Zip together: time to change the signage / conage?
Zip together: time to change the signage / conage?
Author
Discussion

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
I was reminded about halfwits who think because they chose to merge left into almost stationary traffic 500 yards back from the lane closure, everyone behind them should do as well. This was at the A11 near Duxford turn off.

No particular problem, everyone was merging nicely at the cones but Mr "I don't like jags" decided to make it difficult (but not impossible) for me.

Sometimes I see the cones helping these hard-of-thinking types by coming in from each side and the sign saying "Merge in turn" with helpful little zippy arrows just so they know how a civilised world operates.

How come this isn't adopted throughout yet?

SM

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
It would be very helpful to have more prominent and visible "merge in turn" signage i na lot of places, I agree. In the case of a two lane road being funnelled into one lane for road works I think it would be a good idea to move both lanes into a single coned "centre lane" before shifting the whole lot to one side or the other. I'm sure it would help to avoid unwarranted self-righteousness among road users who don't want to merge in turn.

3Dee

3,206 posts

252 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Must admit I agree, cos many road users don't seem to understand the concept, and you inevitably get a number of 'dolts' who either physically push in, or just as bad, is determined to stamp his/her authority by making sure there is not enough room to merge.

I remember many years ago, hiring a car in Jersey, coming up to a roundabout, and seeing a 'merge in turn' sign on the rbout! I was initially perplexed and a bit fazed by this, but was very pleasantly surprised how simple it was. It was the norm there and I noted how well behaved the road users were in conforming.

More to the point, each roundabout seem to flow much better and quicker(granted lass traffic than on the mainland).

Never understood why this type of discipline was not adopted by the UK!

alangla

6,834 posts

212 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Here's an idea....

Given that the UK implementation of Filter In Turn is more likely to be for roadworks rather than the more general use that's seen in Jersey, how about (assuming a 2 lane dual carriageway or motorway):

At 2 miles to go, show the man with shovel sign & "Carriageway repairs" or similar.
At 1 mile, repeat the man with shovel & distance board.
At 800 yds, "USE BOTH LANES - MERGE AHEAD, 800 yds"
At 400 yds, "USE BOTH LANES - MERGE AHEAD, 400 yds"
At 200 yds, "MERGE AHEAD 200 yds"
At 100 yds, "SLOW - MERGE AHEAD"
Then at the merge point, funnel in from both sides with "MERGE NOW & a pictogram of a funnel type merge for foreign drivers etc.

Workable? I reckon the funnel rather than a merge-left or merge-right would be more likely to work than a "continuing" and "closing" lane.

julian64

14,325 posts

285 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Oh gawd not again.

This isn't rocket science its common decency, and primary school maths.

Ignore the signs. If the signs told you to drive off a cliff, would you?

Use your common sense. If you are comming up behind two queues of cars merging in turn pick either lane and merge in turn. In my thirty odd years driving I have never seen a problem with this in the uk.

The problem comes when you approach the back of two very uneven queues, where one is long and the other is non existantly short. I'm not talking about a couple of car lengths here, as I've never seen a problem with that outside of london either. I'm talking about a giant clear road where you would have to pass many people to form a new queue at the end.

All you have to do is use your common sense and queue in a way where you let the guy who has been queuing longer than you go through the obstruction first.

You don't improve the throughput of the queue by using both lanes and you are pissing off everyone who has been queuing longer than you.

Surely common decency would stop you driving past large quantities of people who had been queuing longer than you even if you did think they were a bit daft for queuing that way. You wouldn't do it if you were queuing to get into a nightclub, so I don't really understand why having two tonnes of metal around you allows a completely different pattern of thought.

If you are the sort of person that would follow the signage knowing that you are entirely within you rights but are doing something that is pissing people off than I suspect you are also the sort of peron that does 270s on roundabouts to beat queues and my local favourite which is cut across a petrol station forecourt because its easier than waiting for a red light to change.

So forget the signs and try to act like a curteous human being, perhaps both inside and outside the car.

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
OGNA

alock

4,575 posts

242 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
julian64 said:
So forget the signs and try to act like a curteous human being, perhaps both inside and outside the car.
I agree. The main problem I have with the merge and turn principal is at the limits, e.g. who starts using the second lane if the roads are quieter?

