To all the LPG haters...
To all the LPG haters...
Author
Discussion

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Hi everyone,
Not trying to open a can of whooparse, but in light of the recent discussion about my engine doing kaboom and the fact that I shouldn't be driving a car I allegedly can't afford to run, I decided to conduct a test, in the name of science.

I had to rent a car to help me go about my daily chores. It happened to be a mighty Corsa 1.2. I don't even want to know what it is pushing on the fly let alone at the wheels wink Anyway, managed to get 310 miles out of a tank and paid £51 to fill up. Now, that is £16.54 per 100 miles. It's quite funny, because in the similar circumstances, speeds, conditions and type of driving, I have always (repeatedly) managed around 200miles and paid £36 to fill up. That is £18 per 100 miles.

Now, am I really breaking a petrolhead code of conduct by choosing a cool fun car over a boring (not even) shopping cart, whilst still trying to keep the cost of running down?


Cheers
Bart

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
You won't win. hehe

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
ARAF said:
You won't win. hehe
But I'm up for a debate with the experts in the know wink

Glyn84

668 posts

211 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
I've never understood the it's a big V8 you don't buy it for fuel economy argument. If you're just on an average wage LPGing means you can enjoy it daily without having to live in a cardboard box. Nothing puts you in a better mood than burbling your way to work each morning, trust me!

You do need to cover a fair few miles for it to pay though, that's the only catch.

blue666uk

690 posts

155 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
My CV8 runs on LPG, and runs lovely and since changing to NGK LPG5 plugs and new leads, economy has gone up by 2MPG so now averaging 20.5 instead of 18.5 on a very average commute of mixed roads. Also, the new plugs/leads have closed the performance gap so that now it does not 'feel' particularly different between running on petrol or LPG. Like you say, on the continent, people have been running on LPG for years with no problems, though that't not to say there aren't any. Some manufacturers engines do not like it one bit, even with flashlube (oo-er), as their valve seats are made from marshmellow. However, those engines that have pretty good valves as standard will do big miles no problem. There is always the argument that you shouldn't use something that was not originally intended, ie LPG over regular 95RON fuel, but then the reverse arguments is who here doesn't use 98/99 RON fuel (Which the states where our engines come from don't have this fuel typically as they run their cars on marmite), plus who hasn't modded their cars with performance enhancing shiney bits and re-maps which takes the car outside of manufacturers tolerances blah blah etc etc. To the poster, I'm with you on this one!!!
So pistols at dawn eh?
shoot

SteveMJ

919 posts

227 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Another LPG advocate here.

I can't tell the difference in performance on a daily basis (at 2012 PVS, the car did ET 14.1 sec at 99 mph on LPG compared with 13.5 sec at 105 mph on petrol). Except, that I don't feed too much to the treasury or the fuel companies.

When I got the VXR8 I toyed with the idea of a perfomance car plus a runabout, but decided that the cost of the runabout could go towards daily V8 use :-)

Saying that, my son and I now share an Astra Estate for local journeys and bulding work on his place. saves filling the VXR8's boot with cement, timber etc.

Steve

stevieturbo

18,106 posts

278 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
There is no reason at all to hate LPG.

The fuel is decent, it works, and price is better than the government rip off normal fuel.

The main risks are with installers who simply dont know how to properly tune the systems.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Yep nothing wrong except with adding complexity and tune issues.
But I think there is a bit of man math going on when you factor in the purchase price the picture is no doubt different. You also need to factor in opportunity cost, plus maintenance and support cost increases, loss of boot space, etc, etc.

Unless you keep it for decades Id suggest its not really worth it. But Ive not done the numbers, because I dont like the added complexity.

Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication. Leonardo da Vinci

blue666uk

690 posts

155 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
ringram said:
Yep nothing wrong except with adding complexity and tune issues.
But I think there is a bit of man math going on when you factor in the purchase price the picture is no doubt different. You also need to factor in opportunity cost, plus maintenance and support cost increases, loss of boot space, etc, etc.

