Taking Builder To Small Claims Court.
Discussion
Hi guys,
After some advice if I may!
My parents are currently having major renovations and extensions done to a property they bought last year, but have come up against major issues! Basically the concrete base of the house was laid by a specialist foundation company in January as it required non-standard foundations. After plenty of time to set it was found to be defective (crumbly and soft), so specialists were brought in and confirmed the concrete was to blame and that the whole slab would need to be removed and relaid. The foundation company then said that they weren't prepared to rectify the work for 6 weeks, as they were going to work it out with the third party concrete provider.
A 6 week delay is unacceptable for a number of reasons (basically puts the whole project on hold) and every week delay costs money as other contractors are on site etc, so my parent's solicitor sent a letter to them on 26th February, telling them that they had until today (5th March) to begin rectifying the problems or that we'd get someone else to carry out the remedial works and would then be persuing them through the small claims court for the costs. They had the letter delivered in person, by email and by registered delivery but there's been absolutely no response over the past couple of weeks.
As this is likely to result in court action I was wondering if there was anything else we needed to do now to increase our chances of succeeding later on? They were given ample opportunity to rectify the works themselves but aside from saying they'd do it in 6 weeks we've had nothing from them at all. Is that reasonable of them and are we likely to succeed against them as we gave them the two weeks to begin fixing it?
Cheers!
Dom
After some advice if I may!
My parents are currently having major renovations and extensions done to a property they bought last year, but have come up against major issues! Basically the concrete base of the house was laid by a specialist foundation company in January as it required non-standard foundations. After plenty of time to set it was found to be defective (crumbly and soft), so specialists were brought in and confirmed the concrete was to blame and that the whole slab would need to be removed and relaid. The foundation company then said that they weren't prepared to rectify the work for 6 weeks, as they were going to work it out with the third party concrete provider.
A 6 week delay is unacceptable for a number of reasons (basically puts the whole project on hold) and every week delay costs money as other contractors are on site etc, so my parent's solicitor sent a letter to them on 26th February, telling them that they had until today (5th March) to begin rectifying the problems or that we'd get someone else to carry out the remedial works and would then be persuing them through the small claims court for the costs. They had the letter delivered in person, by email and by registered delivery but there's been absolutely no response over the past couple of weeks.
As this is likely to result in court action I was wondering if there was anything else we needed to do now to increase our chances of succeeding later on? They were given ample opportunity to rectify the works themselves but aside from saying they'd do it in 6 weeks we've had nothing from them at all. Is that reasonable of them and are we likely to succeed against them as we gave them the two weeks to begin fixing it?
Cheers!
Dom
Edited by Zeemax_Mini on Wednesday 5th March 13:20
Zeemax_Mini said:
Basically the concrete base of the house was laid by a specialist foundation company in January as it required non-standard foundations. After plenty of time to set it was found to be defective (crumbly and soft), so specialists were brought in and confirmed the concrete was to blame and that the whole slab would need to be removed and relaid. The foundation company then said that they weren't prepared to rectify the work for 6 weeks, as they were going to work it out with the third party concrete provider.
Jeez that's messy, Just out of interest did your parents employ a builder who employed/subcontracted a specialist foundation company who received 'defective' supplies from a 'concrete' company.
If so surely parents would claim off who they had contract with ie builder and so it goes down the line, builder claims from specialist who claims from concrete co,, no wonder lawyers are loaded.
Just out of interest was it a proper concrete mixer or the volumetric type that 'mix' on site?
If your solicitor is good, and of course knows your case inside out, then with respect, you are not going to get better advice on a forum with a few line basic explanation of your case.
You need to make a commercial decision on whether it is worth waiting for rectification which may or may not happen, or temporarily writing this sum off pending legal action to keep the build going. If the sums are significant enough, it will not be held against you in court for proceeding. Indeed, if this is mitigating your losses you would be expected to do so.
