Debt Enforcement Options
Author
Discussion

UpTheIron

Original Poster:

4,058 posts

299 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
All - hoping for some pragmatic advice about what is probably a fairly straightforward situation...

In 2010 I had a non-paying tenant who was evicted and I obtained a judgement against them in court. At the time I was 99.9% sure that they had no assets or job so did not pursue the debt any further.

The judgement was for circa £6k of unpaid debt, and upon obtaining access to the property I also found significant damage - ultimately a refurb cost a further £6k or so, although I didn't take any action over this as they had no means to pay. I'm sure my lettings firm (who coordinated all the work) would vouch for this, and would probably have photographic evidence still.

I've just found out they are now gainfully employed, and I suspect they would be able to repay some of the debt.

What enforcement options do I have? Is there any point at all in considering pursuing for the subsequent damage - I presume I've missed the boat on that one?


Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
Options - http://www.compactlaw.co.uk/free-legal-information...

If you know who is employing him, apply for an Attachment of Earnings Order. Two things to be aware of.

- There will be a protected earnings amount (set by the judge) - http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/manuals/dmbmanual/dmbm66755...
- If he changes jobs the Order doesn't transfer with him. You will have to find out who the new employer is to get the Order reapplied to them.

Was the CCJ just for the rent arrears and costs? If so the obvious question for the court will be why you chose not to pursue for the damage to the property once it was quantifiable. If he didn't have the means to pay, then it would have made little difference whether you obtained judgement for £6k or £12k at the time.

UpTheIron

Original Poster:

4,058 posts

299 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
Options - http://www.compactlaw.co.uk/free-legal-information...

If you know who is employing him, apply for an Attachment of Earnings Order. Two things to be aware of.

- There will be a protected earnings amount (set by the judge) - http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/manuals/dmbmanual/dmbm66755...
- If he changes jobs the Order doesn't transfer with him. You will have to find out who the new employer is to get the Order reapplied to them.

Was the CCJ just for the rent arrears and costs? If so the obvious question for the court will be why you chose not to pursue for the damage to the property once it was quantifiable. If he didn't have the means to pay, then it would have made little difference whether you obtained judgement for £6k or £12k at the time.
Cheers.

CCJ was for arrears & costs - I've found the paperwork after my original post - about £6.7k.

At the time I then incurred further costs - further legal fees & bailiff, and following eviction I then became aware of the damage - had no idea prior to that. I didn't bother pursuing it at the time as although I would likely have obtained another judgement in my favour I was of the view that the tenant did not and would not have the means to pay, and that I would be throwing good money after bad.

Attachment of Earnings may not be an option, as they are running a pub and I suspect they are a tenant rather than an employee so I presume there isn't an "employer" involved in the traditional sense. A bit more detective work required perhaps to establish if they have any assets.

Tyre Tread

10,697 posts

247 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
If he is running the pub as a tenant in person (not under the gise of a Ltd Co. he may have seizable assets.

Don't use County Court Bailifs - they're useless - tansfer up to the High Court and use High Court Bailiffs.

Best thing they can levy on (IMHO) is (if you can find out if he OWNS one) a car. No good if on HP or PCP though. Great if its not got finance registered on it.

As its a pub, if he lives on the premises and has personal assets there the bailifs should find it relatively easy to gain peaceable entry and seize personal goods. Obviously dependant upon if he has any!

PIGINAWIG

2,339 posts

196 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
They're high court enforcement officers. County court bailiffs can also levy on vehicles.

For the sum of over 6K, use high court enforcement officers.

Red Devil

13,534 posts

239 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
UpTheIron said:
Attachment of Earnings may not be an option, as they are running a pub and I suspect they are a tenant rather than an employee so I presume there isn't an "employer" involved in the traditional sense. A bit more detective work required perhaps to establish if they have any assets.
yes You need to find out whether they are a manager or a tenant. Big difference.

Example FAQs
http://www.myrobinsonspub.com/support/tenancyexpla...
http://www.shepherdneame.co.uk/join-us/run-tenancy...

If they are a manager than the AoE Order will be against the employer (the brewer/pub chain owner). If he is a tenant then the situation is not markedly different from any other business which is leasing the premises they trade from. The pub will most likely be run under the umbrella of a limited company (often with an odd-sounding name as it won't have been changed from that used by the formation agent).

Your claim is against them as an individual rather than the pub business so getting your money may not be easy unless a salary is being received through the limited company (in which case it's back to a AoE Order). One way to force the issue may be the same one I suggested to blindswelledrat on his thread. Get the debtor into court for an oral examination.

UpTheIron

Original Poster:

4,058 posts

299 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
Red Devil said:
yes You need to find out whether they are a manager or a tenant. Big difference.
Indeed. I've not got a lot to go on at present... it's a Pubmaster pub, which IIRC are mainly (all?) tenanted, although I do have a press story that infers they are an employee but I suspect that was just to make it sound better (along the lines of "landlord being moved in by PubCo to turn pub around").

No sign of a Ltd Company from a few searches.

What's the deal with HCOE's - if I instruct them, give them the pub address, it turns out they live at the premises (it looks like there is accommodation above) and they seize goods then great. But what if they (genuinely) don't live there... do I need to find their residential address first?