House Insurance Question
Discussion
Hi folks,
Not sure if SP&L is the right forum for this. Mods please feel free to move if necessary.
MIL's house was flooded a few weeks ago. She suffered a modest amount of damage (a couple of electrical appliances lost the will to live, and the carpets were knackered - probably about 5K in total), but has contents insurance to the tune of 85K so all appeared to be well.
Loss adjuster rocked up a couple of days ago and told MIL that - in his opinion - she appears to be under-insured for the value of the house's contents, and that as a consequence her claim may be denied.
I know very little about such matters, but this seemed a bit odd to me. I would have thought that the amount insured placed a maximum on the value of any claim, and that if she chose to under-insure herself then that's her problem. I haven't seen the small print of her policy, but I can't see any justification for refusing a claim (in circumstances where the amount claimed falls far below the amount insured) because she didn't place the right value on her possessions.
Can anyone shed any light on this? Is there really a risk her claim might be refused? MIL is admittedly as mad as a box of frogs, so she could just be making this up, but SWMBO is concerned on her behalf.
Thanks in advance for any assistance.
Not sure if SP&L is the right forum for this. Mods please feel free to move if necessary.
MIL's house was flooded a few weeks ago. She suffered a modest amount of damage (a couple of electrical appliances lost the will to live, and the carpets were knackered - probably about 5K in total), but has contents insurance to the tune of 85K so all appeared to be well.
Loss adjuster rocked up a couple of days ago and told MIL that - in his opinion - she appears to be under-insured for the value of the house's contents, and that as a consequence her claim may be denied.
I know very little about such matters, but this seemed a bit odd to me. I would have thought that the amount insured placed a maximum on the value of any claim, and that if she chose to under-insure herself then that's her problem. I haven't seen the small print of her policy, but I can't see any justification for refusing a claim (in circumstances where the amount claimed falls far below the amount insured) because she didn't place the right value on her possessions.
Can anyone shed any light on this? Is there really a risk her claim might be refused? MIL is admittedly as mad as a box of frogs, so she could just be making this up, but SWMBO is concerned on her behalf.
Thanks in advance for any assistance.
Thanks for the responses.
The house is a 4 bed detached house, but MIL has a fair bit of jewelry hence the apparently high amount insured. The problem with the loss adjuster appears to have arisen because the adjuster is saying that various bits of furniture (which aren't being claimed for) are "high value antiques", whereas MIL says she bought them for peanuts in auctions 40+ years ago and hence they have little value in her eyes!
Thanks for the link to the ombudsman's pages, but this seems to relate (primarily) to circumstances where "the "sum insured" - is not enough to cover the full value of the claim" - although there is a mention of insurers trying to void policies from their inception.....which is worrying but I guess (hope?) quite unusual.
The house is a 4 bed detached house, but MIL has a fair bit of jewelry hence the apparently high amount insured. The problem with the loss adjuster appears to have arisen because the adjuster is saying that various bits of furniture (which aren't being claimed for) are "high value antiques", whereas MIL says she bought them for peanuts in auctions 40+ years ago and hence they have little value in her eyes!
Thanks for the link to the ombudsman's pages, but this seems to relate (primarily) to circumstances where "the "sum insured" - is not enough to cover the full value of the claim" - although there is a mention of insurers trying to void policies from their inception.....which is worrying but I guess (hope?) quite unusual.
Hungry Pigeon said:
The problem with the loss adjuster appears to have arisen because the adjuster is saying that various bits of furniture (which aren't being claimed for) are "high value antiques", whereas MIL says she bought them for peanuts in auctions 40+ years ago and hence they have little value in her eyes!
That sounds like sharp practice. Is it a well-known firm?Very few pieces of furniture are worth serious money. It would cost more to make new versions of most "antique" furniture.
NPI said:
That sounds like sharp practice. Is it a well-known firm?
Very few pieces of furniture are worth serious money. It would cost more to make new versions of most "antique" furniture.