As an example, you are the 2nd car out of 3 all travelling sensibly in the left hand lane at about 70mph on a dual carriage way. Ahead is a merge point and the queue stops exactly at the merge point. The first car pulls up at the end of the queue. Where do you then go as the 2nd car? Do you really chose lane 2? What about the car behind you?

NH1

1,333 posts

160 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Oh gawd not again.

This isn't rocket science its common decency, and primary school maths.

Ignore the signs. If the signs told you to drive off a cliff, would you?

Use your common sense. If you are comming up behind two queues of cars merging in turn pick either lane and merge in turn. In my thirty odd years driving I have never seen a problem with this in the uk.

The problem comes when you approach the back of two very uneven queues, where one is long and the other is non existantly short. I'm not talking about a couple of car lengths here, as I've never seen a problem with that outside of london either. I'm talking about a giant clear road where you would have to pass many people to form a new queue at the end.

All you have to do is use your common sense and queue in a way where you let the guy who has been queuing longer than you go through the obstruction first.

You don't improve the throughput of the queue by using both lanes and you are pissing off everyone who has been queuing longer than you.

Surely common decency would stop you driving past large quantities of people who had been queuing longer than you even if you did think they were a bit daft for queuing that way. You wouldn't do it if you were queuing to get into a nightclub, so I don't really understand why having two tonnes of metal around you allows a completely different pattern of thought.

If you are the sort of person that would follow the signage knowing that you are entirely within you rights but are doing something that is pissing people off than I suspect you are also the sort of peron that does 270s on roundabouts to beat queues and my local favourite which is cut across a petrol station forecourt because its easier than waiting for a red light to change.

So forget the signs and try to act like a curteous human being, perhaps both inside and outside the car.
I agree with this, the only time merge in turn works is if the traffic is free flowing. If the traffic is stopped in a queue then driving past that queue and entering near the front does not and cannot in any way speed up the traffic flow, whatever is causing the traffic to build up can only let a certain amount of cars through for a given amount of time no matter where they come from.
If L1 has a queue in it, by driving down to the front in L2 and "pushing in" will result in longer delays for the people further back in L1. As stated its simple maths, if a queue of 100 cars in one lane take 1hr to get through an obstruction it will still take 1hr to get 2 queues of 50 cars each through, probably longer as they have to stop and start to let people merge in.
Also usually once the cars have merged together the speed of the traffic picks up again. This states to me the hold up is caused by cars merging together not the obstruction itself. IF people merged when the queue weas still moving it would help considerably.
Anyway these people that state they have the right to drive to the front and use the whole of the road network to its fullest I would say I agree with you, you can do what you want. So how can you then have a problem with someone not letting you in at the front, they are just doing what they want, I don't think its any business of yours what they decide to do.

supersport

4,646 posts

258 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
I would have thought that the common sense would have been to use both lanes in the first place not simply form one ridiculously long queue only using half the road. But hey maybe that's just me rolleyes

Personally I would use the empty road, don't see why I should sit at the end of queue like a lemming just top stop some numpty feeling put out.

Swervin_Mervin

5,012 posts

269 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Oh gawd not again.

This isn't rocket science its common decency, and primary school maths.

Ignore the signs. If the signs told you to drive off a cliff, would you?

Use your common sense. If you are comming up behind two queues of cars merging in turn pick either lane and merge in turn. In my thirty odd years driving I have never seen a problem with this in the uk.

The problem comes when you approach the back of two very uneven queues, where one is long and the other is non existantly short. I'm not talking about a couple of car lengths here, as I've never seen a problem with that outside of london either. I'm talking about a giant clear road where you would have to pass many people to form a new queue at the end.

All you have to do is use your common sense and queue in a way where you let the guy who has been queuing longer than you go through the obstruction first.

You don't improve the throughput of the queue by using both lanes and you are pissing off everyone who has been queuing longer than you.

Surely common decency would stop you driving past large quantities of people who had been queuing longer than you even if you did think they were a bit daft for queuing that way. You wouldn't do it if you were queuing to get into a nightclub, so I don't really understand why having two tonnes of metal around you allows a completely different pattern of thought.

