Insurance Repair advice needed
Insurance Repair advice needed
Author
Discussion

H5V VE

Original Poster:

615 posts

234 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
So, not the best of days today.

Someone has decided to remodel the front of my VXR8 - and - despite people thinking that could only be a good thing on a VXR8 :-) - it really hasnt done it any favours.

It was a pretty low speed impact because I was stationary at the time but the front bumper is completely mullered, right hand light cluster and fogs have had it, there is a BIG panel gap between the wing and the edge of the bonnet now - I think that its the wing that has had it rather than the bonnet, bumper has been pushed back to foul the wheel and its pouring coolant out of the bottom somewhere - AND, its destroyed my Walkinshaw fog light covers - which has really pissed me off because there is a fat chance of getting a new set :-(

The question is, what is the best bet for repairs? The insurers approved repairer, take it to Vx, or get a specialist to have a look? Given that it seems to be a combination of bodywork and mechanical (dead rad plus whatever else given the intercooler etc at the front) I am unsure of the best route there.

Any advice welcome.

Phil

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
Really sorry to hear, Phil. frown

From personal experience, do not use the insurance company's approved repairer. I don't know anyone that specialises in the repair of our cars.

It took us five months, so really hope you manage to do better.

H5V VE

Original Poster:

615 posts

234 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
Oh dear

What was the issue with the approved repairer?

mik_ok

1,580 posts

272 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
Sorry to hear this : similar happened to me when my Hawkeye WRX was about 9m old ; an XC90 went into reverse at a set of lights and smacked straight into me. Not a scratch on his car. £4500 damage to mine.

Where in the country are you?

H5V VE

Original Poster:

615 posts

234 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
mik_ok said:
Sorry to hear this : similar happened to me when my Hawkeye WRX was about 9m old ; an XC90 went into reverse at a set of lights and smacked straight into me. Not a scratch on his car. £4500 damage to mine.

Where in the country are you?
Ouch

I'm in Berkshire - just south of Reading.

If its going to cost that sort of money, at what point does it become uneconomic to repair?

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
H5V VE said:
Oh dear

What was the issue with the approved repairer?
Let's just say the shine went off ownership. I'll let you know details if you PM me, but won't revisit here, under the name and shame rules.

I will say that Dougie did his best to help. You may also want to PM Liam1986, as his car was fixed at Motorbodies Luton. His accident was after mine, and the car was repaired before ours was finished.

mik_ok

1,580 posts

272 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
I think the rear bumper on the VXR8 is the really expensive one (?)

I have a friend in Weston SuperMare with both mechanical and (superb) bodywork skills ( owns his own place).

H5V VE

Original Poster:

615 posts

234 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the info so far.

Given that I was stationary at the time, I rather hope that it will not be my NCD that takes the hit on this one and I shall be holding out for a decent repair job.

Hopefully it wont take too long.

r8black

1,405 posts

160 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
Sounds like a write off mate mine had less damage and I was quoted £15000 by Vx dealer,
Managed to do a deal with insurance company and bought second hand parts and used local garages had her back on the road for less than£6000 they agreed not to write it off.


H5V VE

Original Poster:

615 posts

234 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
r8black said:
Sounds like a write off mate mine had less damage and I was quoted £15000 by Vx dealer,
Managed to do a deal with insurance company and bought second hand parts and used local garages had her back on the road for less than£6000 they agreed not to write it off.
What?

F*(ck me - £15K? Even assuming a new bumper, wing and lights, i cant see how it would get even close to that?

r8black

1,405 posts

160 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
From memory a new wing is £2300 front bumper was £ 2400 headlight £400 side skirt £1800 now you can see how the bits on these cars. Add up but maybe you'll be lucky

H5V VE

Original Poster:

615 posts

234 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
r8black said:
From memory a new wing is £2300 front bumper was £ 2400 headlight £400 side skirt £1800 now you can see how the bits on these cars. Add up but maybe you'll be lucky
My word.

£2300 for a front wing? I assumed that you had misplaced the decimal point for a minute :-)

Oh dear - this really isnt looking very promising at all.

r8black

1,405 posts

160 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
I think a I paid £900 for an 8 year old wing that neede some repair also

H5V VE

Original Poster:

615 posts

234 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Its being collected for repair on Thursday so we will see what the estimate comes in at.

Doesnt look too bad from a distance but that new panel gap worries me








EmmaJ

4,525 posts

177 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Those are shocking prices if correct. I thought Monaro parts were expensive but given the numbers of VXR8 brought in you'd think parts would be a lot cheaper than that!

Sorry to hear about the accident Phil hope it's a quick repair. Have you gone via a AMC, if so what have they put you in? Something tasty I hope smile

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
EmmaJ said:
Those are shocking prices if correct. I thought Monaro parts were expensive but given the numbers of VXR8 brought in you'd think parts would be a lot cheaper than that!

Sorry to hear about the accident Phil hope it's a quick repair. Have you gone via a AMC, if so what have they put you in? Something tasty I hope smile
There are more Monaros than VXR8s. The expensive panels for both, are the ones that are unique to HSV. If a Monaro can be fixed with Holden CV8 parts (or a VXR8 with Commodore parts), then they are significantly cheaper.

raving

1,183 posts

221 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
r8black said:
From memory a new wing is £2300 front bumper was £ 2400 headlight £400 side skirt £1800 now you can see how the bits on these cars. Add up but maybe you'll be lucky
All those prices less the headlight are incorrect

Sent you a pm Phil

H5V VE

Original Poster:

615 posts

234 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
EmmaJ said:
Those are shocking prices if correct. I thought Monaro parts were expensive but given the numbers of VXR8 brought in you'd think parts would be a lot cheaper than that!

Sorry to hear about the accident Phil hope it's a quick repair. Have you gone via a AMC, if so what have they put you in? Something tasty I hope smile
The insurance company did try and push me through an AMC but, in all conscience, I cant justify a replacement - for 2 reasons. Firstly, I cycle to the station during the week, and I still have the GTS for 5 seats and the weekend. Secondly, until I know what the quote is looking like, I really dont want to push up the costs towards write off territory.

Somewhat bizarrely, it would appear that my policy entitles me to a courtesy car anyway while mine is being repaired to the AMC trying to get me a hire car is a waste of someones money anyway.

Cant argue about how outrageous those prices are though. (Although i think that the bumper is way cheaper than that for the front)

r8black

1,405 posts

160 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Al these prices were correct from a vxr dealer yes there are cheaper used parts available but must insurance company's
Will not use them speed4u does a good used parts service rearly nice man to do business
With

r8black

1,405 posts

160 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
H5V VE said:
EmmaJ said:
Those are shocking prices if correct. I thought Monaro parts were expensive but given the numbers of VXR8 brought in you'd think parts would be a lot cheaper than that!

Sorry to hear about the accident Phil hope it's a quick repair. Have you gone via a AMC, if so what have they put you in? Something tasty I hope smile
The insurance company did try and push me through an AMC but, in all conscience, I cant justify a replacement - for 2 reasons. Firstly, I cycle to the station during the week, and I still have the GTS for 5 seats and the weekend. Secondly, until I know what the quote is looking like, I really dont want to push up the costs towards write off territory.

Somewhat bizarrely, it would appear that my policy entitles me to a courtesy car anyway while mine is being repaired to the AMC trying to get me a hire car is a waste of someones money anyway.

Cant argue about how outrageous those prices are though. (Although i think that the bumper is way cheaper than that for the front)
They're painted and fitted costs