I don't know which firm it is, but knowing the MIL I would have expected her to insure with someone "off the telly" (in the absence of John Lewis doing contents insurance), and hence it's fair to assume they are well known.Very few pieces of furniture are worth serious money. It would cost more to make new versions of most "antique" furniture.
I think that most of the furniture is probably on the grotty side of tat. If the insurance company take this further I'll probably get a valuer in to give us a price.
That makes for scary reading. I wonder if the average clause works the other way? (yeah right...)
I purchased our contents insurance based on how much I think it would cost to replace everything, as a guestimate. I would have expected that this would set a maximum rather than be used as a stick to beat down any payment in respect of a claim!
I've purchased contents insurance twice and not once been told about that devious clause... Thanks for OP!
And good luck with your claim.
I purchased our contents insurance based on how much I think it would cost to replace everything, as a guestimate. I would have expected that this would set a maximum rather than be used as a stick to beat down any payment in respect of a claim!
I've purchased contents insurance twice and not once been told about that devious clause... Thanks for OP!
And good luck with your claim.
Snowboy said:
This is a guess;
But if the chair is an antique worth £800 but she is happy with a replacemt £50 IKEA chair, then she ok to insure it for £50.
She just wants a chair - she doesn't care if it's antique.
I'd agree that that seems entirely logical! By analogy, if you have a Ferrari 458 but you chose to insure it for a replacement value of 25K, then it's your tough titty if you prang it and it's written off. It would seem odd to refuse to pay out anything simply because you chose to insure your possession for less than it was actually worth - especially when you're not seeking the full replacement value of that possession!But if the chair is an antique worth £800 but she is happy with a replacemt £50 IKEA chair, then she ok to insure it for £50.
She just wants a chair - she doesn't care if it's antique.
surveyor said:
The way that I understood it, was that if you were under-insured the payout was reduced by the % that you were under-insured by.
So if cover should have been £150k, but you only had £75k then the payout would be reduced by 50%.
Things may have changed.
Correct, and it's called "applying average". Only fair really. If you have £150K of stuff and only insure for £75K, then if £20K is damaged it's only fair to assume half of that was covered and you'll get £10K. You can't say "I only insured half my stuff but luckily for me, all the stuff that was damaged was insured."So if cover should have been £150k, but you only had £75k then the payout would be reduced by 50%.
Things may have changed.
Hungry Pigeon said:
I don't know which firm it is, but knowing the MIL I would have expected her to insure with someone "off the telly" (in the absence of John Lewis doing contents insurance), and hence it's fair to assume they are well known.
JohnLewis does do contents insurance, although I had an issue with them on travel insurance regarding the scope of cover which they resolved by refunding me even after we'd travelled. Basically they told me to f off.Hungry Pigeon said:
I think that most of the furniture is probably on the grotty side of tat. If the insurance company take this further I'll probably get a valuer in to give us a price.
Who knows what hidden treasures she's got, but the chances of an average valuer spotting a "high value antique" must be pretty remote.TwigtheWonderkid said:
Correct, and it's called "applying average". Only fair really. If you have £150K of stuff and only insure for £75K, then if £20K is damaged it's only fair to assume half of that was covered and you'll get £10K. You can't say "I only insured half my stuff but luckily for me, all the stuff that was damaged was insured."
Thanks Twig (and Surveyor, earlier). I had no idea that they can do this. I always thought that the sum insured was just a maximum they'd pay out. Ho hum...guess I'll be revisiting our own insurance policy ASAP.Edited by Hungry Pigeon on Monday 3rd March 12:09
I had this issue.
My shed was broken into and they sent a form wanting a list of EVERY ITEM in the house down to cutlery !
On a new for old policy it's surprising how these things add up
I said I'd be happy to sell you everything in my house for the £20k I was insured for but as previous posters have pointed out that appears not to be the point (which is ridiculous)
In response I removed high value items from the house - so it became a non issue.
I'm sure a friendly valuer could do similar in your case
My shed was broken into and they sent a form wanting a list of EVERY ITEM in the house down to cutlery !
