It's ok to see off roaders on the road.
It's ok to see off roaders on the road.
Author
Discussion

Madkat

Original Poster:

1,147 posts

201 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
I'm thinking of trying a different vehicle to my usual hot hatch choice. A 4x4. The roads around here are so broken beaten and scarred (thanks Metallica) and scattered with disintegrating speed bumps that something with a generous tyre profile 15>mm tread blocks and forgivving grippy suspension is more at home on roads that no kidding are rougher than some Forrest tracks i've been down.

As such i've changed my perspective of 4x4 drivers. At least not the affluent pretentious types. From driving stupid unnecessary heavy vehicles to actually being quite sensible. Although i will not extend that to soft roaders. having previously driven a Ford ranger (that was horrible) and a freelander MK1 i'm prepared to give them a go and be ready expect some fairly major differences to ridiculously taught hot hatches with planks of wood for suspension.

I'm thinking A Pajero or more likely a Shogun SWB would be up my street as i like the look of them and don't want anything too big yet i would still like to retain a decent level of pace (all things relative of course). I would like something that is reasonably firmly sprung for a 4x4 so i can make differences with tyre pressure if i feel the need. maybe i should take up off-roading as a hobby then.

andy-xr

13,204 posts

233 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
One of my neighbours picked up a Hilux Surf and it was one of the most comfortable vehicles i've ever been in. He got a Jeep Grand Cherokee after that and it was alright, not quite as nice but plenty of toys and it wasnt uncomfortable. Didnt really feel much from the roads in either

richs2891

906 posts

282 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Depends where you live, I live in the stick and see lots of most different makes every day an its looks perfectly normal to me, but in the centre of town, can be a bit big and cumbersome.
Be prepared for the fact that a proper off roader such as the pajero you have mentioned wont have particularly good road manners, a swb pajero especially can be more than a bit choppy and a little tail happy in the wet at round abouts. Had one, got a lwb which is better but is certainly not a Range Rover comfort wise. But is a relaxed driving experience
Unless you need the extra bits a that a true off roader gives, then stick with a cross over, BMW X3 and X5 cover most bases, drive well, Image problem - well maybe if you care about that.
The LR products do both the on road and off road manner probably best - but reliability is not their strong point and just plain expensive.
Toyota Landcruiser if can stomach the purchase price would be a v good choice in my eyes

Spare tyre

12,558 posts

159 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
ive changed from fast cars for fun, to silly little 4x4s

im on my second jimny now and its great, wish i'd discovered them when i was 17, would have save a load of near misses, scrapes and wasted money on ridiculous insurance trying to keep up with my mates

Censorious

15,169 posts

263 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
We had a MkI Freelander 1.8 petrol and despite people slating them as being crap ours was good to drive, economical, quiet, excellent ride, handling not bad for a 4x4 and it was reliable. Very capable around a quarry too as I found out smile

GT101

967 posts

313 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Depends on your budget but the Nissan Pathfinder is a pretty good bet

Madkat

Original Poster:

1,147 posts

201 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Think about £5k is about as much as i'd go for a 4x4. I hadn't really considered the choppy side of things as now you mention it my parents have a Rav4 3dr and sitting in the back of that thing is pretty bouncy although that could be knackered shocks wouldn't surprise me.

Are the freelander 2's any good, not really in budget i know but would have to see about that. Also living in a built up area the clutch, gearbox and brakes would get quite a lot of use.

Ecosseven

2,367 posts

246 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Soft roaders are the target of much abuse from some PH's but if you only plan on using the car on the road then they are probably a better bet than something like a Shogun, Nissan Patrol Discovery, etc. A previous model Honda CRV is actually a pretty good all rounder in my opinion and the ride quality is fine if you stick with the 16" wheels.

Digga

48,133 posts

312 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
There are few drives as entertaining as an unladen, 2 seat Hi-Lux pickup, left in RWD mode. Surprisingly nimble.

schmalex

13,616 posts

235 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
I'd hapilly consider a Shogun Evolution as a fun, slightly terrifying way of getting about...

mikey k

13,074 posts

245 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
SG Forester Turbo is great, very civilised, nippy (230 BHP) with decent body control for a high vehicle and adequate off road if it is needed. Thirsty and £475 tax if you get a post 2006 car frown

Madkat

Original Poster:

1,147 posts

201 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
The forrester is also an option like a suppose an Allroad more car manners than a true 4x4 yet with the suspension travel and tyre profile to handle the worse than third world country roads that Liverpool possesses.

richs2891

906 posts

282 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
doogz said:
My SWB Shogun was pretty manouverable, although had a very slow rack.

Our Kia is has a cracking turning circle, and is very easy to manouvre.

But my Shogun Sport has the turning circle of a mid sized oil tanker! You have to nail your turn in, in multi story car parks, or you're the dick that has to 3 point it, and piss everyone behind you off! laugh
Lol you have not seen my other half trying to manoeuvre my lwb shogun, yeah its the typical 3 point turn,and generally a dogs dinner, yet I don't have any issues with it length wise.

What Kia have you got as I find my dad old shape kia sorento poor for its turning circle (given its size), but overall a cracking 4x4 - if a little poor on ground clearance as standard, but not sure if it has the correct tyres on it..

DH01

820 posts

197 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Mk 1 Cayenne, the most fun you can have with £7500 that'll only upset the Mrs a bit !
4.5S 340hp.

Diff locks make it quite capable of climbing too.

Edited by DH01 on Monday 3rd March 17:32

V8RX7

28,982 posts

292 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Madkat said:
I would still like to retain a decent level of pace
Eliminate all the old / basic 4x4 then.

I'd suggest a Forester turbo

Bill

58,650 posts

284 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
V8RX7 said:
Eliminate all the old / basic 4x4 then.

I'd suggest a Forester turbo
This.

Although there's a certain amount of fun to be had drifting a Shogun eek

mikey k

13,074 posts

245 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Madkat said:
The forrester is also an option like a suppose an Allroad more car manners than a true 4x4 yet with the suspension travel and tyre profile to handle the worse than third world country roads that Liverpool possesses.
The Subaru AWD is unusual in that it is permanent and locked AWB not some electronically controlled system that sits in FWD most the time, gives a few "performance" cars a nasty surprise in Turbo and STi format wink

A.J.M

8,387 posts

215 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
I had 2 freeby 1's. Both td4 and one had a twisted performance remap on it.

I found them really good as a daily driver, great fun in the snow, decent handling. I used to take mine on PH runs... hehe would average high 30s and had lots of toys.

Go for an auto SE/HSE. Blank the EGR, change the boost hoses, change the crank filter for the BMW one and remap it.

People look down on them but for sliding around in the snow or over wet grass and clay, they are great fun.

£5k will get a really good one.

I moved onto a Disco3 and that's even better for soaking up the bumps and dealing with crap roads.

Baryonyx

18,281 posts

188 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
V8RX7 said:
Madkat said:
I would still like to retain a decent level of pace
Eliminate all the old / basic 4x4 then.

I'd suggest a Forester turbo
Yes, and forget any sort of economy from an older 4x4 too; they're slow, torquey and thirsty.

jkh112

23,933 posts

187 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Madkat said:
Think about £5k is about as much as i'd go for a 4x4. I hadn't really considered the choppy side of things as now you mention it my parents have a Rav4 3dr and sitting in the back of that thing is pretty bouncy although that could be knackered shocks wouldn't surprise me.
The RAV4 is one of the better riding small 4x4s. It has independent suspension and rides far more car like than the other 4x4s I have driven (SJ, vitara, defender and disco).