (with data ;))
Author
Discussion

SturdyHSV

Original Poster:

10,443 posts

198 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Perhaps not the best PID selection, but any thoughts on the Knock? It seems to appear in 3/4 after discrepancies between CALC.CYLAIR and the MAF's reading.

The MAF will be taking priority here, so is it perhaps a little off? When logging without the MAF and with PE disabled, I don't get knock like this, hence me thinking MAF maybe?

It's a 13.25 1/4 from Santa Pod on Sunday, so 1st to 4th. ECT was around 100 throughout (3 runs with some queueing, not ideal temp at all) and IAT was around 17 (drops during the run but similar)

4 degrees pulled. Only revving to about 6.1k, waiting until my wideband is in and all tuned nicely before pushing it too much, want to be sure.



Also feel I should mention, if car is left to cool a bit, so ECT at 80 or so before the run, no knock at all. It's a slightly audible ping, to be honest it sounds more like dust / grit hitting the underside of the car almost, only really encounter it at the pod after queueing up etc...

Thanks for any input or criticism, I have loads to learn still, so be blunt and cut to the chase! smile

VinceM

1,906 posts

169 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
What does all this mean in English? confusedlaugh

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
VinceM said:
What does all this mean in English? confusedlaugh
+1 paperbag

SturdyHSV

Original Poster:

10,443 posts

198 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
I may be losing a little power when the engine is warm and risking damage to stuff.

Think it may be to do with the mass air flow sensor being slightly inaccurate after mods, but not sure as I don't know enough yet.

stick100

7,017 posts

199 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Ditch the maf

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
So where it pulls 4* or so. Looks around 4200rpm or near you should take 2* out using the area blend function.
That will take it from the area around as well, but not as much as the peak.

Dont worry about the little 2* one, though you could tap that down 1* if you wanted.

Then repeat and log and see how it goes.

Sounds like your maf airflow might not agree with your mafless flow if knock only occurs with maf.
They should be the same in theory.

SturdyHSV

Original Poster:

10,443 posts

198 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
stick100 said:
Ditch the maf
There is that, but I'm hardly pushing a lot of power? I'm seeing the MAF frequency hit 10900, I expect I'm losing accuracy up there?

stick100

7,017 posts

199 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
SturdyHSV said:
There is that, but I'm hardly pushing a lot of power? I'm seeing the MAF frequency hit 10900, I expect I'm losing accuracy up there?
Ringram knows loads more then me on subject then me but it doesn't look like its a accurate as it should be

SturdyHSV

Original Poster:

10,443 posts

198 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
stick100 said:
Ringram knows loads more then me on subject then me but it doesn't look like its a accurate as it should be
Not sure if the calc stuff is maybe off because of my VE table tuning (only using stfts so far, wideband going in soon) so don't want to jump to any conclusions.

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
I've never seen knock like that on a log. But there again, I ditched the maf pretty early on in proceedings. (LS2, E40, and cam)

gsd2000

11,515 posts

214 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
Could a dirty maf sensor be causing the discrepancy and knock?

Is the k&n filter over oiled?

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Monday 24th February 2014
quotequote all
gsd2000 said:
Could a dirty maf sensor be causing the discrepancy and knock?

Is the k&n filter over oiled?
Doesn't matter ditch it. Only something else to go wrong.

MadMaxHSV

1,816 posts

229 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Worth logging your fuel trims see what they're upto.
If the MAF is out of whack they should be compensating.
Wideband would help also...

MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
MadMaxHSV said:
Worth logging your fuel trims see what they're upto.
If the MAF is out of whack they should be compensating.
Wideband would help also...
If he wants to keep the maf, maybe recalibrate it?

SturdyHSV

Original Poster:

10,443 posts

198 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
MadMaxHSV said:
Worth logging your fuel trims see what they're upto.
If the MAF is out of whack they should be compensating.
Wideband would help also...
The STFTs are being logged, but it would have been open loop during this, so not a lot of use?

It does only seem to be something I get at the Pod, presumably due to all the heat in the engine from sitting around queueing so much before then giving it the beans?

I was thinking of perhaps trying to recalibrate the MAF, as much as ditching it sounds tempting. In your experience, do the signals from MAFs zig zag like that, or is mine perhaps to near the throttle body or some such? I've got an OTRCAI so naturally there aren't too many placement options...

MadMaxHSV

1,816 posts

229 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
MAF could be correct still, but without fuelling info (wideband or trims at least) you can't tell if its lean (for one reason or another) or running to much spark advance.

But yes MAF could be re-calibrated if it is skewing trims.



EmmaJ

4,525 posts

177 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Fit some batteries and a big leccy motor and use torque fill hehe

MadMaxHSV

1,816 posts

229 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
SturdyHSV said:
The STFTs are being logged, but it would have been open loop during this, so not a lot of use?
LTFTs are carried through to Open Loop, usually on the safe side. Are they on your log file? See what they show.

MadMaxHSV

1,816 posts

229 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
SturdyHSV said:
I've got an OTRCAI so naturally there aren't too many placement options...
This could be your problem. Technically any change in the air flow path for the MAF could need it to be recalibrated.

SturdyHSV

Original Poster:

10,443 posts

198 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
MadMaxHSV said:
LTFTs are carried through to Open Loop, usually on the safe side. Are they on your log file? See what they show.
I've turned those off so they won't be involved. I've got a wideband, just waiting for a friend to have a moment to get the bung welded on (I know, I could take it to an exhaust place). Naturally I'll know much more then, on a dyno the AFR looks good though, right around 13:1, sometimes dropping a little richer to 12.5.

I think perhaps it is the OTR changing the airflow characteristics and the MAF needing re-calibration ( or chucking in the skip, depending on your outlook hehe )

At the moment it feels like the MAF is at least a bit of a safety net in case the VE table isn't spot on, once I have the wideband I'll be getting the VE table dialled in properly and getting on with tuning the thing better!