If you are the sort of person that would follow the signage knowing that you are entirely within you rights but are doing something that is pissing people off than I suspect you are also the sort of peron that does 270s on roundabouts to beat queues and my local favourite which is cut across a petrol station forecourt because its easier than waiting for a red light to change.

So forget the signs and try to act like a curteous human being, perhaps both inside and outside the car.
Hmm, where to start with that one.

1: Seriously, you've never seen people struggle with the concept of merging in turn? I see it almost everyday.

2: You are correct in what you say about two queues not increasing throughput more than 1 long queue. But guess what - the total queue length on the stretch of road is reduced, meaning the route has a greater capacity.

3: Why should someone not do the correct thing, just because most of the people to their left are stupid? If there were 2 queuing "lanes" at a nightclub and one had none in it, I certainly would use it! It's not there for decoration is it?

mrtwisty

3,057 posts

196 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
supersport said:
I would have thought that the common sense would have been to use both lanes in the first place not simply form one ridiculously long queue only using half the road. But hey maybe that's just me rolleyes

Personally I would use the empty road, don't see why I should sit at the end of queue like a lemming just top stop some numpty feeling put out.
This.

'A long line of stupid people have formed an unnecessary queue, I must therefore join them'.... doesn't make a lot of sense to me.

AngryPartsBloke

1,439 posts

182 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Oh gawd not again.

This isn't rocket science its common decency, and primary school maths.

Ignore the signs. If the signs told you to drive off a cliff, would you?

Use your common sense. If you are comming up behind two queues of cars merging in turn pick either lane and merge in turn. In my thirty odd years driving I have never seen a problem with this in the uk.

The problem comes when you approach the back of two very uneven queues, where one is long and the other is non existantly short. I'm not talking about a couple of car lengths here, as I've never seen a problem with that outside of london either. I'm talking about a giant clear road where you would have to pass many people to form a new queue at the end.

All you have to do is use your common sense and queue in a way where you let the guy who has been queuing longer than you go through the obstruction first.

You don't improve the throughput of the queue by using both lanes and you are pissing off everyone who has been queuing longer than you.

Surely common decency would stop you driving past large quantities of people who had been queuing longer than you even if you did think they were a bit daft for queuing that way. You wouldn't do it if you were queuing to get into a nightclub, so I don't really understand why having two tonnes of metal around you allows a completely different pattern of thought.

If you are the sort of person that would follow the signage knowing that you are entirely within you rights but are doing something that is pissing people off than I suspect you are also the sort of peron that does 270s on roundabouts to beat queues and my local favourite which is cut across a petrol station forecourt because its easier than waiting for a red light to change.

So forget the signs and try to act like a curteous human being, perhaps both inside and outside the car.
Do you often find yourself joining a random queue for no apparent reason?

"Oh, I wonder what everyone is queuing for. I'll queue and find out"

Why would I sit at the end of a line of traffic when I don't have to? For a start it just causes tailbacks and more congestion

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Oh gawd not again.

This isn't rocket science its common decency, and primary school maths.

Ignore the signs. If the signs told you to drive off a cliff, would you?

Use your common sense. If you are comming up behind two queues of cars merging in turn pick either lane and merge in turn. In my thirty odd years driving I have never seen a problem with this in the uk.

The problem comes when you approach the back of two very uneven queues, where one is long and the other is non existantly short. I'm not talking about a couple of car lengths here, as I've never seen a problem with that outside of london either. I'm talking about a giant clear road where you would have to pass many people to form a new queue at the end.

All you have to do is use your common sense and queue in a way where you let the guy who has been queuing longer than you go through the obstruction first.

You don't improve the throughput of the queue by using both lanes and you are pissing off everyone who has been queuing longer than you.

Surely common decency would stop you driving past large quantities of people who had been queuing longer than you even if you did think they were a bit daft for queuing that way. You wouldn't do it if you were queuing to get into a nightclub, so I don't really understand why having two tonnes of metal around you allows a completely different pattern of thought.

If you are the sort of person that would follow the signage knowing that you are entirely within you rights but are doing something that is pissing people off than I suspect you are also the sort of peron that does 270s on roundabouts to beat queues and my local favourite which is cut across a petrol station forecourt because its easier than waiting for a red light to change.

So forget the signs and try to act like a curteous human being, perhaps both inside and outside the car.


