Insurance question
Author
Discussion

Allanv

Original Poster:

3,540 posts

217 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
I had the insurance renewal for my car through and online it was £100 cheaper so went and paid in full for that.

Spoke to the previous insurance company tonight to stop the auto renew and one question was asked and that was what day does the new policy start.

fair question but I had made a mistake and the new policy with the new copany starts 1 day before the old one runs out, he told me that it is illegal to have 2 policies one one car is this correct?

To me it is just an overlap between companies, but should I change the date with the new company just to be sure?

I am asking here as lines are now closed frown

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Allanv said:
I had the insurance renewal for my car through and online it was £100 cheaper so went and paid in full for that.

Spoke to the previous insurance company tonight to stop the auto renew and one question was asked and that was what day does the new policy start.

fair question but I had made a mistake and the new policy with the new copany starts 1 day before the old one runs out, he told me that it is illegal to have 2 policies one one car is this correct?

To me it is just an overlap between companies, but should I change the date with the new company just to be sure?

I am asking here as lines are now closed frown
It's not illegal.

It would be illegal if you tried to claim on both policies eg if your car was stolen and you tried to claim off both companies.

How much no claims bonus do you have?

Allanv

Original Poster:

3,540 posts

217 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
dacouch said:
It's not illegal.

It would be illegal if you tried to claim on both policies eg if your car was stolen and you tried to claim off both companies.

How much no claims bonus do you have?
9+ years or the maximum they recognise.

It was a simple mistake but I don't want anything to happen should anything happen if you get my drift.

And thank you.

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Allanv said:
9+ years or the maximum they recognise.

It was a simple mistake but I don't want anything to happen should anything happen if you get my drift.

And thank you.
Most call center staff have very little knowledge of insurance and are on very low wages, if they don't know the answer to a question they tend to guess or answer using urban myths

The insuring a car twice is illegal is a common answer from uninformed people, if it were true you would not be able to buy temporary insurance or a seperate learner driver insurance for a parents car.

The reason I asked about your no claims is because if you did not have maximum then technically you would not have earned a year for the 364 days you had insured. As you have maximum it should not be a problem unless you get a really officious admin clerk who handles your no claims bonus at the new company.


Allanv

Original Poster:

3,540 posts

217 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
dacouch said:
Most call center staff have very little knowledge of insurance and are on very low wages, if they don't know the answer to a question they tend to guess or answer using urban myths

The insuring a car twice is illegal is a common answer from uninformed people, if it were true you would not be able to buy temporary insurance or a seperate learner driver insurance for a parents car.

The reason I asked about your no claims is because if you did not have maximum then technically you would not have earned a year for the 364 days you had insured. As you have maximum it should not be a problem unless you get a really officious admin clerk who handles your no claims bonus at the new company.
Thank you very much for the reply it is very much appreciated.

The renewal notice mentions the NCB and when I asked the operator he said just email that over to the new company so all that should be fine as it is more like 20 years NCB but it never seems to rise above 9+ frown

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
this does seem to be a little more than an urban myth
I have read it mentioned on here many times and i have been told it twice in the past by call centre staff in quite a matter of fact manor, i've never bothered going down the route of trying to correct them because trying to tell someone in a call that they are wrong is even more pointless than arguing on the internet, it's like trying to wrestle a fat woman covered in baby oil, some people enjoy it but i'm certainly not one of them.

I think there has been some incorrect information being given out to staff by some major insurers, either incompetently or deliberately (if there was a tin foil hat smilie i would use it here)

TwigtheWonderkid

49,270 posts

181 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
ging84 said:
this does seem to be a little more than an urban myth
I have read it mentioned on here many times and i have been told it twice in the past by call centre staff in quite a matter of fact manor, i've never bothered going down the route of trying to correct them because trying to tell someone in a call that they are wrong is even more pointless than arguing on the internet, it's like trying to wrestle a fat woman covered in baby oil, some people enjoy it but i'm certainly not one of them.
Exactly. never argue with an idiot. They'll drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
ging84 said:
this does seem to be a little more than an urban myth
I have read it mentioned on here many times and i have been told it twice in the past by call centre staff in quite a matter of fact manor, i've never bothered going down the route of trying to correct them because trying to tell someone in a call that they are wrong is even more pointless than arguing on the internet, it's like trying to wrestle a fat woman covered in baby oil, some people enjoy it but i'm certainly not one of them.

I think there has been some incorrect information being given out to staff by some major insurers, either incompetently or deliberately (if there was a tin foil hat smilie i would use it here)
I've worked for a couple of large Insurers (As well as small companies) the large companies tend to take staff from any back ground but give all staff an induction training. The training touches on Insurance and they give a brief history of Insurance which always includes about how a long long time ago people would take out Insurance on ships not belonging to them travelling from say chins full of tea as a wager which was eventually made illegal. If you combine this with the urban myths about insurance I can see how a lot of staff make this wrong statement.

I've been told literally dozens of times by call center staff that you can't insure a car twice