On a new for old policy it's surprising how these things add up
I said I'd be happy to sell you everything in my house for the £20k I was insured for but as previous posters have pointed out that appears not to be the point (which is ridiculous)
In response I removed high value items from the house - so it became a non issue.
I'm sure a friendly valuer could do similar in your case
V8RX7 said:
I had this issue.
I said I'd be happy to sell you everything in my house for the £20k I was insured for but as previous posters have pointed out that appears not to be the point (which is ridiculous)
It isn't ridiculous, it's only right. Most people have a new for old policy. So the sum insured needs to reflect the new replacement cost. If you don't want to do that, you can take out an indemnity policy that doesn't give new for old cover. Your sum insured will then be the actual value of all the stuff in your house, 2nd hand prices. But don't start moaning when your 3 y/old tv gets nicked and they offer you £100 when it's going to cost you £700 to go out and replace it. Unless you want to be trawling ebay for a 3 y/o replacement set.I said I'd be happy to sell you everything in my house for the £20k I was insured for but as previous posters have pointed out that appears not to be the point (which is ridiculous)
Couldn't the amount of jewellery (especially if worth over £85k) represent a far greater risk in terms of likelihood of burglary, accidental damage, etc, i.e. it's not sufficient to simply say "oh I'll just get half the value back if it comes to it" when the risk simply from the total value existing in the property being so much higher makes the risk too great for the insurers? At the very least it would probably make the premium being paid too low.
Kinda seems to me like only insuring the doors on a supercar (if such a thing were possible) and saying "I'll deal with the rest if it comes to it"
Then again that might just be an extremely tortured analogy from a clueless guy.
Kinda seems to me like only insuring the doors on a supercar (if such a thing were possible) and saying "I'll deal with the rest if it comes to it"
Then again that might just be an extremely tortured analogy from a clueless guy.

Edited by Durzel on Monday 3rd March 13:06
TwigtheWonderkid said:
V8RX7 said:
I had this issue.
I said I'd be happy to sell you everything in my house for the £20k I was insured for but as previous posters have pointed out that appears not to be the point (which is ridiculous)
It isn't ridiculous, it's only right. Most people have a new for old policy. So the sum insured needs to reflect the new replacement cost. If you don't want to do that, you can take out an indemnity policy that doesn't give new for old cover. Your sum insured will then be the actual value of all the stuff in your house, 2nd hand prices. But don't start moaning when your 3 y/old tv gets nicked and they offer you £100 when it's going to cost you £700 to go out and replace it. Unless you want to be trawling ebay for a 3 y/o replacement set.I said I'd be happy to sell you everything in my house for the £20k I was insured for but as previous posters have pointed out that appears not to be the point (which is ridiculous)
Similarly I recently built my house.
It cost me £120k and a year. I wanted to insure it for £170k but was told that wasn't enough as they estimated it would cost £350k - the fact that I'd JUST BUILT IT seemed lost on them.
V8RX7 said:
I specifically asked for a set amount of cover £20k - that was the price I was more than happy to accept and I paid the premiums accordingly.
Similarly I recently built my house.
It cost me £120k and a year. I wanted to insure it for £170k but was told that wasn't enough as they estimated it would cost £350k - the fact that I'd JUST BUILT IT seemed lost on them.
Mine is with LV=. They have a default £1M of building cover and the contents is the same price from anything to (I think) £65K except that once you get over £50K they start imposing terms like the windows must be locked when you're out.Similarly I recently built my house.
It cost me £120k and a year. I wanted to insure it for £170k but was told that wasn't enough as they estimated it would cost £350k - the fact that I'd JUST BUILT IT seemed lost on them.
I find clothes the hardest thing to value and in reality if they got destroyed it'd be doing most people a favour!
V8RX7 said:
I specifically asked for a set amount of cover £20k - that was the price I was more than happy to accept and I paid the premiums accordingly.
But did you ask them for an indemnity policy. If you took out a new for old policy, they would assume that £20K is the cost to replace everything as new.Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