You need to make a commercial decision on whether it is worth waiting for rectification which may or may not happen, or temporarily writing this sum off pending legal action to keep the build going. If the sums are significant enough, it will not be held against you in court for proceeding. Indeed, if this is mitigating your losses you would be expected to do so.
would think there is a possibility that something has gone wrong with the batching plant, maybe there,s more batches in your area, mixed around the time of yours, that are not to spec
people could even be building on them, would think 3 days would be more realistic to check back to were there problems start and finnish
people could even be building on them, would think 3 days would be more realistic to check back to were there problems start and finnish
Cheers guys,
I'm just waiting to hear back from my Dad with a few more details and hopefully a copy of the contract. He has spoken to his solicitor, who wrote the letter, but apparently they don't specialise in litigation so aren't able to do much more than write the letter. Obviously we're not wanting to get into expensive legal battles, so I was just wondering if there were any key "must dos" when expecting a small claims procedure, ie giving them an opportunity to remedy the situation, which we have.
Thanks again,
Dom
I'm just waiting to hear back from my Dad with a few more details and hopefully a copy of the contract. He has spoken to his solicitor, who wrote the letter, but apparently they don't specialise in litigation so aren't able to do much more than write the letter. Obviously we're not wanting to get into expensive legal battles, so I was just wondering if there were any key "must dos" when expecting a small claims procedure, ie giving them an opportunity to remedy the situation, which we have.
Thanks again,
Dom
speedyguy said:
Jeez that's messy,
Just out of interest did your parents employ a builder who employed/subcontracted a specialist foundation company who received 'defective' supplies from a 'concrete' company.
If so surely parents would claim off who they had contract with ie builder and so it goes down the line, builder claims from specialist who claims from concrete co,, no wonder lawyers are loaded.
Just out of interest was it a proper concrete mixer or the volumetric type that 'mix' on site?
This particular part of the work was contracted directly between the specialist foundation company and my father - the concrete supply was nothing to do with him and all sorted out by that company. Given that his contract is with them, he's mitigating costs by getting the remedial work carried out without waiting for them and the proper third party tests were carried out which show the concrete isn't to spec I'd hope it'd be a fairly clear cut case, but these things never seem to be!Just out of interest did your parents employ a builder who employed/subcontracted a specialist foundation company who received 'defective' supplies from a 'concrete' company.
If so surely parents would claim off who they had contract with ie builder and so it goes down the line, builder claims from specialist who claims from concrete co,, no wonder lawyers are loaded.
Just out of interest was it a proper concrete mixer or the volumetric type that 'mix' on site?
Cheers,
Dom
Be interesting to see how it pans out,
When I used to have a mixer if there was a 'dodgy' load with an issue ie aggregate size, slump, lack of cement or excess water etc it could be traced back quite easily to the concrete plant as there were timed printouts of everything that went into the load and that was in the 'old' days going back 8ish years ago, since then some companies have fitted 'verifiers' to measure added water etc to prevent claims when site oppo's insist on p*ssing it up to make it easier to work with thereby reducing strength etc.
Not sure how they measure 'quality' if it is on those volumetric mix on site jobs.
Hope they get it sorted quick, sounds like everyone is trying to deny liability for their part.
When I used to have a mixer if there was a 'dodgy' load with an issue ie aggregate size, slump, lack of cement or excess water etc it could be traced back quite easily to the concrete plant as there were timed printouts of everything that went into the load and that was in the 'old' days going back 8ish years ago, since then some companies have fitted 'verifiers' to measure added water etc to prevent claims when site oppo's insist on p*ssing it up to make it easier to work with thereby reducing strength etc.
Not sure how they measure 'quality' if it is on those volumetric mix on site jobs.
Hope they get it sorted quick, sounds like everyone is trying to deny liability for their part.
Walford said:
would think there is a possibility that something has gone wrong with the batching plant, maybe there,s more batches in your area, mixed around the time of yours, that are not to spec
people could even be building on them, would think 3 days would be more realistic to check back to were there problems start and finnish
I've bought thousands of cube of designated mixes and if there was a batching plant issue it would be known within 24hrs due to other customer complaints and definitely be known at the 7 day point when to comply with the European standard for ready-mix the batching would have to test a retained sample cube. people could even be building on them, would think 3 days would be more realistic to check back to were there problems start and finnish
For batches suspected to be defective you can crush early age cubes to identify strength gain against standard/design. You would in this case then crush further cubes again at the 7 day and 28 day point to identify if design strength is ever likely to be reached.
