Sensible sentencing
Author
Discussion

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,023 posts

279 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
I was involved in a case of shoplifting. A woman committed three offences whilst on bail. She'd broken up with her boyfriend who'd left her with some debts. I nicked her for her penultimate offence, a total of about £20, most of it edible but some clothing. She was on bail so she was kept in custody for court and then bailed again.

Next time she moved to the MPD and got caught again, this time nicking waterproof and cold weather clothing for her to wear. This time she was remanded in custody. I turned up for the court case in case it went for a NG trial but she pleaded.

The total she was charged with was around £125, although there were a few TICs.

She got 3 months, although she'd spent a month on remand.

So compare that with this:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-ord...

Slightly different of course as it is not theft, although the judge reckons it was a case of money, some £75,000, being stolen from taxpayers.

The shoplifter was told that stealing clothes was a selfish act as she could have gone to a charity.

Edited by Derek Smith on Saturday 1st March 09:49

CoolHands

23,709 posts

226 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
I love it when things like epilepsy come into it. "Oh sorry I was criminal but I stubbed my big toe at the weekend..." + she denied it all!

I reckon she was spared cos she looks a bit posh totty

Derek Smith

Original Poster:

50,023 posts

279 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
CoolHands said:
I love it when things like epilepsy come into it. "Oh sorry I was criminal but I stubbed my big toe at the weekend..." + she denied it all!

I reckon she was spared cos she looks a bit posh totty
The shoplifter was just as attractive, common, and of mixed race.

She was a bit of a wimp but, according to her, he boyfriend had left her with his debts and she had no one to go to. A few years ago my younger daughter's partner got himself into financial trouble, used my daughter's credit card to the max and then cleared off. So I sympathise with the shoplifter.

The Met officer in charge of the final case had brought someone along to help her, not expecting a custodial. It was evident that had she looked for help she'd have had most of her problems solved.

Mind you, she didn't win £235k in compensation for being upset, nor did she have any capital she could convert.

£75,000 over a period of years, and pleading not guilty.

Makes me feel I did a good job with the shoplifter.

I was told by a detective sergeant who was a bit of a role model for me that the police should present evidence and then leave it at that. But this case is wrong.

Zeeky

2,954 posts

243 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
The two cases are incomparable unless the first example involved epilepsy or another illness as it is the illness that led to the suspended sentence in the second example.

carinaman

25,298 posts

203 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
Thought provoking post.