IT. IS. NOT. ABOUT. THROUGHPUT. OF. TRAFFIC.

By using BOTH lanes ALL the way up to the merge point you shorten the length of both lines. Think of it this way: 1 lane has 500 cars in it stretching back 1 mile, whilst the other lane is empty. If there is an entry slip joing that road, traffic on that slip will be unable to join because there is a line of cars blocking them. Therefore, traffic now builds up on that sliproad, which then starts to build up on the roundabout just before the sliproad.

Now think about if BOTH lanes were being used. Each lane contains only 250 cars meaning the queue is only HALF A MILE long, meaning that sliproad is no longer blocked, meaning cars don't queue on the sliproad and nor do they end up queuing back onto the roundabout.

You are actually correct when you say a problem qccurs when you happen across 2 very uneven queues of traffic. The problem is not people using the empty lane, it's the utter morons who all blindly joined the queue in lane 1 for no reason thus creating the illusion of a long queue. If everyone used BOTH lanes up to the merge point there would be NO LONGER QUEUE, they'd both be of equal length, NO-ONE would have an advantage of any sort, and the length of queueing traffic would be as short as physically possible thereby minimising it's effect of traffic on the surrounding roads.

Impasse

15,099 posts

272 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Snipers and a small fleet of fast response tow trucks.

NH1

1,333 posts

160 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Swervin_Mervin said:
Hmm, where to start with that one.

1: Seriously, you've never seen people struggle with the concept of merging in turn? I see it almost everyday.

2: You are correct in what you say about two queues not increasing throughput more than 1 long queue. But guess what - the total queue length on the stretch of road is reduced, meaning the route has a greater capacity.

3: Why should someone not do the correct thing, just because most of the people to their left are stupid? If there were 2 queuing "lanes" at a nightclub and one had none in it, I certainly would use it! It's not there for decoration is it?
I might be a bit thick but I don't follow how point 2 works. If you have 100 cars in lane 1 and 100 cars in lane 2 then for merge in turn to work every car in lane 1 would have to leave a gap big enough in front of them to let the right hand car in. This would be the same length as a 200 car long queue.
A single lane of 200 cars will move at least as quick a 2 lanes of 100 cars therefore the queue will be no further back if its a single line or double line. In my oppinion it would move quicker because there is no stop start where people are let in.

julian64

14,325 posts

285 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Centurion07 said:


IT. IS. NOT. ABOUT. THROUGHPUT. OF. TRAFFIC.

By using BOTH lanes ALL the way up to the merge point you shorten the length of both lines. Think of it this way: 1 lane has 500 cars in it stretching back 1 mile, whilst the other lane is empty. If there is an entry slip joing that road, traffic on that slip will be unable to join because there is a line of cars blocking them. Therefore, traffic now builds up on that sliproad, which then starts to build up on the roundabout just before the sliproad.

Now think about if BOTH lanes were being used. Each lane contains only 250 cars meaning the queue is only HALF A MILE long, meaning that sliproad is no longer blocked, meaning cars don't queue on the sliproad and nor do they end up queuing back onto the roundabout.

You are actually correct when you say a problem qccurs when you happen across 2 very uneven queues of traffic. The problem is not people using the empty lane, it's the utter morons who all blindly joined the queue in lane 1 for no reason thus creating the illusion of a long queue. If everyone used BOTH lanes up to the merge point there would be NO LONGER QUEUE, they'd both be of equal length, NO-ONE would have an advantage of any sort, and the length of queueing traffic would be as short as physically possible thereby minimising it's effect of traffic on the surrounding roads.
A truly weak argument. The chances of a queue so long as to block the next junction would be rare. Even if it did the cars on the sliproad would simply merge in turn.

.
.
.
.
.

I suspect somewhere in the world a kitten has just died.

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Centurion07 said:


IT. IS. NOT. ABOUT. THROUGHPUT. OF. TRAFFIC.

By using BOTH lanes ALL the way up to the merge point you shorten the length of both lines. Think of it this way: 1 lane has 500 cars in it stretching back 1 mile, whilst the other lane is empty. If there is an entry slip joing that road, traffic on that slip will be unable to join because there is a line of cars blocking them. Therefore, traffic now builds up on that sliproad, which then starts to build up on the roundabout just before the sliproad.

