Formal and informal chats with plod
Formal and informal chats with plod
Author
Discussion

Sexual Chocolate

Original Poster:

1,583 posts

175 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Right, lets say in an informal chat with the police you admit an offence. Several days past and in a formal chat with the police, under caution, you deny everything. What usually happens?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
First tell us what you have done.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
PS:-

https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal/a_to_c/confession_and...


The CPS said:
Section 76(2) PACE directs the court to exclude from the trial process, confession evidence which has been obtained either as: a result of oppression; or: In circumstances which were likely to make the confession unreliable.

Prosecutors should also note that where the admissibility of confession evidence is challenged under section 76 of PACE, the prosecution must establish beyond reasonable doubt that the confession was not in fact made as a result of oppression, nor in circumstances which were likely to have made it unreliable.

The term "Oppression" for the purposes of section 76 PACE includes "torture, inhuman or degrading treatment, and the use or threat of violence". This reflects the wording of Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The meaning of the term was also considered by the Court of Appeal in the case of R v Fulling 1987 2 All E.R. 65. The court held that "oppression" was to be given its ordinary dictionary meaning and was likely to involve some impropriety on the part of the interrogator.

Unreliable Confessions

Unreliable confessions were given a broad interpretation by the Court of Appeal in R v Fulling (above).

This included:

Confessions obtained as the result of an inducement - for example a promise of bail or a promise that a prosecution would not arise from the confession;
Hostile and aggressive questioning;
Failure to record accurately what was said;
Failure to caution;
Failure to provide an appropriate adult where one is required;
Failure to comply with the Code of Practice in relation to the detention of the accused - for example a failure to allow sufficient rest prior to an interview;
Failure of the Defence Solicitor or Appropriate Adult to act properly - for example by making interjections during interview which are hostile to the defendant. It is important that prosecutors take into consideration whether confessions can be adduced to be reliable or not by the Courts.
Edited by anonymous-user on Tuesday 25th February 16:30

Sexual Chocolate

Original Poster:

1,583 posts

175 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Breadvan72 said:
Makes no sense to me.

The wife had a run in with a local gamekeeper who threatened to shoot our dogs (dogs are trained to the gun) if he saw her on private land again however it wasn't private land it was a public footpath. Chap admitted to it in a informal chat with plod and said that he just said he wanted to scare her as he was concerned about his live stock(game birds - so not livestock). Wife pushed ahead and now he has denied all knowledge of any altercation between him and my Mrs.






dingg

4,569 posts

250 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
what was his offence - other than threatening to shoot your dogs??

is this a crime??

what would you like to see him charged with?


John145

2,847 posts

187 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
dingg said:
what was his offence - other than threatening to shoot your dogs??

is this a crime??

what would you like to see him charged with?
Sexual Chocolate said:
he just said he wanted to scare her
Sounds like an offence to me.

Sexual Chocolate

Original Poster:

1,583 posts

175 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
dingg said:
what was his offence - other than threatening to shoot your dogs??

is this a crime??

what would you like to see him charged with?
Public order offence section 4 i think. Using words, action or behaviour to cause distress to others. Something like that anyway.


Law says said:
The offence is created by section 4 of the Public Order Act 1986:
(1) A person is guilty of an offence if he -
(a) uses towards another person threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour, or
(b) distributes or displays to another person any writing, sign or other visible representation which is threatening, abusive or insulting,
with intent to cause that person to believe that immediate unlawful violence will be used against him or another by any person, or to provoke the immediate use of unlawful violence by that person or another, or whereby that person is likely to believe that such violence will be used or it is likely that such violence will be provoked.
I also know the guy and he has never said a word to me, just always used to smile and wave. Maybe he just likes to kick off on women. He is, and what is now becoming increasingly more common within the shooting fraternity, a thug in tweed.

Edited by Sexual Chocolate on Tuesday 25th February 17:04


Edited by Sexual Chocolate on Tuesday 25th February 17:05

dingg

4,569 posts

250 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
I reckon the informal chat will have had the desired result

ie he will calm down a bit now

why not just have a word yourself with him?

no need to try to give the man a criminal record for something so trivial , which if the CPS decided to prosecute (v doubtful) he'd probably be aquitted on anyway - all IMO btw

V8 Fettler

7,019 posts

163 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Shotgun licence probably needs to be withdrawn.

Randomthoughts

917 posts

164 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
V8 Fettler said:
Shotgun licence probably needs to be withdrawn.
This. Threatening to use your licenced weapons should result in an instant removal of the licence to hold them. At least if there is a degree of common sense involved.

Bill

58,913 posts

286 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Randomthoughts said:
This. Threatening to use your licenced weapons should result in an instant removal of the licence to hold them. At least if there is a degree of common sense involved.
It depends whether game birds constitute livestock, no? He's quite within his rights to protect livestock.

Council Scum

42 posts

153 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Bill said:
Randomthoughts said:
This. Threatening to use your licenced weapons should result in an instant removal of the licence to hold them. At least if there is a degree of common sense involved.
It depends whether game birds constitute livestock, no? He's quite within his rights to protect livestock.
Were the dogs on leads? Was the livestock in danger?




Bill

58,913 posts

286 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
Both good points. The gamekeeper could be justified, he may well not be.

73mark

774 posts

158 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
2 years or so ago. I a wild fowler out on the mud had a member of the publics dog run out and attack my dog. I walk back in and the woman whose dog it was phoned the police and said,I'd said. I was going to shoot her dog which I had not,but I did f and blind at her. I had my guns took away,went to the police station made a statement got a caution and my guns back




Ian Geary

5,651 posts

223 months

Tuesday 25th February 2014
quotequote all
So, in reply to the OP, using the CPS stuff posted by Breadvan, we can assume that an informal chat to the police could not be used as evidence in a prosecution because the officer would have demonstrated a:

Failure to record accurately what was said;
Failure to caution;



So, no doubt an awkward moment at the station when the failure to recall events accurately is made clear, but definitely an example of the less said, sooner mended.



Ian

Sexual Chocolate

Original Poster:

1,583 posts

175 months

Wednesday 26th February 2014
quotequote all
Bill said:
It depends whether game birds constitute livestock, no? He's quite within his rights to protect livestock.
Game birds are only conisdered livestock when in holding pens. Once released the are considered wild. There are no holding pens where she walked them.

Thanks for your reply Ian. I suspect this is why nothing much will happen.

jesta1865

3,453 posts

240 months

Wednesday 26th February 2014
quotequote all
dingg said:
what was his offence - other than threatening to shoot your dogs??

is this a crime??

what would you like to see him charged with?
depends if he had his gun on him, although no mention of it was made by the OP.

but the threat is wrong, especially if the dogs were on a lead and legally on the land.

elanfan

5,527 posts

258 months

Wednesday 26th February 2014
quotequote all
I think you should do 2 things - report the incident to the Police department responsible for the Firearms licence and secondly to the landowner - surely he would not want his gamekeeper associated with threatening the public with firearms??