The "reliable" VAG 1.9tdi PD engine
Discussion
Morning all,
I have a 56 plate Polo with a 1.9tdi PD 100bhp engine. I understand (please correct me if I'm wrong) that this is one of the "reliable" VAG engines capable of intergalactic mileage (assuming well looked after, serviced etc etc) and returns good mpg. I know mine doesn't have a DPF to go wrong, but not sure about a DMF?
If I'm correct in my assumption, I would be grateful for advice on which makes/models within the VAG group use this engine, which years of manufacture are "best", and what state of tune is "best" for this engine in terms of reliability/longevity (I'm sure I've read that higher output versions (150 bhp?)can have problems?
The reason I ask is that my girlfriend will be needing to replace her car thanks to some idiot writing it off. Due to an upcoming change of job etc, it is likely that she will end up with a lengthy motorway commute (maybe 30K plus a year). I have been thinking that a possible option will be something from the VAG back catalogue.
Any advice much appreciated
I have a 56 plate Polo with a 1.9tdi PD 100bhp engine. I understand (please correct me if I'm wrong) that this is one of the "reliable" VAG engines capable of intergalactic mileage (assuming well looked after, serviced etc etc) and returns good mpg. I know mine doesn't have a DPF to go wrong, but not sure about a DMF?
If I'm correct in my assumption, I would be grateful for advice on which makes/models within the VAG group use this engine, which years of manufacture are "best", and what state of tune is "best" for this engine in terms of reliability/longevity (I'm sure I've read that higher output versions (150 bhp?)can have problems?
The reason I ask is that my girlfriend will be needing to replace her car thanks to some idiot writing it off. Due to an upcoming change of job etc, it is likely that she will end up with a lengthy motorway commute (maybe 30K plus a year). I have been thinking that a possible option will be something from the VAG back catalogue.
Any advice much appreciated

If she is doing 30k per year there will be no dpf issues. (Apart from the pd170 which is a s
te engine)
Anything up to 08 uses the later pd105 which isn't a perfect engine itself tbh, there have been cases of making a hole in the block.
We need a budget to decide what's best to reccomend
te engine)Anything up to 08 uses the later pd105 which isn't a perfect engine itself tbh, there have been cases of making a hole in the block.
We need a budget to decide what's best to reccomend
Cheers for the reply 

SteBrown91 said:
Anything up to 08 uses the later pd105 which isn't a perfect engine itself tbh, there have been cases of making a hole in the block.
Is that 105bhp? If so, is the 105bhp PD engine a different engine to the 100 bhp PD engine in my Polo, or is it the same with a different level of tune (all 5 bhp of it)?SteBrown91 said:
We need a budget to decide what's best to reccomend
Not really sure what budget is "best." The mileage she will be doing will cause rapid depreciation, so I don't think its worth buying anything too new and paying a premium, but don't want something too old that's not going to be able to take the mileage she will do. I'm thinking it might be better to buy something a bit older and run it into the ground or until repairs outweigh the cars value. Maybe something around £6000 or less? Not sure what makes the most financial sense (weighing up depreciation against running costs and purchase price etc). I've got a 130 tdi in a 2002 golf, 182000 well hammered miles and it's been fantastic and still going strong.
I've got a 105 tdi in a 2007 Passat, 55000 on the first engine before it disintegrated and another 65000 on the next engine (was taken out of a 25000 mile right off) and no end of problems.
I've got a 105 tdi in a 2007 Passat, 55000 on the first engine before it disintegrated and another 65000 on the next engine (was taken out of a 25000 mile right off) and no end of problems.
The ATD engine on my last Golf (2002 100BHP) was great and I suspect it would have lasted many more happy miles. There's a lad down the road with 2001 Golf GTD that is still going well - in spite of the lad being a hooligan!
The BLS on my current Golf (2008 105BHP) has just been changed at 117K miles as the last one ran a big end bearing (and then the oil pump seized). I read somewhere that BXE and one or two similar engines have that problem too - there's a thread somewhere about PD engines (which is why I joined the forum!)
I have no proof, but suspect that a lot of the problem is variable interval servicing (which my car had with the previous owner) - 20K miles without an oil change is 10K or more too many in my opinion - especially on a diesel, I prefer to change at around 7K (or at least once a year when I do less than 7K pa).
There shouldn't be any problems with a DPF - assuming that you/she doesn't spend al day pottering at 30MPH in top gear! Even with my low mileage, I have few problems: the car tells me to drop down a gear or two and the DPF warning light has never come on since I started doing what it said. Fair enough, you feel like an idiot doing 30MPH in second gear (or worse - first!) but that's a small price to pay if it stops the DPF blocking up!
The BLS on my current Golf (2008 105BHP) has just been changed at 117K miles as the last one ran a big end bearing (and then the oil pump seized). I read somewhere that BXE and one or two similar engines have that problem too - there's a thread somewhere about PD engines (which is why I joined the forum!)
I have no proof, but suspect that a lot of the problem is variable interval servicing (which my car had with the previous owner) - 20K miles without an oil change is 10K or more too many in my opinion - especially on a diesel, I prefer to change at around 7K (or at least once a year when I do less than 7K pa).
There shouldn't be any problems with a DPF - assuming that you/she doesn't spend al day pottering at 30MPH in top gear! Even with my low mileage, I have few problems: the car tells me to drop down a gear or two and the DPF warning light has never come on since I started doing what it said. Fair enough, you feel like an idiot doing 30MPH in second gear (or worse - first!) but that's a small price to pay if it stops the DPF blocking up!
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