Now think about if BOTH lanes were being used. Each lane contains only 250 cars meaning the queue is only HALF A MILE long, meaning that sliproad is no longer blocked, meaning cars don't queue on the sliproad and nor do they end up queuing back onto the roundabout.

You are actually correct when you say a problem qccurs when you happen across 2 very uneven queues of traffic. The problem is not people using the empty lane, it's the utter morons who all blindly joined the queue in lane 1 for no reason thus creating the illusion of a long queue. If everyone used BOTH lanes up to the merge point there would be NO LONGER QUEUE, they'd both be of equal length, NO-ONE would have an advantage of any sort, and the length of queueing traffic would be as short as physically possible thereby minimising it's effect of traffic on the surrounding roads.
A truly weak argument. The chances of a queue so long as to block the next junction would be rare. Even if it did the cars on the sliproad would simply merge in turn.

.
.
.
.
.

I suspect somewhere in the world a kitten has just died.
Aren't you a doctor?

julian64

14,325 posts

285 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Centurion07 said:
julian64 said:
Centurion07 said:


IT. IS. NOT. ABOUT. THROUGHPUT. OF. TRAFFIC.

By using BOTH lanes ALL the way up to the merge point you shorten the length of both lines. Think of it this way: 1 lane has 500 cars in it stretching back 1 mile, whilst the other lane is empty. If there is an entry slip joing that road, traffic on that slip will be unable to join because there is a line of cars blocking them. Therefore, traffic now builds up on that sliproad, which then starts to build up on the roundabout just before the sliproad.

Now think about if BOTH lanes were being used. Each lane contains only 250 cars meaning the queue is only HALF A MILE long, meaning that sliproad is no longer blocked, meaning cars don't queue on the sliproad and nor do they end up queuing back onto the roundabout.

You are actually correct when you say a problem qccurs when you happen across 2 very uneven queues of traffic. The problem is not people using the empty lane, it's the utter morons who all blindly joined the queue in lane 1 for no reason thus creating the illusion of a long queue. If everyone used BOTH lanes up to the merge point there would be NO LONGER QUEUE, they'd both be of equal length, NO-ONE would have an advantage of any sort, and the length of queueing traffic would be as short as physically possible thereby minimising it's effect of traffic on the surrounding roads.
A truly weak argument. The chances of a queue so long as to block the next junction would be rare. Even if it did the cars on the sliproad would simply merge in turn.

.
.
.
.
.

I suspect somewhere in the world a kitten has just died.
Aren't you a doctor?
Not for kittens. instant furball if you try mouth to mouth on them. That and you get a lot of funny looks from passers by

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
I just find it quite funny, actually no, I find it quite scary that someone has the intelligence to be able to qualify as a doctor and yet has such a complete lack of understanding of a concept this basic.

Humour me and pretend that there is a queue of such length and magnificence that it does indeed manage to block a sliproad entry (although why on earth you think it impossible for roadworks to be in such a location that could possibly cause a sliproad to be blocked is beyond me!); you say it wouldn't matter as they would all just merge in turn, yet you also say you should wait your turn and allow people that have been queueing longer than you to go first? So how would that work then? I drive down the sliproad and then have to wait half an hour whilst all these other cars slowly drive past until I get to my "rightful" position within the queue?

If EVERYONE USED ALL THE AVAILABLE SPACE no-one would have any advantage, so your perceieved outrage at being "queue-jumped" would be irrelevant because there would be no queue jumping! You even alluded to this yourself: "Use your common sense. If you are comming up behind two queues of cars merging in turn pick either lane and merge in turn."

"The problem comes when you approach the back of two very uneven queues, where one is long and the other is non existantly short. I'm not talking about a couple of car lengths here, as I've never seen a problem with that outside of london either. I'm talking about a giant clear road where you would have to pass many people to form a new queue at the end."

You have just admitted the problem is caused by retards that join a lane earlier than they should.

Maybe you should try acting the courteous human being by using all the available lanes up until the merge point and thus preventing any perceived injustice occuring in the first place?!


Try this link: http://www.dot.state.mn.us/zippermerge/ and make sure you watch the video.



Edited by Centurion07 on Tuesday 4th March 18:36

h8tax

447 posts

174 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Conage or Coneage ? Or neither ?