Audi S3 Sportback - loud noises!!!
Discussion
Hi all,
first post here although have been an avid reader for quite some time - my decision to buy the S3 was actually based on what i had read here!
i have loved the audi from the minute i sat in her for the first time back in july and the novelty hasnt worn off one bit, in fact, i still find myself making excuses to take her out!!
recently, though, in the mornings and when i finish work, as soon as i set off there is a really unhealthy grinding noise coming from what i can only assume is the gearbox. obviously a lot more noticeable at low speeds, and seems to get worse once the clutch is engaged. once she starts warming up though, the sound disappears completely. and i mean COMPLETELY, then doesnt reappear until shes cold again.
anyone experienced anything similar, or know what the problem might be? im preparing myself for worst case scenario, based on the fact it sounds like an expensive problem!
thanks in advance,
J
first post here although have been an avid reader for quite some time - my decision to buy the S3 was actually based on what i had read here!
i have loved the audi from the minute i sat in her for the first time back in july and the novelty hasnt worn off one bit, in fact, i still find myself making excuses to take her out!!
recently, though, in the mornings and when i finish work, as soon as i set off there is a really unhealthy grinding noise coming from what i can only assume is the gearbox. obviously a lot more noticeable at low speeds, and seems to get worse once the clutch is engaged. once she starts warming up though, the sound disappears completely. and i mean COMPLETELY, then doesnt reappear until shes cold again.
anyone experienced anything similar, or know what the problem might be? im preparing myself for worst case scenario, based on the fact it sounds like an expensive problem!
thanks in advance,
J
OK, diagnosing noises via the internet never works particularly well. Even on cars with a common fault the noise consensus thinks it is can pop up somewhere completely different.
If you're worried about it; get the car to someone that knows what they're doing and get a proper diagnosis.
In terms of systems that 'warm' on an S3 it could be the gearbox mechatronics, haldex clutch, power steering, flywheel... How many miles has the car done and have all the relevant fluid changes been done on time?
If you're worried about it; get the car to someone that knows what they're doing and get a proper diagnosis.
In terms of systems that 'warm' on an S3 it could be the gearbox mechatronics, haldex clutch, power steering, flywheel... How many miles has the car done and have all the relevant fluid changes been done on time?
cheapest quote for running diagnostics on gearbox so far was 350 so i was worried you might say that!!
does what i am saying make sense though? is it common for a problem/noise to just disappear after a miles driving? also, it doesnt feel any different whatsoever, no loss of power, clunky gears etc, its just that noise.
Yes to fluids etc. - as far as i have been led to believe after having bought the car in august - full service the week i bought it, FSH provided as well. done 8k since so due for a service soon.
does what i am saying make sense though? is it common for a problem/noise to just disappear after a miles driving? also, it doesnt feel any different whatsoever, no loss of power, clunky gears etc, its just that noise.
Yes to fluids etc. - as far as i have been led to believe after having bought the car in august - full service the week i bought it, FSH provided as well. done 8k since so due for a service soon.
How many miles has the car done? Has the gearbox oil been changed and on time? Has the Haldex oil been changed and on time? The interval for these is 38,000 miles.
£350 for a diagnostic sounds mad unless they're taking the gearbox out. We charge an hour's labour and find 80+% of faults within that time.
£350 for a diagnostic sounds mad unless they're taking the gearbox out. We charge an hour's labour and find 80+% of faults within that time.
How many miles has the car covered now? 41? 141?
If it's just crept past 40k the late oil changes are unlikely to cause a problem. If it's on 90 and never had box or diff oil you may well be looking at the case.
'Work' is based in Bucks but email me if you wanted to ask a work question. I don't want to step on forum rules.
Who has quoted you to take the gearbox out? If it's a dealer or known specialist there's probably little point in someone else repeating the work they've already done. If the car's at a 'Mr Clutch' you'd be well advised to seek out a more qualified opinion (there are a lot of fiddly jobs and specialist tools for S-Tronic boxes).
If it's just crept past 40k the late oil changes are unlikely to cause a problem. If it's on 90 and never had box or diff oil you may well be looking at the case.
'Work' is based in Bucks but email me if you wanted to ask a work question. I don't want to step on forum rules.
Who has quoted you to take the gearbox out? If it's a dealer or known specialist there's probably little point in someone else repeating the work they've already done. If the car's at a 'Mr Clutch' you'd be well advised to seek out a more qualified opinion (there are a lot of fiddly jobs and specialist tools for S-Tronic boxes).
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