I would expect a competent contractor to notify the client if strength is suspected to be below specification and from experience the major ready-mix batching plants are used to resolving this quickly without undue inconvenience for all parties.
Zeemax_Mini said:
This particular part of the work was contracted directly between the specialist foundation company and my father - the concrete supply was nothing to do with him and all sorted out by that company.
Did the specialist design the foundations or simply install them in accordance with a design prepared a structural engineer working for your father? This is a subtle point but if a independent engineer designed the founds the contractor should have consulted said person to confirm the designated mix complied with the design strength if they didn't your solicitor may have a fast track route to demonstrating contractual non compliance allowing for the contract to be voided.Without getting all complex an engineer will specify concrete as a design strength say C30 which means 30 newtons 28 day strength, they may then specify other restrictions such as cement replacement, aggregate size etc. However the batching plant will supply what is known as a designated mix say RC25 or FND1 etc there will be whole series of additional codes after this such as S3, CEM I, PFA, GGBS etc these define the exact characteristics and contents within the mix. Placing a mix containing a high PFA or GGBS content as cement replacement in January is generally not a good idea unless the weather is favourable. Also placing into flooded trenches unless the water content of the mix has been adjusted to suit is usually not good etc..
The type of contract the foundations installer has been placed on with determine if employing others represents mitigation of costs or falling to mitigate loss. Employing others where the original was on a JCT contract would not be acceptable if still within the defects remediation period, you could however look to recover all delay costs incurred from the contractual completion date. Should the contract not specify a period of works and/or completion date you'll be somewhat stuck.
You generally can not demand immediate remediation of a defect but equally the contractor can not just state an earliest return date that suits. The contract should cover mobilisation periods to attend site. Equally the contractor can not blame their supplier and basically leave you hanging whilst they agree (or don't) with said supplier the route forward. They as the contracted party have the obligation to sort you out.
Should the contract not be a formal construction contract then your father is probably going to have to go all the way to recover costs.
It's unfortunate that your Dads specialist contractor has been let down by his supplier but better finding out now, rather than after the extension had been finished.
What doesn't make sense is why have you ended up going down the court route due to a potential 6 weeks delay? Solicitors letters often have a negative effect in commercial situations where good-will becomes secondary to protecting a businesses legal position. There must have been something in the agreement with the specialist contractor about completion dates, and what the remedy is should that be missed.
Also, why was the foundation package not included within the main contractors works? I'll guess that it was to avoid paying the main contractor his overheads and profit, and therefore to save money by taking the risk and management responsibilities on himself. In this instance, taking on that responsibility has backfired.
I hope that the works get back on tract nice and quickly and that the costs for the foundation delay gets sorted without years of legal wrangling and legal fees, but by getting a solicitor involved to write a letter demanding that they come to site quicker, I suspect that will be the way it goes....
What doesn't make sense is why have you ended up going down the court route due to a potential 6 weeks delay? Solicitors letters often have a negative effect in commercial situations where good-will becomes secondary to protecting a businesses legal position. There must have been something in the agreement with the specialist contractor about completion dates, and what the remedy is should that be missed.
Also, why was the foundation package not included within the main contractors works? I'll guess that it was to avoid paying the main contractor his overheads and profit, and therefore to save money by taking the risk and management responsibilities on himself. In this instance, taking on that responsibility has backfired.
I hope that the works get back on tract nice and quickly and that the costs for the foundation delay gets sorted without years of legal wrangling and legal fees, but by getting a solicitor involved to write a letter demanding that they come to site quicker, I suspect that will be the way it goes....
Wow - I wasn't expecting such detailed responses, really appreciate you all taking the time to help (especially b0rk and Surveyor!). This is what I love about PH!
I've just got some further info from my Dad which may help understand the situation - it would actually seem that the concrete company isn't at fault, but the foundation company entirely. The foundation company was contracted separately to the main building contractor because the whole house required serious piling, so this was being sorted out before the main contractor started.