Unless you keep it for decades Id suggest its not really worth it. But Ive not done the numbers, because I dont like the added complexity.

Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication. Leonardo da Vinci
Ringram, I know your a non-LPG believer, so we may have to agree to disagree on a few bits, but, I agree, to an extent, but then the same can be said for Supercharging (for example)??
I have a big boot CV8 so there is no loss of boot space as such, I just ditched the spare wheel and the LPG tank sits in the wheel well. If I have a puncture worse than what a can of tyre gunge can handle, that's why I have break down cover.
Servicing is dirt cheap, especially when the LPG installer is very local, it's only a system check and filter check.
I do intend to keep the car for as long as I possible can (many many years hopefully) and as for Man maths - surely that was the very method used to convince our lovely wives and g'f's that running a ridiculously over-engined V8 in the UK was a good idea anyway (along with the subsequent mods and upgrades......!
Blimey, I don't normally so much as squeak on here much, but the car passed the MOT yesterday with no advisories, so now I'm thinking what shall I spend the money set aside for any remedial works. Must be in a good mood!!!biglaugh

stevieturbo

18,106 posts

278 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
blue666uk said:
Ringram, I know your a non-LPG believer, so we may have to agree to disagree on a few bits, but, I agree, to an extent, but then the same can be said for Supercharging (for example)??
Richard may be a non LPG believer, but is also a non boost believer lol.

So no point trying to convince him about supercharging.



ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
Richard may be a non LPG believer, but is also a non boost believer lol.
So no point trying to convince him about supercharging.
Maybe the problem is less about the technology, and more about the pressure. If gas vehicles were still fitted with the massive atmospheric gas bags on the roof of their vehicle, he might be happier. hehe


blue666uk

690 posts

155 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Pearls of wisdom and enlightenment as always!!!
I don't know where you get these pictures and knowledge from but it keeps us all amused.
thumbup

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Thats Ian's car from when he was a teenager and picking up his sailor mates from the pub

ARAF

20,759 posts

254 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
ringram said:
Thats Ian's car from when he was a teenager and picking up his sailor mates from the pub
laugh

Has anyone told you lately, that it's time for you to go home? hehe

m00k

51 posts

169 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
I love LPG

Have been running it in various cars for past 7 years and it has been superb

Mine was converted already this time so doubt saved me money but if I hadn't bought this one my plan was still to LPG one after purchase

Makes sense with the family etc as my daily driver and using the car for work

Tbh ppl saying if you can't afford to run it on petrol you can't afford one is coming across a little pompous

I also have two classic turbo cars so think I spend enough on tax fuel mot etc


MyM8V8

9,468 posts

226 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
If LPG is that good as a fuel, tell me why the manufacturers don't use or offer it as standard?


bimsb6

8,809 posts

252 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
MyM8V8 said:
If LPG is that good as a fuel, tell me why the manufacturers don't use or offer it as standard?
Because you are not allowed in the chunnel with an lpg vehicle ? Vauxhall used to do lpg equipped cars btw .

raving

1,183 posts

221 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
They do , we had a vauxhall factory bi , done the valves
Volvo factory conversion st itself
Fords - factory couldnt even get it to work properly we had them 16 weeks late then packed up and just ran them on petrol

Everyone to their own , if you like it use it , but it is ste

djwilk

Original Poster:

1,693 posts

200 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
MyM8V8 said:
If LPG is that good as a fuel, tell me why the manufacturers don't use or offer it as standard?
As someone has mentioned already, why do manufacturers not mod their vehicles at the factory? Talking about the level of mods we do on here?

As for the cost of the kit and the time to break even, assume £100 per 1k miles.

SteveMJ

919 posts

227 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
In 2009 I calculated my payback woudl be 20,000 miles - that was when petrol was ~80p/L and gas about 40p/L. So I recuperated the cost somewhat less than that mileage.

Steve