Minor collision, other driver on phone, worth pursuing?
Minor collision, other driver on phone, worth pursuing?
Author
Discussion

DickyC

Original Poster:

58,922 posts

229 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
Last night driving up a spiral ramp in a multi storey car park, a woman coming down was on her phone, over the line, startled to see me, swerved but scraped my rear door, wheel arch and wheel. No visible damage to her car. No witnesses. I observed she was on the phone and she said sharply, "I was putting it down." My insurance rang her and she answered - as she was driving home - that we had simply met in the middle. She would not admit guilt and as far as she is concerned it's 50:50.

I know the time of the collision within a minute or two and, if the Police were interested, they could prove she was on the phone there and while driving home.

Worth doing? Or bite the bullet and not pursue it?

It's not badly damaged and I have protected No Claims; it's more to do with the principle.

Had we met in the middle, as she suggested, she wouldn't have hit me amidships, both offside fronts would have collided.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
Have you contacted the car park with regards CCTV? They should be obliged to provide footage which includes you and they cannot hide behind the DPA to refuse where likely or actual proceedings require it.

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
Have you informed your own insurance company of this? What's their view?

DickyC

Original Poster:

58,922 posts

229 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
Have you contacted the car park with regards CCTV? They should be obliged to provide footage which includes you and they cannot hide behind the DPA to refuse where likely or actual proceedings require it.
Yes, did that. No CCTV on the ramp itself, sadly. There was a car behind the car that collided with me but the driver's view was obscured by the central pillar of the spiral.

Typically, I have been debating whether to buy a dash cam and hadn't got around to it rolleyes

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
Your word against hers. The Police won't bother with tracing calls for a minor insurance bingle, even if you could prove the exact time to the second.

If she was pulling over the GW line, though, that's going to be harder for her to argue.

Just hand it to your insurance, put the bit about the phone and her reply in your statement, and get on with life.

DickyC

Original Poster:

58,922 posts

229 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
james_tigerwoods said:
Have you informed your own insurance company of this? What's their view?
Speaking to them within five minutes. They agreed with me, particularly as the scrape starts in the middle of my car, but can't move if she doesn't admit responsibility.

DickyC

Original Poster:

58,922 posts

229 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
Your word against hers. The Police won't bother with tracing calls for a minor insurance bingle, even if you could prove the exact time to the second.

If she was pulling over the GW line, though, that's going to be harder for her to argue.

Just hand it to your insurance, put the bit about the phone and her reply in your statement, and get on with life.
Judging by the conversations I was having last evening, the insurance will take the easiest route too.

It wouldn't take too many hours chasing her to make the pursuit uneconomical.

A900ss

3,314 posts

183 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
If she admits its 50:50 then pay for your car yourself then pursue 50% of your costs from her insurance company direct.

Be aware that she can pursue 50% of her costs from you as well, however if her costs are zero (non damage), 50% of zero is zero.

Good luck.

Edited by A900ss on Friday 28th February 14:47

Alfa numeric

3,169 posts

210 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
DickyC said:
I have protected No Claims; it's more to do with the principle.
Protected No Claims or not, if you have a claim on your record your premium will go up next time.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
DickyC said:
but can't move if she doesn't admit responsibility.
Of course they can.

All it takes is her insurer to agree with them, and it's a done-deal, no matter what she herself says.
If her insurer also disagree, then if the payout was big enough it might be worth taking to court, but...

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
DickyC said:
My insurance rang her and she answered .
No they didn't. Don't let that ruin your story though.

That's my only comment.

nipsips

1,167 posts

166 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
Your insurer wouldn't have contacted her direct. Especially with regards to liability.

Your insurer would have put your allegations direct to her insurer who would then contact her, establish her version of events and then go from there.

If shes saying you met in the middle its likely to go 50/50. The phone evidence maybe something however you need solid proof - which if she wasn't prosecuted at the scene then its unlikely to go anywhere and even then you would need to prove her being on the phone caused the accident - neither of which you can do. If there is no CCTV of the actual accident itself you are onto a losing path I'm afraid!

TwigtheWonderkid

49,270 posts

181 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
Alfa numeric said:
Protected No Claims or not, if you have a claim on your record your premium will go up next time.
"Might go up", not "will go up". You have no idea who the insurer is and how the calculate premiums.

AREA

497 posts

256 months

Friday 28th February 2014
quotequote all
DickyC said:
...spiral ramp... scraped my rear door, wheel arch and wheel...

Had we met in the middle, as she suggested, she wouldn't have hit me amidships, both offside fronts would have collided.
Spot on. Don't settle for 50/50, this will count against you in the future.

Go for no fault. On your points above you should be able to make a water tight case.

DickyC

Original Poster:

58,922 posts

229 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks one and all.

Plenty to ponder there.

Jon1967x

8,205 posts

155 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Might go up...

Might go down

Your point would be more accurate if you said it will almost certainly be the same or higher than it would have been without the claim.

I've had a no fault claim and it came down the following year. The effect of the driver bring older, the car being worth less etc all play a part plus changes to their rating algorithms. Might be pedantic but it's more accurate. The same argument rages in here all the time regarding speeding convictions and speed awareness course

OP I'm afraid there's prob not a lot you can do other than 50/50 as it's not worth the bother to anyone excerpt you.

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
What I find conflicting is that if there was an accident with an offender on the phone and the police had been in attendance, then they would probably pursue the phone angle.....

Wouldn't they?

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
james_tigerwoods said:
What I find conflicting is that if there was an accident with an offender on the phone and the police had been in attendance, then they would probably pursue the phone angle.....

Wouldn't they?
Possibly. I'd be inclined to report it to the Police; if they don't take it forwards then it's no big problem, but if they do have a quiet afternoon and decide to look into it you're going to have a much easier argument with the insurers.

Zeeky

2,954 posts

243 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
The offence of using the phone applies when on a road. Whether or not the ramp in the car park is a road is a matter of fact but if the Police are aware that the offence applies only to roads they might not be interested in use in a car park. I am also not convinced that driving over the centre of the ramp is an obvious inference that can be made from being on the phone.

Flibble

6,538 posts

212 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
Car parks that are open to the public count as roads for motoring offence purposes. All the police would have done is given her a fixed penalty though and with only after the fact reporting all they'll do is have a word at best.