________________________________
Some background info from my Dad:
The strengths and base and re-inforcement were all specified in detail by our structural engineer, and [the foundation company] agreed to follow those. Subsequent concrete tests of slab show these concrete hardness standards have not been reached. [the foundation company] accept this.
Our builder thinks the pre mix driver was encouraged to add more water to the mix by [the foundation company] because they were running slow on laying it.
Cube tests were done and concrete company says these are OK
All that points to DGS gang screwing up the laying process with too much water.
_____________
Cheers guys, really appreciate your time.
Dom
I've just got some further info from my Dad which may help understand the situation - it would actually seem that the concrete company isn't at fault, but the foundation company entirely. The foundation company was contracted separately to the main building contractor because the whole house required serious piling, so this was being sorted out before the main contractor started.
________________________________
Some background info from my Dad:
The strengths and base and re-inforcement were all specified in detail by our structural engineer, and [the foundation company] agreed to follow those. Subsequent concrete tests of slab show these concrete hardness standards have not been reached. [the foundation company] accept this.
Our builder thinks the pre mix driver was encouraged to add more water to the mix by [the foundation company] because they were running slow on laying it.
Cube tests were done and concrete company says these are OK
All that points to DGS gang screwing up the laying process with too much water.
_____________
Cheers guys, really appreciate your time.
Dom
I think it depends what you include - there are significant penalties on the main contractor for every week over agreed completion he goes (he started on site before the slab was laid), the rental accommodation is £2k per month (plus council tax/utilities), furniture etc is in storage until the new house is done so that costs every week...expect there are other things. They're all costs that wouldn't have been there if the slab hadn't been defective.
Dom
Dom
Cheers for the additional information, makes much more sense now and certainly sounds like something the ground works guys should be held responsible for. I take it the remedial works to the rest of the house foundations doesn't have the same issues?
Keep us updates as to how this goes and how the company responds. For info, make sure your Dad agrees an 'extension of time' on the contract as a result of these delays, including associated costs. The Liquidated and Ascertained Damages Clause (technically not a penalty clause anymore) should be left for delays at the end of the contract where caused by the contractor, not the employer. Usually this will be say 6 weeks extension of time at 6 x 1 week preliminarys (the contractors weekly costs, site cabins, fencing, management costs etc). These costs should be included within the claim against the ground works contractor in addition to the other costs incurred by your Dad (extended rental, furniture storage, interest on borrowing etc). Don't leave it until the end of the job to extend the contract in case there are other non-associated delays incurred as a result of the main contractors actions as that's when it often gets messy.
As before, I hope I gets sorted.
Keep us updates as to how this goes and how the company responds. For info, make sure your Dad agrees an 'extension of time' on the contract as a result of these delays, including associated costs. The Liquidated and Ascertained Damages Clause (technically not a penalty clause anymore) should be left for delays at the end of the contract where caused by the contractor, not the employer. Usually this will be say 6 weeks extension of time at 6 x 1 week preliminarys (the contractors weekly costs, site cabins, fencing, management costs etc). These costs should be included within the claim against the ground works contractor in addition to the other costs incurred by your Dad (extended rental, furniture storage, interest on borrowing etc). Don't leave it until the end of the job to extend the contract in case there are other non-associated delays incurred as a result of the main contractors actions as that's when it often gets messy.
As before, I hope I gets sorted.
Thanks Paul - lovely Tuscan by the way, I'm an ex Tamora and Cerb owner!
I'll pass that onto my Dad, it's exactly the kind of advice I was after so cheers. In terms of the foundations for the rest of the building, the pilings all over the property (including under the defective slab) are fine, as is another slab which was laid separately - it's just the one for the new extension which is defective and which means the builder can't progress.
Cheers!
Dom
I'll pass that onto my Dad, it's exactly the kind of advice I was after so cheers. In terms of the foundations for the rest of the building, the pilings all over the property (including under the defective slab) are fine, as is another slab which was laid separately - it's just the one for the new extension which is defective and which means the builder can't progress.
Cheers!
Dom
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


