F.a.o Legal People. Opinions on this statement please
F.a.o Legal People. Opinions on this statement please
Author
Discussion

sim16v

Original Poster:

2,177 posts

232 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
Basically I was the victim of a break in at my lockup a couple of years ago, and i've been monitoring the interweb since.

I've found a few items and the police have recovered them, and I hope to get them back eventually.


Anyway, to the point, I would like a legal opinion on this statement if possible.

Thanks.

"As for stolen goods if the person whom has bought them pays ‘fair value’ ie similar to what they are worth, then they still remain stolen goods but the buyer has a right in law to have a claim over them. For example when people buy cars that have been stolen but paid fair value, they have a right to challenge the ownership of the vehicle as they have bought the vehicle in good faith."

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
My understanding is that legal title never passed to them, in which case it's irrelevant whether they bought in good faith or otherwise. Their course of action is against the scroate what sold 'em the contraband.

XCP

17,761 posts

259 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
Police Property Act if it is recovered and ownership is disputed. Civil case at Mags court.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
Search for the Nemo dat rule...

340600

610 posts

174 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
My understanding is that legal title never passed to them, in which case it's irrelevant whether they bought in good faith or otherwise. Their course of action is against the scroate what sold 'em the contraband.
This is correct. More often than not the person who loses out the most is the one who bought the property in good faith.

craigjm

21,700 posts

231 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
My understanding is that legal title never passed to them, in which case it's irrelevant whether they bought in good faith or otherwise. Their course of action is against the scroate what sold 'em the contraband.
exactly

Mk3Spitfire

2,921 posts

159 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
The "fair value" is more to reduce the likelihood of an innocent party being liable to prosecution. It shows that they are less likely to be a part of the theft or handling of the stolen goods. Stolen cars get recovered from innocent buyers all the time.

sim16v

Original Poster:

2,177 posts

232 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies, exactly as I thought.

It's bloody frustrating, that is one of the replies from the policeman originally dealing with the case.

Basically he doesn't want to go and get the latest bits i've found.